Subscribe to Print Edition | Thu., December 06, 2007 Kislev 26, 5768 | | Israel Time: 07:34 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Rosner's Domain
Diplomacy
Defense Jewish World Opinion National
Print Edition
Advertising
Books Arts & Leisure Business Real Estate Easy Start Travel Week's End Anglo File Hanukkah
Satellite imagery of Iran's nuclear facility in Natanz. (AP)
del.icio.us
Digg It!  new
Last update - 09:27 04/12/2007
U.S.: Iran halted nuclear weapons development in 2003
By Yossi Melman, Haaretz Correspondent, Haaretz Service and The Associated Press
Tags: nuclear, U.S., intelligence 

Iran halted its nuclear weapons development program in the fall of 2003 and the program remains on hold, according to a U.S. intelligence assessment released Monday. (Click here to read the report)

"Tehran's decision to halt its nuclear weapons program suggests it is less determined to develop nuclear weapons than we have been judging since 2005," states the summary of the report.

The findings are a change from two years ago, when U.S. intelligence agencies believed Iran was determined to develop a nuclear capability and was continuing its weapons development program.
Advertisement
U.S. intelligence officials pointed to the findings as evidence that international pressure on Iran was working. "It suggests that Iran is susceptible to diplomatic pressure," the official said.

"This is good news in that the U.S. policy coupled with the policies and actions of those who have been our partners appear to have had some success. Iran seems to have been pressured," one of the officials said. "Given that good news we don't want to relax. We want to keep those pressures up."

The National Intelligence Estimate, which represents the consensus view of all 16 American spy agencies, states that Tehran's ultimate intentions about gaining a nuclear weapon remain unclear, but that Iran's "decisions are guided by a cost-benefit approach rather than a rush to a weapon irrespective of the political, economic and military costs," the New York Times reported.

Despite the suspension of its weapons program, Tehran may ultimately be difficult to dissuade from developing a nuclear bomb because Iran believes such a weapon would give it leverage to achieve its national security and foreign policy goals, the assessment concluded.

Director of National Intelligence Mike McConnell decided last month that the key judgments of NIEs should as a rule not be declassified and released. The intelligence officials said an exception was made in this case because the last assessment of Iran's nuclear program in 2005 has been influential in public debate about U.S. policy toward Iran and needed to be updated to reflect the latest findings.

To develop a nuclear weapon Iran needs a warhead design, a certain amount of fissile material, and a delivery vehicle such as a missile. The intelligence agencies now believe Iran halted design work four years ago and as of mid-2007 had not restarted it.

But Iran is continuing enrich uranium for its civilian nuclear reactors. That leaves open the possibility the fissile material could be diverted to covert nuclear sites to make enough highly enriched uranium to make a bomb.

The amount of fissile material Iran has is closely linked to when it can produce a weapon. Even if the country went all out with present enrichment capability, it is unlikely to have enough until 2010 at the earliest, the officials said. The State Department's Intelligence and Research office believes the earliest likely time it would have enough highly enriched uranium would be 2013. But all agencies concede Iran may not have sufficient enriched uranium until after 2015.

Iran would not be capable of technically producing and reprocessing enough plutonium for a weapon before about 2015, the report states. But ultimately it has the technical and industrial capacity to build a bomb, if it decides to do so, the intelligence agencies found.

According to Israel's intelligence assessments, Iran could produce a nuclear bomb as early as 2010. The difference in the American and Israeli assessments is derived not from different information but rather different approaches - Israel focuses on the worst case scenario, while the U.S. approach assumes that, once acquiring the necessary technology, Iran will still have difficulty implementing it in order to produce the bomb.

This national intelligence estimate was originally due in the spring of 2007 but was delayed because the agencies wanted more confidence their findings were accurate, given the problems with a 2002 intelligence estimate of Iraq's weapons of mass destruction program. They also got a late influx of new data that caused changes in their findings.

"There was a very rigorous scrub using all the trade craft available, using the lessons of 2002," a senior official said.

At the White House, National Security Adviser Stephen Hadley said the findings confirm that the risk of Iran acquiring a nuclear weapon remains a serious problem.

"The estimate offers grounds for hope that the problem can be solved diplomatically without the use of force as the Administration has been trying to do," Hadley said. "And it suggests that the president has the right strategy: intensified international pressure along with a willingness to negotiate a solution that serves Iranian interests, while ensuring that the world will never have to face a nuclear armed Iran."

"The bottom line is this: for that strategy to succeed, the international community has to turn up the pressure on Iran with diplomatic isolation, United Nations sanctions, and with other financial pressure and Iran has to decide it wants to negotiate a solution," Hadley added.

Related articles:
  • Study: U.S., Israel should begin planning strike on Iran nuclear sites
  • Bush warns nuclear Iran could spur 'World War III'
  • MI: Iran will cross nuclear threshold by 2009
  • Chronology of Iran's nuclear program
    • Bookmark to del.icio.us
    Hostile environment
    Arab states reject a proposed UN environment center due to inclusion of Israel.
    Poverty report
    A study shows the number of poor asking for food has doubled in the last 5 years.
      1.   Oh darn! 19:42  |  mrmcgoo 03/12/07
      2.   Err, why make this public? 19:56  |  SystemF 03/12/07
      3.   Which officials? Which agency? 19:56  |  Ovadiah ben Avraham 03/12/07
      4.   every week, we hear a different Iran nuclear forcast 19:59  |  Richard S 03/12/07
      5.   LET WORLD INVESTIGATE ISRAEL`S PROGRAM 20:09  |  TrippleJump 03/12/07
      6.   Spin 20:09  |  Misha 03/12/07
      7.   Bush lied once again about intelligence! 20:15  |  MARK 03/12/07
      8.   senior U.S. intelligence officials said Monday? Really! 20:17  |  Manfred 03/12/07
      9.   mrmcgoo 20:17  |  vik 03/12/07
      10.   Livni knew this and accidentally leaked it out. 20:19  |  Mark 03/12/07
      11.   how convenient 20:21  |  tony 03/12/07
      12.   Sounds fishy as it`s almost 2008 20:23  |  Gili 03/12/07
      13.   If True, Time To Lower The Volume 20:30  |  dyinglikeflies 03/12/07
      14.   Iran, the oil giant, and nukes 20:34  |  Mathew 03/12/07
      15.   Good News for Iran 20:34  |  Christian 03/12/07
      16.   Catch-22? 20:37  |  Diznar 03/12/07
      17.   Iran, the oil giant, and nukes 20:40  |  Mathew 03/12/07
      18.   9/11 was an Inside Job, Bin ladin is also dead 20:44  |  Mark 03/12/07
      19.   Frielichs answer 20:45  |  Chris Linthwaite 03/12/07
      20.   Sigh. What will we do for a war now? 20:47  |  Colin Wright 03/12/07
      21.   US says Iran halted Nuke Weapons Dev.in 2003 20:50  |  Millie 03/12/07
      22.   LOLZ @ Israel + US WARMONGERS 20:52  |  POP 03/12/07
      23.   #3, all of them. 20:52  |  Yoni Gross 03/12/07
      24.   Missiles? Check. Bomb design? Check. Enriched uranium? Soon. 20:53  |  David Samson 03/12/07
      25.   MAYBE BUSH IS TRYING TO "DIVEST" 20:56  |  Robert 03/12/07
      26.   To Mathew from Atlanta 21:00  |  Greg 03/12/07
      27.   More American BS 21:00  |  Frank 03/12/07
      28.   To Diznar 21:02  |  Greg 03/12/07
      29.   Time to hold politicians accountable? 21:04  |  Greg USA 03/12/07
      30.   #8 Manfred 21:06  |  Chris Linthwaite 03/12/07
      31.   Who can believe ANYTHING we are told 21:07  |  Clickfool 03/12/07
      32.   " The Fiddlers Fix Is In"! 21:07  |  Stephen. 03/12/07
      33.   #8 Doubting Manfred - Full Text from the Dir. of National Securty 21:08  |  Pablo B 03/12/07
      34.   Boy does this sound familiar 21:15  |  Jerremiah 03/12/07
      35.   #3 Ovadiah - Dir. of Nat. Intel. Mike McConnell 21:16  |  Pablo B 03/12/07
      36.   trust me, I am a politician 21:18  |  Iranian-American 03/12/07
      37.   The US has been wrong twice before 21:20  |  B 03/12/07
      38.   Crap Report 21:23  |  Brod 03/12/07
      39.   Well Well Well 21:24  |  Paul Wood 03/12/07
      40.   #6 Misha - goto the dni website and look at the Full Text 21:32  |  Pablo B 03/12/07
      41.   Do they. don`t they. Will they, Won`t they? 21:36  |  H 03/12/07
      42.   THE GREAT LOSER US INTELLIGENCE 21:37  |  Iskander 03/12/07
      43.   Bomb Iran Anyways 21:44  |  Schlomo Goldberg 03/12/07
      44.   Who is stupider? The US Govt or the press? 21:53  |  Joe Sittizen 03/12/07
      45.   Oh golly, no war with Iran, geez! 21:56  |  ballistic 03/12/07
      46.   #18 Say Mark 21:57  |  ballistic 03/12/07
      47.   Bring Iran Back to the Fold 21:58  |  Jane 03/12/07
      48.   no nuclear program? 21:58  |  yeah right 03/12/07
      49.   How sad for Israel 22:01  |  Michael N 03/12/07
      50.   Iran still looks pretty busy to me 22:04  |  Efox 03/12/07
      51.   Mis - Assesmment ! 22:05  |  Henry 03/12/07
      52.   #9 you`re over the line.... 22:05  |  EA 03/12/07
      53.   re: Mark 22:05  |  Efox 03/12/07
      54.   Halted, really?! 22:07  |  Ari 03/12/07
      55.   Chris Linthwaite 22:12  |  rich 03/12/07
      56.   This report is as stupid and naive !!! 22:19  |  Moshe Benzaquen 03/12/07
      57.   #55 Rich 22:32  |  Chris Linthwaite 03/12/07
      58.   Oh,no! Now we can`t attack Iran and kill thousands! What a big... 22:33  |  Toronto`s Finest 03/12/07
      59.   #56 Relax Moshe 22:35  |  ballistic 03/12/07
      60.   To Moshe Benzaquen 22:36  |  Greg 03/12/07
      61.   See HERE for TEXT OF REPORT 22:37  |  POP 03/12/07
      62.   Bush scares me... 22:39  |  Greg 03/12/07
      63.   It`s all Clinton`s fault! 22:39  |  W 03/12/07
      64.   Oil at 100$ barrel. They make enough money. Why would they halt? 22:43  |  Aounist 03/12/07
      65.   US Intelligence??? 22:43  |  Major R 03/12/07
      66.   This makes Israel and neo-cons look like FOOLS 22:46  |  Wendy 03/12/07
      67.   # 8 Need you ask 22:58  |  Outsider 03/12/07
      68.   nothing but lies 23:00  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 03/12/07
      69.   This is bad news for Israel and warmongers.. 23:02  |  John 03/12/07
      70.   BiN Ladin died. This was reported in 2001 23:06  |  Mark 03/12/07
      71.   #56 Moshe Benzquen 23:09  |  Chris Linthwaite 03/12/07
      72.   The Government Version of 9/11 is a lie! 23:09  |  Mark 03/12/07
      73.   And we all know how good US intelligence is,right? 23:09  |  Nemesis 03/12/07
      74.   This is why people want the truth of 9/11 23:14  |  Mark 03/12/07
      75.   It May Be Up To Israel Alone 23:20  |  Steve 03/12/07
      76.   Regardless of Israel 23:24  |  christoph 03/12/07
      77.   #34 Oh Golly, BULListic is so concerned 23:34  |  * BEN JABO 03/12/07
      78.   Paranoia / part I 23:35  |  Bob 03/12/07
      79.   Paranoia / part II 23:37  |  Bob 03/12/07
      80.   The straw that broke the camel`s back ! 23:42  |  Judah N. Wenkel 03/12/07
      81.   The report is a "GUESSTIMATE" 23:43  |  * BEN JABO 03/12/07
      82.   Ballistic #45 23:43  |  Brod 03/12/07
      83.   Who will be attacked instead? 23:48  |  Tosefta 03/12/07
      84.   #46 FRUITCAKE BULListic 23:49  |  * BEN JABO 03/12/07
      85.   #19 Chris Linthwaite - Congressional Oversight 23:54  |  Pablo B 03/12/07
      86.   to Chris Linthwaite # 30 23:58  |  Judah N. Wenkel 03/12/07
      87.   # 38 brod 00:05  |  Axel 04/12/07
      88.   #1 -- "neocons" not looking for a war 00:07  |  Paul Freedman 04/12/07
      89.   GW Bush and Israel Proven To Be Liars Once Again 00:10  |  Mr. Knowitall 04/12/07
      90.   This was known earlier on but the report is coming out now 00:18  |  lakshmi 04/12/07
      91.   Jane #47 00:21  |  Brod 04/12/07
      92.   Let`s hope they`re right 00:30  |  B 04/12/07
      93.   WTF america is going to let the axis win again 00:34  |  s 04/12/07
      94.   intelligence 00:46  |  Shmuelshachor 04/12/07
      95.   #45..golly day,ballistic...... 00:47  |  Nemesis 04/12/07
      96.   More Breaking News... Keep it Coming 00:47  |  Alex 04/12/07
      97.   Advice to Slowman 00:55  |  Yossi Melman 04/12/07
      98.   TRPPLE JUMP When Israel signs the NPT.Iran HAS signed! 01:11  |  PETER SM 04/12/07
      99.   TO JUSTIFY US COWARDNESS TO ATTACK 01:11  |  indrajaya 04/12/07
      100.   9 Vic - Volunteering? 01:13  |  Mark of Lewiston 04/12/07
      101.   They smell democratic victory... 01:16  |  Jewboy 04/12/07
      102.   How convenient. Don`t believe this report for a minute. 01:19  |  Chaim 04/12/07
      103.   iran 01:21  |  tom 04/12/07
      104.   LINTHWATE Call for bombingOR look at ALL options including dialog 01:25  |  PETER SM 04/12/07
      105.   Brod - Read the NIE 01:28  |  Mark of Lewiston 04/12/07
      106.   Three observations 01:37  |  Mark Lincoln 04/12/07
      107.   Who will be attacked instead? 01:39  |  Tosefta 04/12/07
      108.   #56 Moshe Benzaquen-relax Moshe 01:41  |  Hubal 04/12/07
      109.   How should Haaretz deal with Slowman? 01:45  |  Yossi Melman 04/12/07
      110.   Iran, Nukes 01:45  |  Chaim Gorenstein 04/12/07
      111.   Jane. #47 wise words 01:49  |  Hubal 04/12/07
      112.   ISRAEL + USA just got PWNED!!!!111!!!11!!!!!!1! 01:50  |  POP 04/12/07
      113.   Nuclear Threat from Iran 01:56  |  Ken Bill 04/12/07
      114.   iran halted nuclear weapons dev in 2003 02:06  |  jorge 04/12/07
      115.   US MILITARY AGAINST WAR with Iran 02:07  |  Lynden 04/12/07
      116.   US to Israel: We are out. Take care of yourself 02:08  |  Scientist 04/12/07
      117.   Effective Sanctions. ...... eh? 02:12  |  Iranian-American 04/12/07
      118.   olmert and us on iran response 02:16  |  marcel 04/12/07
      119.   Tosefta playing fool - US knows full well why Syria supports Hez 02:21  |  Jewboy 04/12/07
      120.   98Peter SM,israel not only has nukes,it biological &chemical 02:22  |  lakshmi 04/12/07
      121.   Americans Waking Up 02:22  |  Steven Grumman 04/12/07
      122.   to 116 02:25  |  Steven Grumman 04/12/07
      123.   I told you so! 02:27  |  Joe 04/12/07
      124.   #86 Judah N. Wenkel 02:28  |  Chris Linthwaite 04/12/07
      125.   I guess that means Israel won`t be getting the war that it wants 02:30  |  peacelover 04/12/07
      126.   Iranian-American 02:36  |  schafe82 04/12/07
      127.   to #116.Ozirak all over again 02:39  |  Shmuelshachor 04/12/07
      128.   lakshmi 02:44  |  schafe82 04/12/07
      129.   Splash 02:55  |  jjvanka 04/12/07
      130.   Any left-wing jew-hating idiots actually read past the headline? 02:57  |  Aaron 04/12/07
      131.   PEACELOVER Quote the Israeli government source asking for war? 03:01  |  PETER S .M. 04/12/07
      132.   Israel, just chill, not all Americans are cowards 03:02  |  Another Scientist 04/12/07
      133.   peacelover #125 03:02  |  schafe82 04/12/07
      134.   To Schlomo Goldberg 03:17  |  Persian Kitty 04/12/07
      135.   GO FOR IT ZIONISTS, "CREATE" YOUR OWN VERSION OF REALITY! 03:19  |  PADDY 04/12/07
      136.   To Steven Grumman 03:24  |  Persian Kitty 04/12/07
      137.   so i guess syria was building nukes alone in the bldg. we bombed 03:32  |  yahn goodey 04/12/07
      138.   A GOLDEN OPPORTUNITY FOR IRAN 03:34  |  indrajaya 04/12/07
      139.   Right, Israel`s just the "Neighborhood Bully" 03:39  |  David 04/12/07
      140.   Scientist #116 03:45  |  Brod 04/12/07
      141.   Now, I`d like to point out something here..... 03:48  |  Johnboy 04/12/07
      142.   #124 Linthwaite - you should be the last to talk 03:50  |  * BEN JABO 04/12/07
      143.   Greg #26, next time read the report Einstein 03:52  |  Mathew 04/12/07
      144.   The US Dep`t of States Road Map Blues Rythm 03:59  |  Joseph E . 04/12/07
      145.   Greg the idiot 04:04  |  Mathew 04/12/07
      146.   #110. There`s a simpler answer 04:06  |  ManintheMiddle 04/12/07
      147.   THE USA 04:07  |  Mike Torrengo 04/12/07
      148.   Israel`s running out of excuses to make peace now 04:08  |  Marty McKenna 04/12/07
      149.   These same Guesstimators were responsible 04:08  |  * BEN JABO 04/12/07
      150.   Israeli lobby failed this time 04:09  |  kia 04/12/07
      151.   #5 Tripple Jump 04:11  |  * BEN JABO 04/12/07
      152.   To Matthew re Greg 04:53  |  Persian Kitty 04/12/07
      153.   Myths of our time 04:55  |  ATLAS 04/12/07
      154.   The NEOCONS..must be burning... 04:55  |  ali 04/12/07
      155.   Bomb Iran anyway - Schlomo says 04:59  |  wibism 04/12/07
      156.   #139 DAVID - POOR ISRAEL, ONLY 200+ NUKES OF THEIR OWN! 05:01  |  PADDY 04/12/07
      157.   good sense reigns for a change 05:03  |  margaret 04/12/07
      158.   # 150 kia @ Tehran 05:19  |  Joseph E . 04/12/07
      159.   To Mathew (#145) 05:24  |  Morris Valentine 04/12/07
      160.   PADDY poor Arabs+Iran. Outgun Israel 5:1+ Wmd`s 05:52  |  PETER S.M. 04/12/07
      161.   PADDY create YOUR own reality.Look at the racist Islamic media 05:57  |  PETER S.M. 04/12/07
      162.   What now? 05:57  |  Steve Beikirch 04/12/07
      163.   Poor Lieberman (and Olmert too) 06:01  |  Tosefta 04/12/07
      164.   Persian Kitty 06:04  |  Mathew 04/12/07
      165.   Read the report Manfred 06:15  |  Victor 04/12/07
      166.   TO BEN JABO #151 06:27  |  Steve Beikirch 04/12/07
      167.   TO JOSEPH E. (the plagiarist) #158 06:30  |  Steve Beikirch 04/12/07
      168.   Yes, Work stopped above ground (picture is proof) 06:35  |  Rob 04/12/07
      169.   Israel You Decide! 06:40  |  Yosemite 04/12/07
      170.   154Ali, but you do believe that Iran will have nukes soon? Right? 06:43  |  Rob 04/12/07
      171.   TO DAVID #139 06:45  |  Steve Beikirch 04/12/07
      172.   THE BIG LIE..... 06:51  |  Dagme 04/12/07
      173.   #23 "intelligence available to the US".Intelligence & the US a co 06:56  |  L A 04/12/07
      174.   US model for dealing with Iran will be based on "the evil empire" 07:06  |  martin 04/12/07
      175.   maybe i`m very smart 08:33  |  dani.a 04/12/07
      176.   Iranian-American, and Sanctions beyond the Time/Space continum 09:03  |  Pablo B 04/12/07
      177.   Sure, and Ahmadinejad loves Israel... 09:05  |  Sim 04/12/07
      178.   Needn`t develop; just buy some. 09:18  |  jim 04/12/07
      179.   139 David - The existential threat card 09:19  |  Pablo B 04/12/07
      180.   Hallelujah for war games # 115 09:19  |  Clickfool 04/12/07
      181.   Why they have a nuclear programme 09:21  |  Ben 04/12/07
      182.   LAKSHMI TOXIC weapons don`t just cause" fits".Check Kurd corpses! 09:28  |  PETER S.M. 04/12/07
      183.   Clickfool #31 I agree with you BUT 09:42  |  S 04/12/07
      184.   #166 Beikirch - Why should I tell you ANYTHING 16:46  |  * BEN JABO 04/12/07
      185.   Beikirch - you really shouldn`t call others names 16:48  |  * BEN JABO 04/12/07
      186.   Schafe82 knows all about paranoid schizophrenic 18:51  |  Israeli 04/12/07
      187.   The antisemites are out here in force 18:55  |  Israeli 04/12/07
      188.   #187 OutInForce 20:51  |  jjvanka 04/12/07
      189.   #184 Say Ben Jabo 22:30  |  ballistic 04/12/07
      190.   program freeze 07:28  |  Shmuelshachor 05/12/07
      191.   #189 2ND TRY BULListic aka Fruitcake 09:57  |  * BEN JABO 05/12/07
      192.   #34 Say Ben Jabo 16:46  |  ballistic 05/12/07
      193.   Say Brod 16:51  |  ballistic 05/12/07
      194.   #192 BULListic aka NUTCAKE 22:05  |  * BEN JABO 05/12/07
     Today Online
    Bush to make first official visit to Israel in January to push talks
    Responses: 174
    Zvi Bar'el: Time has come for U.S. to pursue talks with Iran
    Responses: 122
    Rosner: Israel certain Iran is playing tricks on U.S. intelligence
    Responses: 105
    Uzi Benziman: Settlers must back voluntary evacuation bill
    Responses: 76
    Amira Hass: Land grab pushing garbage dumps into PA towns
    Responses: 94
    Rosner's Domain
    A ticket to heaven from Huckabee (WTR)
    Poll: Do you trust the new intelligence on Iran?
    Military option is off the table
    Israel Factor: the panel wants a 'Clinton' but votes Giuliani


    More Headlines
    07:04 Dichter nixes U.K. trip; fears 'war crimes' arrest
    04:31 Court orders state to disclose secrets of citizenship process
    01:19 Hamas: Palestinians will be freed in any Hezbollah-Israel swap
    02:39 Olmert, Livni, Barak to select head of Israeli team for PA talks
    02:46 Polish film recounts heroism of Poles who helped Jews in WWII
    03:01 Undercover IDF unit accidentally kills PA policeman in Bethlehem
    05:54 Excavation near J'lem's Dung Gate unearths ancient mansion
    04:27 Defense Ministry: Negev base okayed without environment report
    02:01 EU honors Kiryat Ata school for Web-based history project
    Previous Editions
    Special Offers
    Advertisement
    Invest in Macedonia
    New Business Heaven in Europe
    Long-term Israel programs
    MASA is your gateway. More programs. More grants.
    Eldan Rent a Car
    Israel's leading car rental company offers you a 20% discount on all online reservations
    Dead Sea Salt
    Beauty and skin care from the Dead Sea. Coupon code HAARETZ for 10% off!
    Junkyard
    Junk a car - get free towing nationwide and a tax-deductible receipt.
    Holiday Inn and Crown Plaza Israel
    Lowest internet rate Guaranteed at ichotelsgroup.com !
    Home| TV| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
    © Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved