Driver's seat / Who needs an electric car anyway? - Haaretz

Subscribe to Print Edition

Mon., January 14, 2008 Shvat 7, 5768

Israel Time: 09:39 (EST+7)

web haaretz.com

Back to Homepage

Rosner's Domain

Diplomacy

Defense

Jewish World

Opinion

National

Print Edition

Advertising

Books

Arts & Leisure

Business

Real Estate

Easy Start

Travel

Week's End

Anglo File

Last update - 22:50 14/11/2007

Driver's seat / Who needs an electric car anyway?

By Avi Bar-Eli

Tags: Israel, environment

During the last two weeks, we seem to have been under the spell of the Vision. Namely, the Vision of the Electric Car. It's become almost messianic in its purported powers.

Hail ye, hail ye, electric car: We do not question your merits, we stand in awe of the innovation while, at the same time, we calculate on a napkin just what its economic potential might be, not to mention its contribution to the environment, to society, to world peace. Hail ye!

Yesterday we learned that our ministers in government have hastened to worship at the altar. Any day now fisticuffs will break out in cabinet over who will have the privilege of heaping the most benefits on the electric car initiative, and outshine his or her rivals in government. One suggests completely removing the import tax on electric cars. Another delivers a blow by proposing to relax various regulations, the sort of regulatory relief that the real estate market and infrastructure sector have been seeking for decades. Hail ye, o car!

	Advertisement

But have any of them slammed on the brakes to ponder what economic benefits Israel - or the world - might stand to gain, in practice, from encouraging people to buy the beasts?

Recently the Transport Ministry initiated a study on the cost of traffic congestion. The study aims to quantify the number of lost work hours, following a similar research project in the United States. The American study delivered a number: a loss of $70 billion a year to the economy as a consequence of traffic jams. Israel also has several catastrophe-scenario forecasts suggesting that the country's infrastructure will be unable to handle the growing number of cars used in its metropolises.

Has anybody actually checked how this gauzy vision of electric cars is supposed to solve the dreadful problems we are expected to face? Or why, in an era when the emphasis is on mass transportation, the state is striding backwards and insisting on promoting yesterday's vehicle, instead of tomorrow's?

Has anybody considered how much more smog 1,000 electric cars will have caused in 10 years' time, compared with the amount of smog we could have been spared if people eschewed these conveniences and traveled by train? The state is prepared to waive the tax on electric cars, but perhaps instead of doing that, it should waive the import tax on buses.

The answer is, that beneath the cloak of optimistic words, there are hidden facts that we choose to forget. We preferred to focus on the gimmick. No one asks by just what authority the state has chosen to mobilize its powers for the benefit of this initiative, as opposed to hundreds of others equally worthy of support.

With all due respect to the initiative of Shay Agassi and Idan Ofer, a wave of public support orchestrated by a well-oiled public campaign shouldn't dictate economic and strategic policy for Israel. And of course, neither this nor any other initiative can be exempted from the principals of good governance.

Bookmark to del.icio.us


	Iranian rhetoric
	Iranian boats threaten, so the U.S. candidates step up rhetoric.


	A new citizen
	Israeli pianist Daniel Barenboim takes Palestinian citizenship




1.	Winners and loosers.	00:22	\|	Colin	15/11/07

2.	better tech than the electric cars	04:02	\|	diego	15/11/07

3.	Electric Cars Will Only Be Practical When Electricity is Nuclear	05:55	\|	Efox	15/11/07

4.	Public transport (in Israel) is bullshit	08:52	\|	Yakov	15/11/07

5.	200 kg battery for 200 km drive??	09:03	\|	S	15/11/07

6.	what type of car	09:32	\|	David	15/11/07

7.	AGAIN!!! THE ELECTRIC CAR WILL ONLY BE	10:02	\|	Robert	15/11/07

8.	FROM # 1 TO # 5 ARE ALL RIGHT, QUESTION:	10:06	\|	Robert	15/11/07

9.	Commuting	10:15	\|	Susan	15/11/07

10.	To #3 Efox	10:17	\|	Susan	15/11/07

11.	Hybrid cars	10:22	\|	Susan	15/11/07

12.	MY PREVIOUS MAIL GARBLED	10:40	\|	Robert	15/11/07

13.	MY PREVIOUS MAIL GARBLED #2	10:46	\|	Robert	15/11/07

14.	MY PREVIOUS MAIL GARBLED #3	10:54	\|	Robert	15/11/07

15.	To Susan and Yakov	12:25	\|	Colin	15/11/07

16.	To Robert	08:39	\|	Sam	14/01/08

Today Online


	Zvi Bar'el: The Arabs should stop whining
	Send response


	Akiva Eldar: We must help Abbas, not invade Gaza
	Send response


	Yossi Sarid: Nice things in U.S., which would do Israel well
	Responses: 118


	Gideon Levy: Time for PM to oust refusers of peace in government
	Responses: 87


	Haaretz.com TV: Gaza parents can't join their sick children in Israel
	Responses: 184

More Headlines
08:45 Sources: Barak, settlers reach deal on outposts


08:20 IAF strike kills three Palestinian militants near Gaza City


09:36 Haaretz probe: Shin Bet count of civilian deaths in Gaza is low


07:07 Court to hear petition against segregation of sexes on buses


08:44 Court won't issue back-to-work orders for striking lecturers


08:51 PM 'unworried' by Lieberman's threat to leave gov't over peace talks


03:45 Families lament ignorance of Lamed Heh's heroic sacrifice


03:50 PM aide: We'll fire rabbis who refuse to recognize legitimate converts


02:17 Diskin to MKs: Hamas managed to smuggle $100 million into Gaza


04:30 Cops: Mistaken identity behind attacks on elderly millionaire