Subscribe to Print Edition | Thu., July 10, 2008 Tamuz 7, 5768 | | Israel Time: 09:17 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Rosner's Domain
Diplomacy
Defense Jewish World Opinion National
Print Edition
Car Rental
Books Peres Conference Business Real Estate Easy Start Travel Week's End Anglo File
Last update - 16:22 17/02/2008
Kosovo, in Israeli eyes
By Adar Primor
Tags: Kosovo, Serbia, Milosevic 

On the eve of his extradition to the War Crimes Tribunal in The Hague, as the noose tightened around his neck, Slobodan Milosevic decided to grant his last journalistic interview to, of all papers, Haaretz. In that interview in March 2001, the deposed leader of Yugoslavia called for the suppression by force of the Kosovar Albanians' "terrorist separatism," lest the separatist snowball roll through all of the Balkans.

Milosevic also expressed his esteem for Ariel Sharon, who was one of the few leaders to come out against the Albanian separatists and against the North Atlantic Treaty Organization's bombing of the Serbian forces.

Eight years after the war in Kosovo, it appears as though the province's disengagement from Serbia is a fait accompli and that its independence will be declared soon. In Israel, it seems that there are those - in diplomatic and academic circles - who are adopting Sharon's political philosophy and are warning of the implications of this development. Their arguments are many and varied.
Advertisement
Today Serbia - tomorrow Israel: Israel must oppose the perception whereby a political and territorial conflict can be ended by means of an external, imposed solution and without the support of both sides to the conflict. If not, who will guarantee that in the future Israel will not have a solution with the Palestinians imposed upon it?

Moreover, who will guarantee Israel that an attempt by the Arabs of Israel to disengage from it - in Galilee, for example - will not also win active international support?

Damage to the international order: Israel must declare that it will not recognize the independence of any entity that has not been granted recognition by the United Nations Security Council. Bypassing the Security Council, which would negate the Russian's (who are opposed to independence for Kosovo) veto, will boomerang against Israel, which itself needs the American veto.

The "Serbian Jerusalem": Kosovo is not just a part of Serbia but also "the cradle of its nationalism and culture." If the "Serbian Jerusalem" is taken away from it, why should "Al Quds" not be taken from us in the future and become the capital of the independent Palestine?

The danger of Islam: The establishment of Kosovo will award a prize to a violent ethnic-religious minority, whose leaders have ties to the Mafia and to the global jihad. Recognizing them will increase Islamic influence and will strengthen anti-Semitic and anti-Israeli opinions in Europe.

Snowball, domino effect, Pandora's box: All of these are terms aimed at deterring a decline into irredentist struggles and bloody wars in the Balkans, and beyond. These arguments - some of which seem to have been taken from the Serbian propaganda machine, others of which spring from internal Israeli fears - are all baseless.

The Kosovar analogy does not resemble the Israeli-Palestinian situation: A declaration of Kosovar independence will not be unilateral, but rather with the agreement of the United States and (most of) Europe, and in accordance with conditions that will be established in advance.

The demographic/geographic reality in Kosovo, where the Albanians constitute a majority of 90 percent of the population, also does not resemble that of Galilee, where the population is mixed. No significant international body will recognize a separatist demand by the Arabs of Israel.

The need to bypass the UN derives from the recognition of its inability to resolve ethnic disputes. "The international order" does not, after all, enable intervention in the genocide in Darfur or the use of force in Iran.

Since the 19th century there has been a Jewish majority in Jerusalem, whereas in the "Serbian Jerusalem" there has not been a Serbian-Orthodox population for more than 200 years now; nevertheless, the Jews (or at least some of them) are willing to compromise in Jerusalem whereas the Serbs are refusing to relinquish "their heart and soul."

Kosovar society is mainly secular, the Islam there is moderate and will remain so since the new state will have no existence outside of the European area.

The desire - in the entire Balkans - to be annexed to that area is also what will render the bloodbath hypothesis unlikely.

In the end, Israel must be part of the democratic and enlightened world that recognizes both the self-determination of an oppressed people that has recently experienced slaughter, rape and ethnic cleansing, and its national aspirations.
Bookmark to del.icio.us  
 
By the numbers
A study shows Jewish Israeli men live almost four years longer than Israeli Arabs.
Local threat
The Shin Bet arrests two Bedouin, accused of supplying information to al-Qaida.
  1.   Milosevich admires Ariel Sharon 14:54  |  T A Sheppard 19/12/07
  2.   KOSAVA NEEDS TO MERGE WITH ALBANIA 15:26  |  Albanian 19/12/07
  3.   It`s not anti-semetism, it`s morality 15:33  |  Abba 19/12/07
  4.   Liberate Palestine 15:35  |  Walter Hurt 19/12/07
  5.   Israel/Kosovo 15:39  |  Sean 19/12/07
  6.   peas in a pod 15:43  |  gearoid 19/12/07
  7.   Pathetic attempt to link Israel to the evils of other people. 15:46  |  common sense 19/12/07
  8.   Serbs were ehnically clensed out of Kosovo by KLA 15:58  |  Boris 19/12/07
  9.   Serbs were ehnically clensed out of Kosovo by KLA 15:58  |  Boris 19/12/07
  10.   Serbs were ehnically clensed out of Kosovo by KLA 15:58  |  Boris 19/12/07
  11.   #7 Israeli War Crimes 16:08  |  EA 19/12/07
  12.   Thank You, Albanian 16:09  |  CHGODMK 19/12/07
  13.   The Holbrooke connection 16:12  |  D.R. Zukerman 19/12/07
  14.   "noose tightened" on Israel.... 16:16  |  POP 19/12/07
  15.   Shamefull 16:16  |  Albanian JEW 19/12/07
  16.   Sean in Derry #5 16:17  |  CHGODMK 19/12/07
  17.   THANKS TO "OUR FRIEND" BOSNIAN-SERB 16:18  |  indrajaya 19/12/07
  18.   THANKS TO "OUR FRIEND" BOSNIAN-SERB 16:18  |  indrajaya 19/12/07
  19.   Abba? "The fact that Anti-Semetism"? 16:22  |  Yosemite 19/12/07
  20.   Pathetic attempt to link Israel to the evils of other people. 16:22  |  David 19/12/07
  21.   Boris #8 16:23  |  D.R. Zukerman 19/12/07
  22.   Abba # 3 _ A Good Start For Your Juvenile Tantrum 16:31  |  Eli 19/12/07
  23.   Abba #3 and nonsense 16:39  |  dovvod 19/12/07
  24.   Somewhat Convoluted Article But This Is Key... 16:44  |  Yosemite 19/12/07
  25.   To Albanian JEW 16:58  |  CHGODMK 19/12/07
  26.   History lesson 17:02  |  ALBANIAN JEW 19/12/07
  27.   Kosovo 17:08  |  Rankovic Crni 19/12/07
  28.   To CHGODMK 17:15  |  Sean 19/12/07
  29.   Some very sad people 17:21  |  Enver 19/12/07
  30.   Response to all you 17:21  |  ALBANIAN JEW 19/12/07
  31.   An academic exercise... 17:36  |  Esther 19/12/07
  32.   this serb propaganda 17:36  |  David 19/12/07
  33.   CHGODMK on Kosova and Serb Claims 17:45  |  Yaakov Sullivan 19/12/07
  34.   kosova or kosovo? 17:49  |  bozhidar 19/12/07
  35.   CHGODMOK and Hate Groups 18:08  |  Yaakov Sullivan 19/12/07
  36.   MOTHER TERESA`S ORIGIN IS ALBANIA 18:23  |  indrajaya 19/12/07
  37.   that is true 18:24  |  Albanian JEW 19/12/07
  38.   Break up of communism led to the rise of nationalism 18:35  |  Ethel 19/12/07
  39.   Protection of civilian populations needed 18:42  |  Ethel 19/12/07
  40.   I do not know Israel`s fate tomorrow 18:47  |  Ethel 19/12/07
  41.   Road to Peace: Minority Civility 18:50  |  dea 19/12/07
  42.   We will ovewrcome the antisemites and haters 19:05  |  HIlda 19/12/07
  43.   to Boris, your dire prediction 19:11  |  Hilda 19/12/07
  44.   It is quite dangerous 19:17  |  Kris 19/12/07
  45.   Separate Matters: Ordinary Serbs v. Milosevic Maffia 19:19  |  dea 19/12/07
  46.   #9 19:21  |  Hilda 19/12/07
  47.   Albanian Jew 19:25  |  Hilda 19/12/07
  48.   History lesson 19:34  |  Hilda 19/12/07
  49.   Diplomacy, not war 19:41  |  Ethel 19/12/07
  50.   #42 Hilda 19:42  |  T A Sheppard 19/12/07
  51.   # 28 most of them are from the US anyway. 19:43  |  Kris 19/12/07
  52.   Jews and albanians 19:51  |  ALBANIAN JEW 19/12/07
  53.   Serbs have no history in Kosovo 20:46  |  Benjamin 19/12/07
  54.   RE: Jews and albanians 20:57  |  UC BERKELEY 19/12/07
  55.   #41 Dea 20:57  |  gearoid 19/12/07
  56.   Kosovo is the Heart of Serbia 21:24  |  Panetelija 19/12/07
  57.   Kosovo, SERBIA! 21:31  |  Boris 19/12/07
  58.   KOSOVO in Israeli Eyes 21:32  |  Lidia 19/12/07
  59.   Sounds like you have no history in fact finding 21:40  |  Boris 19/12/07
  60.   To UC Berkeley 21:50  |  Benjamin 19/12/07
  61.   HISTORY DEPT/ HARVARD edu part 1 22:07  |  Austin Wiesel 19/12/07
  62.   Serbia was the first Jewish Free State 22:07  |  Benjamin 19/12/07
  63.   HISTORY DEPT/ HARVARD edu part 2 22:28  |  Austin Wiesel 19/12/07
  64.   HISTORY DEPT/ HARVARD edu part 3 22:30  |  AustinWiesel 19/12/07
  65.   to Benjamin 22:40  |  Aleks 19/12/07
  66.   Shame on you! 23:44  |  Lazar 19/12/07
  67.   Austrian Kris, I can see right through your trick 23:57  |  Jake 19/12/07
  68.   Srbian Jerusalem 00:15  |  Nikolai Jankovic 20/12/07
  69.   kosovo 00:28  |  john 20/12/07
  70.   Kosovo 02:10  |  Dimal 20/12/07
  71.   What a British did to Jewish State they did also to Serbia