Subscribe to Print Edition | Wed., February 25, 2009 Adar 1, 5769 | | Israel Time: 00:39 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
Haaretz Toolbar
Diplomacy
Defense Jewish World Opinion National
Print Edition
Car Rental
Books Haaretz Magazine Business Real Estate Joy of Giving Travel Week's End Anglo File
Pensioner Affairs Minister Rafi Eitan. (Alon Ron)
Last update - 00:00 10/11/2007
Germans irate over initiative to reopen Holocaust reparations deal
By Anshel Pfeffer, Haaretz Correspondent
Tags: Holocaust, Israel 

A recent Haaretz report, outlining Israel's demand to reopen the 1952 reparations agreement with Germany, sparked outrage among German officials over the weekend.

Minister for Pensioner Affairs Rafi Eitan, who is in charge of the talks with Germany on reparations for Holocaust survivors and retrieving Jewish property, told Haaretz he intends to discuss the matter with the German finance minister when he comes to Israel in two weeks' time.

The German media gave wide coverage to Eitan's initiative.
Advertisement
German Finance Minister Peer Steinbrueck's spokesman on Saturday issued a statement saying that the German official has no intention of discussing the topic during his upcoming visit, despite the fact that Eitan has already submitted a request to meet with him.

Eitan told Haaretz that the original reparations agreement, the Luxembourg Agreement, did not take into account many issues relating to Holocaust survivors and should therefore be reopened. That agreement stipulated that Germany would give Israel $833 million in money and merchandise, and Israel would look after the survivors, who would not be permitted to sue Germany directly.

A state comptroller's report on the treatment of Holocaust survivors, released this past August, said that in the 50 years between 1954 and 2004, the government had spent some $3.5 billion on the survivors, more than four times the sum transferred by Germany.

"We see Germany as responsible for the Holocaust survivors," Eitan told Haaretz. "The agreements with them had many holes. Nobody estimated the high cost of the last stage of life in the modern era, or that people would live at least ten years longer on average than they did in the 1950s."

The Luxembourg Agreement also failed to take into account the arrival of many additional survivors to Israel. "Nobody thought that 175,000 Holocaust refugees from the former Soviet Union would come to Israel," Eitan said. "That changed the entire picture, even if the Germans aren't interested."

An agreement between the Israeli government and survivors' organizations, which the cabinet approved earlier this week, provides for payments and benefits to survivors totaling NIS 2 billion over the next three years. The government undertook to finance the plan, but now expects Germany to contribute its share.

Over the last four months, while government officials were negotiating the agreement with survivors' representatives, Prime Minister Ehud Olmert and other ministers said in closed forums that Israel ought to ask Germany to cover the increased payments. However, this is the first time a minister has said so publicly.

The German weekly Der Spiegel reported last week that Eitan sent a letter to German Chancellor Angela Merkel in August, demanding that Germany waive an Israeli debt of 500 million euros, after which Israel would deposit this money in a fund dedicated to survivors' needs. The German deputy finance minister rejected the idea, and Eitan told him: "So just give us the money," Der Spiegel reported.

Eitan responded that he did not make demands of Germany, and that this was merely one of many ways in which Germany could finance the survivors' stipends.

Sources in the Ministry for Pensioner Affairs said that Accountant General Yaron Zelekha was the one who thought of waiving the debt.

The Foreign Ministry is concerned that Eitan's demands might damage the delicate relations between Israel and Germany. "I never denied that my approach is problematic, but it's based on facts and the truth," Eitan responded. "I'm acting for the good of Holocaust survivors."

"It's not enough to work with one minister or another," Eitan said. "We told the Germans that we must set up a professional team to examine the issue in a professional way."

A senior German Foreign Ministry source told Haaretz that Germany would accept some of the Israeli demands, and that Merkel had instructed officials to handle the matter "sympathetically." However, the German treasury wants to avoid setting a precedent by reopening the reparations agreement.

Eitan is convinced that "ultimately, Germany will agree to the demands. They have their own 'treasury boys,' as we do, who guard the public coffers; they're right from their point of view. They're doing their job, and I'm doing mine."

More Jewish World news and features
Bookmark to del.icio.us  
 
A mandate for peace
Peres tells new Knesset to reach peace deal by end of term.
Drunken U.S. policy
Obama should start his Mideast policy slowly - after all, the region isn't going anywhere.
  1.   You had to expose yourselves??? 20:59  |  Amir 10/11/07
  2.   Ashamed 21:10  |  Nathaniel 10/11/07
  3.   I would be, too... 21:20  |  democrat 10/11/07
  4.   Lesson one on how to make people hate you 21:33  |  Never Learn 10/11/07
  5.   Jews: Annoying people for 2000 years 21:37  |  Ad Man 10/11/07
  6.   Jews and money 22:54  |  Ahmed 10/11/07
  7.   Dier Yassin, Sabra&Shatila, Jenin, Nablus 22:58  |  Nanni 10/11/07
  8.   The Naqba survivors 23:00  |  Refugee 10/11/07
  9.   Great Material for the Anti-Semites of the world 23:05  |  howard 10/11/07
  10.   The guilt trip wears out 23:06  |  Mark Lincoln 10/11/07
  11.   Ahmed, your people cry all the time, has your race no shame? 23:16  |  Doron Katz 10/11/07
  12.   response to nani 23:16  |  rikdil lopez 10/11/07
  13.   Response to those upset with this 23:19  |  Reuben Jacobs 10/11/07
  14.   This is not a Jewish trait 23:20  |  Garba 10/11/07
  15.   Refugee # 8 23:26  |  ChanahS 10/11/07
  16.   Are You Willing to Compensate The Palestinians 23:44  |  William J 10/11/07
  17.   Repeated proposal 23:48  |  Frank 10/11/07
  18.   # 5 Ad Man: Jews annoying people for 3000, not 2000 years 00:01  |  Max Zinger,P.Chimist 11/11/07
  19.   Israel passes the buck 00:23  |  Steve 11/11/07
  20.   Rafi Eitan Must be taking his cue from this: 00:31  |  Veritas 11/11/07
  21.   to# 16 00:31  |  Levi 11/11/07
  22.   To #17 00:34  |  Levi 11/11/07
  23.   Ask for more money 00:41  |  JJ 11/11/07
  24.   The shame is... 00:45  |  Esther 11/11/07
  25.   Germans got rich of us 01:05  |  Sheldon B. 11/11/07
  26.   Palestinian Compensation? Hahaha 01:44  |  Awake 11/11/07
  27.   William #16 02:11  |  judith 11/11/07
  28.   Reopening Reparations Deal 02:16  |  Walt 11/11/07
  29.   When will you learn... 02:26  |  Friend of Israel 11/11/07
  30.   # 2 don`t be ashamed 02:33  |  Alex 11/11/07
  31.   Pay, Pay, Pay 02:44  |  Morrie 11/11/07
  32.   An Holocaust arithmetic lession for idiots like Nanni #7 03:05  |  Dr. L. Brnd 11/11/07
  33.   What about the free subs Germany gave Israel? 03:23  |  Tim 11/11/07
  34.   Max Zinger,P.Chimist: Hyperbole won`t save the day 03:30  |  Ad Man 11/11/07
  35.   Hindus: Bringing light to the world for 5,000 years 03:31  |  Buddha 11/11/07
  36.   Hindus: Bringing light to the world for 5,000 years 03:31  |  Buddha 11/11/07
  37.   Jews can`t stick to an agreement when money is concerned 03:34  |  Aaron 11/11/07
  38.   Germany framed 03:37  |  Joe Hill 11/11/07
  39.   The Jews repeatedly create the conditions to their awful plight 03:37  |  mw 11/11/07
  40.   The Jews repeatedly create the conditions to their awful plight 03:37  |  mw 11/11/07
  41.   The Jews repeatedly create the conditions to their awful plight 03:37  |  mw 11/11/07
  42.   Germans irate? 04:11  |  Axel 11/11/07
  43.   Embarrassed 04:20  |  Michael 11/11/07
  44.   nobody asked my opinion; but i`m talking anyway... 04:53  |  eric 11/11/07
  45.   Reparations 05:36  |  Matthew Houston 11/11/07
  46.   Sheldon B. #25 -- and offensive comments 10:21  |  democrat 11/11/07
  47.   eric 20:56  |  sweis Melbourne 11/11/07
  48.   hey Melbourne 17:31  |  edgar 13/11/07
  49.   this is so annoying 23:51  |  dp 24/02/09
 Haaretz Hot Topics
Israel 2009 election results: Voter breakdown
Israel goes to the polls
Conflict in Gaza
Israel vs. Hamas
Iran: Nuclear and regional ambitions
More Headlines
23:16 'Syria built missile facility on nuclear site bombed by IAF'
21:19 Gaddafi: Israel, not Sudan, to blame for crisis in Darfur
20:36 Peres tells new Knesset to reach peace deal by end of term
23:47 Officials: U.S. to pull most troops out of Iraq within 19 months
23:58 Syrian envoy to meet U.S. diplomat in sign of thaw in relations
21:10 BOI chief rejects Netanyahu offer to be finance minister
22:33 'You guys just don't understand'
23:06 Openly gay MK submits bill to legalize civil marriages
22:26 Abbas frees 42 Hamas prisoners ahead of reconciliation talks
19:42 Hamas says it reserves right to bring arms into Gaza
20:36 Olmert pledges Israel still making every effort to free Shalit
21:54 Jerusalem: No plans yet to raze Arab homes in area designated for park
21:35 State Department: Special U.S.-Israel ties will no doubt stay strong
15:02 Amos Gilad hunts politicians and rides them to the top
11:46 Teen suspected of killing hundreds of cats in various 'murder scenarios'
20:26 Gaza tensions force spectator ban at Israel-Sweden tennis match
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
Spring Specials-Dan Hotels
Jerusalem from 179$. Tel-Aviv from 223$. Herzliya from 336$
Dead Sea Skin Care
Quality cosmetics from the Dead Sea. Coupon code HAARETZ for 12% off!
Summer in Israel
Israeli style - Tzofim Chetz V'Keshet 2009
Passover Vacations
The BEST Passover Vacations around ? Mexico, Arizona and Florida
Camp Kimama Israel 2009
The best place for your children this summer
Eldan Rent a Car
Israel's leading car rental company offers you a 20% discount on online reservations
Jewish Singles Personal Ads
Find the love of your life on JDate.com
Junkyard
Junk a car - get free towing nationwide and a tax-deductible receipt
Home | TV | Print Edition | Diplomacy | Opinion | Arts & Leisure | Sports | Jewish World | | Israel 2009 election results
Site rules | Makom: Engaging on Israel | Search engine marketing
Haaretz.com, the online edition of Haaretz Newspaper in Israel, offers real-time breaking news, opinions and analysis from Israel and the Middle East. Haaretz.com provides extensive and in-depth coverage of Israel, the Jewish World and the Middle East, including defense, diplomacy, the Arab-Israeli conflict, the peace process, Israeli politics, Jerusalem affairs, international relations, Iran, Iraq, Syria, Lebanon, the Palestinian Authority, the West Bank and the Gaza Strip, the Israeli business world and Jewish life in Israel and the Diaspora.
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved