Amendment to Basic Law on Jerusalem shakes up coalition - Haaretz

Subscribe to Print Edition

Fri., November 16, 2007 Kislev 6, 5768

Israel Time: 05:32 (EST+7)

web haaretz.com

Back to Homepage

Print Edition

Diplomacy

Defense

Arts & Leisure

Real Estate

Jewish World

National

Advertising

Easy Start

Magazine

Business

Opinion

Rosner's Domain

Anglo File

Week's End

Books

del.icio.us

Digg It! new

Last update - 07:58 15/11/2007

Amendment to Basic Law on Jerusalem shakes up coalition

By Shahar Ilan and Zvi Zrahia, Haaretz Correspondents

tags: Annapolis, Gideon Sa'ar

Officially, the government took no stand Wednesday on the matter of amending the Basic Law on Jerusalem, and the coalition allowed its members to vote their conscience. Most Kadima MKs stayed away. In other words: at least for the preliminary reading, the coalition expressed its blessing more than its objection to the bill seeking, ahead of the Annapolis conference, to hobble the government and prevent it from making concessions in Jerusalem. Six ministers backed the bill. Only Labor's ministers voted against it, including Raleb Majadele, who announced the day before in the same place that Israeli law does not apply to the Temple Mount.

Under the amendment, proposed by MK Gideon Sa'ar (Likud) and 25 other MKs, a majority of 80 MKs would be required to concede any territory or jurisdiction in Jerusalem.

Meretz-Yahad chair Yossi Beilin said that the fact that Sa'ar does not make do with the simple majority of 61 shows that he knows his position has become a minority view. Beilin's statement may be true with regard to the public, but in the Knesset Sa'ar won a large majority of 54 versus 24.

	Advertisement

What was the message Sa'ar sought to convey? "Everyone will know from one end of the world to the other, everywhere - in Ramallah, in Washington, in London and in Moscow - that Israel's Knesset expressed its faith in Jerusalem as the eternal capital that is not in dispute."

Beilin said he is troubled by that self-same message: "This government is not worthy of ruling on this issue if it does not take a stand and tell the opposition, 'Do not bind our hands.' I am ashamed of Israel's position."

What are the odds of this bill passing in first, second and third readings? Slim. This government cannot afford it - Sa'ar presumably remembers that in the next term, he could be in a government that has to give up parts of Jerusalem.

In the hour after the amendment passed, it looked like there was no coalition in the land. One after another, the coalition parties dumped coalition discipline, resulting in a series of defeats for the government in subsequent votes on various bills. This was the coalition's first day of defeats since the winter session opened and Kadima's Eli Aflalo took over as coalition chair.

MK Reuven Rivlin of Likud said in response to Wednesday's events that Wednesdays, when bills go to the plenum for preliminary vote, are days that dismantle coalitions. Rivlin recalled that the Likud under Ariel Sharon took advantage of Wednesdays to topple Ehud Barak's government. When Sharon came to power in 2001, he made a point of sitting in the plenum on Wednesdays, to forestall defections. After three defeats, Prime Minister Ehud Olmert arrived in the plenum and spoke with Shas chairman Eli Yishai. The coalition was reestablished. The defeats stopped immediately.

Bookmark to del.icio.us


	War speculations
	An aide to Sharon says the ex-PM wouldn't have sent ground troops to Lebanon.


	Nuclear inspection
	An IAEA report concludes Iran is generally truthful but still defying UN demands.




1.	HOW MUCH MONEY WAS YISHAI PROMISED TO SAVE THE UNHOLY COALITION?)	09:35	\|	VOICE))))))))	15/11/07

2.	Some idiots are useful and some are not	11:15	\|	Natallie Durson	15/11/07

3.	Jerusalem is not for sale!	11:17	\|	Avraham	15/11/07

4.	Natallie Durson, one of the non-useful idiots	12:00	\|	Yaakov	15/11/07

5.	Jerusalem at what price?	05:18	\|	Mel	16/11/07

Today Online


	Minister Lieberman: PA must recognize Israel as Jewish state
	Responses: 177


	Tom Segev: Germany should pay as long as even one Holocaust survivor still lives
	Responses: 102


	Aluf Benn: U.S. wants Israel to get used to the Iranian bomb
	Responses: 173


	Haaretz.com TV: Hebron settlers taped abusing Palestinians
	Responses: 94


	Aide: Sharon wouldn't have sent ground troops into Lebanon
	Responses: 76

Rosner's Domain

Between Tehran and Des Moines

Americans expect to stay in Iraq (WTR)

Poll: Should Israel "get used" to the Iranian bomb?

Rosner's Guest: A revolution in the Orthodox synagogue

More Headlines
04:41 Russia to Israel: Syria will take part in Annapolis


04:42 IAEA: Iran was cooperative with UN nuclear probe, but still defying demands


04:44 U.S. says will push for new Iran sanctions despite UN report


04:47 U.S. court rules against Orthodox Jew in privacy case


04:24 E-mail snub to Israel by Prince Charles' aides results in furor


05:26 Man cleared of causing suicide of prof who wrote of 'Jewish conspiracy'


22:14 Palestinian billionaire launches movement to rival Fatah, Hamas


23:50 Hamas to release Fatah supporters detained after Gaza rally


02:47 Jerusalem tax, city employees arrested for taking bribes


04:48 Friedmann bill to limit High Court on defense, diplomacy