Subscribe to Print Edition | Sat., September 06, 2008 Elul 6, 5768 | | Israel Time: 01:41 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Haaretz Toolbar
Diplomacy
Defense Jewish World Opinion National
Print Edition
Car Rental
Books Haaretz Magazine Business Real Estate Easy Start Travel Week's End Anglo File
Last update - 10:48 13/11/2007
VIEWPOINT / 'Israel Lobby' book may have sinister impact in U.K.
By Dave Rich
Tags: anti-Semitism, British Jewry 

John Mearsheimer and Stephen Walt's campaign to expose the power of Washington's Israel lobby through the promotion of their book, "The Israel Lobby and U.S. Foreign Policy," has now completed its tour of Britain, with more sinister consequences than they perhaps realize.

The two professors are adamant that they bear no hostility to Israel, and that both Israel and America would benefit from the removal of the lobby's control over their relationship. Their concern for Israel's wellbeing will be appreciated by its citizens, but what should we Brits make of them?

This is not an incidental question. "The Israel Lobby" was first published in the London Review of Books, and Britain has a strong and vigorous anti-Zionist campaigning movement, which has managed to persuade several British trade unions to support a boycott of Israeli goods. Mearsheimer and Walt may have written about America, but their book leaves its imprint on Britain.
Advertisement
The professors have strongly rejected the frequent accusation by their critics that they are merely mainstreaming the core idea of modern anti-Semitism: that Jews, in whatever form, conspire to control governments, provoke wars and so on. They insist that the Israel lobby in America is "only doing what other special interest groups do, but doing it very much better."

The problem on this side of the Atlantic is that British politics lacks anything approaching the American system of openly declared political lobbies; a similar, AIPAC-style operation in Westminster would not just influence policy, it would also subvert fundamental democratic mechanisms.

This has not stopped people from making similar claims about pro-Israel influence in Britain. In 2003, Labour MP Tam Dalyell claimed that former prime minister and party leader Tony Blair was unduly influenced by a "cabal of Jewish advisers."

More recently, Liberal Democrat peer Baroness Tonge claimed that "the pro-Israeli lobby has got its grips on the Western world... its financial grips." Those who assume that Zionism has a global reach and unlimited power cannot but assume that what they now "know" - thanks to Mearsheimer and Walt - is done in Washington must have its equivalents in London, Paris and elsewhere.

So the might of Jewish organizations is inflated, conspiracies imagined, to fill the gap between the reality of a Jewish community trying to do its best for Israel, and the fantasy of politicians and prime ministers bowing their knee to the power of the almighty Lobby.

And what does this power consist of? The most recent evidence presented concerns a debate that was held at the Oxford Union in October, on the question "This House believes that one-state is the only solution to the Israel-Palestine conflict."

To argue for the motion, three well-known advocates of the Palestinian cause. And to argue against it, amongst others, Norman Finkelstein, author of The Holocaust Industry and Beyond Chutzpah, and hardly known as a supporter of Israel. When several people informed Luke Tryl, the President of the Oxford Union, that Finkelstein was not normally considered an advocate for Israel, Tryl withdrew the invitation, sparking the predictable claims that this was evidence of the lobby silencing one of Israel's critics.

How do Finkelstein's supporters know that the Israel lobby was behind Tryl's change of mind? Because Tryl, in an email to Finkelstein, revealed that, "Many people expressed concern that the debate as it stood was imbalanced and people felt that as someone who had apparently expressed anti-zionist sentiments that you might not be appropriate for this debate. I tried to convince them otherwise but was accused of putting forward an imbalanced debate and various groups put pressure on me. I received numerous emails attacking the debate and Alan Dershowitz threatened to write an Oped attacking the Union. What is more he apparently attacked me personally in a televised lecture to Yale."

Had Finkelstein originally been billed to speak for the motion, nobody would have objected and the debate would have gone ahead as planned; as in fact happened at the Union in May of this year, when he spoke, ironically enough, for the motion that "This House believes the pro-Israeli lobby has successfully stifled Western debate about Israel's actions." He has already been invited back for 2008. Three invitations to the Oxford Union in two years: so much for being "stifled." Finkelstein made his name writing about the finances of Holocaust compensation. (He should try getting a book about Saudi funding for terrorism past the British libel courts to really feel what it means to be silenced.)

In Britain at least, Israel gets more media coverage than any other ongoing overseas story. The case against Israel is frequently aired in the mainstream media and debated at the conferences of Britain's biggest trade unions. The idea that critics of Israel are in any way gagged is absurd. Yet British anti-Zionists see themselves as holders of a hidden truth, struggling against a mighty and terrifying conspiracy to silence them, and now they have confirmation from the highest levels of American academia. If there is a Jewish conspiracy, it is remarkably ineffective.

Dave Rich is Deputy Director of Communications at Community Security Trust, a U.K. organization for the defense of British Jewry.
Bookmark to del.icio.us  
 
Playing with fire
Sarkozy warns Iran it risks Israeli strike on nuke program.
Our own desert island
Israel tries to lure 'Big Brother' type U.S. reality TV series.
  1.   David`s surname alone`d suffice for Brit dumbasses 16:24  |  Absolute Sweden 12/11/07
  2.   mearsheimer & walt 16:32  |  Shmuelshachor 12/11/07
  3.   British Already Have Enough Problems... 16:40  |  Yosemite 12/11/07
  4.   If the Jewish people would only understand...... 16:48  |  Swiss (Dino) 12/11/07
  5.   Anti-semitism 16:53  |  Jan Elshout 12/11/07
  6.   STEPHEN WALT IS A GENIUS 17:17  |  indrajaya 12/11/07
  7.   Another example 17:38  |  Jack 12/11/07
  8.   It is all very true...no need to debate, just look 17:39  |  American 12/11/07
  9.   swiss (dino) and jan elshout 17:40  |  scallywag 12/11/07
  10.   Gnom from Zürich,Dino,from the country controlled by the Jews 17:44  |  Absolute Sweden 12/11/07
  11.   Waltscheimer preaching to Choir 17:48  |  APS 12/11/07
  12.   Certain circles in Britain are infected with neo-socialism and 17:49  |  Dara Fura 12/11/07
  13.   Cabal of Gentiles 18:00  |  jpudentain 12/11/07
  14.   RE: #5 18:11  |  Staas 12/11/07
  15.   indrajaya - that`s very revealing.... 18:24  |  scallywag 12/11/07
  16.   # 9 scallywag 18:28  |  Swiss (Dino) 12/11/07
  17.   PRE GERMANY WW2 18:34  |  EREZ 12/11/07
  18.   # 10 absolute Sweden, not too many "Gnoms" in Stockholm.... 18:36  |  Swiss (Dino) 12/11/07
  19.   #7 Jack 18:42  |  Boycott 12/11/07
  20.   Poor anti-Israel campaigners victimzed by Jewish cabal 18:43  |  Izik 12/11/07
  21.   indrajaya,you getting to be a more sofisticated 18:45  |  TOMY 12/11/07
  22.   #4 Swiss, Jewish people understand it very 18:57  |  TOMY 12/11/07
  23.   #4 Swiss, Jewish people understand it very 18:58  |  TOMY 12/11/07
  24.   Imagine if in the US a large % of Congress was Arab 18:59  |  Oh gosh! 12/11/07
  25.   Gnom from Zürich offuscates unproportional Swiss control of money 19:16  |  Absolute Sweden 12/11/07
  26.   # 22 / # 23 TOMY, you can be influential and "nice"..... 19:38  |  Swiss (Dino) 12/11/07
  27.   To # 6 indrajaya. Stephen Walt was not convincing 19:44  |  L A 12/11/07
  28.   Dino (Swiss) 19:50  |  Joe Slovo 12/11/07
  29.   # 25 Absolute Sweden, how envious can you get up there.... 19:51  |  Swiss (Dino) 12/11/07
  30.   swiss (dino) again 20:13  |  scallywag 12/11/07
  31.   Critics of Israel in US don`t get supressed... 20:24  |  Raymond from DC 12/11/07
  32.   Israeli Lobby Book 20:42  |  P. J. Casey 12/11/07
  33.   # 30 scallywag 20:43  |  Swiss (Dino) 12/11/07
  34.   Israel Lobby in Britain? 20:43  |  Arik Silverman 12/11/07
  35.   Your "Arguments" are Not Convincing 20:48  |  APS 12/11/07
  36.   # 4 Swiss...excuse me? 20:50  |  Lynn 12/11/07
  37.   scallywag of Germany 20:53  |  Lynn 12/11/07
  38.   # 29 Swiss... CAIR is just as bad 20:57  |  Lynn 12/11/07
  39.   Gee Swiss Dino, your words of help sound like someone offering us 21:05  |  Jacob Blues 12/11/07
  40.   It`s amazing that for those in the know, how poorly the book... 21:11  |  Jacob Blues 12/11/07
  41.   Bravo #31; as for #4 21:20  |  D.R. Zukerman 12/11/07
  42.   #39 Jacob Blues 21:35  |  Boycott 12/11/07
  43.   # 36 Lynn 21:38  |  Swiss (Dino) 12/11/07
  44.   # 39 Jacob Blues 21:51  |  Swiss (Dino) 12/11/07
  45.   oh please 22:24  |  dan 12/11/07
  46.   Like a jealous bastard the Gnom from Zürich can`t 22:50  |  Absolute Sweden 12/11/07
  47.   This British anti-Zionist doesn`t think so 22:58  |  Clickfool 12/11/07
  48.   poor israel, porr israel`s friends 23:03  |  GOLARA HAMZEH 12/11/07
  49.   Jewish lobby and Britain 23:09  |  Fed UP 12/11/07
  50.   Conclusions R Us 23:12  |  D.R. Zukerman 12/11/07
  51.   Not really Boycott, my argument is based on reading their work 23:22  |  Jacob Blues 12/11/07
  52.   # 39 Jacob Blues, by the way...... 23:28  |  Swiss (Dino) 12/11/07
  53.   #47 the yellow streak speaks up for gerald of wilson fame 23:31  |  victor hardman 12/11/07
  54.   I would not call it a sinister impact 23:33  |  christa 12/11/07
  55.   Zionist use of the word `sinister` 23:53  |  Chanalau, Tova 12/11/07
  56.   One man,one vote,one time.democracy Hamas style 00:37  |  PETER SM 13/11/07
  57.   CFOOL."This British anti-Zionist doesn`t think" just conspiracies 00:46  |  PETER SM 13/11/07
  58.   #51 Jacob Blues 00:56  |  Boycott 13/11/07
  59.   Jan Elshout - antisemitic prejudice 01:05  |  Michael Jacobs 13/11/07
  60.   # 46 Absolute Sweden, don`t worry, I don`t even know.... 01:06  |  Swiss (Dino) 13/11/07
  61.   Rich Comment 01:07  |  Shay Duffy 13/11/07
  62.   Victor Hardylaman, why call Clickfool yellow streak 47? 01:21  |  Michael 13/11/07
  63.   Nothing sinister except the activities of the Lobby. 02:08  |  Labhras 13/11/07
  64.   Mearsheimer`s book 02:11  |  KAHN 13/11/07
  65.   authors get more attention in UK proves AIPAC control and bias 02:26  |  0 Degrees! 13/11/07
  66.   Absolute Sweden are you a Jew? 02:38  |  Semite 13/11/07
  67.   Finkelstein for a 2 states solution 05:22  |  Nic 13/11/07
  68.   Jan Elshout - Do you have a prejudice? 05:48  |  Michael Jacobs 13/11/07
  69.   Comment 67 12:16  |  Dave Rich 13/11/07
  70.   Lies of Zionists 15:58  |  Martin 13/11/07
  71.   Jews who are critical of Israel are true jews 17:12  |  Nic 13/11/07
  72.   Nic - War is the first purpose 18:49  |  Michael Jacobs 13/11/07
  73.   Dave Rich #69 19:25  |  Brad Brzezinski 13/11/07
  74.   who wants to eradicate ? 19:36  |  Nic 13/11/07
  75.   Nic - Zero obligations 00:42  |  Michael Jacobs 14/11/07
  76.   Your view is interesting 05:03  |  Nic 14/11/07
  77.   walt and mersheimer are german descent 05:18  |  Nic 14/11/07
  78.   #77 Nic Mel Gibson was generalizing too much 10:50  |  Traude 14/11/07
  79.   mearsheimer and Walt 19:34  |  traps 24/11/07
  80.   Possible Israel Lobby in the UK 15:42  |  Steve 02/12/07
  81.   Gnom from Zurich 07:51  |  ingrid 07/03/08
  82.   to #2: Read the book... 13:38  |  Katlin 13/06/08
  83.   Finkelstein fees 17:11  |  Chris 13/06/08
  84.   Incorrect about Finkelstein 22:41  |  Matthew Rosen 13/06/08
  85.   This is absurd of course 18:47  |  Bitin Dawg 05/09/08
 Read & React
Rosenblum: Israeli leaders want to be Obama
Responses: 21
Pfeffer: Jewish Agency has signed its own death certificate
Responses: 71
Greenberg: The hero on flight 11
Responses: 20
Nasrallah: We still seek fallen guerillas' bodies
Responses: 71
Top IDF officer: Israel not prepared for next war
Responses: 56
Chabad envoy to Alaska: Palin staunch friend of Jews
Responses: 59


