Subscribe to Print Edition | Mon., November 05, 2007 Cheshvan 24, 5768 | | Israel Time: 20:15 (EST+7) web haaretz.com   Back to Homepage Print Edition Diplomacy Defense Arts & Leisure Real Estate Jewish World National Advertising Magazine Week's End Business Opinion Rosner's Domain Anglo File Books Travel

High Court justices conducting a hearing Sunday on the Winograd war probe report. (Tess Scheflan / Jini) del.icio.us Digg It!  new Last update - 10:45 05/11/2007 Military Advocate General asks court to freeze war probe report By Amos Harel and Yuval Azoulay, Haaretz Correspondents tags: Second Lebanon War  The office of the Military Advocate General (MAG) asked the High Court of Justice on Monday to halt the publication of the Winograd Committee's final report on the failures of the Second Lebanon War until a ruling is issued on the right of response for Israel Defense Forces officers who stand to be harmed by the report. The probe committee informed the High Court on Sunday that its final report will not contain findings, conclusions or recommendations about individuals, obviating the need for sending out warning letters to individuals who might be harmed by its contents. "The committee members reached the conclusion," the Winograd Committee said in its letter to the court, "that the most appropriate route is not to include personal matters in the final report." This is the first time the committee has declared its intentions in this regard. Advertisement About two months ago the committee promised the High Court to send warning letters to any individuals who might be harmed by findings, conclusions or recommendations in the final report. Later, the chairman of the committee, retired judge Eliyahu Winograd, announced that the committee had decided to accelerate its work and to publish the final report before the end of 2007, a decision that would have consequences for the report's contents. On Sunday, however, in its response to High Court appeals by the MAG and the Movement for Quality Government, was the first time the committee explained that decision. A senior source in the MAG said Sunday that the committee was evading its promises to allow those who might be harmed by the report to appear before the committee, to question witnesses and the like. "Even if the committee's findings will refer to systemic and not personal failures, it will be clear who was behind them. They must be granted the right to defend themselves." In its announcement to the High Court, the war probe committee wrote that "the extent of the issues and the large amount of material that has piled up on the committee's table led it to the conclusion that the wider the scope of the examination, and the more it becomes clear that the failures that were revealed were an issue of policy and of judgment over time on the part of various people during various periods, and that the failures resulted from organization cultures, from social ethos and from political ethos, the more the issuing of personal findings, conclusions and recommendations misses the original point of the committee." "It is not appropriate," the letter said, "to focus on a small number of present-day office holders and not to deal with all of the office holders over the years." According to the committee, "the argument that the very nature of the committee obligates it to arrive at personal conclusions or to make personal recommendations must be rejected." The committee's letter added that "it would appear that the MAG has completely crossed the line. We wish to settle accounts with the MAG for arguing that we do not intend to honor the High Court's ruling. What is the foundation for this harsh and unrestrained conclusion? We were not aware that the MAG has supernatural powers and can predict the future ... There is nothing left to do but to conclude that the entire purpose of the petition is to attempt to undermine the public trust in the committee and to throw a monkey wrench into its work." According to a statement issued Sunday by the IDF Spokesman's Office on behalf of the MAG, "The committee's response, with all due respect, ignores the main point - the committee's promise to the court and the MAG to indicate the manner in which the right of response and examination [of evidence] will be given. The committee did not indicate why the right will not be given. The MAG very much respects the committee, and we regret the committee's responses. The [MAG's] petition is based entirely on explicit obligations undertaken by the committee, and to our regret it is not clear why it is no longer keeping them." Related articles: Lebanon war probe accuses Olmert of 'severe failure,' blasts Halutz, Peretz Winograd to court: War report won't include personal findings Winograd Committee to publish final war report by end of year Bookmark to del.icio.us Academic freedom The High Court has challenged strict IDF criteria for the entry of Palestinian students. Rapping rabbi British Jewish rapper MC Rebbe is a finalist in the world's largest blog competition.   1.   The final evidence of how Israel has changed 03:56  |  Mark Lincoln 05/11/07   2.   MILITARY AND OLMERT IN BED TOGETHER 07:41  |  WARRIOR 05/11/07   3.   report 07:51  |  colin 05/11/07   4.   It all makes me ill 10:45  |  Proud Israeli 05/11/07   5.   Evading by all means the truth. 17:35  |  H.H.M 05/11/07   6.   IDF Has No Moral Right to Request a Freeze 18:11  |  Tod Zuckerman 05/11/07   7.   It is quite clear 18:41  |  Kris 05/11/07   8.   to Proud Israeli 19:09  |  dovale 05/11/07

Today Online Lebanon: Reported Hezbollah exercise 'probably simulation' Responses: 147 Akiva Eldar: Question of when, not if, Mideast goes nuclear Responses: 33 PM slams 'violent brutes' of Beitar J'lem who booed Rabin Responses: 96 Abbas: Aiming for peace deal before Bush leaves office Responses: 102 Rosner's Domain * Mayor Bloomberg: No rational case for bombing Iran * Guest: Childbirth, menstruation and rape in the Torah * Poll: A "regional peace settlement" before Bush leaves office? * AIPAC trial: Bring on the top government officials More Headlines 18:53 PA surrounds Nablus camp in pursuit of Al-Aqsa gunmen 18:29 Abbas: Aiming for peace deal before Bush leaves office 16:40 Hezbollah: Maneuvers held near border in 'response to enemy' 19:01 Arab delegates meet in Syria for talks on reviving boycott of Israel 18:59 Rock concert planned at site of former Nazi death camp cancelled 11:31 PM: I'm Beitar fan, but I detest violent brutes who booed Rabin 17:07 IDF thwarts Palestinian teen's plan to stab soldier in Hebron 14:06 Cop impersonation of reporters in arrest raid raises ire of Ch. 2 18:02 No deal in high-level talks to end professors' strike 12:29 Extremist Eskin arrested, suspected of wiretapping Lieberman 20:14 Meshal: Annapolis summit a U.S. ruse meant to distract from war vs. Iran Previous Editions Select Day 04 nov 02 nov 01 nov 31 oct 30 oct 29 oct 28 oct 26 oct 25 oct 24 oct 23 oct 22 oct

Special Offers Advertisement learn Hebrew online with israel's best teachers. Sign up for a trial lesson today Invest in Macedonia New Business Heaven in Europe Long-term Israel programs MASA is your gateway. More programs. More grants. Eldan Rent a Car Israel's leading car rental company offers you a 20% discount on all online reservations JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here! Dead Sea Salt Beauty and skin care from the Dead Sea. Coupon code HAARETZ for 10% off! Junkyard Junk a car - get free towing nationwide and a tax-deductible receipt. Holiday Inn and Crown Plaza Israel Lowest internet rate Guaranteed at ichotelsgroup.com !

Home | TV | Print Edition | Diplomacy | Opinion | Arts & Leisure | Sports | Jewish World | Underground | Site rules |

© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved