Subscribe to Print Edition | Thu., November 15, 2007 Kislev 5, 5768 | | Israel Time: 20:14 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Arts & Leisure Real Estate Jewish World National Advertising
Easy Start Magazine Business Opinion Rosner's Domain Anglo File Week's End Books
del.icio.us
Digg It!  new
What will happen after Bush?
By Itamar Rabinovich
tags: Bush

In its latest issue, dated November 8, The New York Review of Books published in a prominent - if not screaming - manner a letter signed by eight famous individuals and addressed to United States President George W. Bush, warning him of the grave dangers inherent in a possible failure of the Annapolis conference.

To avert this danger, the signatories suggest adopting a number of recommendations that will distance both the conference and Washington's policy from the widespread view that prevails today, albeit with slight variations, in the Bush administration and the government of Israel. The signatories include Zbigniew Brzezinski, the national security advisor in the administration of former president Jimmy Carter; Lee Hamilton, the former chairman of the House Foreign Affairs Committee; Brent Scowcroft, the national security advisor of former president George H. Bush; and Thomas Pickering, the former U.S. ambassador to Israel.

The authors see the Annapolis conference as "a genuine opportunity for progress toward a two-state solution." They believe that the Middle East is in the throws of an extremely grave crisis and that a conference with a positive outcome will play a crucial role in stemming instability and violence. They also hold that the conference must deal with "the substance of a permanent peace" and that it should adopt the outlines of a permanent status agreement, especially in light of the impossibility of reaching a comprehensive agreement before the end of November. If Israelis and Palestinians do not manage to reach such an agreement, the Middle East Quartet (made up of the U.S., Russia, the EU and the UN) will have to propose a formulation of its own for an agreement that will be based on UN Security Council Resolutions 242 and 338, the Clinton parameters of 2000, the Arab peace initiative of 2002 and the 2003 road map.
Advertisement
The main points of a comprehensive agreement are the partition into two states on the basis of the June 4, 1967 lines, with additional territorial exchanges at a ratio of one to one; Jerusalem as the capital of both states; a solution to the Palestinian refugee problem in a manner concordant with the principle of two states, alongside addressing the profound sense of injustice among the refugees and their compensation and rehabilitation.

The signatories congratulate the Bush administration for inviting Syria to the conference but believe that the U.S. government itself should also enter into negotiations with Damascus, based on the belief that a breakthrough in this channel could change the regional situation. As for Hamas, it is preferable to hold a dialogue with it than to attempt to isolate it.

The recommendations that appear in "the letter of the eight" and the basic assumptions on which it rests are not surprising. Its initiators have been disagreeing with the Bush administration's Middle East policy for years now. The letter is presented as a joint initiative of the U.S./Middle East Project, Inc. headed by General Brent Scowcroft and Henry Siegman and the International Crisis Group headed by Gareth Evans, along with the New America Foundation/American Strategy Program.

Scowcroft's chilly attitude toward Israel has been known for years and Henry Siegman, who was the director general of the American Jewish Congress, has been identified with and continues to uphold opinions that are in line with those of Meretz's left wing. For more than a decade now, Gareth Evans, Australia's former foreign minister, has been the primary advocate at the International Crisis Group of a view that disagrees with the positions of the governments of Israel and the Bush administration. Hamilton was James Baker's partner in the Baker-Hamilton committee, which recommended embarking on a dialogue with Iran and Syria, which he viewed as one of the essential elements for a solution to the Iraqi mess - the other element being the Israeli-Arab conflict. In their view, the Israeli-Arab conflict, and its Palestinian aspect in particular, are responsible for the region's instability and the spread of anti-American attitudes. Without giving the Israeli-Palestinian issue a "root canal" treatment, the United States will not be able to resolve the crisis in Iraq and deal with the other challenges it is facing in the region.

It is not surprising that this letter was published in The New York Review of Books, the bastion of the liberal intelligentsia in the United States. Among its regular contributors are those who can be found on the left of the Israeli consensus, and it published historian Tony Judt's article calling for the establishment of a binational state in Israel.

The chances that "the letter of the eight" will influence the Bush administration's policy are small. The administration wants the Annapolis conference to be a success for reasons of its own and it is certainly not interested in another resounding failure in the Middle East. Indeed, its attempts to prevent a negative outcome - including the American secretary of state's efforts to invite Syria to the conference - are narrowing the gap between it and the letter's formulators. Nevertheless, the letter's spirit and the practical suggestions it contains are unacceptable to the administration and, above all, to the president.

The importance of this letter must be sought in two other contexts. The first is the effort to shape the American agenda on "the day after" the presidential elections. This is not the only attempt. Think tanks and other organizations are preparing reports of their own, with all of them aspiring to repeat the extraordinary success of the 1976 Brookings report that was adopted by the Carter administration as its Middle East policy. The day after the elections will see an increase in the efforts to convince the new president, whoever he or she may be, that there is no better way to shake off Bush's legacy than by bringing about a far-reaching change in the Middle East policy of the United States.

Another context is the continuing erosion of Israel's standing in the United States. This does not manifest itself in public opinion polls and in votes in Congress, but rather in the loss of the "moral horizon," the change that has occurred in the standing of Israel, which used to be regarded as an attractive and just state. A clear expression of this is the recent reception of Jimmy Carter's book and of the book written by John Mearsheimer and Stephen Walt about the Israeli lobby, which not only expressed criticism of Israel's policy but also questioned its legitimacy. Despite the criticism to which they have been subjected, these books are making waves and their authors are appearing throughout the United States. The "letter of the eight" is another link in this chain.

The author, a Middle East specialist, was Israel's ambassador to the United States from 1993-1996.
Bookmark to del.icio.us
New Kids in the Strip
Hamas' new police band lifts spirits by crooning about Islamic holy war.
Less than equal
A poll shows 70% of youth don't think Bedouin deserve the same rights as Jews
  1.   Why Walt & Mearsheimer was a critical event in Israel`s history 10:02  |  Clickfool 29/10/07
  2.   MOST PROBABLY THESE THINGS WILL HAPPENS 10:14  |  indrajaya 29/10/07
  3.   The danger of not knowing your limits...... 11:05  |  Swiss (Dino) 29/10/07
  4.   writing on the wall 11:40  |  ravi 29/10/07
  5.   John Mearsheimer`s and Stephen Walt`s substandard scholarship 11:49  |  akiva (zionist) 29/10/07
  6.   indrajaya, prophet extraordinaire! 11:50  |  akiva (zionist) 29/10/07
  7.   Swiss 11:54  |  akiva (zionist) 29/10/07
  8.   ..I will seek to destroy all nations that come against Jerusalem. 11:55  |  mary for jews 29/10/07
  9.   "Questioned Whose Legitimacy?" 11:57  |  Yaakov Sullivan 29/10/07
  10.   #1, Clickfool 12:00  |  Hannah 29/10/07
  11.   ravi, , graffiti on the wall... 12:01  |  akiva (zionist) 29/10/07
  12.   #5, Akive, zionist 12:20  |  Hannah 29/10/07
  13.   # 7 akiva (zionist) More openness, more self-esteem.... 12:22  |  Swiss (Dino) 29/10/07
  14.   #1 (Fake?) Clickfool 12:24  |  Daybreak 29/10/07
  15.   Arab Hannah 12:46  |  Hannah 29/10/07
  16.   # 6, AKIVA (PATYS TZIONI) 12:49  |  indrajaya 29/10/07
  17.   Swiss (Dino) 13:01  |  akiva (zionist) 29/10/07
  18.   schizophrenic hannahs 13:14  |  akiva (zionist) 29/10/07
  19.   OK, then what? 15:55  |  Michael N 29/10/07
  20.   Nothing will change 17:23  |  Howard Mirkin 29/10/07
  21.   Deja Vu 18:00  |  FinanceDoc 29/10/07
  22.   #15 Non-Arab Hannah 18:25  |  Nidra Stein 29/10/07
  23.   #8 Hi there Mary 19:57  |  ballistic 29/10/07
  24.   #5 Akiva re Dershowitz 20:06  |  ballistic 29/10/07
  25.   #15 Say there Hannah of Israel 20:10  |  ballistic 29/10/07
  26.   FinanceDoc 20:16  |  ballistic 29/10/07
  27.   #22 Hi there Nidra 20:20  |  ballistic 29/10/07
  28.   what will happen after BUSH 12:18  |  ron 30/10/07
  29.   most probably 12:23  |  ron 30/10/07
