Report: Wide gaps between test scores in Jewish, Arab schools - Haaretz

Subscribe to Print Edition

Tue., December 04, 2007 Kislev 24, 5768

Israel Time: 21:36 (EST+7)

web haaretz.com

Back to Homepage

Rosner's Domain

Diplomacy

Defense

Jewish World

Opinion

National

Print Edition

Advertising

Books

Arts & Leisure

Business

Real Estate

Easy Start

Travel

Week's End

Anglo File

Hanukkah



		Fifth-grade students taking tests. (Lior Mizrahi)

del.icio.us

Digg It! new

Last update - 18:07 28/11/2007

Report: Wide gaps between test scores in Jewish, Arab schools

By Or Kashti, Haaretz Correspondent

Tags: Education Ministry

The Education Ministry published statistics Wednesday that indicate significant differences between the test scores of students attending Jewish and Arab schools. The statistics were drawn from the Measure of Efficiency and Growth in School standardized tests (Meitzav), which were last given at the end of the last school year.

The average mathematics score for fifth-graders was 56.9 percent last year, while English and technology scores were higher, at around 70 percent. On the language test (Hebrew and Arabic), students from the Jewish sector achieved an average of 79 percent, while the Arab students' average was 60.9 percent.

The report also revealed that one third of the students were unsatisfied with their school, and that 15 percent of them had been involved in various violent incidents.

	Advertisement

The tests were administered in 937 schools to 80,000 students from the second, fifth, and eighth grades. The exams focused on four main subjects- language (the student's mother tongue), mathematics, English, and technology and sciences. In addition, the test evaluated topics related to teachers-student relations, and the "social climate" at the schools.

The scores in the various subjects reveal significant differences between the Jewish and Arab students. For example, the average mathematics test score (which assesses the students' knowledge of natural numbers, simple fractions, geometry, and measurements) was 61.3 percent in Jewish schools as opposed to 45.9 percent in Arab schools. In English, the average score among Jewish students was 74.2 percent compared with 68.6 percent among Arab students. In the sciences and technology test, the scores for the Jewish and Arab students were 72.5 and 60 percent, respectively.

Gaps between males and females
The gap between males and females on the national level was considerably small, according to the statistics, but when each sector was evaluated separately, it emerged that in Jewish schools, females reached higher averages in Hebrew and English than males, but lower in mathematics. In the Arab sector, females reached considerably higher averages than males in all the subjects.

The data also revealed that in each subject and within both sectors, there was a correlation between the socio-economic status of fifth grade students and their academic performance. For example, there is a 10-20 point gap on average on the different tests. The greatest gap was seen on the mathematics test, where students from low socio-economic strata had an average of 44.9 percent, as opposed to 65.8 percent among students from higher socio-economic backgrounds.

With regard to the "school social climate," it was found that two-thirds of the students reported high satisfaction with their schools (higher satisfaction was found with fifth-sixth graders than with seventh- eighth graders), but only 46 percent of them related positive relations with their teachers, expressed through feelings of respect, closeness, and concern. When asked in more detail, only 43 percent of the students agreed with the statement "most of the teachers do not act in a hurtful or offensive manner."

Israel ranks 31 in international reading test
Israeli students ranked in 31st place out of 45 states in an international test which evaluated fourth graders' reading literacy. The test, called The Progress in International Reading Literacy Study (PIRLS), conducted by Boston College, assessed 215,000 fourth-grade students' ability to read both literary and informational text.

The ranking was not much higher than the Israel's previous 2001 ranking.

Russia topped the 2006 PIRLS study, followed by Hong Kong and Singapore
and researchers said students' reading ability in those places had improved dramatically since the last study period in 2001.

The worst performances came from South Africa, Morocco, Kuwait, Qatar,
Indonesia, Iran, Trinidad and Tobago, Macedonia, Georgia and Romania.

"Most of the highest-achieving countries in 2006 showed significant
improvement since 2001," Ina Mullis and Michael Martin, directors of the
Boston College research center that conducted the survey, said in a statement.

Some 40 countries were involved in the 2006 study while the 2001 survey
looked at reading performance in 26 countries, making ranks from five years ago not directly comparable.

Related articles:

2007 budget to perpetuate gaps between Jewish, Arab schools

Education Ministry split over transfer of NIS 50m to Arab communities

Shin Bet will no longer scrutinize Arab educators

Jewish fifth-graders to learn conversational Arabic

Bookmark to del.icio.us


	Muslim about-face
	A key U.K. Muslim group ends its boycott of Holocaust Memorial Day.


	Calling all Aleppo Jews
	Yad Ben-Zvi is calling for the return of centuries-old Aleppo Codex fragments.




1.	Big deal- Jews do better than most outside of Israel too	17:23	\|	Dani	28/11/07

2.	So what is new here. Blame it on the Jews.	18:38	\|	common sense	28/11/07

3.	fascinating	19:15	\|	Shimon	28/11/07

4.	# 2 - agree	20:04	\|	Fares	28/11/07

5.	How did Israeli Arabs compare with Jordanians or Saudi?	20:27	\|	Terry	28/11/07

6.	No. one and nine	22:14	\|	Steve	28/11/07

7.	I bet they do well studying the Koran	22:16	\|	Ron	28/11/07

8.	#10, and yet the Lebanese cannot create one successful country?	22:37	\|	Terry	28/11/07

9.	It`s a worldwide problem	23:11	\|	leo	28/11/07

10.	Why is Haaretz removing posts?	01:01	\|	Terry	29/11/07

11.	Why be proud of these results for either	09:08	\|	Tamar	29/11/07

12.	UK league tables	12:22	\|	Joseph	29/11/07

13.	How they view teachers...	12:25	\|	Motic	29/11/07

14.	Re: How did Israeli Arabs compare with Jordanians or Saudi?	18:44	\|	Katie	29/11/07

15.	They can`t post all the messages people send in for many reasons	04:05	\|	Jason	30/11/07

16.	Terry	20:54	\|	Margie in Tel Aviv	04/12/07

Today Online


	PM: Report on Iran nukes justifies tighter sanctions
	Responses: 218


	Colleagues back Israeli Arab lecturer who threw out soldier
	Responses: 184


	Rosner and Benn: Iran nuke study pulls military option off table
	Responses: 80


	Editorial: Bring home the settlers east of the West Bank fence
	Responses: 82


	Palestinians slam Israeli plan for new E. Jerusalem homes
	Responses: 43

Rosner's Domain

Israel Factor: the panel wants a 'Clinton' but votes Giuliani

Poll: Do you trust the new intelligence on Iran?

The Jewish post denominational reality

Palestine as a disincentive-free zone (WTR)

More Headlines
21:33 American President Bush to visit Israel in January


21:04 Bush: World must continue to pressure Iran despite nuke report


21:05 Olmert: Nuke report on Iran shows need for tighter Iran sanctions


20:05 Pines-Paz: Ethiopians must be allowed a secular education


21:25 Greek far-right historian on trial over allegedly anti-Jewish book


18:11 Palestinians slam Israeli move to build new homes in E. Jerusalem


20:59 Israeli Arab leaders: A Palestinian state is not the solution for us


16:21 PA deploys hundreds of security officers in West Bank crackdown


20:29 Exam shows Israel ranks 39th out of 57 in scholastic performance


16:41 Finance Ministry announces budget surplus of NIS 7.7 billion for 2007