Subscribe to Print Edition | Wed., December 19, 2007 Tevet 10, 5768 | | Israel Time: 04:53 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Rosner's Domain
Diplomacy
Defense Jewish World Opinion National
Print Edition
Advertising
Books Arts & Leisure Business Real Estate Easy Start Travel Week's End Anglo File Hanukkah
Filmmaker Nizar Hassan. (Adi Mazan)
del.icio.us
Digg It!  new
Last update - 09:06 04/12/2007
Colleagues back lecturer who threw soldier out of classroom
By Tamara Traubmann, Haaretz Correspondent
Tags: IDF, Israeli Arabs, Israel 

Filmmaker Nizar Hassan, who was suspended recently from lecturing at Sapir College near Sderot, pending a disciplinary hearing, after he ordered a student to leave the classroom for wearing an Israeli army uniform and carrying a weapon, received a show of support Monday from his colleagues and censure from Knesset members.

The student was serving as an Israel Defense Forces reservist at the time.

Nearly 40 Jewish and Arab lecturers at Sapir signed a letter to the college's president and disciplinary committee stating that Hassan "is a talented and courageous artist whose only sin was his attempt to maintain universal civic values, and whose action pointed to the serious phenomenon of the great involvement of the army in campus life."
Advertisement
Hassan's disciplinary hearing is scheduled for Thursday.

The Knesset Education Committee discussed his case Monday, at the behest of MK Zevulun Orlev (National Religious Party) and others, and decided to condemn Hassan "harshly."

"There is a national, civic and moral duty to ensure the honor of army reservists," a committee resolution stated. The committee also requested to be briefed on the results of the disciplinary hearing.

Last month, Eyal Cohen, an intelligence officer in the reserves, came to a film class taught by Hassan while wearing his army uniform. Hassan reportedly told him to leave immediately, saying, "I do not teach soldiers, policemen and officers in uniform."

Cohen did not leave, and Hassan continued to make negative comments about the Israel Defense Forces during the class.

The lecturers' letter defended Hassan, stating: "For an Arab lecturer who does not identify with the Israeli army and who does not share in the naturalness with which many of us accept those who carry arms among us, it is reasonable that he will request that the necessary boundaries between the army and academia be adhered to and to remind us all of how crucial these are."

The letter notes that there were no disciplinary hearings in previous cases when Jewish lecturers removed armed soldiers from lecture halls.

Sapir College has no written disciplinary regulations, and a senior college official told Haaretz that the disciplinary committee will follow "a clear statement by the college president and the academic ethos, according to which you do not bring politics into the classroom, or insult a student."

Hassan's temporary employment contract warns him against mixing ideology and politics in his lessons. This is the only contract at Sapir (or any other institute of higher learning, as far as is known) in which such a clause has been included.

Related articles:
  • http://www.haaretz.com/hasen/pages/ShArt.jhtml?itemNo=286916&contrassID=2&subContrassID=14&sbSubContrassID=0&listSrc=Y
  • Cabinet approves grants package for reservists
    • Bookmark to del.icio.us
    Organic memory
    Israeli research is among '50 most significant scientific breakthroughs in 2007.'
    Floating the PA
    International donors pledged $7.4 billion to help boost the PA economy .
      1.   Authoritarian mindset 03:46  |  Hafez ibn Alawi 04/12/07
      2.   No Arab lecturers - it`s a Jewish State 04:00  |  Muhammad the Bear 04/12/07
      3.   Guns in the classroom 04:15  |  Jay 04/12/07
      4.   Beat the leftists with their own stick 04:33  |  brnard ross 04/12/07
      5.   teachers 04:37  |  colin 04/12/07
      6.   hassan wrong. stop this left wing lunacy before it takes over!!!! 04:40  |  ralph 04/12/07
      7.   the necessary boundaries between the army and academia?? 04:45  |  gilead 04/12/07
      8.   If his mind is set against Israel, let him go teach in Gaza 04:51  |  Jorge 04/12/07
      9.   Soldier thrown out of classroom 04:54  |  Stephen 04/12/07
      10.   the Hassan`s defenders should be ashamed of themselves 04:55  |  Baruch 04/12/07
      11.   When Can Students Be Ejected From the Classroom? 05:00  |  Brad 04/12/07
      12.   dangerous precedent 05:25  |  aussie 04/12/07
      13.   Silly and counter-productive 05:28  |  David Band 04/12/07
      14.   This guy should be teaching politics 05:39  |  Yoav Naor 04/12/07
      15.   Thugs & Goons go to school.. really? 05:46  |  POP 04/12/07
      16.   IDF Is Necessary To Country`s Safety 06:50  |  Laguna Geno 04/12/07
      17.   Fire Hassan 06:58  |  Ron 04/12/07
      18.   Censure Them As Well 07:09  |  Yishai Kohen 04/12/07
      19.   The lecturer should be severely reprimanded 07:10  |  Shalom Freedman 04/12/07
      20.   Close Sapir College. If you beleve in justice send this to all 07:15  |  Alex 04/12/07
      21.   He broke his contract! 07:17  |  redmike 04/12/07
      22.   In Countries Hassan likes better, they kill people like him 07:56  |  Efox 04/12/07
      23.   Raise the ethical standards at Sapir 08:10  |  Michael 04/12/07
      24.   arabs can get away with it, not jews 08:13  |  eliezer 04/12/07
      25.   Racism aside 08:24  |  Dani Reiss 04/12/07
      26.   Hassan should be penalised. 08:50  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 04/12/07
      27.   lecturering and politics should not mix 09:13  |  HM 04/12/07
      28.   lecturer 09:14  |  jeffrey turkel 04/12/07
      29.   outrageous 09:19  |  Jewish State 04/12/07
      30.   fascist posters 09:19  |  Israeli 04/12/07
      31.   Even in Switzerland is the army all over the place. 09:21  |  S 04/12/07
      32.   Nizar Hassan 09:40  |  Steve 04/12/07
      33.   Soldiers in classroom 09:45  |  Gabe 04/12/07
      34.   Disgraceful 09:47  |  Dawn 04/12/07
      35.   More Mixing of the military into civilian life 10:10  |  Yaakov Sullivan 04/12/07
      36.   Nizar 10:13  |  Reuven 04/12/07
      37.   gilead is saddend, but by what? #7 10:18  |  Yaakov Sullivan 04/12/07
      38.   Hassan should be thrown out 10:35  |  paul almond 04/12/07
      39.   Universities are not barracks 10:35  |  Leser 04/12/07
      40.   #30 - you are simply pretending to be Israeli! 10:36  |  redmike 04/12/07
      41.   So says Gabe of Haifa 10:44  |  Yaakov Sullivan 04/12/07
      42.   Universities in Gaza 10:47  |  Seth J. Frantzman 04/12/07
      43.   it is not complex, if he is not fired, cut off this college! 10:55  |  Pavel 04/12/07
      44.   What a scumbag! Shame he did not try that in an Arab country 11:00  |  PETER S .M. 04/12/07
      45.   Dani Reiss and others 11:04  |  ChanahS 04/12/07
      46.   IN ISRAEL, THE ARMY DOES WHAT IT WANTS 11:05  |  TrippleJump 04/12/07
      47.   So the poor Israeli Arabs are frightened and persecuted? 11:05  |  PETER S.M. 04/12/07
      48.   The lecturer was right: his classroom is not an army barrack 11:06  |  Eric 04/12/07
      49.   IT SMEELS RACISM....LECTURER OUGHT TO BE APPLAUDED 11:07  |  Elliot 04/12/07
      50.   He should be expelled, not suspended.. 11:22  |  bf 04/12/07
      51.   Steve from Skokie on Israel`s Arabs 11:31  |  Yaakov Sullivan 04/12/07
      52.   "Israeli" 11:37  |  a real Israeli 04/12/07
      53.   Sullivan on what basis should the student have been expelled 11:39  |  Israeli 04/12/07
      54.   fire him 11:40  |  ka 04/12/07
      55.   Sullivan - the finest idiocy 11:43  |  Israeli 04/12/07
      56.   This is just plain stupid.... 11:50  |  Ofer Maimon 04/12/07
      57.   BBZZZZZZZZZZ Sullivan 11:51  |  Israeli 04/12/07
      58.   Israeli # 53 on defending Israel 11:53  |  Yaakov Sullivan 04/12/07
      59.   Yaakov,,,try being quiet and just listen.... 11:53  |  Ofer Maimon 04/12/07
      60.   reasonable responses 11:55  |  Richi 04/12/07
      61.   Israeli and his assumptions #55 11:56  |  Yaakov Sullivan 04/12/07
      62.   But it is O.K. for Jewish lecturers to remove... 12:07  |  Maureen Ann 04/12/07
      63.   Find Another Pulpit 12:08  |  Yehudit 04/12/07
      64.   Re Yishai #18 12:15  |  Esther 04/12/07
      65.   Ofer Maimon, not a chance 12:15  |  Yaakov Sullivan 04/12/07
      66.   Hassan should be disciplined 12:31  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 04/12/07
      67.   #61 Sullivan 12:43  |  ka 04/12/07
      68.   provocation,on vacation;what`s the regulation 12:48  |  uzi`s the 1 for me 04/12/07
      69.   College at fault 12:56  |  Fahmi Natour 04/12/07
      70.   ROTC on US Campuses 12:57  |  American 04/12/07
      71.   CJ Cohen on rights in the classroom 13:01  |  Yaakov Sullivan 04/12/07
      72.   ka on his "moral ground" #61 13:09  |  Yaakov Sullivan 04/12/07
      73.   right israel 13:11  |  sev 04/12/07
      74.   #71 Sullivan`s law 13:19  |  ka 04/12/07
      75.   Outrage 13:24  |  Sherlock Holmes 04/12/07
      76.   politics on leave?has he left his senses 13:25  |  sipurei savta 04/12/07
      77.   Re: Esther #64 13:30  |  Yishai Kohen 04/12/07
      78.   a reservist with weapon is "normal" by Israeli standards 13:33  |  Bob 04/12/07
      79.   Never mind the uniform, what about the gun?? 13:36  |  Mr. T 04/12/07
      80.   ka I agree there should be a policy 13:40  |  Yaakov Sullivan 04/12/07
      81.   64 Ester - blind and irrational 13:46  |  ka 04/12/07
      82.   Mr T on the IDF and zionists #79 13:50  |  Yaakov Sullivan 04/12/07
      83.   AMAZING thiose "racist" Israelis defending Arab against Jew 13:50  |  PETER S.M. 04/12/07
      84.   `yaacov` the anti-semite 13:52  |  goldenberg 04/12/07
      85.   two issues.... 13:54  |  Teresa-Maria (Tess) 04/12/07
      86.   I Don`t Understand the Case 13:59  |  Avi Yerushalmi 04/12/07
      87.   #49 It SMEELS? YIKES! WHAT A SCHOLAR! OY VEY! 13:59  |  Petra 04/12/07
      88.   No 2 is wrong 14:03  |  Jackie 04/12/07
      89.   Marigie #26 14:05  |  Teresa-Maria (Tess) 04/12/07
      90.   dismiss the lecturer 14:15  |  real vision 04/12/07
      91.   Sappir College 14:16  |  Sarah 04/12/07
      92.   Send this dog to Aza (where he belongs) 14:19  |  Yehuda Maccabbee 04/12/07
      93.   For your information 14:25  |  Shachar 04/12/07
      94.   He hates soldiers who defend Israel 14:30  |  Tomer 04/12/07
      95.   Soldier intimidating 14:34  |  fk 04/12/07
      96.   THERE ARE SEVERAL ANGLES TO THIS STORY 14:36  |  Robert 04/12/07
      97.   ##### YAAKOV SULLIVAN, LECTURER 14:36  |  HM 04/12/07
      98.   goldenberg, you are clincal and need attention #84 14:57  |  Yaakov Sullivan 04/12/07
      99.   The lecturer had a right to throw him out 15:29  |  eli 04/12/07
      100.   WHY stop with there ? Women without Abayas and Burqas also offend 15:29  |  PETER S.M. 04/12/07
      101.   #97 15:30  |  O`Sullivan 04/12/07
      102.   To Yaakov Sullivan...today you brilliant 15:37  |  The stupid ant 04/12/07
      103.   40 more Sapir leftists should be fired 15:43  |  Alan 04/12/07
      104.   Re ka #81 15:44  |  Esther 04/12/07
      105.   Guns in class? 15:54  |  The Northern Wind 04/12/07
      106.   I have no problem with soldiers in classroom but 16:05  |  Rami 04/12/07
      107.   Knee jerk leftists: I used to be one too 16:11  |  AA 04/12/07
      108.   Soldier on duty 24/7/365 16:13  |  * BEN JABO 04/12/07
      109.   Seperating Yaacov Sullivan from his hysteria 16:15  |  Jacob Blues 04/12/07
      110.   Why didn`t Hassan just call someone in authority 16:16  |  PETER S.M. 04/12/07
      111.   Teresa-Maria 16:19  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 04/12/07
      112.   Psych 101 for Maureen 16:22  |  Jacob Blues 04/12/07
      113.   delusional pacifists 16:23  |  izzy d 04/12/07
      114.   #104 ester still unconvincing 16:24  |  ka 04/12/07
      115.   Sullivan - Guns in classrooms and schools 16:27  |  * BEN JABO 04/12/07
      116.   The issue was not the gun 16:30  |  Jacob Blues 04/12/07
      117.   #105 Northern Wind 16:31  |  * BEN JABO 04/12/07
      118.   I hope a katyusha.... 16:31  |  Sherman 04/12/07
      119.   Two things to remember about this incident 16:37  |  Jacob Blues 04/12/07
      120.   In response to Gilead 16:39  |  Biba 04/12/07
      121.   # 103 16:41  |  A.M. 04/12/07
      122.   on Nizar Hassan from a non Israeli 16:42  |  EU citizen 04/12/07
      123.   And the veil? 16:45  |  Biba 04/12/07
      124.   Israelis hate when Arabs show confidence... 16:48  |  Ibrahim 04/12/07
      125.   3 99 eli...yes they do, and so do police officers 16:49  |  Lynn 04/12/07
      126.   To Elliot 49, all ROTC students should be expelled 17:14  |  Jorge 04/12/07
      127.   Lynn 17:15  |  Teresa-Maria (Tess) 04/12/07
      128.   Ben Jabo about `yaacov` 17:15  |  goldenberg 04/12/07
      129.   BEN JABO 17:18  |  Albert Seligman 04/12/07
      130.   Reading all kinds of rational discutions on this 17:36  |  TOMY 04/12/07
      131.   No Ben Jabo, unlimitted firearms are not the solution 17:41  |  Jacob Blues 04/12/07
      132.   Jacob Blues and the blues of the classroom 17:42  |  Yaakov Sullivan 04/12/07
      133.   bint jaboo #115 on mental illness 17:44  |  Yaakov Sullivan 04/12/07
      134.   A self-parody of the ultra-left 17:49  |  Berel Dov Lerner 04/12/07
      135.   I think this "teacher" should work on organizing 17:56  |  TOMY 04/12/07
      136.   Thank you 18:01  |  Biba 04/12/07
      137.   #131 Jacob Blues 18:02  |  * BEN JABO 04/12/07
      138.   #133 Turncoat Sullivan 18:05  |  * BEN JABO 04/12/07
      139.   Jacob Blues 18:06  |  Ocoloco 04/12/07
      140.   Yaacov,the raging bull is on the run 18:06  |  TOMY 04/12/07
      141.   To Yaakov Sullivan...be happy ` no choose you 18:08  |  The Dumbite Kid 04/12/07
      142.   `yaacov` the anti-semite 18:10  |  goldenberg 04/12/07
      143.   EU citizen 18:11  |  goldenberg 04/12/07
      144.   Re #1 Kant and God 18:13  |  DJStahl 04/12/07
      145.   Ibrahim 18:13  |  Gina 04/12/07
      146.   3rd-rate lecturer, 3rd-rate school, not another dime from US Jews 18:18  |  Dr. L. Brnd 04/12/07
      147.   To Jacob Jacob B lues & Yaacov Sullivan. Behaviour of a teacher 18:18  |  Altalena 04/12/07
      148.   Prespectives..Cool heads will prevail 18:20  |  Buzaglow 04/12/07
      149.   Academic Terrorists 18:22  |  j10 04/12/07
      150.   # 127 Tess..second attempt 18:26  |  Lynn 04/12/07
      151.   American germ infects Israeli university 18:28  |  Mark 04/12/07
      152.   Sullivan`s racism 18:29  |  FOX 04/12/07
      153.   #131-2 Jacob Blues 19:00  |  * BEN JABO 04/12/07
      154.   #2 19:00  |  Dave 04/12/07
      155.   Ibrahim projecting 19:13  |  peter 04/12/07
      156.   Israelis not a racist State (if you`re Jewish) 19:22  |  Don Camillo 04/12/07
      157.   Lynn - same problem 19:31  |  Teresa- Maria(Tess) 04/12/07
      158.   Once Again 19:45  |  Steve 04/12/07
      159.   Send him to Sudan 19:50  |  Herbert Kaine 04/12/07
      160.   Send him to Sudan 19:50  |  Herbert Kaine 04/12/07
      161.   Send him to Sudan 19:50  |  Herbert Kaine 04/12/07
      162.   Send him to Sudan 19:50  |  Herbert Kaine 04/12/07
      163.   Send him to Sudan 19:50  |  Herbert Kaine 04/12/07
      164.   Send him to Sudan 19:50  |  Herbert Kaine 04/12/07
      165.   dc - not racist - not much! 19:59  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 04/12/07
      166.   Jacob Blues the rifle wasn`t the issue 20:05  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 04/12/07
      167.   Peter, I never said I was upset. 20:15  |  Ibrahim 04/12/07
      168.   Israeli left 20:20  |  Michael 04/12/07
      169.   Gina-you are as usual, incorrect. 20:21  |  Ibrahim 04/12/07
      170.   racist teacher 20:25  |  Kibbutznik 04/12/07
      171.   I would suggest................... 20:34  |  Connie 04/12/07
      172.   hehe nice try Ibrahim 20:37  |  peter 04/12/07
      173.   #156 Don, absolutly wrong,do not take things 20:55  |  TOMY 04/12/07
      174.   Ibrahim s distortions(2nd try) 21:07  |  Danite 04/12/07
      175.   No disciplinary hearing is even called for 21:07  |  Tosefta 04/12/07
      176.   # 157 Tess...remaining as objective as possible 21:10  |  Lynn 04/12/07
      177.   Ibrahim -choices 21:11  |  danite 04/12/07
      178.   Better Mr. Hassan... 21:12  |  Karl 04/12/07
      179.   "Yaakov" the big hypocrite 21:13  |  Danite 04/12/07
      180.   Statistics Ben Jabo 21:15  |  Jacob Blues 04/12/07
      181.   ISRAEL IS SHOWING THE WORLD ITS RACISM 21:20  |  Mike the American 04/12/07
      182.   # 146 The racist Doctor 21:23  |  Mike the American 04/12/07
      183.   Hey Margie 21:23  |  Jacob Blues 04/12/07
      184.   #122 EU citizen 21:27  |  Viper 04/12/07
      185.   # 1 Hafez...and philosophers should be kings 21:39  |  Lynn 04/12/07
      186.   Mike the Yank 21:42  |  Albert Seligman 04/12/07
      187.   ROTC in US classrooms 21:45  |  DJStahl 04/12/07
      188.   If the NRA hears about this, they will lobby to cut Israeli aid. 21:47  |  Toronto`s Finest 04/12/07
      189.   #75 Arabist apologist tries old school 21:59  |  peter 04/12/07
      190.   Danite, why can Jewish professors get away with it? 22:01  |  Ibrahim 04/12/07
      191.   Sounds like Peter from Montreal was in the classroom 22:07  |  Ibrahim 04/12/07
      192.   JB read the Ynet report, 22:11  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 04/12/07
      193.   Ibrahim an armed soldier isn`t `corrupting` 22:14  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 04/12/07
      194.   Its never been about truth, its about advancing an ideology 22:19  |  Scharker Yid 04/12/07
      195.   Ibrahim evades 22:24  |  Danite 04/12/07
      196.   Tosefta one question 22:28  |  Danite 04/12/07
      197.   Slowman`s wisdom on skipping posts 22:30  |  Tamara Traubmann 04/12/07
      198.   Margie on symbols.... 22:37  |  Ibrahim 04/12/07
      199.   Danite, you are digressing... 22:39  |  Ibrahim 04/12/07
      200.   What was the thug doing in the class room? 22:41  |  The Arab Hammer 04/12/07
      201.   # 181 Mike the American...if I wish you a 22:46  |  Lynn 04/12/07
      202.   Ossified brain in the Twilight Zone (Peter the Great #189) 22:48  |  Tosefta 04/12/07
      203.   # 201 Stick top the issues 23:01  |  Mike the American 04/12/07
      204.   Mike #182, ROTC, active-duty US military attend class in uniform 23:01  |  Dr. L. Brnd 04/12/07
      205.   If it was the other way around 23:01  |  No Masochist 04/12/07
      206.   #191 Ibrahim and limited resources 23:01  |  peter 04/12/07
      207.   # 186 Stick to the issue 23:04  |  Mike the American 04/12/07
      208.   Danite, men and their toys 23:24  |  Teresa-Maria (Tess) 04/12/07
      209.   Re the Gun 23:29  |  Brad 04/12/07
      210.   Must be those IDF uniforms 23:34  |  TonyL 04/12/07
      211.   Thanks for the link Margie 23:36  |  Jacob Blues 04/12/07
      212.   Tornto whatever #188 23:38  |  FOX 04/12/07
      213.   Yaacov continues his hysterics 23:44  |  Jacob Blues 04/12/07
      214.   Mike II 23:48  |  Albert Seligman 04/12/07
      215.   # 69 Fahmi....most wise 23:50  |  Lynn 04/12/07
      216.   #175, Tosefta 23:51  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 04/12/07
      217.   TOSEFTA, PETER, et al........ 23:54  |  Lynn 04/12/07
      218.   Seems like both were rude 23:58  |  Mark Lincoln 04/12/07
      219.   No civilized college would allow this 23:58  |  Rick 04/12/07
      220.   #180 Jacob Blues 00:00  |  * BEN JABO 05/12/07
      221.   To The Arab Hammer (86)...be Happy 00:06  |  The Jew Transistor 05/12/07
      222.   "Lecturer" & soldier. 00:06  |  curious 05/12/07
      223.   #208 Teresa-Maria 00:11  |  * BEN JABO 05/12/07
      224.   #198 Ibrahim on Symbols 00:16  |  * BEN JABO 05/12/07
      225.   Gilead # 7 00:24  |  Philippe 05/12/07
      226.   Y. Sullivan you are an angry Irishman..... 00:25  |  NS 05/12/07
      227.   #7 - really bad analogy 00:28  |  Rick 05/12/07
      228.   #218, Mark Lincoln 00:32  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 05/12/07
      229.   Earthly facts are not found by antennas(Bird from Outerspace#216) 00:34  |  Tosefta 05/12/07
      230.   Shachar # 93 00:35  |  Philippe 05/12/07
      231.   BenJabo # 115 00:40  |  Philippe 05/12/07
      232.   #217 Gina, you are in luck 00:41  |  Tosefta 05/12/07
      233.   EU citizen # 122 00:43  |  Philippe 05/12/07
      234.   Brad - mischaracterization 00:46  |  Rick 05/12/07
      235.   Dr. L. Brnd # 204 00:51  |  Philippe 05/12/07
      236.   Ben Jabo 00:57  |  Teresa-Maria (Tess) 05/12/07
      237.   #12 Brad 01:02  |  Rick 05/12/07
      238.   #13 David - nothing to do with academic freedom 01:10  |  Rick 05/12/07
      239.   Soldiers and militants 01:13  |  ChanahS 05/12/07
      240.   campus 01:19  |  Fair 05/12/07
      241.   #4 brnard - no thought police here 01:25  |  Rick 05/12/07
      242.   Ibrahim 01:27  |  Gina 05/12/07
      243.   Ibrahim misses the obvious 01:29  |  Danite 05/12/07
      244.   Teresa maria 01:30  |  danite 05/12/07
      245.   Teresa Tess 236 01:31  |  ChanahS 05/12/07
      246.   #15 IDF don`t just secure the country 01:32  |  Rick 05/12/07
      247.   #18 You have every right to do so 01:34  |  Rick 05/12/07
      248.   Cipora - no, it will not 01:45  |  Mark Lincoln 05/12/07
      249.   Tosefta # 232 01:45  |  Gina 05/12/07
      250.   #60 Richi Beliefs have nothing to do with it 01:46  |  Rick 05/12/07
      251.   Rick from Garland - Texas 01:50  |  Mark Lincoln 05/12/07
      252.   #94 What "hate" ? 01:50  |  Rick 05/12/07
      253.   ChanahS 01:55  |  Gina 05/12/07
      254.   To my friend Yaakov 01:58  |  Rick 05/12/07
      255.   #66 Cipora - what about Jewish profs? 02:04  |  Rick 05/12/07
      256.   Gina, yes I agree... 02:09  |  Ibrahim 05/12/07
      257.   Bad situation, bad approach 02:16  |  Yered Shmuel 05/12/07
      258.   #74 Ka 02:16  |  Rick 05/12/07
      259.   What kind of professors? 02:19  |  dan 05/12/07
      260.   #236 Teresa-Maria 02:20  |  * BEN JABO 05/12/07
      261.   #115 Ben Jabo students with guns were the problem at Columbine 02:24  |  Rick 05/12/07
      262.   Wanted To Say "Hi" To Yaacov Sullivan 02:24  |  Moshe Fitzpatrick 05/12/07
      263.   Colleagues back ANY colleagues regardless of how stupid. 02:25  |  Claudia 05/12/07
      264.   #119 Jacob Blues - more poor reasoning 02:28  |  Rick 05/12/07
      265.   Teresa-Maria (Tess) # 236 02:34  |  Gina 05/12/07
      266.   Mark Lincoln 02:35  |  Rick 05/12/07
      267.   Danite.... 02:36  |  Teresa-Maria (Tess) 05/12/07
      268.   #248, Mark Lincoln 02:44  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 05/12/07
      269.   Ibrahim 02:45  |  Gina 05/12/07
      270.   Danite, 2.... 02:45  |  Teresa-Maria (Tess) 05/12/07
      271.   Apartheid state 02:59  |  Philippe 05/12/07
      272.   #200 The Arab, Your generalizations are sickening 03:06  |  TOMY 05/12/07
      273.   Gina, let`s put some numbers to that... 03:48  |  Teresa-Maria (Tess) 05/12/07
      274.   Sapir College 03:54  |  JL 05/12/07
      275.   Guns in the classroom 04:20  |  Gene Warech 05/12/07
      276.   Cipora - and exactly how many 04:21  |  Mark Lincoln 05/12/07
      277.   Tess, Danite, Peter SM, Tosefta, Mike, et al; 04:37  |  Lynn 05/12/07
      278.   Decency - Equally Aplied to Israelis and Palestinians 05:13  |  deak of deak 05/12/07
      279.   Lynn, quote from the article... 05:36  |  Teresa-Maria (Tess) 05/12/07
      280.   IDF soldiers don`t `strut` with their rifles, Tess 05:47  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 05/12/07
      281.   Sorry Rick, it`s dead on reasoning 05:48  |  Jacob Blues 05/12/07
      282.   Actually Tess, when I went walkabout in Europe 05:52  |  Jacob Blues 05/12/07
      283.   Goldenberg, Jacob Blues - full of hate 05:56  |  Chaim Margalit 05/12/07
      284.   ML: in what way was the soldier `rude`? 06:00  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 05/12/07
      285.   Lynn it states he was carrying a weapon 06:06  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 05/12/07
      286.   Tosefta 06:12  |  Angelique 05/12/07
      287.   Lynn # 277 06:49  |  Philippe 05/12/07
      288.   #259 Dan - You`re reading into this what is not there 07:10  |  Rick 05/12/07
      289.   # 19 Shalom Friedman 07:19  |  Nick Ferriman 05/12/07
      290.   #281 Jacob Blues 07:20  |  Rick 05/12/07
      291.   Well done Hassan for standing up for democracy 07:25  |  Nick Ferriman 05/12/07
      292.   Tess -- Numbers do not matter 07:36  |  Gina 05/12/07
      293.   what if the same happened at Ariel College? 07:39  |  Aviv 05/12/07
      294.   #261 Rick - Texas 07:43  |  * BEN JABO 05/12/07
      295.   #147 Altalena - if all do so, why was he the only student uniform 07:43  |  Rick 05/12/07
      296.   # 166 Margie in Tel Aviv 07:44  |  Nick Ferriman 05/12/07
      297.   #270 Teresa-Maria 07:51  |  * BEN JABO 05/12/07
      298.   #279 Teresa-Maria to Lynn 07:55  |  * BEN JABO 05/12/07
      299.   WRONG 07:57  |  JOJO 05/12/07
      300.   #276 Lincoln (Abe will continue to be ashamed of U 08:01  |  * BEN JABO 05/12/07
      301.   # 204 Dr L Brnd 08:03  |  Nick Ferriman 05/12/07
      302.   Rick #258 08:04  |  ka 05/12/07
      303.   #239 ChanahS Militarisation is not democracy 08:14  |  Nick Ferriman 05/12/07
      304.   re: Yaakov Sullivan 08:16  |  Efox 05/12/07
      305.   soldiers 08:21  |  sweis Melbourne 05/12/07
      306.   #262 moshe fitzpatrick 08:21  |  ka 05/12/07
      307.   re: Jacob Blues 08:27  |  Efox 05/12/07
      308.   re: The Northern Wind 08:30  |  Efox 05/12/07
      309.   #80 Yakov Sullivan 08:32  |  ka 05/12/07
      310.   JL re Sapir College #274 08:45  |  ka 05/12/07
      311.   JL re Sapir College #274 cont. 08:54  |  ka 05/12/07
      312.   # 268 Cipora Julianna Kohn 08:57  |  Nick Ferriman 05/12/07
      313.   What did Nizar Hassan say? 09:16  |  Shtarka 05/12/07
      314.   Nablus & Tul Karam the face of the .. 09:24  |  Akram Zekaria 05/12/07
      315.   Tess -- Numbers do not matter 09:38  |  Gina 05/12/07
      316.   #312 Ferriman - I hope you`ll stick around this time 09:51  |  * BEN JABO 05/12/07
      317.   Nick Ferriman 09:57  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 05/12/07
      318.   To 295. Rick. Humiliation of Jews not Arabs 10:03  |  Altalena 05/12/07
      319.   Dear Cipora Don`t preach ! Discover ! 10:15  |  Akram Zekaria 05/12/07
      320.   ka and his assumptions #309 10:30  |  Yaakov Sullivan 05/12/07
      321.   There is no place for people like Nizar in our society 10:34  |  Alex 05/12/07
      322.   ka and his assumptions, Part II 10:36  |  Yaakov Sullivan 05/12/07
      323.   ben jabbogoldenberg and so many others 10:41  |  Yaakov Sullivan 05/12/07
      324.   to JL re my mails to you 10:55  |  ka 05/12/07
      325.   #295 Rick 11:46  |  ka 05/12/07
      326.   #12, AUSSIE, you forgot to mention his gun 12:05  |  VIPER 05/12/07
      327.   #320 Sullivan 13:25  |  ka 05/12/07
      328.   To Sullivan P art 11 13:43  |  ka 05/12/07
      329.   # 285 Margie in Tel Aviv..LATE,BUT HERE FOR A MINUTE. 16:00  |  JOSH 05/12/07
      330.   # 314 Akram Zekaria 16:23  |  Kathy 05/12/07
      331.   Loony Left 19:32  |  Motic 05/12/07
      332.   #323 TURNCOAT SULLIVAN 21:40  |  * BEN JABO 05/12/07
      333.   #323-2 Poor Ole TURNCOAT SULLIVAN 21:50  |  * BEN JABO 05/12/07
      334.   #326 VIPER - try reading the article SLOWLY 21:55  |  * BEN JABO 05/12/07
      335.   #316 BEN JABO 13:58  |  Nick Ferriman 06/12/07
      336.   #335 Ferriman 16:58  |  * BEN JABO 06/12/07
      337.   #326 VIPER 17:29  |  * BEN JABO 06/12/07
      338.   guns in class 22:13  |  yeastbite 06/12/07
      339.   #338 Maleny - Australia 00:36  |  * BEN JABO 07/12/07
      340.   The Instructor is out of a job 02:50  |  * BEN JABO 08/12/07
      341.   IDF should be penalized 04:36  |  T A Sheppard 19/12/07
     Today Online
    IDF strikes kill at least 11 Islamic Jihad, Hamas militants
    Responses: 453
    Bradley Burston: Killing the Palestinian who wishes you dead
    Responses: 115
    Rosner's guest: The PA's goal is the destruction of Israel
    Responses: 117
    Yoel Marcus: Israel doesn't need a new Vietnam called Gaza
    Responses: 127
    Officials: Israel to allow construction in W. Bank settlements
    Responses: 171
    Rosner's Domain
    Rabin's long memory and the U.S. NIE report on Iran
    The more Jews complain about Huckabee...(What to Read)
    Guest: Leader of the Zionist Organization of America on post-Annapolis Mideast
    Without the Reform movement in Israel, there's no Reform movement


    More Headlines
    03:04 Min. pushes new E. J'lem neighborhood for Jews
    02:52 Argentina: Iran responsible for 1990s bombings at Jewish sites
    04:20 PMO establishes task force to prepare for Bush's visit
    04:44 Analysis / Escalation in Gaza / Anything but an invasion
    01:53 Canadian Jewish tycoon Alex Shnaider buys Maccabi Tel Aviv
    04:42 Olmert vows to continue targeting leaders behind Qassam strikes
    23:34 Shell-shocked troops overlooked by gov't recognized in new law
    03:24 Two Haaretz writers win Sokolow Prize for Journalism
    01:09 Israel expects over 60,000 pilgrims to come for Christmas
    02:13 Treasure-hunting sisters find human remains from Roman era
    Previous Editions
    Special Offers
    Advertisement
    Inbal Jerusalem Hotel
    Unbeatable rates at the Finest hotel in Jerusalem
    Invest in Macedonia
    New Business Heaven in Europe
    Long-term Israel programs
    MASA is your gateway. More programs. More grants.
    Eldan Rent a Car
    Israel's leading car rental company offers you a 20% discount on all online reservations
    Dead Sea Salt
    Beauty and skin care from the Dead Sea. Coupon code HAARETZ for 10% off!
    Junkyard
    Junk a car - get free towing nationwide and a tax-deductible receipt.
    Holiday Inn and Crown Plaza Israel
    Lowest internet rate Guaranteed at ichotelsgroup.com !
    Home| TV| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
    © Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved