Subscribe to Print Edition | Thu., December 20, 2007 Tevet 11, 5768 | | Israel Time: 14:19 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Rosner's Domain
Diplomacy
Defense Jewish World Opinion National
Print Edition
Advertising
Books Arts & Leisure Business Real Estate Easy Start Travel Week's End Anglo File Hanukkah
del.icio.us
Digg It!  new
Last update - 09:23 18/12/2007
A Vietnam called Gaza
By Yoel Marcus
Tags: Qassam, Sderot, Gaza 

Two brave leaders who tried to bring about peace between us and the Palestinians screwed up big-time: Ariel Sharon, who evacuated Gaza unilaterally, without an agreement, and President George Bush, who pressed the Palestinians to hold democratic elections in order to establish a stable regional order. Both failed to give thought to the truth of the well-known saying: The road to hell is paved with good intentions.

Sharon sought to wean his countrymen from the dream of Greater Israel, to prove that Israel is capable of evacuating settlements, and that there is a path to a pragmatic agreement on the horizon. The evacuation of Gush Katif was supposed to be a kind of appetizer for the Palestinians, to tempt them to peacefully establish their state alongside Israel. Bush, for his part, saw in his vision of democratic elections a state of Palestine that would arise as another locale free of terror and of the influence of radical Islam.

Both leaders erred, in a big way. Hamas' victory in the elections caused one of the most vicious civil wars in our region, and turned Gaza into a base for terror against Israel. The expectations that the Qassam rocket fire would end, and that Gaza, with its beautiful beaches, would instead become a tourist mecca and a source of income, proved false. Sderot continued to suffer Qassam strikes, and as time passed, rockets were also fired at most of the other communities near Gaza - all of which are in Israeli territory.
Advertisement
Since the first Qassam was fired in 2001, some 5,900 rockets and mortar shells have landed in Israeli territory. During this period, 18 Israelis have been killed and about 600 wounded. Considering that 210 people have been killed in traffic accidents over the last half year - 35 fatalities a month - world opinion views the number of fatalities from Qassam attacks over the last six years as negligible, surely not enough to justify World War III.

But these are not the victims of traffic accidents; they are victims of a kind of fighting that has put a sizable city in Israel into a state of perpetual fear. Residents of the area are right to say that no country in the world would sit with hands folded if one of its cities were being bombed day after day, night after night. What country would accept a situation in which its neighbor not only bombarded it, but also established an offensive army that is openly preparing for terrorist operations more lethal than rocket fire, such as kidnapping, and extending the range of its rockets to additional cities within Israel?

Sharon was surprised when the Qassam fire resumed after the evacuation of Gush Katif. Shortly before he suffered his stroke, he considered the option of aerial bombardment of the areas from which Qassams are launched, but dropped the idea when it was made clear to him that anyone who starts indiscriminate bombing of a civilian population is liable to end up in the International Criminal Court in The Hague.

Even now, when public demand for sending the army into Gaza is growing, this option is not as simple as it seems. It is impossible to launch a war in a densely populated area, with narrow alleys housing thousands of women and children, without the support of international public opinion. And we cannot muster such support when we have suffered a single kidnapped soldier and 18 fatalities in six years.

Yet the more time passes with thousands of people living unprotected and in constant fear in Sderot, the greater the demand becomes for a massive military incursion into Gaza. And having learned the lesson of the Second Lebanon War - that in order to eradicate terror, you need an M-16, not an F-16 - sending a massive ground force into Gaza for a kind of expanded Operation Defensive Shield is liable to pin us down for months or even years in a bloody war.

With every passing day, every additional rocket that lands in our terrority increases the demand to "give it to them." Public Security Minister Avi Dichter warns that Israel is embroiled in a war of attrition. And a study by the Intelligence and Terrorism Information Center predicts that sooner or later, the terrorist organizations will try to transfer the Qassam method to the West Bank.

For now, both Defense Minister Ehud Barak and Chief of Staff Gabi Ashkenazi are putting their feet on the brakes of the "the big invasion" option. Instead, they are making do with pinpoint operations inside Gaza on a nightly basis, and sanctions that restrict the supply of food, electricity and other goods. They are thereby sticking their fingers in the hole in the dike. In the story, at least, the little boy thus prevented a disaster.

In any major operation, you know how you will enter, but not how or when you will leave, and how much blood will be shed. We already had one Vietnam, in the First Lebanon War. We do not need a second Vietnam in Gaza.
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Religious discrimination
Jerusalem's Latin Patriarch rejects Israel's Jewish identity in a pre-Christmas speech.
Patriot protection
The IDF successfully tested an improved defense missile in anticipation of attacks.
  1.   Mission Objectives and Exit Planning 09:34  |  Mark of Lewiston 18/12/07
  2.   Not Vietnam 09:38  |  Observant Jew 18/12/07
  3.   Vietnam ??? WOOWWW, who do you think you are ? 09:46  |  Atilla Karagözoğlu 18/12/07
  4.   Withdraw from Sderot! 09:47  |  Yitzhak Sokoloff 18/12/07
  5.   yoel marcus writes that... 09:54  |  scallywag 18/12/07
  6.   What will happen after an Israeli incursion ?? 3 predictions..... 10:01  |  Swiss (Dino) 18/12/07
  7.   mark of lewiston 10:07  |  scallywag 18/12/07
  8.   YOU ARE NOTHING WITHOUT THE US 10:10  |  ATİLLA KARAGÖZOĞLU 18/12/07
  9.   CHICKEN NATION...PARAZITE NATION... 10:12  |  ATİLLA KARAGÖZOĞLU 18/12/07
  10.   Ah...how easily history can be rewritten 10:13  |  Clickfool 18/12/07
  11.   VIETNAM :) WOWW...LOOK AT THOSE CHICKENS... 10:14  |  ATİLLA KARAGÖZOĞLU 18/12/07
  12.   VIETNAM didn`t send Qassems or sucide bombers to the US. 10:20  |  PETER SM 18/12/07
  13.   A NATION , WHOES MOTHER IS WHOES SISTER 10:20  |  ATİLLA KARAGÖZOĞLU 18/12/07
  14.   HAARETZ ! I WANT MY QUESTION ANSWERED ! 10:21  |  ATİLLA KARAGÖZOĞLU 18/12/07
  15.   A STORY, TORAH, TWO SISTER, A DRUNK FATHER, A NATION 10:24  |  ATİLLA KARAGÖZOĞLU 18/12/07
  16.   Your right Mr. Marcus, but how to fix the problem. 10:30  |  David G 18/12/07
  17.   TORAH SAYS ABOUT TWO SISTER AND A DRUNK FATHER 10:34  |  ATİLLA KARAGÖZOĞLU 18/12/07
  18.   Only one possible way 10:37  |  Walter 18/12/07
  19.   An idiotic analogy even by Haaretz standards... 10:38  |  Dr. L. Brnd 18/12/07
  20.   MARK OF LEWISTON.Exit plan based on"We will NEVER recogniseIsrael 10:43  |  PETER SM 18/12/07
  21.   I want an answer ! IS YOUR MOTHER ALSO YOUR SISTER, ISRAEL ! 10:48  |  ATİLLA KARAGÖZOĞLU 18/12/07
  22.   I can go to Arutz 7, to ask them, haaretz ! TODAY 10:50  |  Atilla Karagözoğlu 18/12/07
  23.   MARKof Lewiston Exit planning with PLO charter? Room to manouver? 10:51  |  PETER SM 18/12/07
  24.   When was Israel in the old Vietnam??? 10:52  |  Jon 18/12/07
  25.   Marcus should commit suicide,it was him who`s erred and now 10:54  |  Absolute Sweden 18/12/07
  26.   A One Way ticket to Hell 10:57  |  Tzfonit 18/12/07
  27.   ISRAEL ! IS YOUR MOTHER ALSO IS YOUR SISTER ACCORDING TO TORAH ? 11:03  |  ATİLLA KARAGÖZOĞLU 18/12/07
  28.   Sderot 11:03  |  Joe Rosen 18/12/07
  29.   Olmert/Barak would blow The Big Gaza Op, due of INCOMPETENCE 11:14  |  Pavel 18/12/07
  30.   yoel marcus writes that... 11:16  |  scallywag 18/12/07
  31.   mark of lewiston 11:16  |  scallywag 18/12/07
  32.   As If Gaza Were A Garden of Freedom 11:19  |  Yaakov Sullivan 18/12/07
  33.   Helping the Palestinians create their viable, peaceful state 11:50  |  Albert Edelson 18/12/07
  34.   So, What Do You Suggest, Mr. Yoel Marcus? 11:55  |  Jeff Northridge 18/12/07
  35.   Um Gaza is Gaza and not Vietnam! We Took it 1,2,3, 4 times! 12:12  |  Mark Hamil 18/12/07
  36.   Marcus correct, IDF pouring petrol on the fire! 12:13  |  Ivar 18/12/07
  37.   Gaza 13:03  |  G. Sutton 18/12/07
  38.   #34, Jeff Northridge 13:03  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 18/12/07
  39.   Put me in charge of the IDF, Gaza will be no Vietnam 13:21  |  Steven 18/12/07
  40.   # 27 Atillah, no Lots daughters moved to Turkey. 13:33  |  Petra 18/12/07
  41.   Petra ! I want an answer for the question 13:56  |  Atilla Karagözoğlu 18/12/07
  42.   Cipora Juliana Kohn on preferred options 14:02  |  Yaakov Sullivan 18/12/07
  43.   #26, Tzfonit 14:11  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 18/12/07
  44.   Gaza worst 14:45  |  Dav 18/12/07
  45.   #39 Steven makes a proud boast 14:56  |  Johnboy 18/12/07
  46.   "We do not need a second Vietnam in Gaza..." 15:16  |  bat yam 18/12/07
  47.   ATILLA 15:17  |  Andrew 18/12/07
  48.   The real question is 15:18  |  Chris Linthwaite 18/12/07
  49.   Failed strongarm tactics and smoke screens 15:20  |  North Wales, UK 18/12/07
  50.   ok steven you`re in charge 15:40  |  too funny 18/12/07
  51.   The alternative to Vietnam 15:44  |  Tosefta 18/12/07
  52.   SHARON AND BUSH 15:51  |  indrajaya 18/12/07
  53.   Why the Right is SO Dumb already 15:51  |  Danite 18/12/07
  54.   The two model incompetent leaders 15:54  |  Tosefta 18/12/07
  55.   Cipora true but.. 15:55  |  Danite 18/12/07
  56.   c j kohn 38 16:20  |  realism 18/12/07
  57.   "We do not need a second Vietnam in Gaza..." 16:40  |  bat yam 18/12/07
  58.   Luxury Villas 16:45  |  The Teacher/Instruct 18/12/07
  59.   zion`s problem with its attitude toward `goyim` (cattle) 16:51  |  the real problem 18/12/07
  60.   Tosefta? zion would rather kill than be reasonable 16:55  |  truth 18/12/07
  61.   "realism" is back... 16:58  |  scallywag 18/12/07
  62.   7 scallywag - Coordination & Discussion 17:00  |  Mark of Lewiston 18/12/07
  63.   Agree with Artical 17:03  |  Ron 18/12/07
  64.   20 Peter SM - Quoting Verses 17:04  |  Mark of Lewiston 18/12/07
  65.   Not Vietnam - DRESDEN/HIROSHIMA/NAGASAKI 17:09  |  smarter then olmert 18/12/07
  66.   see you monday ! I love you 17:10  |  Atilla Karagözoğlu 18/12/07
  67.   #49 dr ben is now north wales and its still crap 17:28  |  victor hardman 18/12/07
  68.   Haaretz 17:29  |  Danite 18/12/07
  69.   ATILLA; the answer to your question is YES! 17:34  |  Alicia 18/12/07
  70.   If America was in Israel`s shoes 17:46  |  Jon 18/12/07
  71.   Johnboy 41 you bet on it 17:51  |  Steven 18/12/07
  72.   50 I never was on welfare, sorry 17:52  |  Steven 18/12/07
  73.   Can Marcus Get Any Dumber ? 18:02  |  Tod Zuckerman 18/12/07
  74.   Haaretz flower exhibition 18:07  |  myy wei 18/12/07
  75.   Danite #55: the principle question, Danite, is rather - 18:11  |  ivo 18/12/07
  76.   Atilla -- if you were not illiterate.... 18:20  |  bbl 18/12/07
  77.   Vietnam? Take Care Of Yourselves Israel. 18:21  |  Yosemite 18/12/07
  78.   ATILLA #3,8.11,13,17 your answer 18:43  |  Gary Pineda 18/12/07
  79.   Tzfonit #26: only one problem, Tzfonit, - 18:46  |  ivo 18/12/07
  80.   Decency and Civility Can End the Conflict 19:06  |  dea 18/12/07
  81.   Sorry Yoel, but 19:24  |  Mark Lincoln 18/12/07
  82.   Shh, don`t let bb hear about this increasing demand business 19:29  |  Merle 18/12/07
  83.   Anyone who bombs civilians will end up in the Hague? 19:31  |  Efox 18/12/07
  84.   re: Mark of Lewiston 19:34  |  Efox 18/12/07
  85.   mark of lewiston, again 19:35  |  scallywag 18/12/07
  86.   The "smart" Israel and the "dumb" Israel 19:42  |  Swiss (Dino) 18/12/07
  87.   MARK Of Lewiston.I am quoting CURRENT charters 19:53  |  PETER SM 18/12/07
  88.   #12 PETER SM No Vietnamese bombers in the US 19:59  |  hala 18/12/07
  89.   ivar in estonia 20:09  |  scallywag 18/12/07
  90.   stevy boy all of zion is on welfare 20:13  |  truth 18/12/07
  91.   #27 ATILLA and Lot and his daughters 20:19  |  hala 18/12/07
  92.   #41 Atilla, read my reply 20:26  |  hala 18/12/07
  93.   Of course Quassams will end up in WestBank 20:31  |  topanga 18/12/07
  94.   Dino #86: nice try, but it`s not that simple - 20:44  |  ivo 18/12/07
  95.   HALA confused? It was Pals with 5 Arab armies who ethnic cleansed 20:45  |  PETER SM 18/12/07
  96.   hala #88: your whole dictionary is wrong - 21:03  |  ivo 18/12/07
  97.   GAZA - THE TERROR STATE 21:21  |  ISHMAEL ISHMAEL 18/12/07
  98.   For Gary Pineda # 78 21:22  |  Clickfool 18/12/07
  99.   talking about rights... don`t be fooled ! 22:09  |  Nicolas from Paris 18/12/07
  100.   #95 accusations of "confusion" 22:11  |  hala 18/12/07
  101.   # 94 ivo 22:24  |  Swiss (Dino) 18/12/07
  102.   #96 Ivo, saying that "my" dictionary is wrong proves nothing 22:25  |  hala 18/12/07
  103.   23 Peter SM - The British Mandate is Irrelevant 22:31  |  Mark of Lewiston 18/12/07
  104.   #96 Not "my" continent, Ivo 22:33  |  hala 18/12/07
  105.   Danite, and also ivo 22:51  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 18/12/07
  106.   #91+2 Hala on incestious Jewish family-tree 23:00  |  Alicia 18/12/07
  107.   hala #102, 104: still your arguments are twisted (sorry), hala, - 23:13  |  ivo 18/12/07
  108.   Indrajaya 23:32  |  Neal 18/12/07
  109.   hala#91 23:47  |  Danite 18/12/07
  110.   ATTILA - is it the first time you drink alcohol? 23:59  |  17 18/12/07
  111.   hala #102, 104 - 2 00:23  |  ivo 19/12/07
  112.   Hala - you are also right 00:25  |  17 19/12/07
  113.   hala #102, 104 - 3 00:39  |  ivo 19/12/07
  114.   Popular 01:08  |  GPWS1 19/12/07
  115.   dino #101 01:12  |  ivo 19/12/07
  116.   # 86, SWISS (DINO) 01:16  |  indrajaya 19/12/07
  117.   Yoel Marcus and halftruths 01:17  |  truth 19/12/07
  118.   One sided? 01:50  |  Michael N 19/12/07
  119.   Alicia #106: are you kidding me - 02:11  |  ivo 19/12/07
  120.   Cipora 02:28  |  Danite 19/12/07
  121.   Cipora 02:28  |  Danite 19/12/07
  122.   A difference between Vietnam and Gaza 02:29  |  Mark Lincoln 19/12/07
  123.   More Leftist BS 03:01  |  Frank 19/12/07
  124.   Mark Lincoln #115; you`re really talking big nonsense, Mark, - 03:27  |  ivo 19/12/07
  125.   #2 Atila.....hush up and let the grownups talk. 03:39  |  19/12/07
  126.   End the sanctions, free the elected 03:41  |  Joe 19/12/07
  127.   re #90 - Anyone else besides me sick to death... 03:45  |  Steve 19/12/07
  128.   #117, Danite 04:20  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 19/12/07
  129.   Attack for attack 04:23  |  Fadhil 19/12/07
  130.   False posting Alert 04:29  |  Truth 19/12/07
  131.   IVO 04:30  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 19/12/07
  132.   1 bomb is all it takes. 05:08  |  Hard facts 19/12/07
  133.   #83 Efox doesn`t understand what the court in the Hague is for 05:34  |  Johnboy 19/12/07
  134.   enough already, atılla! 05:41  |  eric 19/12/07
  135.   MARK of LEWISTON.Hamas charter calls for the destruction of ALL 05:42  |  PETER SM 19/12/07
  136.   #71 Hairy chested Steven jumps up and down 05:55  |  Johnboy 19/12/07
  137.   # 119 well ivo, i don`t about three times... 06:04  |  eric 19/12/07
  138.   A simple proposal 06:30  |  Morris Valentine 19/12/07
  139.   Cipora 06:45  |  Danite 19/12/07
  140.   Bad Analogies A Brain Doth Not Make 07:05  |  David 19/12/07
  141.   # 122 to mark lincoln in texas; another scenerio 07:09  |  eric 19/12/07
  142.   Israel & Hamas 07:51  |  JLEE 19/12/07
  143.   Johnboy 08:38  |  Steven 19/12/07
  144.   #138, Morris Valentine 09:03  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 19/12/07
  145.   1335 Peter SM - Exit Planning 09:07  |  Mark of Lewiston 19/12/07
  146.   # 116 indrajaya 09:20  |  Swiss (Dino) 19/12/07
  147.   # 115 ivo 09:27  |  Swiss (Dino) 19/12/07
  148.   #119 IVO, tickle your brain! 12:31  |  Alicia 19/12/07
  149.   #143 Steven gets it wrong in the first line 05:16  |  Johnboy 20/12/07
  150.   re: Johnboy 10:38  |  Efox 20/12/07
  151.   Johnboy: let´s get this straight 14:16  |  Alicia 20/12/07
 Today Online
Experts: Far right will up violence in future settlement evacuation
Responses: 61
Israeli Arab group seeks 'supranational regime in historic Palestine'
Responses: 100
Harel: Palestinians live in squalid refugee camps by choice
Responses: 20
Carlo Strenger: Time for us to stop using the term 'Zionist'
Responses: 19
American Zionist group slams U.S. gov't on campus anti-Semitism
Responses: 36


More Headlines
13:53 Qassam strikes by Negev school; IDF kills 4 in Gaza
12:57 Housing Minister backtracks, says no new E. J'lem housing plan
11:16 Israel says it opposes Russian plans for Moscow peace summit
14:17 Barak: Labor Party won't support budget if stipends remain frozen
12:15 American Zionist group slams U.S. gov't on campus anti-Semitism
10:48 Experts: Extreme rightists will use violence if settlements are evacuated
13:25 Adalah center says it may seek supranational regime in 'all historic Palestine'
01:14 Assad says Syria turned down nuclear weapons offer in 2001
04:05 Gaza census bureau at center of Hamas-PA dispute over survey
06:03 Pre-State polio victims being denied NII compensation
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
Inbal Jerusalem Hotel
Unbeatable rates at the Finest hotel in Jerusalem
Invest in Macedonia
New Business Heaven in Europe
Long-term Israel programs
MASA is your gateway. More programs. More grants.
Eldan Rent a Car
Israel's leading car rental company offers you a 20% discount on all online reservations
Dead Sea Salt
Beauty and skin care from the Dead Sea. Coupon code HAARETZ for 10% off!
Junkyard
Junk a car - get free towing nationwide and a tax-deductible receipt.
Holiday Inn and Crown Plaza Israel
Lowest internet rate Guaranteed at ichotelsgroup.com !
Home| TV| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved