Ya'alon: British Gas natural gas deal in Gaza will finance terror - Haaretz

Subscribe to Print Edition

Sun., October 21, 2007 ,

Israel Time: 01:35 (EST+7)

web haaretz.com

Back to Homepage

Print Edition

Diplomacy

Defense

Arts & Leisure

Real Estate

Jewish World

National

Advertising

Magazine

Week's End

Business

Opinion

Rosner's Domain

Anglo File

Books

Travel



		Israel Defense Forces chief of staff Moshe Ya'alon. (Dudu Bachar)

del.icio.us

Digg It! new

Last update - 09:50 21/10/2007

Ya'alon: British Gas natural gas deal in Gaza will finance terror

By Avi Bar-Eli

The public disagreements between former Israel Defense Forces chief of staff Moshe Ya'alon and the politicians running the country have reached a new level, and have put the spotlight on one of the most sensitive affairs in the Israeli economy: the negotiations with BG (British Gas) over the purchase of natural gas from the undersea field off the Gaza coast.

In an article written by Ya'alon that appeared Friday on the Web site of the Jerusalem Center for Public Affairs (JCPA), he accuses the Security Cabinet of not ordering military action in Gaza so that it would not damage the chances of reaching a deal with BG.

T

	Advertisement

he Prime Minister's Office declined to respond to Ya'alon's comments.

The rights to the offshore gas field belong to BG (60 percent); the Lebanese construction and infrastructure company CCC (30 percent); and the investment fund of the Palestinian Authority (10 percent).

The Gaza Marine field was discovered in 2000 after years of gas and oil prospecting in the area, and the 1.4 trillion cubic feet of gas is worth an estimated $4 billion.

In a highly controversial move, then-prime minister Ehud Barak gave up Israel's rights to the natural gas field and gave them to the Palestinian Authority for free.

According to Ya'alon, the British government and Tony Blair pressured former prime ministers Barak and Ariel Sharon to agree to a deal, but Mossad head Meir Dagan objected to such an agreement, fearing the proceeds from selling the natural gas to Israel would not benefit the Palestinian public, but instead would finance more terror attacks against Israel.

The negotiations continued for years, due to both the problems of devising payment methods to prevent the transfer of the proceeds to terror organizations, as well as disagreements over the price of the gas.

More recently, the negotiations have been further delayed by a petition to the High Court of Justice by rival natural gas supplier Tethys Sea. Tethys Sea is asking the court to forbid an agreement between the state and BG without the publication of a tender.

Despite Sharon's refusal to agree to such a deal, Prime Minister Ehud Olmert resurrected the negotiations with BG, and invested quite a lot of energy in trying to reach a deal over the purchase of the gas. This comes despite the increased terror threat from Gaza after the Hamas takeover, said Ya'alon.

"The prospect of an Israeli gas purchase may have played a role in influencing the Olmert cabinet to avoid ordering a major IDF ground operation in Gaza, even though there have been at least 1,000 rocket and mortar attacks against southern Israel since the Hamas takeover of Gaza in June 2007," he wrote.

He further warned that organizations associated with the international Islamist fundamentalist terror network would be highly motivated to attack British Gas' production facilities off the Gaza shore, and said he expected Hamas would increase its attempts to damage the Ashkelon power plant as the negotiations with BG advanced.

Ya'alon further claimed that since 2002, Israel has not held a serious, thorough discussion of the security implications of a natural gas deal with BG.

With his controversial statements, Ya'alon is continuing to make headlines.

"The British government seems to have pinned much of its Middle East policy on the successful outcome of British Gas negotiations with Israel. A September 18, 2007, report in the Arabic al-Quds newspaper noted that the British government views Gaza's natural gas reserves as central to 10 Downing Street's 'economic road map' for the Middle East. Tony Blair's position, first as prime minister and now as the very active Quartet envoy for Palestinian Economic Development, has been that the Palestinian Authority's share of the gas sale proceeds, which could reach well more than $1 billion, could serve as the economic fuel to jump-start the Palestinian economy and advance the peace process," wrote Ya'alon.

He further emphasizes that all the plans to bypass Hamas in Gaza are futile: "British officials have expressed confidence that the gas proceeds can bypass Hamas and benefit the Palestinian public by being deposited and monitored in international bank accounts. Israel also has proposed paying for the gas in goods and services. However, these assessments are mistaken. A gas transaction with the Palestinian Authority will, by definition, involve Hamas. Hamas will either benefit from the royalties, or it will sabotage the project and launch attacks against Fatah, the gas installations, Israel - or all three."

The Jerusalem Center for Public Affairs, an independent policy institution, was founded in 1976 by the late Prof. Daniel J. Elazar, and currently is headed by Israel's former UN ambassador, Dr. Dore Gold.

The JCPA states "it approaches its work without preconceptions to generate new ideas, which may prove vital in Israel's fight for survival."

"Israel must consider whether it can afford to be dependant on the Palestinians for such a critical energy asset as natural gas. If Israel becomes the Palestinians' main gas customer in a multi-year agreement, the PA or Palestinian terror groups could use the continued supply of gas as a lever to pressure Israel to make additional concessions and "gestures" as part of political negotiations. More significantly, the Palestinians could threaten to cut off the natural gas supply to Israel to prevent the IDF from responding to terror attacks and other threats emanating from Gaza or the West Bank," wrote Yaalon in his essay.

He concludes that while Israel needs additional energy resources, including natural gas reserves, "funneling $1 billion into local or international bank accounts on behalf of the Palestinian Authority would be tantamount to Israel bankrolling terror against itself."

Related articles:

BG Group says progress made on deal for Israel to purchase Palestinian gas

Hamas says will not block deal to drill for natural gas off Gaza shore

Bookmark to del.icio.us


	A Palestinian gesture
	The top PA diplomat in Poland joined his Israeli counterpart on a visit to Auschwitz.


	Link to Temple found
	A controversial excavation at Temple Mount has unearthed fragments from First Temple era.




1.	Ya`alon again....	08:45	\|	Esther	21/10/07

2.	Stupidity and selfinterest is guiding Olmert leadership	08:57	\|	Rolland	21/10/07

3.	Suicidal Leadership= NEW ELECTIONS!!!!!	09:09	\|	Ben Uziel	21/10/07

4.	Sell to other customers	10:23	\|	Palestinian Brit	21/10/07

5.	Re #2 and #3	10:37	\|	Esther	21/10/07

6.	Esther	10:38	\|	Margie in Tel Aviv	21/10/07

7.	Esther,if pals could sell gas to anybody else ,they`ve done it	10:57	\|	Absolute Sweden	21/10/07

8.	What the guy suggest is stealing the oil and gas from Palestinian	10:57	\|	Petteri	21/10/07

9.	Good chuckle on a Sunday	11:24	\|	Clickfool	21/10/07

10.	Gaz in Gaza	11:48	\|	whodey	21/10/07

11.	Ya"alon-BG	11:51	\|	khader herzallah	21/10/07

12.	to stupid `malka` Esther	12:32	\|	g	21/10/07

13.	Ya`alon is right.	12:36	\|	Vital	21/10/07

14.	Finally, An Israeli With Courage To Tell The Truth	12:46	\|	Ben Israel	21/10/07

15.	Olmert Gave Away a Gas Field : So What Is Next	12:56	\|	D.Fender	21/10/07

16.	For D.Fender # 15	13:05	\|	Clickfool	21/10/07

17.	ANY PAYMENTS SHOULD GO INTO A MANAGED FUND	13:13	\|	D.Velopment	21/10/07

18.	gaza	13:49	\|	izaak	21/10/07

19.	Barak wants to be PM but he gives away $4 billion in gas free	14:23	\|	zionist forever	21/10/07

20.	Time to expell the Brits colonialists	14:31	\|	Frank	21/10/07

21.	For Frank # 20	15:23	\|	Clickfool	21/10/07

22.	petteri #8	15:47	\|	mike	21/10/07

23.	He wants Palestinians to buy Israeli gaz	15:48	\|	Tamir Palestine	21/10/07

24.	# 8 Petteri of Finbland	15:49	\|	Lynn	21/10/07

25.	Barak not entitled to give national assets to genocidal enemies	15:50	\|	Mike	21/10/07

26.	To #21	16:26	\|	Frank	21/10/07

27.	Again, Barak	18:17	\|	Chcik	21/10/07

28.	Gas Field and ownership.	18:18	\|	Labhras	21/10/07

29.	Olmert got involved only so he could steal somemore money	18:53	\|	Kipperraes	21/10/07

30.	Barak and Peres have direct interest in the deal, so	19:19	\|	Sal	21/10/07

Today Online


	Britain's chief rabbi: Multiculturalism is threat to democracy
	Responses: 140


	Fayad: Suspects in plot to kill Olmert have been arrested again
	Responses: 127


	PM: Annapolis summit will not bring historic breakthrough
	Responses: 101


	Gideon Levy: The time has come for Israel to give up on Ron Arad
	Responses: 90


	Prince Hassan of Jordan: Muslims must differentiate between Israeli action, Jews
	Responses: 66

Rosner's Domain

* Jumblatt to Bush: Send car bombs to Damascus

* Israel's fear: Will Rice put a bridging proposal on the table?

* WTR: 75% of Americans don't believe in peace process

* Guest: Should the Saudis attend Annapolis?

More Headlines
21:38 Palestinian PM: Suspects in plot against Olmert back in custody


21:05 Cheney: U.S. and its allies won't let Iran have a nuclear weapon


23:29 One killed in clashes between Hamas and Jihad in Gaza Strip


01:07 IAF strike injures at least four Hamas gunmen in north Gaza


22:08 In act of joint reflection, Israeli and PA diplomats visit Auschwitz


19:40 Archaeologists find link to 1st temple in controversial J'lem dig


00:18 Lebanese Druze leader calls on U.S. to impose sanctions on Syria


21:43 Tamir proposes external mediation in bid to end university strike


22:20 Seven Iraqi children to be brought to Israel for heart surgery