Subscribe to Print Edition | Sun., October 21, 2007 , | | Israel Time: 06:34 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Arts & Leisure Real Estate Jewish World National Advertising
Magazine Week's End Business Opinion Rosner's Domain Anglo File Books Travel
del.icio.us
Digg It!  new
Last update - 09:12 18/10/2007
Bitter olive harvest / Justice falls short in the West Bank
By Avi Issacharoff

Abed Al-Fatah Al-Hindi, a resident of the Nablus-area village of Tal, reaches the main highway between the Hawara and Git junctions, near the Gilad Farm. An International Red Cross crew stands waiting for him. He is bleeding from a large scalp wound, and his left eye is swollen.

A paramedic bandages his head, and a volunteer from Rabbis for Human Rights cleans his face. "Every year there's a mess," the villager tells Haaretz. "It's just the first day of the olive harvest, and six settlers attacked me. There wasn't much we could do."

Around seven in the morning, Al-Hindi, his sisters and four other men came to the family olive grove, just 200 meters from Gilad Farm, not far from Nablus, one of the dozens of illegal outposts spread across the West Bank. They harvested for three hours, until 10, when they noticed a group of settlers approaching from the direction of the outpost.
Advertisement
"They shouted, 'This is our grove, you can't go near it,' and threw rocks at us," says Al-Hindi. "One of them held my arm and another beat my head with a rock. I yelled 'Allahu Akbar, Allahu Akbar, and they said, 'I don't give a shit.' They beat me until they left."

10:52 - A police jeep arrives at the scene. Officer Amnon Barda gets out and begins questioning Abed. "Where were you? Did you see them? Do you know them? Where is your identity card?"

Zakhariah Sadah, a resident of the neighboring village of Git and an activist who works with Rabbis for Human Rights, offers his services as a translator, but Barda gets by. According to Sadah, after settlers threw rocks at olive harvesters at the nearby Farateh village, he and some Israeli volunteers guarded the groves. He says Al-Hindi and his family came to the grove without coordinating their arrival with Israeli authorities.

10:57 - A unit of the police Special Patrol Unit arrives in two vehicles. Barda updates the unit's commander on the incident. "What were they wearing?" he asks Al-Hindi, translating for a Special Unit member. "A white shirt, dark pants, black, tzitzit (ritual fringes)."

"That doesn't help me," the Special Unit man replies. "Did they have anything special on them? A hat? A pack?" Meanwhile, Barda has explained to Al-Hindi and Sadah they must file a complaint for an investigation to be opened. "This is already the third time that they've attacked in the last few days," Sadah says."

"But we don't hear about this in time," Barda responds.

11:07 - A police convoy slowly enters Gilad Farm. Barda's jeep is at the lead, followed by the two Special Unit vehicles. A new permanent structure is visible on a nearby hilltop, as is the constant expansion of the outpost. The jeep stops, and Special Unit officers are dispatched to remove Haaretz staffers on the grounds they are in a closed military zone.

11:18 - The incident is over. In the space of 11 minutes of activity in the outpost, which did not include searches, but rather polite questioning of a few residents, the police force exits Gilad Farm.

On his way out, Barda explains: "We were there, and we didn't find anything. Ask the spokesman of the Shai [West Bank police] district." The spokesman, Danny Poleg, says, "They searched according to the description of the suspects. This is being given over to handling on the intelligence level."

12:30 - Not far from Al-Hindi's olive grove stands Ibrahim Salah, 54, from Farateh village. Salah has been working for eight days, morning until evening, in the olive groves that belong to him and his family.

On Tuesday, his wife Nadia, his daughter Majed and his five-year-old grandson Salah were harvesting olives in the grove next to their house. They threw the olives onto a large black tarp and sorted them: the black ones solely for olive oil, the green ones for eating or oil.

Especially large green ones are considered a delicacy. They hauled the olives to a neighboring olive press, at which the yield of each tree will provide four to five liters of olive oil. A liter will sell for NIS 20. This year's crop is less successful than last year's.

According to Salah, in the present harvest, at least, the Civil Administration and the police have shown evident desire to help. "We coordinated the harvest at the grove next to the Gilad Farm two months in advance," he says. "Every morning, Rafi from the Coordination and Liaison Office calls me to tell me that I can come. When the police are there, there's no problem whatsoever. The situation this year has improved greatly. But the army by itself is worthless, because the soldiers do not take action."