  30.   Talk to whom ? 13:14  |  Ralph 30/10/07
  31.   SPIN (and more spin) 15:37  |  Iqbal Halani 30/10/07
  32.   What will happen after Bush? 15:51  |  George King 30/10/07
  33.   The Right of Palestinians 16:07  |  Soho 30/10/07
  34.   Keep it in the middle east... 16:32  |  Cainashe 30/10/07
  35.   wake up 21:24  |  Hardev 30/10/07
  36.   nonsense 21:27  |  Hardev 30/10/07
  37.   What will happen after Bush 22:14  |  L.O. Feuerstein 30/10/07
  38.   James Baker 02:09  |  Sean 31/10/07
  39.   what will happen after bush 03:14  |  tony scolloney 31/10/07
  40.   clickfool 03:21  |  M. Allen 31/10/07
  41.   What will happen after Bush 04:38  |  Lester Ness 31/10/07
  42.   Why Israel is right 05:02  |  K. 31/10/07
  43.   Peace, Power, Money, & Ideology 06:51  |  Allen Weinberger 31/10/07
  44.   Talk to whom? #2 07:07  |  Allen 31/10/07
  45.   The Right of Palestinians # 07:17  |  Allen 31/10/07
  46.   mary for jews 08:38  |  phyllis 31/10/07
  47.   Clarity, please. 22:53  |  ConcernedSpeller 31/10/07
  48.   WHAT WE SAY MAKES NO DIFFERENCE 13:12  |  ONEGODAPOSTOLIC 02/11/07
  49.   what will happend aftre bush 11:29  |  hafiz 03/11/07
  50.   what will happen 16:41  |  OTR500 03/11/07
  51.   Middle East Peace? 17:00  |  John 03/11/07
  52.   Why Israel is right??? 17:27  |  Maq 03/11/07
  53.   Peace, Power.... 17:33  |  Maq 03/11/07
  54.   WWII 17:39  |  Maq 03/11/07
  55.   "PEACE"=SUICIDE for Israel 02:40  |  steve clark 04/11/07
  56.   What will happen after Bush 16:15  |  JERRY VAIL 04/11/07
  57.   KEEPING MUSLIM ISSUE IN ARAB LANDS. 16:32  |  JERRY VAIL 04/11/07
  58.   mediterranean peoples 16:40  |  maya 2012 04/11/07
  59.   #57 Shame on you 19:20  |  Wise Syrian 04/11/07
  60.   # 8, so all of us Gentiles have to live... 19:29  |  Wise Syrian 04/11/07
  61.   What will happen after Bush? 20:42  |  Richard 12/11/07
  62.   What will happen after Bush? 21:09  |  Tony 12/11/07
  63.   Keeping Muslim Issue in Muslim Lands 00:54  |  JGP 14/11/07
  64.   Post Bush World 15:47  |  Anthny L 15/11/07
  65.   Why must the United States interfere with M.E. affairs. 16:03  |  Steve 15/11/07
  66.   read the bible 18:37  |  dennis vedin 15/11/07
  67.   Extremists 19:14  |  Anonymous 15/11/07
  68.   Agree to certain parts 19:34  |  Carter 15/11/07
 Today Online
Minister Lieberman: PA must recognize Israel as Jewish state
Responses: 108
Tom Segev: Germany should pay as long as even one Holocaust survivor still lives
Responses: 69
Aluf Benn: U.S. wants Israel to get used to the Iranian bomb
Responses: 84
Haaretz.com TV: Hebron settlers taped abusing Palestinians
Responses: 52
Watchdog group: Only 2 W. Bank roadblocks removed recently
Responses: 37


More Headlines
16:06 Weisglass to Winograd: Sharon wouldn't have sent ground troops to Lebanon
20:01 IAEA: Iran cooperated with UN nuclear probe, but still defying demands
17:04 Arab League to meet on summit stance as Syria mulls participation
15:09 Officials: Two militants killed, 5 hurt, in IDF strike on Gaza Strip
20:08 Four East J'lem Arabs charged with killing alleged collaborator
17:43 Abbas urges Israelis to support peace moves ahead of summit
17:48 Second century Roman road, bath unearthed near Jerusalem temple site
16:56 Israeli stabbed in Sharon; police suspect nationalistic motive
15:12 Police checking possibility PM violated campaign finance laws
11:03 Report: Series of explosions rip through Iranian military site
16:36 Ukraine president: Anti-Semitic acts in my country are marginal
15:06 Peres: Courts are too forgiving with regard to law breakers
11:06 MK Tibi calls for Arab representative on health basket panel
Previous Editions