Why there was partition - Haaretz

Subscribe to Print Edition

Fri., November 30, 2007 Kislev 20, 5768

Israel Time: 15:45 (EST+7)

web haaretz.com

Back to Homepage

Rosner's Domain

Diplomacy

Defense

Jewish World

Opinion

National

Print Edition

Advertising

Books

Arts & Leisure

Business

Real Estate

Easy Start

Travel

Week's End

Anglo File

del.icio.us

Digg It! new

Last update - 15:14 29/11/2007

Why there was partition

By Alexander Yakobson

Tags: Israel, aliyah

November 29 is an opportunity to recall the reasons underlying the decision of the international community in 1947 to divide the country into two nation-states: a "Jewish State" and an "Arab State," in the words of the partition resolution. The United Nations committee that investigated the subject and recommended partition submitted a detailed report to the UN General Assembly, which in the end was adopted in the famous vote. The report said, among other things:

"It is a fact that both of these peoples have their historic roots in Palestine, and that both make vital contributions to the economic and cultural life of the country [...] The basic conflict in Palestine is a clash of two intense nationalisms. Regardless of the historic origins of the conflict... there are now in Palestine some 650,000 Jews and some 1,200,000 Arabs who are dissimilar in their ways of living and, for the time being, separated by political interests. [...] Only by means of partition can these conflicting national aspirations find substantial expression and qualify both peoples to take their places as independent nations in the international community and in the United Nations. [...] Jewish immigration is the central issue in Palestine today and is the one factor, above all others, that rules out the necessary co-operation between the Arab and Jewish communities in a single State. The creation of a Jewish State under a partition scheme is the only hope of removing this issue from the arena of conflict."

The usual way of finding fault with the concept "Jewish State" is to endow it with a groundless anti-democratic interpretation, and then to claim that the concept is anti-democratic in its essence. But in the Partition Plan, and in its wake in the Israeli Declaration of Independence, a "Jewish State" means a state that realizes the right of the Jewish people to national independence.

	Advertisement

The right of nations to self-determination is accepted as a universal democratic principle, although there are some who want to see this principle as a kind of club with a sign on the door saying "Entry to Jews is Absolutely Forbidden." The Jewish State, according to the Partition resolution, is not supposed to be the state of its Jewish citizens alone: The borders of the state were supposed to include a large Arab minority, and the committee report requires the Jewish state to guarantee this minority full civic equality.

Some claim that the expression "a Jewish and democratic state" is a contradiction in terms; the Partition Plan, on the other hand, asserts that the two states, the Jewish one and the Arab one, must be democratic. Some claim that a Jewish state by necessity requires religious coercion; the Partition Plan obligated the two states to guarantee full religious freedom in their jurisdictions without getting into the complex question about the connection between the Jewish nation and the Jewish religion, or the different but very strong and meaningful connection between Arab nationalism and Islam.

The Israeli Law of Return is attacked as a discriminatory and anti-democratic law. On the other hand, the report of the UN committee in 1947 not only anticipates massive Jewish immigration to the Jewish state after its establishment (and even notes that in order to enable this immigration, the Jewish state was allotted an area relatively larger than the percentage of Jews in the population of the country), but states that the dispute between the two nations on the subject of immigration is the main reason for the need for partition and the establishment of a Jewish state in part of the country.

Partition was supposed to remove the subject of immigration from the arena of the conflict, in other words, to turn it into the internal affair of the Jewish state, while the Palestinian Arabs, in their state, would no longer have to fear that Jewish immigration would turn them into a minority in their homeland. All the principles were therefore determined and formulated in 1947; since then, there is little that is new in the interminable debate on the subject.

Bookmark to del.icio.us


	Do Jews have a say?
	How much influence should Diaspora Jews have over Israel's decision?


	Nixon's nuke concern
	Former U.S. president feared Israeli nukes would spark an arms race.




1.	how can the law of return be undemocratic	19:45	\|	zionist forever	29/11/07

2.	Good Article, scholarly, timely and to point	02:03	\|	Rob	30/11/07

3.	Its not arab land, but Jewish	04:24	\|	David	30/11/07

4.	Partition and peace are not the same	04:41	\|	Michael Jacobs	30/11/07

5.	Ahistorical and foolish	07:42	\|	Grif	30/11/07

6.	David: And Indians from America	08:43	\|	ALGERIAN	30/11/07

7.	Partition in the ratio of 650,000:1,200,000	09:22	\|	JK	30/11/07

8.	Grif from San Fran	11:15	\|	Michael Jacobs	30/11/07

9.	Algerian	15:18	\|	Michael Jacobs	30/11/07

Today Online


	Abbas: Now is the moment of truth for Palestinian statehood
	Responses: 106


	Washington: No place yet for Syria in the peace process
	Responses: 40


	Editorial: If Israel wants to avoid its apartheid epithet, it must halt expansion
	Responses: 64


	High Court orders state to delay power cuts to Gaza
	Responses: 27


	Haaretz.com TV: Gazans using Viagra to alleviate distress
	Responses: 13


	Esther Solomon: Falling for falsehood of Holocaust e-mail
	Responses: 5

More Headlines
15:35 High Court orders state to delay power cuts to Gaza


10:42 Washington: There is no place yet for Syria in peace process


15:20 Prisons Service: No more space to absorb Sudanese refugees


14:04 Barak: I'll quit coalition once I know Labor will win elections


07:57 Romanian Jewish groups, anti-Semites reportedly join forces


03:43 U.S. introduces UN resolution endorsing Israel-PA peace deal


05:13 Report warns against proposal for funding of W. Bank outposts


12:34 Year after cancelled gig, Depeche Mode member makes it to Israel


15:29 Cruise wins award following portrayal of would-be Hitler assassin


12:09 Egyptian police seize half a ton of explosives from Bedouin woman