Last year, settlers beat his son, Salah says, his voice charged with emotion. "They cut open his head and broke his arm. The army was there, but they did nothing, and the settlers continued to attack us."

Salah notes that the violence takes place within the villages as well. Three days ago, three armed settlers came to the entrance of the village, attacked a group of harvesters and threw everything they had harvested in every direction. "They have to be thrown out of these lands. They took over these lands and did not purchase them," he says.

Rachel Merhav, a volunteer from Yesh Din (Volunteers for Human Rights), which monitors settler violations of the law in the territories, declines to revel in the improvement this year. "Israel's splendid security forces know how to find the people they want to," she says. "But where violence by settlers is concerned, the process of bringing people to justice falls short." Dozens of cases have been closed under the determination that "the offender is unknown," Merhav says, adding that the pursuit of those cases in which an investigation is opened also falls short.

This week, Yesh Din sent a letter to the overall army's West Bank commander and the commander of the West Bank police district, demanding they take action to safeguard the olive harvest, prevent attacks on Palestinian farmers, and prosecute law breakers seeking to disrupt the harvest.

Yesh Did studied a series of incidents last year between settlers and Palestinian harvesters, finding that not a single indictment was filed from investigations of the attacks.

In response, police spokesman Poleg says Yesh Din's list of demands has yet to reach the police district office, and that the group's complaints will be examined.
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Administrative orphans
Six Hebron children, whose parents were arrested, were left with their grandmother.
Change the past
Father of Jewish psychology suggests avoiding picking away at the scars of the past.
  1.   No Peace No Peace 09:23  |  Yishai Kohen 18/10/07
  2.   The olive harvest criminals 09:37  |  Esther 18/10/07
  3.   Don`t like it when the tables are turned? 09:41  |  Efox 18/10/07
  4.   Intolerable official blind eye at this stage of the Peace procces 10:11  |  Ivar 18/10/07
  5.   Israel, the settlements and the VIAGRA problem..... 10:14  |  Swiss (Dino) 18/10/07
  6.   Untermenschen shouldn`t expect justice 10:39  |  Clickfool 18/10/07
  7.   Settler terrorists 10:41  |  JW 18/10/07
  8.   Settler terrorists 10:43  |  JW 18/10/07
  9.   making enemies 10:49  |  habakook 18/10/07
  10.   ISRAELIS ARE ABOVE THE LAW 10:53  |  indrajaya 18/10/07
  11.   Esther : well said , nice attitdue 11:06  |  Sam (UK) 18/10/07
  12.   onesided reporting 11:17  |  colleen 18/10/07
  13.   Yisha 11:23  |  reality check 18/10/07
  14.   Israel is a criminal entity and its population... 11:24  |  Dutch Dirk 18/10/07
  15.   Military Zone? 11:24  |  Curious 18/10/07
  16.   Effox......................... 11:24  |  reality check 18/10/07
  17.   Re Yishai #1 11:25  |  Esther 18/10/07
  18.   Who says it`s true? 11:54  |  Absolute Sweden 18/10/07
  19.   Esther- let`s see you say that after getting shot at a few times 12:09  |  Dani 18/10/07
  20.   THE "SETTLERS" ARE THE ARABS NOT THE JEWS 12:29  |  PalestniansAreA Myth 18/10/07
  21.   To Absolute Sweden@18 12:46  |  Checker 18/10/07
  22.   Endless Harassment of Jewish Farmers By Arabs 13:01  |  Ben Israel 18/10/07
  23.   Justice 13:19  |  Ralph 18/10/07
  24.   "checker" from Hollywood 13:22  |  Absolute Sweden 18/10/07
  25.   # 21 Checker 13:22  |  Lynn 18/10/07
  26.   Dont believe everything these liars say..except if youre Haaretz 13:31  |  GrossedOut 18/10/07
  27.   Palestinian thres-passsers 13:33  |  Nathan 18/10/07
  28.   Racism on talkback 13:33  |  OneBlood 18/10/07
  29.   #20 Blame the victims again 13:36  |  Boycott 18/10/07
  30.   #14 Dutch Dirk 13:38  |  Boycott 18/10/07
  31.   Note that Israelis claimed they were attacked 13:42  |  Ilan 18/10/07
  32.   #18 Absolute Sweden 13:44  |  Boycott 18/10/07
  33.   Yishai Kohen - I SO agree with you...I still believe tho that 13:46  |  Lee Marks 18/10/07
  34.   To Ester 13:51  |  Jon Hamill, Ph.D. 18/10/07
  35.   Dear Mr. Haaretz ! Why they call you as LEFTIST ? 13:59  |  Atilla Karagözoğlu 18/10/07
  36.   Pinocchio (Absolute) Sweden #24 14:07  |  Gepetto 18/10/07
  37.   Real settlers are the Arabs who colonised our land in 7th Century 14:14  |  Time for Transfer 18/10/07
  38.   Biblical land has lots of Olive trees,whose land is it? 14:30  |  sam 18/10/07
  39.   #2 Esther 14:42  |  Cal me Sam 18/10/07
  40.   ## 7 JW 14:45  |  Ron 18/10/07
  41.   # 20, in Maryland 14:49  |  Sam 18/10/07
  42.   # 34, to Esther from John Hamil Ph.d 14:54  |  Sam 18/10/07
  43.   So what? Fair is fair. 15:08  |  Steven A. 18/10/07
  44.   HAARETZ ! SOME SAY YOU ARE LITTLE LIGHT NEWS SITE ! 15:16  |  Atilla Karagözoğlu 18/10/07
  45.   spreading malignancy 15:18  |  Jimmy Carter 18/10/07
  46.   # 43, So what, Steven in the UK 15:24  |  Bob 18/10/07
  47.   Sam from Tel Aviv...we wish! 15:35  |  Krin 18/10/07
  48.   Olive Trees ! Last week I did buy some BIG YELLOW OLIVES 15:38  |  Atilla 18/10/07
  49.   #46 Bob 15:40  |  Steven A. 18/10/07
  50.   haaretz ! why you dont let me write some great politics ? 15:43  |  why ! 18/10/07
  51.   haaretz ! why you dont let me write some great politics ? 15:43  |  why ! 18/10/07
  52.   Too bad,so sad 15:44  |  Nemesis 18/10/07
  53.   When Dolev vineyard ruined was there outrage? 16:17  |  Ilan 18/10/07
  54.   So realy, how many Arabs were killed by settlers?? 16:25  |  TOMY 18/10/07
  55.   wearing a girl shoes 16:27  |  Atilla 18/10/07
  56.   Some Yesh Din recommendation to the IDF 16:31  |  Tosefta 18/10/07
  57.   Who controls this situation 16:35  |  HARALD 18/10/07
  58.   A common occurance... 16:36  |  Silvienne 18/10/07
  59.   I forgot ! 16:38  |  Atilla 18/10/07
  60.   Last time we had these accusations 16:47  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 18/10/07
  61.   SOLUTION:NEGOTIATE NOT WITH PA,ONLY WITH EACH ARAB FAMILY THAT TH 17:15  |  VOICE of MOSHIACH))) 18/10/07
  62.   Margie in Tel Aviv 17:16  |  Danite 18/10/07
  63.   Nr. 58 and Margie in TelAviv 17:26  |  Krin 18/10/07
  64.   arab = olive thief 17:29  |  Ephraim 18/10/07
  65.   Ilan #53 - of course you`re right 17:31  |  Polybios 18/10/07
  66.   Stopping settlers is not enough 17:40  |  Tosefta 18/10/07
  67.   For Danite #62 18:11  |  Esther 18/10/07
  68.   Danite there are two attitudes: both extreme 18:30  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 18/10/07
  69.   With no proof of a crime ..its "rabbis for piece vs the Jews" 18:40  |  pace306 18/10/07
  70.   Palestine is Jordan 19:21  |  tired of the lies 18/10/07
  71.   Israel founded on socialism 19:24  |  Ethel 18/10/07
  72.   IDF is criminal 19:39  |  Joe 18/10/07
  73.   Tosefta - what hole did you climb out of??? 19:40  |  Dr Eric 18/10/07
  74.   Ben Israel, #22 19:42  |  Maki 18/10/07
  75.   Ron - what are you talking about? 19:43  |  Dr Eric 18/10/07
  76.   The Wild West Rule Reigns, Ephraim #64 19:47  |  Tzfonit 18/10/07
  77.   # 62 Danite 19:50  |  Swiss (Dino) 18/10/07
  78.   Yishai Kohen and the cycle of violence 20:25  |  newageblues 18/10/07
  79.   Usually Innocent until proven guilty 20:25  |  Attorney