Turn the Adi card into a binding will - Haaretz

Subscribe to Print Edition

Fri., October 19, 2007 ,

Israel Time: 23:38 (EST+7)

web haaretz.com

Back to Homepage

Print Edition

Diplomacy

Defense

Arts & Leisure

Real Estate

Jewish World

National

Advertising

Magazine

Week's End

Business

Opinion

Rosner's Domain

Anglo File

Books

Travel

del.icio.us

Digg It! new

Last update - 22:07 18/10/2007

Turn the Adi card into a binding will

By Haaretz Editorial

Israel is near the bottom of the list for people's willingness to donate organs. Even after one signs an Adi organ donor card allowing removal of organs after death, the family's consent is required.

This will remain the case under new legislation to regulate organ donation. Consent by families is actually decreasing, and no law is going to solve this.

There is no religious bar on organ donation that would explain the unwillingness to donate. It seems to stem from some exaggerated respect for the dead at the expense of the living - apparent not just in medicine.

	Advertisement

This week a frustrated Holocaust survivor said the state prefers to commemorate those who perished in the Holocaust than to take care of its survivors. The Israel Defense Forces has put soldiers' lives at risk on several occasions to gather body parts for burial.

The shortage of donated organs is a universal problem, and every state deals with it differently. In Spain, for example, hospitals are rewarded for their success in obtaining organ donations and employ special teams for this task.

In the state of Massachusetts, the local organ donor's card is considered a will that must be honored regardless of the family's position. In Belgium, Austria and Singapore, people's willingness to donate organs after their death is presumed, unless their wills specify otherwise. England is also on the verge of such legislation.

Presumed consent to donate organs is the best solution. While people have difficulty filling in an Adi form when alive, they are usually indifferent to the idea of a post-death donation. However, the likelihood of Knesset legislation to this effect is nil.

MK Otniel Schneller has submitted a private bill to determine the time of death. The bone of contention is whether the time of death is when the heart stops beating or when the brain stops functioning. Schneller believes that an agreement between the religious and medical establishments on this matter would increase the public's willingness to donate. As it did in Italy, for example. Every effort must be made to solve this shameful situation of organ donation - in which even the families of those who have received organ transplants refuse to donate organs after death.

To shorten the long waiting lists, mainly the hundreds who need a kidney donation every year, the proposed law would reward kidney donors financially. This is intended to reduce the black market trade in human organs and institutionalize the legal reward.

The clause stipulating to reward the donor during his lifetime for an organ to be removed after death is much more significant.

Payment for organs from the dead is much more morally sound and does not tempt poor people to sell their organs.

If the Adi card becomes a legally binding will, and this is accompanied by a massive public opinion campaign to sign one plus a financial reward, perhaps the situation would improve, and organ donation from the living would no longer be necessary.

Bookmark to del.icio.us


	Hip Hop Rabbi
	Marc Schneier is on a mission to improve Jewish-Muslim relations.


	Man in a trap
	Olmert has a mandate from his people, but it will not help him in light of his moral weakness




1.	ITS BECAUSE WE FEAR OLMERT	04:36	\|	Lavy	19/10/07

2.	We do donate	07:46	\|	Eve	19/10/07

3.	The Solution Is Simple: HODS- Halachic Organ Donor Society	11:01	\|	Yishai Kohen	19/10/07

4.	Donating organs, dead or alive, is a perversion	14:56	\|	tsipora	19/10/07

5.	Lavy, so what if arabs gain by your donation?	15:22	\|	Sara	19/10/07

6.	Tsipora, your narrow mind is the perversion!	18:45	\|	Robert	19/10/07

7.	Organ Donations Lead to Life	18:51	\|	Lev	19/10/07

8.	MDA	20:14	\|	Shuki	19/10/07

Today Online


	Israel rejects UN envoy's bid to open talks on Shaba Farms
	Responses: 248


	Aluf Benn: Iran nuclear threat seems far more frightening from Israel
	Responses: 102


	President Peres calls for more inclusive definition of Judaism
	Responses: 72


	FM Livni condemns Belarusian President for anti-Semitic jibe
	Responses: 85


	Firillas: On Armenia, what can Turkey learn from German reaction to Holocaust
	Responses: 33


	Bar'el: Some Israeli captives are more equal than others
	Responses: 13

More Headlines
20:11 Report: Syria dismantling facility targeted by IAF


20:12 Hezbollah slams U.S. call for 'partnership' with Lebanon army


18:49 UN chief: Peace conference decisions must get UN okay


22:27 Court orders Winograd Cmte. to reply to petition within 10 days


21:51 MKs threaten to topple Chief Rabbinate kashrut monopoly


21:31 Eight-time world surfing champion in Israel to promote peace


23:04 Egypt arrests 18 Eritreans planning to sneak into Israel


18:56 Musharraf calls strike on Bhutto convoy 'plot against democracy'


18:13 Iran says ready to help nations develop nuclear programs


19:14 Blair gets early backing in race to be EU's first president