Subscribe to Print Edition | Wed., November 07, 2007 Cheshvan 26, 5768 | | Israel Time: 14:12 (EST+7) web haaretz.com   Back to Homepage Print Edition Diplomacy Defense Arts & Leisure Real Estate Jewish World National Advertising Magazine Week's End Business Opinion Rosner's Domain Anglo File Books Travel

del.icio.us Digg It!  new Last update - 14:09 07/11/2007 Not like other murderers By Zvia Valdan tags: Israel, Yitzhak Rabin  A murderer is a murderer, or so it seems, and all murderers have the same legal standing. In his article, "Dangerous words" (October 29), Prof. Ze'ev Segal - referring to the demand to tighten the restrictions imposed on Yigal Amir - claims that "the law does not favor 'personal laws,' and adopting a law on this subject will also not prove beneficial, as laws can be changed." Indeed, personal laws are problematic since a law and its enforcement have to be based on principle. However, it is under no circumstances permissible to treat Yigal Amir as if he were a murderer like all other murderers. A person who murders a social worker because she is a social worker should actually be charged with a double murder - because he killed a human being and because he killed the person because she worked in a certain profession. A murder of this type is different from the murder of a private individual or one that takes place during a robbery, for example. This is true, too, of the murder of a doctor, a policeman, a judge and so forth. In fact, anyone who serves the public - in other words, a person who was appointed by the state to fill a public position - is worthy of and entitled to special protection, and anyone who dares to attack him or her must be included in a specific category of murderers: those who do not enjoy the rights that are accorded to other murderer-prisoners. And this is even more true when we are talking about someone who has murdered an elected public official, and on top of that, the prime minister. He must bear the mark of Cain forever. Advertisement My father, Shimon Peres, was also a "candidate" for murder by the hand of that same despicable assassin, who chose - in cold blood and in a premeditated fashion - to try to take the lives of elected representatives as a means of forcing the voters to accept his point of view; who cast a stain on an entire group of citizens, most of whom do not identify with him even if they do not necessarily accept the views of the late Yitzhak Rabin, and of Shimon Peres, may he have a long life. This is an appropriate place to make a request of the media and the public in general: Leave the newborn infant alone. He does not deserve to suffer because of the transgressions of his parents, who did not hesitate to aggravate the feelings of the public by the demands they made concerning his arrival in the world. If the law proposed here is legislated, and the son grows up to see that his father was the worst of all murderers, perhaps he will some day ask himself for what and why. The legislation of a law that distinguishes in principle between the murderers of private individuals and murderers who undermine the very basis of the state and democracy, and who harm the entire public - by attacking its emissaries - would make it unnecessary every time to discuss Yigal Amir once again. It would divert attention from the murderer and make the focus once again on the murder. And it would spare the children of Yitzhak Rabin the insufferable job that has befallen them: to have to intervene every time Amir abuses the country's legal system. It was not only their father who was assassinated. The rule of law, the democracy, and the entire Israeli public, both the supporters and the opponents of Rabin - all of us are the victims of that murder and we have the duty to remain on guard. The author is a linguist and professor at Beit Berl Teachers Training College and daughter of Israel's president. Bookmark to del.icio.us Guest speaker Peres has been invited to address the Turkish parliament. Serve in the IDF? Not me Nearly 28% of Israeli males avoided conscription in 2007.   1.   Mazal Tov Igal and stay in hell Rabin, legacy of 2,000 dead Jews 10:18  |  Genuine Tosefta 05/11/07   2.   Leave him alone, but observe his mother (very) well..... 10:24  |  Swiss (Dino) 05/11/07   3.   I am prepared not to judge 10:25  |  Big Al 05/11/07   4.   Slippery slope 10:27  |  Bruno 05/11/07   5.   Elite talking. Was she ever taking a bus ride? 10:29  |  Alex 05/11/07   6.   just the murderer 11:04  |  joe 05/11/07   7.   Genuine Tosefta 11:27  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 05/11/07   8.   Little completion to my # 2 12:17  |  Swiss (Dino) 05/11/07   9.   # 2 DINO - DNA is very potent thing... 12:25  |  17 05/11/07   10.   This isn`t about the baby or even about the murderer 14:44  |  newageblues 05/11/07   11.   What a disgusting article 15:16  |  L A 05/11/07   12.   a murder is a murder 15:32  |  Richi 05/11/07   13.   ZVIA A BIT CONFUSED.......... 15:46  |  Robert 05/11/07   14.   Lets have a minutes silence for a mass murderer 15:53  |  Sean 05/11/07   15.   I should have said `only way much of the right will understand` 16:38  |  newageblues 05/11/07   16.   Law 18:32  |  j 05/11/07   17.   The Problem with Israeli Democracy 19:12  |  Alicia 05/11/07   18.   blackout from now on: let us resolve 20:42  |  leucippe 05/11/07   19.   Please answers this question 20:46  |  Zvi 05/11/07   20.   LONG LIVE IGAL AMIR 22:01  |  BLA-BLA-USA 05/11/07   21.   igal amir is subhuman 00:23  |  anne 06/11/07   22.   @2, swiss dino, what right do you have even to 02:58  |  vladimir 06/11/07   23.   why is Amir worse than other murderers? 03:48  |  Asher 06/11/07   24.   Margie, 2,000 dead Jews are not an idea or policies 04:58  |  Genuine Tosefta 06/11/07   25.   Supporting This Bum amir IS Mental Illness ! 05:01  |  MIKE 06/11/07   26.   I Thought Israel Was a Civilized Country. I Guess I Was Wrong! 05:15  |  MIKE 06/11/07   27.   MIKE how civilized is it to bring about the death of 2,000 Jews? 05:52  |  Genuine Tosefta 06/11/07   28.   to LA La La 06:44  |  dr danielito 06/11/07   29.   Igal Amir is a dirty filthy murdering scumbag 09:04  |  Talula 06/11/07   30.   AMIR`S BLANKS DIDN`T MURDER RABIN;HE MURDERED THE RELIGIOUS RIGHT 10:21  |  VOICE of MOSHIACH))) 06/11/07

Today Online Syria repeats demand to put Golan on peace summit agenda Responses: 75 Editorial: Likud is unsurprisingly similar to Hamas Responses: 29 Amira Hass: Gazans already desperately low on water, power Responses: 27 Shmuel Rosner: Neither Republicans nor Democrats will end Iraq war Responses: 4 Haaretz TV: Until 2004, IDF listened in to all int'l calls from Israel Responses: 7 More Headlines 13:29 Syria reiterates demand to put Golan on Annapolis summit agenda 12:59 Haaretz probe: Gaza evacuees lose compensation in apparent scam 12:59 Iran: We have 3,000 centrifuges working at enrichment plant 13:20 One dead in clash between Hamas, Islamic Jihad in Gaza 12:31 Study: Jewish births lead rise in Israeli fertility rates in 2006 11:28 Israel: UN Human Rights Council 'morally bankrupt' 13:01 Yossi Benayoun nets hat trick for Liverpool in Champions League match 11:27 Mukasey one step closer to becoming second Jewish AG in U.S. history 13:00 Barak: Israel to retain control of passage between W. Bank, Gaza 13:17 Hamas plans to build $200 million movie production house in Gaza Previous Editions Select Day 06 nov 05 nov 04 nov 02 nov 01 nov 31 oct 30 oct 29 oct 28 oct 26 oct 25 oct 24 oct

Special Offers Advertisement learn Hebrew online with israel's best teachers. Sign up for a trial lesson today Invest in Macedonia New Business Heaven in Europe Long-term Israel programs MASA is your gateway. More programs. More grants. Eldan Rent a Car Israel's leading car rental company offers you a 20% discount on all online reservations JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here! Dead Sea Salt Beauty and skin care from the Dead Sea. Coupon code HAARETZ for 10% off! Junkyard Junk a car - get free towing nationwide and a tax-deductible receipt. Holiday Inn and Crown Plaza Israel Lowest internet rate Guaranteed at ichotelsgroup.com !

Home | TV | Print Edition | Diplomacy | Opinion | Arts & Leisure | Sports | Jewish World | Underground | Site rules |

© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved