Subscribe to Print Edition | Wed., October 31, 2007 Cheshvan 19, 5768 | | Israel Time: 19:37 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Arts & Leisure Real Estate Jewish World National Advertising
Magazine Week's End Business Opinion Rosner's Domain Anglo File Books Travel
del.icio.us
Digg It!  new
Courage and history
By Michalis Firillas

Nations are measured by their history. But we often forget that they are also measured by the way they confront their history. This can be a difficult task, requiring courage, vision and commitment to a different future. It demands more honesty and less pride. It makes a distinction between dignity and shame - and knows how to enhance the former and address the latter. And it requires the involvement of both the political leadership, on the one hand, and the individual citizen, on the other.

Which brings us to the following question: What can we learn from the German response to the Holocaust that might help Turkey alter its attitude toward the Armenian genocide? A loaded question? Obviously. An unfair one? Maybe. But is it a useful one? Definitely, and not only for the Turks. If there is one lesson we must have picked up on during the 20th century, it is that we are all "built" for genocide. There is no culture, polity, community that is immune from this. There are of course many ways of carrying out genocide. You can starve your victims, parch them, march them into the desert, shoot them, rape them, gas them, burn them, bomb them, hack them to pieces. You do not need to be an industrial powerhouse to do it quickly, efficiently. And by most standards, there is at least one genocide taking place right now, in East Africa.

Mentioning Turkey in the same sentence as the Holocaust is anathema to all Turks - and they are right because it is a horrific stigma to bear. "Placing the Turks in the same category as Nazis is intolerable to us," one Turkish official was quoted as saying in The Economist on October 4. But that is missing the point. This is not about comparative genocide - an exercise that invariably devolves into some form of bean counting. But when a state refuses to acknowledge history, it affects the psyche of the nation, perpetuating stasis, first on a moral level and then in every other aspect of life.
Advertisement
When World War II came to an end in Europe, in May 1945, the crimes of Germany were exposed before the world. The horror was such that for a while there were American officials who sought to reduce Germany to an agrarian society so that it could never again perpetrate such criminal aggression.

Things turned out differently, in great part because of Cold War exigencies. But at least in West Germany, a concerted effort was made by its political leadership - and first and foremost by Konrad Adenauer, the country's first chancellor - to restore Germany to the community of nations, foremost through the acknowledgment of the past. Not only did Germany accept responsibility, but it actively sought to preserve that diabolical chapter in its history - in the memory of the state and of every single German citizen.

It can be argued that the Germans were forced into accepting responsibility. They were occupied, crushed, starving, shocked and shamed. All true. But they did take responsibility, with the understanding that they could not escape history and that if they could muster the courage, they could use that experience to build a better future.

Such a tack requires leadership. And the epitome of Adenauer's leadership came with the reconciliation between West Germany and Israel, which began formally in 1952, with the signing of the reparations agreement. This also required a great deal of courage and leadership on the part of David Ben-Gurion, who pushed that accord through in the face of great opposition at home. It did not mean forgiveness by any means. But it was the start of reconciliation, and that is what genuine leaders owe to the future generations of their people.

Turkey's circumstances are different from those of Germany, and so is its historical development. But finding excuses is always easier than doing what is right. Yes, Turkey has simultaneously struggled with at least three massive challenges since its establishment in 1923, the roots of which dated back to the great reforms started in 1839: building a nation-state; modernization; and democratization. By the time Germany perpetrated the Holocaust, it had gone through all these stages, with greater or lesser success. Indeed, apologists are always quick to point out that "this is not a good time" for Turkey to address the Armenian issue. The bottom line is that it is never a good time: There is always some crisis brewing, some hyper-sensitive general, politician or group, too many other things going on. That is the nature of the mix that makes Turkey what it is.

However, all too often the Turkish people are underestimated. This is more frequently done by its own leaders than by foreigners. When Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan declares that "there was no Armenian genocide," that is precisely what he is doing: underestimating his people, and their ability to look forward and acknowledge mistakes. For the leader of a party whose popularity stems from the desire of many Turks to remove the shackles of a traditionally paternalistic state - this is no way to usher in change. History is not solely the domain of historians, as Erdogan and others would have us believe. Every Turk has a role in the making of Turkish history, and a stake in the making of Turkey's future. Recognizing past wrongs and calling them by name is difficult, and may even seem insurmountable, but the Turks must find the courage to try to do so.

Michalis Firillas is on the editorial staff of Haaretz.
Bookmark to del.icio.us
China, Israel diverge
With Livni in Beijing, China rejects Israel's call for tougher sanctions against Iran.
Amending aliyah
Interior Minister Sheetrit says Jews should not be granted automatic Israeli citizenship.
  1.   Food for thought 16:33  |  sh 19/10/07
  2.   Bill Clinton Also Refused To Consider The Resolution 17:00  |  Tony Anthony 19/10/07
  3.   An excellent line to take - now apply it to Israel!! 17:13  |  Don Camillo 19/10/07
  4.   Turkey is not denying forced exile 17:33  |  David Israel 19/10/07
  5.   Courage and history 17:44  |  LEVON 19/10/07
  6.   Bush`s wisdom on Slowman`s education 17:48  |  Michalis Firillas 19/10/07
  7.   Who would be the biggest looser? 17:56  |  David Israel 19/10/07
  8.   And Israel??? 18:12  |  Collond 19/10/07
  9.   I Need More Information 18:24  |  Yosemite 19/10/07
  10.   What Turkey can learn from Germany 18:35  |  Jonathan S 19/10/07
  11.   Turks are not denying 18:44  |  David Israel 19/10/07
  12.   Who would be the biggest looser? 18:45  |  David Israel 19/10/07
  13.   the Morgenthau Plan 18:57  |  Dee 19/10/07
  14.   Empowering the Turkish extremists 19:03  |  W 19/10/07
  15.   Antisemitism 19:10  |  Ethel 19/10/07
  16.   The bill may not pass sadly 19:29  |  Ethel 19/10/07
  17.   On the Morgenthau plan 19:44  |  Jonathan S 19/10/07
  18.   Well said, Don Camillo 20:26  |  Maki 19/10/07
  19.   Armenians, Greeks and Kurds 20:29  |  Ethel 19/10/07
  20.   Jonathan S 20:35  |  Dee 19/10/07
  21.   sh #1 20:40  |  Danite 19/10/07
  22.   To #4, but also important to all 20:49  |  Steve 19/10/07
  23.   Ethel - don`t take my word but read and investigate the details 20:50  |  David Israel 19/10/07
  24.   Go, Mike, Go! 21:04  |  Paul 19/10/07
  25.   Yosemite 21:19  |  Ethel 19/10/07
  26.   recognizing history 21:20  |  miriam 19/10/07
  27.   dee 21:31  |  sweis Melbourne 19/10/07
  28.   Courage and history 21:39  |  Dr. Snki 19/10/07
  29.   Ethel - don`t take my word but read and investigate the details 21:45  |  David Israel 19/10/07
  30.   Playing games are we? 21:59  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 19/10/07
  31.   Armenians and Palestinians aren`t comparable 22:03  |  Jeffrey Blustein 19/10/07
  32.   #3camillo and the wrong mandate ! 22:16  |  victor hardman 19/10/07
  33.   Jeffrey Blustein 23:13  |  David Israel 19/10/07
  34.   Armenians and Palestinians 23:49  |  Ethel 19/10/07
  35.   Don Camillo Great idea!!! 00:02  |  danite 20/10/07
  36.   Turkish revisionists 00:20  |  Diane 20/10/07
  37.   google attentat adenauer 00:24  |  Axel 20/10/07
  38.   Diane - I am only asking people to study the history 00:43  |  David Israel 20/10/07
  39.   Russia and Armenia 01:18  |  Ethel 20/10/07
  40.   David Israel I guess only Jews are victims? 01:39  |  Palestinian Prince 20/10/07
  41.   Armenians in Turkey were massacred 02:14  |  Ethel 20/10/07
  42.   Armenians in Turkey were massacred 02:14  |  Ethel 20/10/07
  43.   #30sMargie the so called peace maker 03:48  |  Labhras 20/10/07
  44.   #32 Hardhead who is really Paul Harris. 03:54  |  Labhras 20/10/07
  45.   90 years ago 04:44  |  Mark Lincoln 20/10/07
  46.   The problem with reality 04:45  |  Mark Lincoln 20/10/07
  47.   Palestinian prince - Armenians were victims 05:10  |  David Israel 20/10/07
  48.   Morgenthau Plan 06:32  |  Richard D Kaplan, MD 20/10/07
  49.   To Ethel #34 06:39  |  john 20/10/07
  50.   armenian question 07:03  |  avrumiye 20/10/07
  51.   Mark Lincoln If That`s Really You 08:01  |  Yosemite 20/10/07
  52.   Michalis Firillas you are right. 10:22  |  Jan Vlaming 20/10/07
  53.   Reparations? #20 12:19  |  Jonathan S 20/10/07
  54.   #44who is really labarse the irish tinker from new york 12:37  |  victor hardman 20/10/07
  55.   # 18 Maki - Brazil learned from Turkey 13:37  |  Paul Henzen 20/10/07
  56.   Turkey cannot become an EU member state... 13:47  |  Paul Henzen 20/10/07
  57.   Axis of Deniers 14:49  |  cros 20/10/07
  58.   ARMENIAN VS INDIANS 15:26  |  indrajaya 20/10/07
  59.   # 58 Indrajaya -What about Timor, Papua, Aceh, Maluku? 16:59  |  Paul Henzen 20/10/07
  60.   #54 Hardhead aka Paul harris 17:40  |  Labhras 20/10/07
  61.   #35 No, Danite, the word `Israel` can stay right there. 18:16  |  Don Camillo 20/10/07
  62.   the armenian issue 18:44  |  Ronald 20/10/07
  63.   # 58 Indy, my man 19:06  |  Lynn 20/10/07
  64.   One can draw a different moral. 19:07  |  Colin Wright 20/10/07
  65.   1. Keeping an open mind 19:08  |  Diane 20/10/07
  66.   re #4 `Turkey is not denying forced exile.` 19:19  |  Colin Wright 20/10/07
  67.   2. Keeping an open mind 19:29  |  Diane 20/10/07
  68.   re #58 `ARMENIAN VS INDIAN` 19:42  |  Colin Wright 20/10/07
  69.   censorship 22:03  |  wiseUP 20/10/07
  70.   Diane _ I have al lthe reasons to criticize Turkey but 23:50  |  David Israel 20/10/07
  71.   Turkey and Armenia - legal dispute 01:43  |  Ethel 21/10/07
  72.   Question: Was it a genocide? 02:21  |  Ethel 21/10/07
  73.   Gaze Into The Empty Sockets of Chele Kula in Serbia 02:22  |  Efox 21/10/07
  74.   re: Ethel 02:25  |  Efox 21/10/07
  75.   re: cros 02:30  |  Efox 21/10/07
  76.   David 03:03  |  Ethel 21/10/07
  77.   David 03:03  |  Ethel 21/10/07
  78.   2. Keeping an open mind 03:25  |  Diane 21/10/07
  79.   POPE BENEDICT:KILLED FOR ONE REASON: BECAUSE THEY`RE GOD`S PEOPLE 04:23  |  VOICE of MOSHIACH))) 21/10/07
  80.   "We Don`t Regret" 04:37  |  Samuel 21/10/07
  81.   RE: ARMENIAN VS INDIANS 04:45  |  Sam 21/10/07
  82.