More Headlines
17:46 Peres and Abbas: We are closer than ever to peace
16:25 Hamas' Meshal agrees to pass Noam Shalit's letter to Gilad
16:25 Israel okays arms transfer to Palestinian Authority
23:10 Israeli hacker arrested in Canada for $2 million online fraud
23:17 Palestinians clash with IDF as Israel limits entry for Ramadan
19:18 Why was airing of 1st Palestinian soap opera cancelled?
18:26 Jewish World / The language of anti-Semitism
20:53 VIDEO / Nasrallah: Freeing Shaba won`t stop struggle against Israel
01:25 Chabad envoy to Alaska: Palin staunch friend of Jews
14:27 McCain takes swipe at Bush, pledges to recover Americans' trust
16:26 France mulls EU mission to help Palestinian security forces
08:39 Top IDF officer: Israel not prepared for next war
13:17 VIDEO / Police detonate device allegedly aimed for target of Bat Yam shooting
10:08 Nir Barkat campaign first to pursue Anglo constituents in Jerusalem
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
Fattal Hotel Chain
Perfectly located hotels on best resorts of Israel.
JMG your online solution
Jewish Singles Personal Ads
Find the love of your life on JDate.com
MBA in Israel in English
APPLY NOW! Limited spaces available
Israel's Premier Real Estate Website
www. israel-property.com
Hebrew Summer courses
From $39.95
ISRAEL BONDS Build Israel
Israel bonds - a multi-purpose way to celebrate Israel's 60th
Eldan Rent a Car
Israel's leading car rental company offers you a 20% discount on all online reservations
Junkyard
Junk a car - get free towing nationwide and a tax-deductible receipt
Home | TV | Print Edition | Diplomacy | Opinion | Arts & Leisure | Sports | Jewish World | Underground | Site rules |
Real Estate in Israel | Travel to Israel with Haaretz | Hotels Israel | Restaurants Israel | Tourist attractions Israel | Shops Israel
birthright Israel | Search engine marketing
Haaretz.com, the online edition of Haaretz Newspaper in Israel, offers real-time breaking news, opinions and analysis from Israel and the Middle East. Haaretz.com provides extensive and in-depth coverage of Israel, the Jewish World and the Middle East, including defense, diplomacy, the Arab-Israeli conflict, the peace process, Israeli politics, Jerusalem affairs, international relations, Iran, Iraq, Syria, Lebanon, the Palestinian Authority, the West Bank and the Gaza Strip, the Israeli business world and Jewish life in Israel and the Diaspora.
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved