Subscribe to Print Edition | Sat., January 24, 2009 Tevet 28, 5769 | | Israel Time: 20:36 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
Haaretz Toolbar
Diplomacy
Defense Jewish World Opinion National
Print Edition
Car Rental
Books Haaretz Magazine Business Real Estate Joy of Giving Travel Week's End Anglo File
Londoners marching against Israeli policies in the Palestinian Territories. (Archive)
Last update - 00:00 21/11/2007
U.K. radical left wing sees one-state solution to Israel-Palestinian conflict
By Assaf Uni, Haartez Correspondent
Tags: Israeli-Palestinian conflict 

Over a decade after the Israeli right in effect abandoned the vision of a Greater Israel, the radical left in both Israel and Britain has come to favor the idea with a few essential changes.

On Sunday, London saw the conclusion of a conference on the so-called one-state solution for the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. While pro-Israel groups accused the organizers of staging a provocation aimed at bashing Israel's image, academics from Israel and the Palestinian Authority discussed possible models for the formation of a single state ranging from the Mediterranean to the Jordan River, and maybe even further east.

The conference, which attracted many academics as well as local activists from Palestinian solidarity groups, students and Arab activists, was perhaps the latest stage in a series of projects that have given London its image as one of Europe's most anti-Zionist capitals.
Advertisement
Indeed, the British left's attitude toward Israel has been characterized by warrants for the arrest of Israel Defense Forces officers, boycotts of Israeli products on the part of various trade unions, condemnations of Israel as an apartheid state by churches, and the recent academic boycott initiative.

The latest two-day event, at the University of London's School of Oriental And African Studies (SOAS), attracted no less than 300 people. The participants discussed establishing either a binational state or a "state of all its citizens", or a secular democracy that would include the entire population of the Palestinian Authority plus all the Palestinian refugees.

They also entertained the notion of an Israeli-Palestinian confederation and other creative solutions.

Among the notable guests were Palestinian civil rights activist Omar Barghouti, Israeli historian Ilan Pappe and one of the instigators of the academic boycott, Professor Haim Bereshit. The panel members discussed the status of Palestinians and Israelis in the would-be unified state, relying on historic precedents like South Africa and Northern Ireland.

The conference was organized by the London One State Group  an association of about a dozen Israeli, Palestinian and Jewish students who are studying or have studied in London. The funding, they say, came from ticket sales.

Along with the lofty talk about political theory, visitors could hear radical views on Israel, which was regularly described as "a colonialist power" and "an apartheid state."

In the small conference hall, Zionism was not only a dirty word, but an immoral, inexcusably cruel utterance. "I don't believe the Jewish lie," one Arab representative said.

Yonni Eshpar, a young graphic designer from Tel Aviv who was among the conference's initiators, said that he put the event together because "Israel is a discriminatory and racist country and I am interested in seeing to my children's future." The group's main goal, Eshpar said, was to initiate a discussion of the one-state option.

Explaining why he wanted to include residents of the Palestinian Authority in his proposed "state of all its citizens," Eshpar said, adding "They are the citizens of this land. They were there before us. Besides, the nation-state system has concluded its historical role all over the world, from Singapore through Denmark to Israel."

Pro-Israel groups say that this initiative should not be taken seriously. "Our internal polls have shown that the majority of British people support the Balfour Declaration and the existence of the Jewish state," said Lorna Fitzsimons, CEO of the pro-Israeli organization BICOM, the Britain Israel Communications and Research Centre.

According to Fitzsimons, the one-state initiative which has recently gained popularity in academic circles should not be associated with the academic boycott of Israeli educational institutions.

"How do you propose to deal with the crimes the Israelis are perpetrating in the Occupied Territories?" a female Palestinian student asked panel members at the end of the conference's first day. "Should Israeli military commanders be put on trial for war crimes? Should truth and reconciliation committees be set up?"

It was then that an Israeli student remarked: "Excuse me, but you sound just like the far right in Israel. Are the Israelis not entitled to self-determination? Do Israelis only understand force? This kind of discussion hampers progress, because it fails to recognize the other side.
Bookmark to del.icio.us  
 
Geert accused
Dutch MP behind film on radical Islam says move to prosecute him is political.
Immunity for soldiers
Israel to approve aid for IDF officers accused of Gaza war crimes.
  1.   They are delusional to say the least! 06:00  |  Larry 21/11/07
  2.   Same Old Jackasses 06:20  |  Tod Zuckerman 21/11/07
  3.   the solution 06:44  |  Shmuelshachor 21/11/07
  4.   RETAKE GAZA, W.BANK, DISMANTLE TERROR, PEACE WITHOUT ENEMIES))) 07:07  |  VOICE of MOSHIACH))) 21/11/07
  5.   What a stupid idea 07:24  |  Awake 21/11/07
  6.   ONE -STATE SOLUTION FOR WHOM? 08:24  |  Jordan 21/11/07
  7.   Interfering busybodies 08:44  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 21/11/07
  8.   Who is paying for the cost of this meeting?Lefties?? 08:45  |  PETER S.M. 21/11/07
  9.   naive 09:26  |  a lebanese 21/11/07
  10.   UK radical left is wrong, wrong, wrong.... 09:29  |  Swiss (Dino) 21/11/07
  11.   It`s demographics 09:36  |  Robert 21/11/07
  12.   Instead of promoting real peace 09:36  |  Fawaz 21/11/07
  13.   Fossils 09:36  |  Colin 21/11/07
  14.   UNDER THE BANNER OF STAR OF DAVID? 09:37  |  indrajaya 21/11/07
  15.   the left wing should worry about britain ! 09:43  |  victor hardman 21/11/07
  16.   facts politicians don`t like 09:48  |  Israeli 21/11/07
  17.   If Annapolis fails, one state, without apartheid will result 09:51  |  Ivar 21/11/07
  18.   LIVING IN HARMONY OR LIVING IN HATRED 09:51  |  Jordan 21/11/07
  19.   one-state solution 09:52  |  Ralph 21/11/07
  20.   We are the only guilty one. 10:00  |  Atilla Karagözoğlu 21/11/07
  21.   Argument bait. Not a serious possibility, now or ever 10:06  |  Natallie Durson 21/11/07
  22.   WHY not demonstrate against thousands of Brit.Moslem terrorists 10:12  |  PETER.SM 21/11/07
  23.   LONDON : NOW THE CAPITAL OF EUROSTAN 10:12  |  Anne Gree 21/11/07
  24.   Then, why not a one-state solution for both sides of the Jordan? 10:21  |  Fairplay 21/11/07
  25.   IVAR You are right! Estonia will be fully consulted. 10:21  |  PETER S.M. 21/11/07
  26.   One State Solution? 10:22  |  David Nigel Braham 21/11/07
  27.   Ivar,your apartheid Estland should be dissolved and joined with 10:25  |  Absolute Sweden 21/11/07
  28.   # 23 # THE UK IS PART OF: WWW. EUROSTAN. EU 10:30  |  E.Speranto 21/11/07
  29.   No two-state solution 10:35  |  Realistic 21/11/07
  30.   Natallie Durson 10:38  |  Natallie Durson II 21/11/07
  31.   SHARIA LAW COMING TO A EUROPE NEAR YOU! 10:39  |  WARRIOR 21/11/07
  32.   THE HAND OF G-D WILL DESTROY THESE PEOPLE! 10:40  |  WARRIOR 21/11/07
  33.   INDRAJAYA.UNDER THE FLAG OF ISLAM.22 states not enough? 10:45  |  PETER SM 21/11/07
  34.   India and Pakistan should become one state too 10:51  |  Paul 21/11/07
  35.   They know that they are doomed and want to take us down with them 10:58  |  Judith, Haifa 21/11/07
  36.   Anne Gree`s nasty little diatribe 23 11:02  |  Michael 21/11/07
  37.   one state 11:03  |  yossi 21/11/07
  38.   One State Solution? Hurray!!! 11:13  |  Yohan Dahal 21/11/07
  39.   Is Lebanon a model as one-state solution ? 11:17  |  Gilbert 21/11/07
  40.   # 34, PAUL 11:22  |  indrajaya 21/11/07
  41.   One state or two? 11:25  |  Tarik 21/11/07
  42.   what can I say so I won`t be censored 11:26  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 21/11/07
  43.   Great Britain 11:29  |  Clickfool 21/11/07
  44.   PAKISTAN and Bangaladesh.Just one happy state of Moslem brothers 11:31  |  PETER S.M. 21/11/07
  45.   # 9, naieve 11:31  |  John 21/11/07
  46.   # 6 One State Solution 11:37  |  Edward 21/11/07
  47.   This from a country where they want to split 11:38  |  SystemF 21/11/07
  48.   Hate or stupidity? 11:39  |  deborah 21/11/07
  49.   Love thy Muslim 11:39  |  SystemF 21/11/07
  50.   #18 Jordan 11:41  |  Leroy 21/11/07
  51.   After the demise of communism, these people look for a new agenda 11:43  |  AA 21/11/07
  52.   # 31 Shria Law 11:45  |  Mohammed 21/11/07
  53.   One State Solution? Hurray!!! 11:46  |  Yohan Dahal 21/11/07
  54.   # 34 11:48  |  Hussein 21/11/07
  55.   Ivar writes with delectation about the failure of the Jews 11:56  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 21/11/07
  56.   George Galloway and his left wing facist cronies 11:59  |  Nicole 21/11/07
  57.   One State Solution? Hurray!!! 12:00  |  Yohan Dahal 21/11/07
  58.   # 39 Cipora, very good, I am glad you agree with me.... 12:00  |  Swiss (Dino) 21/11/07
  59.   CFOOL.@36.A series of British Islamic terrorist attacks show that 12:03  |  PETER S.M. 21/11/07
  60.   Failed one states.... 12:08  |  Alon 21/11/07
  61.   AA The "new left" had to find a cause after Vietnam 12:08  |  PETER S.M. 21/11/07
  62.   #40 Clickfool 12:14  |  Sarah 21/11/07
  63.   London Europe`s most anti-Zionist capital? Rubbish. 12:15  |  Michael 21/11/07
  64.   There Is Enough Hypocracy To Go Around 12:18  |  Yaakov Sullivan 21/11/07
  65.   #50 Mohamed 12:19  |  Sarah 21/11/07
  66.   There Is Enough Hypocracy To Go Around Part II 12:27  |  Yaakov Sullivan 21/11/07
  67.   MOHAMED Surveys amongst British Moslems on introduction of Sharia 12:28  |  PETER S.M. 21/11/07
  68.   `Cloud cuckoo land` springs to mind.... 12:31  |  Wilbur Rice 21/11/07
  69.   #60 Alon 12:31  |  Sarah 21/11/07
  70.   Cipora.#42 Humanist, not marxist, and not totalitarian! 12:34  |  Hubal 21/11/07
  71.   #~2 Well said Tom Zuckermam from San Francisco 12:37  |  Peter XM 21/11/07
  72.   #63more from michael and the borders that never were 12:37  |  victor hardman 21/11/07
  73.   Notice what the same groups don`t call for 12:40  |  David Teich 21/11/07
  74.   Fawaz: sense in a sea of nonsense 12:42  |  Wilbur Rice 21/11/07
  75.   Ann gree of London 12:42  |  Paul Wood 21/11/07
  76.   The one state sounds good on paper but is not workable in this 12:44  |  lakshmi 21/11/07
  77.   #28 E. Speranto 12:44  |  Richard of York 21/11/07
  78.   The latest dance repertoire.... 12:45  |  Esther 21/11/07
  79.   Yaacove Sullivan 12:47  |  rich 21/11/07
  80.   #63 Michael 12:47  |  Sarah 21/11/07
  81.   #70 Hubal, Your words prove what CJK said 12:49  |  Uri 21/11/07
  82.   Mohammed in Europe 12:49  |  rich 21/11/07
  83.   # 63 Michael, just curious..... 12:52  |  Swiss (Dino) 21/11/07
  84.   # 28 # UK HAS DONE ISRAEL NO FAVOURS !! 12:53  |  E U R O S T A N. eu 21/11/07
  85.   # 52 Mohammed 12:54  |  Petra 21/11/07
  86.   Victor 72, get over yourself. 12:54  |  Michael 21/11/07
  87.   300 is a non-event and not newsworthy! 13:01  |  redmike 21/11/07
  88.   Israel should share nukes with Hamas who 13:03  |  PALESTINIANPEACELOVE 21/11/07
  89.   Hamas should be put on Trial for war crimes; not Israel 13:18  |  semsem 21/11/07
  90.   Don`t think that Jordan wants One State solution 13:19  |  Laila 21/11/07
  91.   Arrest Eshpar for Treason 13:21  |  Elly 21/11/07
  92.   Laila, # 90 13:37  |  Myself 21/11/07
  93.   to all pal lovers 13:39  |  vladimir 21/11/07
  94.   #89michael the technician knows it aint so !! 13:40  |  victor hardman 21/11/07
  95.   # 89, Hamas 13:41  |  George 21/11/07
  96.   Divorce brings peaqce between disputing parties 13:43  |  Adel 21/11/07
  97.   the antisemitic British 13:48  |  Hilda 21/11/07
  98.   Swiss (Dino) 13:49  |  Dr. Frank 21/11/07
  99.   Uri #81 don`t be shy. 13:54  |  Hubal 21/11/07
  100.   one state solution 13:54  |  rikdil 21/11/07
  101.   TWO STATES:GREATER ISRAEL and JORDAN that,s all we need.. 13:56  |  E U R O S T A N. eu 21/11/07
  102.   Pals can make a small fortune if start with a big fortune 13:57  |  Alan 21/11/07
  103.   NOTE the children.Palestine issue a school holiday in London? 13:57  |  PETER SM 21/11/07
  104.   Left Back in the Formative Years of USSR 14:12  |  Jane 21/11/07
  105.   Keeping it in proportion 14:17  |  Briton 21/11/07
  106.   Excellent, Ms. Durson 14:19  |  Buzaglow 21/11/07
  107.   #103 Peter SM 14:23  |  Chris Linthwaite 21/11/07
  108.   # 107 Dr.Frank 14:51  |  Swiss (Dino) 21/11/07
  109.   ed in ill. 14:59  |  sptz 21/11/07
  110.   U.K. radical left wing sees one-state solution to Israel-Palestin 15:01  |  salladin 21/11/07
  111.   Swiss (Dino) vs. Dr. Frank 15:06  |  Yael 21/11/07
  112.   One state solution 15:06  |  Gene 21/11/07
  113.   94 Vicky Hardman supports Arab majority shock! 15:08  |  Michael 21/11/07
  114.   Michael 86, sorry but Victor is correct and 15:09  |  The Equalizer 21/11/07
  115.   At last 15:09  |  jjvanka 21/11/07
  116.   Who are these people to talk 15:12  |  ARA 21/11/07
  117.   No to 1 state. Pro-Israelis can go and live in Israel too 15:13  |  Tamir Palestine 21/11/07
  118.   # 42 Cipora JK 15:16  |  Lynn 21/11/07
  119.   NOT EVEN NEWSWORTHY 15:18  |  don 21/11/07
  120.   One state solution would only suit 2 third world arab countries 15:20  |  Tamir Palestine 21/11/07
  121.   Equalizer 114 you`ve been living too sheltered a life 15:20  |  Michael 21/11/07
  122.   # 12 Fawaz 15:25  |  Lynn 21/11/07
  123.   One State 15:26  |  Jay 21/11/07
  124.   Chris Linthwaite # 107 It`s An Impractical Idea 15:38  |  Jeff Northridge 21/11/07
  125.   Haaretz scraping the bottom of the barrel to excite readers 15:41  |  Tosefta 21/11/07
  126.   # 108 Swiss 15:43  |  Lynn 21/11/07
  127.   U.K. radical left wing sees one-state solution to Israel-Palest 15:47  |  steve 21/11/07
  128.   ALSO OUR RADICAL RIGHT SEES A ONE 15:48  |  Robert 21/11/07
  129.   22 Moslem states - no protests. 1Jewish state - pandemonium. Why? 15:50  |  common sense 21/11/07
  130.   It`s Clear That They Really Want the ZERO-STATE-SOLUTION 15:51  |  Klaudia 21/11/07
  131.   4 STATES:W.BANK/GAZA/JORDAN/ISRAEL: 15:52  |  Lou Knee 21/11/07
  132.   Indrayagagaga Keeps Talking and Talking and Talking 15:54  |  Tex 21/11/07
  133.   Israeli on America 15:55  |  Lynn 21/11/07
  134.   Natallie Durson: For Once You Are Right! 16:00  |  CHGODMK 21/11/07
  135.   Be Positive!-It is New Thinking 16:01  |  Eleanor 21/11/07
  136.   Just like the debate in the US 16:03  |  W 21/11/07
  137.   Thr criminals telling the victims how to fix themselves? 16:03  |  David Turner 21/11/07
  138.   The Difference of Tarik 16:06  |  Tex 21/11/07
  139.   Support Balfour and Implement the Torah 16:08  |  Kevin 21/11/07
  140.   one state -what the settlers have built in the last 40yrs 16:10  |  SD 21/11/07
  141.   Michael # 86 Provisionally Only 16:11  |  Jeff Northridge 21/11/07
  142.   It seems that this marginal group is the core of 16:15  |  Dr. Frank 21/11/07
  143.   Jane. Non sequiturs #104 16:18  |  Hubal 21/11/07
  144.   one state solution for Belgium ! 16:24  |  17 21/11/07
  145.   DINO - Theological question 16:27  |  17 21/11/07
  146.   `1 state solution` is just a PC way of saying destroy Israel 16:30  |  Steve Randolph 21/11/07
  147.   Won`t Work Because This Thing Reeks Of Hatred For Jews 16:36  |  Yosemite 21/11/07
  148.   UK lefties 16:37  |  Scott 21/11/07
  149.   LondonStan Is already the answer to the Palestinian problem 16:40  |  Pragmatist 21/11/07
  150.   jjvanka # 115 It Would Cause More Problems 16:47  |  Jeff Northridge 21/11/07
  151.   Shocking radicalizm of socalled "accademics" 16:58  |  TOMY 21/11/07
  152.   Great Britain 17:00  |  H 21/11/07
  153.   Non-Zionist solution 17:05  |  Naftali Lavie 21/11/07
  154.   What is the value of an education..... 17:09  |  tz 21/11/07
  155.   As for "Jews" who participate,my personal expe 17:12  |  TOMY 21/11/07
  156.   Selfish and narrow minded 17:14  |  Tor 21/11/07
  157.   Left wing fascism will come to nought 17:15  |  Jake 21/11/07
  158.   You have to either pathologically naive 17:21  |  Mark Littleton 21/11/07
  159.   300 people 17:23  |  Tom C 21/11/07
  160.   # 111 Yael "Dreams and realities......" 17:24  |  Swiss (Dino) 21/11/07
  161.   When Pakistan gives up its independence 17:26  |  Ravi 21/11/07
  162.   300 People Attended - About The Same Percentage 17:36  |  Eli 21/11/07
  163.   jjvanka, and whose going to enforce this nonsense? 17:39  |  Jake 21/11/07
  164.   There should be a bi-national State - with JORDAN! 17:40  |  Lesley 21/11/07
  165.   ONE STATE SOLUTION IS ALREADY HAPPENING! 17:40  |  Ask a Ninja 21/11/07
  166.   EURASTAN VS. JEWLANDIA / Europe vs. the US 17:42  |  Goalie 21/11/07
  167.   #92: Jordan the country (not poster) not interested in 1 State 17:42  |  Laila 21/11/07
  168.   Yonni Eshpar 17:43  |  Simple 21/11/07
  169.   Advice to Slowman 17:45  |  Assaf Uni 21/11/07
  170.   Hubal, simply pathetic 17:49  |  Jake 21/11/07
  171.   Utopia vs. Realism 17:56  |  Ethel 21/11/07
  172.   Moderators - Where is my Message? 17:58  |  Dagma 21/11/07
  173.   #40 Indrajaya who tells half truth 18:04  |  Paul 21/11/07
  174.   inevtitable.. 18:09  |  ravi 21/11/07
  175.   The people in Iran are unhappy 18:16  |  Ethel 21/11/07
  176.   Swiss Dino-hard question 18:25  |  Ibrahim 21/11/07
  177.   300 arabs plus Ilan Pappe, Haim Bereshet - who cares? 18:27  |  Me 21/11/07
  178.   they wouldnt be intilectuals if they didnt have these ideas 18:27  |  zionist forever 21/11/07
  179.   #113 michael has learning difficulties ! 18:27  |  victor hardman 21/11/07
  180.   Foolish, destructive vision 18:38  |  Noam 21/11/07
  181.   ONE STATE IS ONLY SOLUTION 18:40  |  Ali 21/11/07
  182.   To jjvanka # 115 - World Peace? 18:48  |  Dolly 21/11/07
  183.   Jake-116. Simply obtuse. 18:52  |  Hubal 21/11/07
  184.   Ethal; Iran and revolution 18:55  |  Observor 21/11/07
  185.   Lesley- Sure! But! 18:58  |  Observor 21/11/07
  186.   Haaretz scraping the bottom of the barrel to excite readers 18:58  |  Tosefta 21/11/07
  187.   Ibrahim about "reconcilliation" 19:00  |  Yael 21/11/07
  188.   Jane. Non sequiturs #104 19:01  |  Hubal 21/11/07
  189.   Swiss-Dino left wing/right wing 19:09  |  Roger 21/11/07
  190.   Ali Witness Lebanon 19:13  |  Yosemite 21/11/07
  191.   All like a happy Scandinavia - together! 19:17  |  Harald Haaretssen 21/11/07
  192.   To Ali: Pragmatics 19:17  |  CHGODMK 21/11/07
  193.   Ethel # 137 Well Said 19:24  |  Jeff Northridge 21/11/07
  194.   The Only One State Solution would be ..... 19:25  |  Dagma 21/11/07
  195.   300 people go for a stroll/ Desperate aas 19:26  |  Jasmine Murphy 21/11/07
  196.   One state -- for Kosovo/Serbia! 19:28  |  DavidAK 21/11/07
  197.   # 142 Dr. Frank about the British Neo-Socialists 19:29  |  Gil 21/11/07
  198.   Ravi #153 19:30  |  Hubal 21/11/07
  199.   to Ravi - Indian partitiion 19:30  |  SD 21/11/07
  200.   Michael it`s true though you don`t like it 19:30  |  Israeli 21/11/07
  201.   Naftali Lavie 19:45  |  CHGODMK 21/11/07
  202.   # 126 Lynn 19:54  |  Swiss (Dino) 21/11/07
  203.   # 145 17 20:00  |  Swiss (Dino) 21/11/07
  204.   Ali # 181 The Three-State Solution Is The Only Solution 20:05  |  Jeff Northridge 21/11/07
  205.   Ordinary people can get along 20:15  |  Ethel 21/11/07
  206.   Dolly #182 20:18  |  jjvanka 21/11/07
  207.   Vicky Hardman has morality difficulties 179 20:18  |  Michael 21/11/07
  208.   Lesley #164 20:24  |  jjvanka 21/11/07
  209.   Tomy- What was the neme of city you grew up? 20:30  |  17 21/11/07
  210.   USA is not so bad 20:31  |  Ethel 21/11/07
  211.   LINMTHWAITE There were a million people in this march?? 20:45  |  PETER S.M. 21/11/07
  212.   #192 CHGODMK 20:46  |  tbora 21/11/07
  213.   To Ali (One state is the only solution) 20:49  |  Gene 21/11/07
  214.   #23, Anne Gree... 20:49  |  Silvienne 21/11/07
  215.   #36, Michael... 20:51  |  Silvienne 21/11/07
  216.   ALI Look at Lebanon and weep. 20:51  |  PETER S.M. 21/11/07
  217.   Good to see 21:06  |  Jeremiah 21/11/07
  218.   In the mood for dancing 21:06  |  Albert Bakker 21/11/07
  219.   as long as Israel is alive and well... 21:10  |  felix 21/11/07
  220.   Leaving the sanctimonious Europeans out of this, as Zionists the 21:11  |  David turner 21/11/07
  221.   Slowman`s wisdom on skipping posts 21:15  |  Assaf Uni 21/11/07
  222.   94 Victor Hardman - Which Part 21:22  |  Mark of Lewiston 21/11/07
  223.   # 176 Ibrahim 21:27  |  Swiss (Dino) 21/11/07
  224.   # 189 Roger and "the right-wing" syndrom 21:39  |  Swiss (Dino) 21/11/07
  225.   LINTHWAITE.A million people marching in support of one state?? 21:39  |  PETER S .M. 21/11/07
  226.   I agree!!!! One state solution called Israel 21:41  |  Yossi 21/11/07
  227.   The UN - a failure 21:41  |  Ethel 21/11/07
  228.   #42 Cipora, another gem! 21:42  |  S 21/11/07
  229.   The problem affects the region 21:51  |  Ethel 21/11/07
  230.   The two state solution is dead, see Annapolis 21:54  |  Fritz Teich 21/11/07
  231.   LINTHWAITE"Sarkozy paid by Mossad".Your sources for this? 22:02  |  PETER S.M. 21/11/07
  232.   Chris Linthswaite`s million 22:02  |  Cyasher 21/11/07
  233.   #220, S 22:11  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 21/11/07
  234.   Naff off! 22:14  |  Yoav Ben Zakai 21/11/07
  235.   tbora: There Is NO "Palestine" and There NEVER Will Be 22:14  |  CHGODMK 21/11/07
  236.   # 41 Cipora Julianna Kohn.CENSORING SUCH WONDERFUL POST? 22:18  |  Fed-Up 21/11/07
  237.   #207michaels one way ethnic cleansing 22:23  |  victor hardman 21/11/07
  238.   DINO - Albertl was a relativist 22:23  |  17 21/11/07
  239.   Naff Off Part II 22:24  |  Yoav Ben Zakai 21/11/07
  240.   # 130 Klaudia..SOME OF US ARE NOT FOOLED BY THESE LOONIES.. 22:32  |  Kathy 21/11/07
  241.   # 228 S...re:Cipora`s Gem...YES INDEED..I APPROVED MUCH 22:33  |  Fed-Up 21/11/07
  242.   Albert #218 22:34  |  jjvanka 21/11/07
  243.   Chris Linthwaite`s technicolour world 22:34  |  Joe Hill 21/11/07
  244.   Antisemitic hypocrisy and double standards 22:36  |  Daniel Leopold 21/11/07
  245.   #231 Peter SM 22:42  |  Chris Linthwaite 21/11/07
  246.   The Israel plan is the most logical only problem is its not PC 22:46  |  zionist forever 21/11/07
  247.   Fritz Teich-#230 22:57  |  Daniel Leopold 21/11/07
  248.   76 23:00  |  zionist forever 21/11/07
  249.   Chris Linthwaite`s fireworks 23:05  |  rich 21/11/07
  250.   Fritz Teich # 230 The One-State Solution Died 60 Years Ago 23:06  |  Jeff Northridge 21/11/07
  251.   these idiots should condem palestian child abuse instead of Israe 23:15  |  zionist forever 21/11/07
  252.   Haaretz 23:15  |  Yoav Ben Zakai 21/11/07
  253.   Balfour 23:26  |  ibrahim 21/11/07
  254.   #236, Fed-Up 23:27  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 21/11/07
  255.   #113 Say Michel re Paul Harris aka Hardman 23:28  |  ballistic 21/11/07
  256.   # 219 felix..as long as Israel is alive and well... 23:29  |  JOSH 21/11/07
  257.   DINO 23:30  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 21/11/07
  258.   Commenting and Paraphrasing... 23:46  |  Fed-Up 21/11/07
  259.   Commenting and Paraphrasing (Part Two) 23:49  |  Fed-Up 21/11/07
  260.   FAIRPLAY WINNER 2007: ISRAEL AND CROATIA 23:54  |  Swiss (Dino) 21/11/07
  261.   Ibrahim 23:55  |  rich 21/11/07
  262.   A suggestion of sheer ignorance. 00:01  |  Akram Zekaria 22/11/07
  263.   SD 00:13  |  Ravi 22/11/07
  264.   # 249 rich..Chris Linthwaite`s fireworks..YEA HA HA HA HA TO HIM. 00:15  |  JOSH 22/11/07
  265.   Yoav ben Zakai, Amen to that 00:24  |  Jake 22/11/07
  266.   tbora #212, don`t you get tired of yourself 00:25  |  Johnny 22/11/07
  267.   Ali #181, one state solution? Muslims can not live with others. 00:27  |  Johnny 22/11/07
  268.   Fritz Teich # 230 Dead Solutions 00:28  |  Jeff Northridge 22/11/07
  269.   LINTHWAITE probing ties is NOT the same as Paid By is it? 00:30  |  PETER SM 22/11/07
  270.   Why doesn`t Britain allow? 00:33  |  Mark Lincoln 22/11/07
  271.   Ibrahim 00:39  |  markinlondon 22/11/07
  272.   U.K radical left is right about one-state solution 00:46  |  peter 22/11/07
  273.   1 Confederation, Two State Solution like USA 00:51  |  Mark 22/11/07
  274.   Israel builds obstacles to peace. 00:54  |  Maureen Ann 22/11/07
  275.   This state is willing to Include Jews! Progress 00:57  |  Mark 22/11/07
  276.   Ibrahim-#253-Balfour 01:02  |  Daniel Leopold 22/11/07
  277.   Funny how true democrats are called "radical" 01:02  |  peacelover 22/11/07
  278.   Implement The Sanders Peace Plan 01:03  |  Mark 22/11/07
  279.   In a Perfect World, They`re Right.... 01:09  |  B`Galil 22/11/07
  280.   the idea that `arabs` have 22 states and dont need more 01:10  |  african american 22/11/07
  281.   # 173, PAUL 01:19  |  indrajaya 22/11/07
  282.   # 211 Peter SM re:Limpthwaite....Very Limp...A million? 01:20  |  JOSH 22/11/07
  283.   231 Peter SM- re mossad , linthwaite, sarko 01:27  |  17 22/11/07
  284.   There already is a binational state 01:30  |  Peter H 22/11/07
  285.   # 259 Akram Zekaria..A suggestion of sheer ignorance. 01:39  |  JOSH 22/11/07
  286.   The talkbacker #271, I hope he gets traced by authorities 01:39  |  Johnny 22/11/07
  287.   # 271 Montreal peter...what you sod?YOU GAVE ME A SHOCK!! 01:45  |  JOSH 22/11/07
  288.   #257-258, Fed-Up 01:47  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 22/11/07
  289.   # 282 17...OH YOU DO HAVE A LOVELY SENSE OF HUMOUR.. 01:53  |  JOSH 22/11/07
  290.   african american 02:05  |  rich 22/11/07
  291.   What Haaretz are not telling you 02:18  |  Paul Wood 22/11/07
  292.   You flunked your Constitution Course Mark? 02:24  |  Mark Lincoln 22/11/07
  293.   17.He tells lies here all the time".Israel to DEMOLISH churches" 02:24  |  PETER SM 22/11/07
  294.   My post re #171 is aimed at "peter" from montreal noone else 02:35  |  Johnny 22/11/07
  295.   And the baying mob goes quite 02:48  |  Paul Wood 22/11/07
  296.   285# Josh. A question to every fool at the end of this post. 03:31  |  Akram Zekaria 22/11/07
  297.   african american.if Pals deny it to Israel why do they deserve it 03:37  |  PETER SM 22/11/07
  298.   The giberish of INDRAJAYA 03:54  |  No Ordinary Prophet 22/11/07
  299.   NAME OF ONE STATE WILL BE 03:56  |  TOBIA 22/11/07
  300.   What`s the far right have to do with this 04:34  |  D.R. Zukerman 22/11/07
  301.   258# Fed up . 04:46  |  Akram Zekaria 22/11/07
  302.   Paul Wood - Brit Bashing 04:51  |  Mark Lincoln 22/11/07
  303.   Enough Already 05:04  |  Howard 22/11/07
  304.   To African American #280 05:12  |  Jacob 22/11/07
  305.   african american.Out of 1 million Jews living in Arab countries. 05:21  |  PETER SM 22/11/07
  306.   Brits believe in one state, b/c thats what they`ll do 2 Ireland 05:24  |  topanga 22/11/07
  307.   # 202 Swiss......?????????? 05:44  |  Lynn 22/11/07
  308.   #302 Mark Lincoln....by far not even half of it 06:08  |  Lynn 22/11/07
  309.   pora # 42 and Fed-Up # 258/259 06:20  |  Klaudia 22/11/07
  310.   What Arabs call the `Jewish lie` 06:33  |  Chick 22/11/07
  311.   Why must one side always win and then compromise? 06:59  |  Sam 22/11/07
  312.   This is the only practical way forward 07:48  |  Khalil Ishabib 22/11/07
  313.   What Britain does not seem to know........ 09:28  |  Dagma 22/11/07
  314.   For Paul Wood # 291 09:42  |  Clickfool 22/11/07
  315.   Klaudia #309 09:46  |  S 22/11/07
  316.   #315, S 09:57  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 22/11/07
  317.   # 131 # THE VERY BEST SOLUTION 2 STATES ISRAEL and JORDAN 09:58  |  E U R O S T A N 22/11/07
  318.   solution 12:42  |  The Teacher 22/11/07
  319.   # 288 Cipora Julianna Kohn,...WHY DID I NOT? 14:46  |  Fed-Up 22/11/07
  320.   #270 Mark Lincoln 14:49  |  Boycott 22/11/07
  321.   #284 Peter H 14:53  |  Boycott 22/11/07
  322.   One State Solution - Tex 15:36  |  Said 22/11/07
  323.   #93 vladimir 16:05  |  Mart 22/11/07
  324.   # 312 Khalil Ishabib 17:15  |  Lynn 22/11/07
  325.   317#Eurostan.Both you and Lou Knee-103 Are Right 18:42  |  Akram Zekaria 22/11/07
  326.   To Peter SM In Melbourne 18:50  |  african american 22/11/07
  327.   Response to Rich, 19:07  |  african american 22/11/07
  328.   disillusionment can be first step to enlightment 19:43  |  peacemaker 22/11/07
  329.   Retake Gaza etc? 22:41  |  Jon 22/11/07
  330.   Dino 22:44  |  Jon 22/11/07
  331.   One State 22:45  |  Jon 22/11/07
  332.   the best all around and equitable long-term solution! 01:36  |  eric 23/11/07
  333.   To Eleanor, # 135 04:30  |  Saleem 23/11/07
  334.   Reply to 115 jjvanka 04:36  |  Saleem 23/11/07
  335.   Reply to Judith from Haifa 04:50  |  Palestinian Yvette 23/11/07
  336.   Eric."the best all around and equitable long term solution` 06:22  |  Akram Zekaria 23/11/07
  337.   90# Liala. The Palestinians are not Arabs. 06:46  |  Akram Zekaria 23/11/07
  338.   one state! 19:40  |  s 25/11/07
  339.   230: Poor, unoriginal Fritz is back 14:58  |  David Teich 26/11/07
  340.   284: Peter misses it as usual 15:02  |  David Teich 26/11/07
  341.   312: Khalil`s jihadist take 15:08  |  David Teich 26/11/07
  342.   Misunderstood 22:33  |  Jane 26/11/07
  343.   342: Not Misunderstood, lying 15:36  |  David Teich 29/11/07
  344.   U.K. radical left wing sees one-state solution to Israel-Palestin 19:58  |  Julian 17/01/08
  345.   #342, one state solutions everywhere 03:17  |  Johnson 12/02/08
  346.   Lebanon, the poster country for the "one state"solution 03:23  |  Johnson 12/02/08
  347.   Most illogical idea ever 08:33  |  Dafna 17/02/08
  348.   One state solution 13:39  |  Joseph Arellano 09/11/08
 Read & React
UN rights official: Gaza evokes memories of Warsaw Ghetto
Responses: 266
Obama: We will aggressively seek lasting Mideast peace
Responses: 191
Dutch MP behind film on radical Islam: Decision to prosecute me is political
Responses: 119
Israel to approve aid for IDF officers accused of Gaza war crimes
Responses: 125
Shashi Tharoor: India watched in envy as Israel attacked Gaza
Responses: 62