ANALYSIS: Winograd report to expose system failures, nothing personal - Haaretz

Subscribe to Print Edition

Mon., November 05, 2007 Cheshvan 24, 5768

Israel Time: 08:51 (EST+7)

web haaretz.com

Back to Homepage

Print Edition

Diplomacy

Defense

Arts & Leisure

Real Estate

Jewish World

National

Advertising

Magazine

Week's End

Business

Opinion

Rosner's Domain

Anglo File

Books

Travel

del.icio.us

Digg It! new

Last update - 02:48 05/11/2007

ANALYSIS: Winograd report to expose system failures, nothing personal

By Ze'ev Segal, Haaretz Correspondent

tags: Winograd, Second Lebanon War

The Winograd Committee's response to the High Court of Justice on Sunday constitutes the first official announcement that its final report on the Second Lebanon War will include no personal findings, conclusions or recommendations.

The panel based this decision in part on its conclusion that the failures it uncovered stemmed from policies adopted by many different people over many years, as well as from "organizational cultures, society's ethos and the political culture," thus making it difficult to assign personal responsibility. It therefore decided to focus its final report instead on systemic problems. And since no individual will be hurt by its conclusions, it argued, there is no need to allow any individual to study the evidence or cross-examine witnesses, as such rights are traditionally accorded only to those who are liable to suffer personal harm from a probe.

The committee is relying on the precedent set by the Shamgar Commission, which investigated the 1994 shooting in Hebron's Tomb of the Patriarchs. That panel sent no warning letters, granted no individuals a right of response and published no personal conclusions or recommendations; like the Winograd Committee, it chose this route because it saw the shooting as stemming from the acts of many people over many years, and viewed its main task as making systemic recommendations in order to prevent a recurrence.

	Advertisement

That stance is legitimate, though unusual: Most inquiry committees have issued personal conclusions as well as systemic ones, believing that personal conclusions are necessary to make it clear to the public just how seriously senior officials have deviated from proper norms of behavior.

But for the Winograd Committee, this stance presents a unique problem: The Commissions of Inquiry Law - whose principles the committee has accepted, though they do not formally apply - states that an individual can be denied a right of response only if "nothing in the investigation could harm him." But the Winograd Committee's partial report included scathing criticisms of several individuals; thus these individuals could legitimately argue that they have already been harmed. And even senior army officers who were not mentioned by name could still argue that the partial report's conclusions about the army's failures were damaging to them. The Shamgar Committee, in contrast, never issued a partial report.

Thus the question of whether senior officers have already been harmed by the partial report is likely to be at the heart of the court's decision on whether to require the committee to issue warning letters and to grant a right of response, as army defense attorneys are demanding.

Related articles:

Military Advocate General to ask for freeze of Winograd report

Lebanon war probe accuses Olmert of 'severe failure,' blasts Halutz, Peretz

Winograd to court: War report won't include personal findings

Winograd Committee to publish final war report by end of year

Bookmark to del.icio.us


	Academic freedom
	The High Court has challenged strict IDF criteria for the entry of Palestinian students.


	Rapping rabbi
	British Jewish rapper MC Rebbe is a finalist in the world's largest blog competition.




1.	Fluffy Wordy Useless Winograd Report	07:37	\|	Irate Israeli	05/11/07

2.	The army versus Winograd	08:43	\|	Esther	05/11/07

Today Online


	Court challenges criteria for Palestinian student entry to Israel
	Responses: 132


	Turkey seeks right to build monument in Jerusalem's Old City
	Responses: 172


	IAF strikes kill four Palestinians after Qassams hit Negev
	Responses: 268


	Leftists scuffle with supporters of Rabin's assassin outside jail
	Responses: 131


	Olmert: Core issues are on the agenda for Annapolis summit
	Responses: 226

Rosner's Domain

* NY's Bloomberg: No rational case for bombing Iran

* Rosner's new Guest: Women's perspective on the Torah

* The genes that make Jews smart (What To Read)

* AIPAC trial: Bring on the top government officials

More Headlines
08:36 PM to free more Palestinian prisoners ahead of summit


08:10 Military Advocate General to ask for freeze of war probe report


08:14 Israeli Arabs get rare chance to see legendary singer Fairuz


08:11 Beitar J'lem soccer fans boo Rabin before draw with Maccabi Haifa


08:23 Foreign Ministry gains access to raw military intelligence reports


05:45 Study: Dry winter days mean more urban air pollution


03:45 Israeli businessmen to demolish oldest hotel on Vegas Strip


02:48 ANALYSIS: Winograd report to expose system failures, nothing personal


04:08 Official: Telling family Dawit's body was found might have risked deal


06:08 Civil Service suspends dismissal of pregnant employee