This time, the IDF favors Syria - Haaretz

Subscribe to Print Edition

Thu., November 22, 2007 Kislev 12, 5768

Israel Time: 23:21 (EST+7)

web haaretz.com

Back to Homepage

Rosner's Domain

Diplomacy

Defense

Jewish World

Opinion

National

Print Edition

Advertising

Books

Arts & Leisure

Business

Real Estate

Easy Start

Magazine

Week's End

Anglo File

del.icio.us

Digg It! new

Last update - 09:31 20/11/2007

This time, the IDF favors Syria

By Amir Oren

Tags: Annapolis, Ehud Olmert, Syria

Ehud Olmert is superfluous at Annapolis. And not only superfluous, but detrimental. The substantial gap between the Israeli and Palestinian positions is currently unbridgeable; it is like the "safe passage" between the Gaza Strip and the West Bank - not currently applicable. Diplomatically, there is no marvelous juggling act that only Olmert can perform, because a reasonable and stable deal between nations must be able to stand on its own, independent of the identities of the negotiators. Politically, Olmert's presence at the head of the government harms the chances of obtaining and implementing an agreement. The criminal investigations against him - which are wholesale, as opposed to the retail probes of several of his predecessors - make him "damaged goods," as the Americans say. His motives will always be suspect.

But with or without Olmert, Israel cannot improve either its security or its diplomatic situation by storming the Palestinian front. All the alternatives are bad, from tolerating the ongoing Qassam rocket attacks and the strengthening of Hamas to attacking built-up areas of Gaza - which would be even worse, as it would exact a heavy price and leave the Israel Defense Forces there for a long time, with no effective exit. The General Staff will eventually second the Southern Command's recommendation to launch such an operation, but only when forced to do so by a change in the balance among these alternatives, not because it is seeking a pretext or an opportunity.

It is not only the Egyptians who are to blame for the sieve that their border with Gaza has become. The Americans share the blame, as they have not exerted their full force to solve the problem. After all, it does not really affect them.

	Advertisement

Over the past few months, President George W. Bush has invested great effort, as well as $550 million, in the Merida Initiative, named after the Mexican city that hosted this year's summit of leaders of North and Central America. Bush is trying to block the drug smuggling routes into his country. He understands that the battle will be lost if it begins at Mexico's border with California, Arizona, New Mexico and Texas; it must be waged, financed and made more efficient, including by cleansing armies and police forces of corruption, far away, in the drugs' countries of origin.

In order to block Hamas in the Egyptian part of Rafah or the depths of Sinai, what is needed is a Middle Eastern "Merida Initiative" - even if it is gray, dusty and generally less photogenic than the Bush-Blair-Olmert-Abbas speeches we can expect at Annapolis.

Faced with this feeling of constant siege - which one can survive with a mixture of ease and suffocation, but which it is better to break out of, into a different life - the IDF favors accelerating peace talks with Syria. The calculation is simple and practical: Such a move could sever extremist elements in the Palestinian Authority and Lebanon from external support by breaking the chain that leads from Iran via Damascus to Hezbollah, Hamas and Islamic Jihad.

Events in the Israeli-Syrian theater in recent months have obligated the IDF, and especially Chief of Staff Gabi Ashkenazi, to reconsider the relationships among the permanent and variable elements of the equation.

Ashkenazi, who was GOC Northern Command toward the end of Israel's presence in Lebanon, is known to support an agreement with Syria at the specified price, which in his view is steep, but worth paying in exchange for Israel's national security. As chief of staff, Ashkenazi returned to an army that was afraid of sliding, whether deliberately or accidentally, into war with Syria.

But another factor was suddenly inserted into the complex web: the necessity of coping with the intelligence, operational and diplomatic challenge of what foreign publications have described as Syria's nuclear ties with North Korea. It was like a sniper faced with a nearby enemy who is holding a hand grenade and sitting on a bomb: The goal is to hit only the grenade, not the man, as he is liable to fall on the bomb and set it off, killing them both. Or in this case, to conduct a pinpoint operation against a specific threat while also containing the larger conflict.

After 60 years of fighting, the IDF's top brass does not delude itself that military successes are an end in themselves. Without diplomatic follow-up - "leverage" is the fashionable term - military operations, regardless of whether they succeed or fail, will continue forever. Just as Anwar Sadat leveraged the Yom Kippur War to achieve peace with Jerusalem (and Washington), the General Staff believes that this is an opportune time to leverage the IDF's power to achieve peace with Bashar Assad.

Bookmark to del.icio.us


	The Syrian secret
	The IAF didn't target a nuclear reactor, but something far more vicious.


	In good company
	Study: Young U.S. Jews are most comfortable when surrounded by non-Jews.




1.	either leftists are mad,or rightists are blind	09:59	\|	shalom cruel forum	20/11/07

2.	IDF correct in acknowledging Syria`s essential role	11:07	\|	Ivar	20/11/07

3.	very very risky to give golan	12:15	\|	Dr Eric	20/11/07

4.	MOST PROBABLY THIS IS THE REASON	12:29	\|	indrajaya	20/11/07

5.	that is as big a lie as saying holocaust never happened	12:52	\|	mehmet	20/11/07

6.	#5, mehmet	13:08	\|	Cipora Julianna Kohn	20/11/07

7.	#5 Mehmet, Thank you. A Turk finally admitting that the Holocaust	13:27	\|	Haham me Bat Yam	20/11/07

8.	Headline = Gov`t Appoint Top IDF Brass that Fit Lefties Views	13:38	\|	Joseph E .	20/11/07

9.	#3, Dr. Eric	13:39	\|	Cipora Julianna Kohn	20/11/07

10.	I agree	14:01	\|	JJ	20/11/07

11.	dr.eric and mr.snide	15:10	\|	oz veyal	20/11/07

12.	Golan is Israel for ever	18:38	\|	Rafa	20/11/07

13.	In soccer, often the worst player shoots the goal.	20:20	\|	Fortuna Benmayor	20/11/07

14.	IDF	20:47	\|	P. J. Casey	20/11/07

15.	To Dr Eric (#3)	21:47	\|	Morris Valentine	20/11/07

16.	As usual	22:30	\|	the syrian	20/11/07

17.	Wanted PM and COS with brains and backbone	00:13	\|	Gee	21/11/07

18.	Thank you General Ashdenazi: Syria was always the main issue, 2	02:55	\|	David Turner	21/11/07

19.	This time every time the IDF favors the IDF RIGHT ???	22:00	\|	M. S.	22/11/07

Today Online


	U.S. demands Israel crack down on Iranian pistachio imports
	Responses: 135


	Israel Harel: Time to tell Israel's Arabs they have gone far enough
	Responses: 178


	PA source: Gaps between Israel, PA still great ahead of summit
	Responses: 108


	Report: Syria decided not to attend Mideast peace conference
	Responses: 78


	Study: Young U.S. Jews feel best when around non-Jews
	Responses: 63

More Headlines
21:46 Israel to start gradually reducing Gaza power supply December 2


20:26 Report: IAF knocked out Syria radar during Sept. 6 strike


19:44 Syria reportedly to skip summit, as Haniyeh calls meet 'stillborn'


23:12 Source: Lebanon opposition to skip president election Friday


22:20 German minister: Reparations deal not up for renegotiation


18:24 Ex-defense min.: IDF could have brought Hezbollah to its knees


21:40 Rightist manifesto: Settler evacuation is 'crime against humanity'


21:44 Near 20 mortar shells fired from Gaza over course of Thursday


22:39 Osem recalling snacks containing lead in prize jewelry