Bush's baby - and ours - Haaretz

Subscribe to Print Edition

Thu., November 29, 2007 Kislev 19, 5768

Israel Time: 16:48 (EST+7)

web haaretz.com

Back to Homepage

Rosner's Domain

Diplomacy

Defense

Jewish World

Opinion

National

Print Edition

Advertising

Books

Arts & Leisure

Business

Real Estate

Easy Start

Travel

Week's End

Anglo File

del.icio.us

Digg It! new

Last update - 10:14 27/11/2007

Bush's baby - and ours

By Yoel Marcus

Tags: peace talks, Israel

Israel's fate does not depend on whether a trip to the United States is successful, Menachem Begin used to say, in the days of the peace process with Egypt. Once, he even called into his office Samuel Lewis, the U.S. ambassador to Israel, and gave him an earful. "Are we a vassal of yours?" he famously asked.

But when Anwar Sadat and Begin landed at Andrews Air Force Base on September 5, 1978, on their way to the Camp David summit, Sadat praised America's involvement. Begin also applauded the U.S. administration as he disembarked from the plane. "The day will come and we will say 'habemus pacem' [Latin for "we have peace"] at Camp David," he said. Later, Begin's aides would join the journalists in singing "Habemus Pacem Aleichem" to the tune of "Heveinu Shalom Aleichem."

Unlike President Carter, a devout Christian from the South who was not a supporter of Israel, and who applied atomic pressure on Begin to give up all of Sinai and its settlements and made him sign a document recognizing the legitimate rights of the Palestinian people, President Bush is a fan - even a groupie - of Israel.

	Advertisement

First Ariel Sharon, and then Ehud Olmert, established close personal ties with him. They embraced Bush's vision of two states for two peoples, and adopted his road map. But the failure of the war in Iraq, the Iranian nuclear threat, the rise of fundamentalist Islam, the spread of global terror, and the growing strength of Hamas in Gaza - all these have dragged Bush down to rock bottom in the U.S. public opinion polls.

Bush's road map has tangled up everything in a knot with its sequential demands: Before commencing permanent status talks, the Palestinians are supposed to halt terror and dismantle the terror organizations, and Israel is supposed to evacuate outposts in the territories. These demands have set the proverbial dog running in circles, chasing its own tail. Sly foxes like Sharon and Olmert have embraced the road map on the supposition that the Palestinians are not capable of ending terror.

Condoleezza Rice is the one who urged Bush to cut this Gordian knot with an international conference attended by the Quartet, the moderate Arab countries, and anyone supportive of peace in the Middle East. The conference thus created sponsorship for the two-states-for-two-peoples solution, a return to 1967 borders, and the creation of settlement blocs based on territorial exchange. Israel, which has always been traumatized by the idea of an imposed solution, received a promise from Bush that the Annapolis summit would only sponsor the talks, and not twist Israel's arm.

The summit in its current configuration, with Syria represented by a deputy minister (half coffee/half tea) has divided the world into good guys and bad guys, and isolated Iran and Hamas. For Bush, that is already a major accomplishment, says Americologist Zvi Rafiah.

As far as the talks themselves are concerned, it is still up to the Palestinians to prove that they're on the side of the good guys. The presence of the moderate Arab states is meant to back up Palestinian Authority Chairman Mahmoud Abbas. That is important not only for Abbas, but also for Israel.

We have never had a president like George W. Bush, and chances are we will never have another. If we reach an agreement, we are not only clinching a deal with Mahmoud Abbas, but with the whole of the moderate Arab world. On the other hand, Israel could find itself under pressure and sanctions from the whole of the international community if it fails to open up and engage in a serious discussion of core issues, as Olmert promised to do a few weeks ago.

It is doubtful that America's next president will be as friendly and supportive as Bush, who can be trusted not to pressure us on issues that compromise Israel's security and survival. So whatever can be achieved we must try to achieve now, while Bush is still at the helm. We are not going to be able to fool all of the people all of the time.

Israel will have to be more flexible in implementing the road map. We will have to give up the sequential order, for example - the idea of first wiping out terror and only then embarking on final-status talks. These two things will have to be done simultaneously.

At the moment, the fact that part of the Arab world has cut itself off from Hamas in Gaza is an impressive preliminary achievement. Olmert's administration is facing its most important challenge yet. Now that Syria has joined, the Annapolis summit is forging a new regional map, with the sons of light pitted against the sons of darkness.

All credit for this remarkable gathering goes to Bush. It's his baby. But the opportunity is all ours - an opportunity that we dare not pass up.

Bookmark to del.icio.us


	Breaking his silence
	The Annapolis summit provoked Iran's president to lash out against Israel.


	Israel's school daze
	Education Ministry data reveal a gap in test scores between Jewish and Arab schools.




1.	Why even bother?	10:43	\|	Natallie Durson	27/11/07

2.	I`m afraid Yoel Marcus got it wrong this time......	10:55	\|	Swiss (Dino)	27/11/07

3.	Natallie #1 is in a panic....	11:02	\|	Esther	27/11/07

4.	BUSH`S BABY: SHARON WAS THE MAN OF PEACE	11:09	\|	indrajaya	27/11/07

5.	our great fortune	12:04	\|	born under bad sign	27/11/07

6.	To Esther: Panic? Ummmm, ok	12:08	\|	Natallie Durson	27/11/07

7.	" Just follow the good guys"!	12:10	\|	Stephen	27/11/07

8.	Swiss (Dino)	12:52	\|	A.M.	27/11/07

9.	#2 swiss	13:01	\|	duncan	27/11/07

10.	If only we had a leader like Begin today	13:06	\|	kobi	27/11/07

11.	Natallie Durson	13:18	\|	Martha Hoelzermann	27/11/07

12.	Swiss Dino	13:24	\|	Martha Hoelzermann	27/11/07

13.	Indrajaya	13:25	\|	Martha Hoelzermann	27/11/07

14.	# 13, MARTHA HOELZERMANN	13:38	\|	indrajaya	27/11/07

15.	# 8 A.M. "The left-right problematic"	13:46	\|	Swiss (Dino)	27/11/07

16.	# 9 duncan	13:51	\|	Swiss (Dino)	27/11/07

17.	# 12 Martha Hoelzermann	14:00	\|	Swiss (Dino)	27/11/07

18.	Bush could care less about Israel.	14:36	\|	Devin Leonard	27/11/07

19.	BUSH WANTS TO SHINE HIS UGLY IMAGE: ABU GHRAIB NOT FORGOTTEN	15:28	\|	TrippleJump	27/11/07

20.	Swiss Dino - Your quote	15:33	\|	Martha Hoelzermann	27/11/07

21.	Indrajaya - Man of peace	15:34	\|	Martha Hoelzermann	27/11/07

22.	# 20 Martha Hoelzermann	16:06	\|	Swiss (Dino)	27/11/07

23.	What a load of garbage	16:26	\|	Gee	27/11/07

24.	bush is as dulplicious as he is stupid	16:33	\|	Yaakov Sullivan	27/11/07

25.	Look how desperate antisemites write in bold letters here	16:37	\|	Fortuna Benmayor	27/11/07

26.	# 21, MARTHA HOELZERMANN	16:54	\|	indrajaya	27/11/07

27.	the Bushes are groupies of Saudies and Arabs...	16:59	\|	felix	27/11/07

28.	ONLY HAARETZ WOULD GIVE MARCUS COLUMN SPACE	17:14	\|	B.Heddim	27/11/07

29.	Response for Natallie #6	17:26	\|	Esther	27/11/07

30.	Swiss Dino - quotes	17:35	\|	Martha Hoelzermann	27/11/07

31.	Re Fortuna #25	17:37	\|	Esther	27/11/07

32.	Yoel Marcus captures the essence of this opportunity	17:37	\|	Smadar	27/11/07

33.	indrajaya	17:42	\|	A.M.	27/11/07

34.	What gives???	17:42	\|	Tarek	27/11/07

35.	Bush`s Baby - and ours	17:52	\|	Ben	27/11/07

36.	"habemus pacem aleichem"	18:40	\|	scallywag	27/11/07

37.	martha and swiss	18:45	\|	scallywag	27/11/07

38.	# 30 Martha Hoelzermann	20:02	\|	Swiss (Dino)	27/11/07

39.	The Deluge	21:24	\|	John Hanks	27/11/07

40.	Next American President	21:28	\|	Seth Goldstein	27/11/07

41.	#16 swiss	22:05	\|	duncan	27/11/07

42.	#16 swiss p2	22:10	\|	duncan	27/11/07

43.	to Martha Hoelzermann #11	22:24	\|	zeev	27/11/07

44.	Response to Mr. Leonard ( #18)	22:52	\|	Tod Zuckerman	27/11/07

45.	The American people and its Congress support Israel	23:23	\|	Democrat	27/11/07

46.	to Ben #35, falsely accusing	01:20	\|	zeev	28/11/07

47.	Bush`s baby	03:11	\|	Delray Kunz	28/11/07

48.	#19, TrippleJump	03:18	\|	Silvienne	28/11/07

49.	Marcus Needs to Learn About Friendship	05:01	\|	MB	28/11/07

50.	#28	06:46	\|	GPWS1	28/11/07

51.	#49	06:57	\|	GPWS1	28/11/07

52.	#48 silvienne	12:55	\|	duncan	28/11/07

53.	Not Returning to the Borders Pre-67	16:09	\|	Barney	29/11/07

54.	US Support For an Enlarged Israel	16:42	\|	Barney	29/11/07

Today Online


	Olmert to Haaretz: Two-state solution, or Israel is finished
	Responses: 170


	Algerian minister: Sarkozy in power thanks to Jewish lobby
	Responses: 84


	Rice said to compare life in U.S. south to Palestinians' plight
	Responses: 51


	Tom Segev: Israel has more to lose than the Palestinians, who've already lost everything
	Responses: 21


	Debate rages on World Jewry's role in peace concessions
	Responses: 46

More Headlines
14:08 Olmert to Haaretz: Two states, or Israel is done for


13:34 Report: Nixon feared Israeli nukes would spur arms race


16:24 Report: Hamas urges UN to rescind decision that made Israel a state


13:41 Report: Rice compares life in U.S. south to Palestinians' plight


15:28 Israel and EU launch talks in Brussels on 'open skies' deal


09:26 Palestinians: Two IAF strikes kill 4 Hamas militants in south Gaza


05:45 Debate rages on World Jewry's role in peace concessions


16:08 Lebanon delays presidential election for sixth time


11:38 Egyptian FM: Arab states will respond favorably to settlement freeze