Subscribe to Print Edition | Thu., December 20, 2007 Tevet 11, 5768 | | Israel Time: 10:04 (EST+7) web haaretz.com   Back to Homepage Rosner's Domain Diplomacy Defense Jewish World Opinion National Print Edition Advertising Books Arts & Leisure Business Real Estate Easy Start Travel Week's End Anglo File Hanukkah

del.icio.us Digg It!  new Last update - 09:16 19/12/2007 A major invasion of privacy By Haaretz Editorial Tags: Communication Data Law The justified fear of soaring crime has recently given birth to fantastic legislative proposals, like the Communications Data Law that the Knesset passed Monday night. Another bill, which is being pushed by Public Security Minister Avi Dichter, would allow the police to enter anyone's home in order to collect evidence, without the owner being present, without informing him in advance and without even informing him after the fact. While the United States permits concealed entry only in terror cases, and the person whose house was searched must be told no more than one month afterward, the Israeli proposal includes no restrictions or limitations. It would not even bar concealed searches of the houses of lawyers, psychologists or journalists, whose professions require confidentiality. Instead of equipping the police with resources that match the magnitude of their tasks, increasing the number of policemen and improving their level of professionalism - just as the Shin Bet security service, from which Dichter draws his ideas, did - the minister has chosen the easy but invasive solution. In reality, police will probably find it difficult to enter the houses of high-level criminals without their knowledge. But citizens suspected of minor crimes, or even those from whom the police hope to obtain information about other people, will be easy prey. The bill would not enable those whose houses are entered to insist on their rights, because they would not even know that their privacy had been invaded. Advertisement This astounding bill follows the Communications Data Law, which enables the authorities to obtain and even store information about any citizen's Internet, telephone and cell phone communications with excessive ease. While the U.S. Congress is debating the question of whether to allow law enforcement agencies to access telephones and personal computers, the Israeli Knesset passed this invasive and sensitive law with no trouble. Only at the last minute was an amendment adopted that would forbid data searches of professionals whose jobs require confidentiality. From now on, police will be able to obtain information from the telephone, cell phone and Internet companies with virtually no restrictions and with no connection to the severity of the crime under investigation. Even today, the franchises awarded the cell phone and Internet companies include security annexes that enable the security services to access communications data in real time, while scrutiny of their actions takes place only after the fact, at periodic intervals. The restrictions on obtaining private information that the new law contains are minimal and do not sufficiently protect privacy. Should the new law be challenged in the High Court of Justice, the court might well rule it disproportionate, even though it serves an appropriate purpose. The U.S. Congress, meanwhile, has been considering a bill similar to the Israeli law for almost a year, after the sweeping permits granted the authorities to track drug and terrorism suspects led to invasion of privacy lawsuits by private citizens against the telephone and cell phone companies. The search for the easiest and most readily available tools in the war on crime attests to a lack of creativity among the investigative agencies and, even more, to a lack of professional staff and resources. If the police's computer department includes only six investigators, it is no wonder that they need Channel 10's investigative reporters in order to locate pedophiles over the Internet, and need draconian laws in order to fight crime. Bookmark to del.icio.us Religious discrimination Jerusalem's Latin Patriarch rejects Israel's Jewish identity in a pre-Christmas speech. Patriot protection The IDF successfully tested an improved defense missile in anticipation of attacks.   1.   It was only a matter of time.... 10:00  |  Adi 19/12/07   2.   Slaves of the State 11:17  |  Klaudia 19/12/07   3.   Typical of far Left governments 11:31  |  Binyamin Dissen 19/12/07   4.   Why expect the right to privacy ? The Feds Own You. 11:54  |  Klaudia 19/12/07   5.   Response to Binyamin Dissen - our government is leftist? 12:21  |  Dan 19/12/07   6.   Wow. Well said Adi (#1) 12:23  |  Dan 19/12/07   7.   I couldn`t have said it better, Adi (#1) [end] 12:42  |  Leo 19/12/07   8.   Leftists give away Jewish land 13:09  |  Binyamin Dissen 19/12/07   9.   Adi #1 13:23  |  JG 19/12/07   10.   Response to Binyamin Dissen - A Jewish government 13:43  |  Dan 19/12/07   11.   Yes,that`s really too far... 13:46  |  Hastaroth 19/12/07   12.   JG- you want to change the subject 14:12  |  Adi 19/12/07   13.   Totalitarian, dictatorship invasions of privacy 14:23  |  Ivar 19/12/07   14.   Is Israel becoming America? 14:39  |  Mark Lincoln 19/12/07   15.   A Poem 14:47  |  Frank 19/12/07   16.   Totally right, Adi!!! 14:49  |  Simone 19/12/07   17.   Adi totally wrong 16:28  |  JG 19/12/07   18.   JG changing the argument again 17:19  |  Dan 19/12/07   19.   A question to Simone (#16) 18:35  |  Leo 19/12/07   20.   Reply to Leo # 19 23:44  |  Simone 19/12/07   21.   JG: Your point is quashed 00:59  |  Adi 20/12/07

Today Online Experts: Far right will up violence in future settlement evacuation Responses: 29 Arab group seeks supranational regime in 'historic Palestine' Responses: 56 Harel: Palestinians' national pride trumps personal well-being Send response Strenger: The terms 'Zionist' and 'post Zionist' are amorphous Send response Falafel recipe painted on West Bank fence as part of protest Responses: 70 More Headlines 09:13 Experts: Far right will up violence in future pullouts 09:29 Adalah center says it may seek 'regime in all historic Palestine' 01:14 Assad says Syria turned down nuclear weapons offer in 2001 05:15 Aides: Olmert, Livni were not told about E. J'lem housing plan 09:29 U.S. Jewish group slams gov't ruling on campus anti-Semitism 04:05 Gaza census bureau at center of Hamas-PA dispute over survey 06:03 Pre-State polio victims being denied NII compensation 00:59 Knesset okays tax incentives for 'green' construction 23:40 Saudi king invites Iranian President Ahmadinejad to Mecca for hajj 08:14 Striking university lecturers, treasury deadlocked over wage dispute Previous Editions Select Day 19 dec 18 dec 17 dec 16 dec 14 dec 13 dec 12 dec 11 dec 10 dec 09 dec 07 dec 06 dec

Special Offers Advertisement Inbal Jerusalem Hotel Unbeatable rates at the Finest hotel in Jerusalem Invest in Macedonia New Business Heaven in Europe Long-term Israel programs MASA is your gateway. More programs. More grants. Eldan Rent a Car Israel's leading car rental company offers you a 20% discount on all online reservations Dead Sea Salt Beauty and skin care from the Dead Sea. Coupon code HAARETZ for 10% off! Junkyard Junk a car - get free towing nationwide and a tax-deductible receipt. Holiday Inn and Crown Plaza Israel Lowest internet rate Guaranteed at ichotelsgroup.com !

Home | TV | Print Edition | Diplomacy | Opinion | Arts & Leisure | Sports | Jewish World | Underground | Site rules |

© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved