Subscribe to Print Edition | Tue., October 23, 2007 , | | Israel Time: 17:26 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Arts & Leisure Real Estate Jewish World National Advertising
Magazine Week's End Business Opinion Rosner's Domain Anglo File Books Travel
del.icio.us
Digg It!  new
Last update - 10:44 12/10/2007
Germany's Iranian secret
By Benjamin Weinthal

Germany's role in the crisis caused by Iran's nuclear program typifies a kind of split national personality. On the one hand, already in early 2006 Chancellor Angela Merkel, of the Christian Democratic Union (CDU), drew a diplomatic line in the sand when she declared, "A president who questions Israel's right to exist, a president who denies the Holocaust, cannot expect to receive any tolerance from Germany." The fact that Ahmadinejad openly entertains the notion of exterminating Israel prompted Merkel to add, "We must take the Iranian president's rhetoric seriously."

But Merkel's tough political rhetoric stands in sharp contrast to the pricey business deals German firms have closed with the Tehran regime, to the tune of $5.7 billion in 2006. That makes Germany Iran's most important trading partner in the European Union.

A total of 5,000 German enterprises conduct business with Iran, and the list reads like a "Who's Who" of blue-chip corporations, including Mercedes-Benz, Volkswagen, Krupp and Hermes, the debt guarantee entity for exports. The extent of the Iranian economy's dependency on German know-how was summed up by Michael Tockuss, the former president of the German-Iranian Chamber of Commerce in Tehran: "Some two thirds of Iranian industry relies on German engineering products."
Advertisement
The government's tolerant attitude toward the private-public sector business relationship with Iran was best captured in a late September conference - an initiative of Germany's Economics Ministry - intended to promote expanded trade with Iran. During a follow-up to this conference in early October, the German Chambers of Industry and Commerce (IHK) advised companies about "market entry and opportunities of expansion" in Iran. But this splendid business partnership may very well be Germany's best-kept secret. According to the German business paper Handelsblatt, "German companies are trying ... not to publicize their contracts with Tehran." For that reason, the power of Iran in Germany is the scandal that dares not speak its name.

How does one explain the disconnect between Merkel's tough political rhetoric and her government's inability to clamp down on the mushrooming business deals, many of which involve the sale of dual-use technology (that is, for both civilian and military purposes)?

Petra Hitzler, who oversees trade relations with Iran in the Economics Ministry, said she cannot comment on dual-use technology because "it is not possible to inspect the business transactions of private companies." A spokesperson from the Federal Office of Economics and Export Control - the agency charged with scrutinizing business with Iran - told me that privacy laws prevent her from publicly naming German firms that have received special permission to supply material for civilian-use nuclear reactors in Iran. More disturbingly, she added, "we cannot control how the material is utilized in Iran."

The revelation in early July that the public prosecutor in the city of Potsdam expanded its ongoing investigation of a group of German companies - whose contracts with Iran total between $100 million and $150 million - because of their allegedly unlawful supply of materials has raised troubling questions about Germany's official policy of being committed to preventing Iran from acquiring the bomb.

The initial investigation involved some 50 companies, but has meanwhile been narrowed down to three or four firms, accused of smuggling technology to Iran's Bushehr nuclear plant. In 1974, Siemens played a vital role in building Bushehr's reactor, which was destroyed during the Iran-Iraq war. Matthias Kuentzel, a German political scientist and a leading observer of the field of German-Iranian relations, wrote: "In August 2003, Siemens signed a contract for the delivery of 24 power stations. To make this deal, Siemens had to commit itself to 'technology transfer with regard to small and medium-sized power stations.'"

Foreign Minister Frank Walter-Steinmeier has asserted that an Iranian nuclear bomb must be prevented, but he clearly is unwilling to match his rhetoric with concrete action. In short, Germany will not initiate unilateral sanctions against Iran.

Thomas von der Osten-Sacken, a Middle East expert who heads the Wadi organization, based in Iraq, argues that "the Foreign Ministry is blocking Merkel, who is alone in her human rights policy." Even Merkel's party colleague Ruprecht Polenz, the CDU chairman of the German parliament's foreign relations committee, calls this an "international crisis, whose key does not lie with Germany." When I asked him if Germany could take a cutting-edge role in imposing an economic embargo against Iran, Polenz replied that such an approach is not "sound."

The director of the Middle East section of the German Institute of Global Area Studies, Dr. Udo Steinbach, offered reasons for such an attitude in a interview he gave to the Eurasisches Magazin in April: "Europe should in no way feel threatened," if Iran secures nuclear weapons; rather, he said, "Iran is a threat to a secular Turkey and, of course, Israel." Steinbach's Middle East department receives a lot of funding from the German Foreign Ministry. The British-American journalist Christopher Hitchens has written, in a different context, that "only a moral cretin thinks that anti-Semitism is a threat only to Jews." Similarly, you'd have to be an imbecile to think a nuclear-armed Iran is a threat only to a secular Turkey and Israel. Is Germany smart enough to move beyond short-term profit maximization, to work for long-term peace in the Middle East and Europe?

Benjamin Weinthal is a journalist working in Berlin.
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Killer father
Rabin killer's wife says will tell their son his father 'sacrificed himself for his people'.
Tehran to Tel Aviv
A Christian-Jewish group is promising dozens of Iranian Jews a better life in Israel.
  1.   German bashing - Israelis favourite pasttime 11:02  |  Leona 12/10/07
  2.   Everything will come out 11:23  |  Jonathan S 12/10/07
  3.   Asian companies 11:26  |  Shahin 12/10/07
  4.   If we know about 11:29  |  Chris Linthwaite 12/10/07
  5.   If Israel is unhappy with germany 11:32  |  Chris Linthwaite 12/10/07
  6.   basically trade should 11:47  |  cool 12/10/07
  7.   For Chris Linthwaite 11:54  |  Jonathan S 12/10/07
  8.   #7 Jonathan S 12:08  |  Chris Linthwaite 12/10/07
  9.   One thing less popular than a German is a self-hating German. 12:08  |  Andreas 12/10/07
  10.   For Andreas 12:17  |  Jonathan S 12/10/07
  11.   What Germany is doing is 100% normal and legal 12:21  |  Mark B. 12/10/07
  12.   Chris Linthwaite 12:22  |  S 12/10/07
  13.   #8 12:28  |  kraut 12/10/07
  14.   Hello,Israel-bashers! 12:39  |  Hastaroth 12/10/07
  15.   Exterminating Israel? 12:44  |  Aren Haich 12/10/07
  16.   Farewell to the West 12:46  |  Jonathan S 12/10/07
  17.   German behaviour is amoral and illegal 12:56  |  Jonathan S 12/10/07
  18.   #12 S 13:01  |  Chris Linthwaite 12/10/07
  19.   #15 Aren Haich 13:23  |  Hastaroth 12/10/07
  20.   Linthwaite and his futile hopes #12 13:33  |  Jonathan S 12/10/07
  21.   # 2 Jonathan S 13:38  |  Lynn 12/10/07
  22.   #17 Jonathan S 13:54  |  Chris Linthwaite 12/10/07
  23.   Chris Lithwaite 13:55  |  Lynn 12/10/07
  24.   For Lynn 14:13  |  Jonathan S 12/10/07
  25.   To # 19 Dissolution of Israel 14:14  |  Aren Haich 12/10/07
  26.   To No. 19 Dissolving Israel 14:24  |  Aren Haich 12/10/07
  27.   $$$ Ahead of Morals 14:40  |  Ruth 12/10/07
  28.   #20 Jonathan S 14:45  |  Chris Linthwaite 12/10/07
  29.   To no. 19 Future of Israel 14:53  |  Aren Haich 12/10/07
  30.   Weinthal understands nothing, or intentionally misleads, or both 14:56  |  Tosefta 12/10/07
  31.   #20 14:59  |  kraut 12/10/07
  32.   Remember: the USA did biz with the Nazis 15:03  |  POP 12/10/07
  33.   its not Germanys fault this time! 15:12  |  Igor D. 12/10/07
  34.   No. 17 But German`s Behaviour is NORMAL!!! 15:21  |  Sohel Saheen 12/10/07
  35.   tosefeta`s willful blindness 15:21  |  Leon 12/10/07
  36.   Tosefta understands nothing, knows nothing 15:24  |  Jonathan S 12/10/07
  37.   @27 Ruth on morals 15:26  |  Mark B. 12/10/07
  38.   Israel like a FAT & SPOILT little kid 15:29  |  Espart 12/10/07
  39.   Linthwaite the Chamberlain of our times 15:36  |  Jonathan S 12/10/07
  40.   Aren Haich 15:38  |  millie 12/10/07
  41.   For Kraut 15:58  |  Jonathan S 12/10/07
  42.   The willful paranoids (Leon #35; Jonathan S #36) 16:31  |  Tosefta 12/10/07
  43.   #23 Lynn 16:43  |  Chris Linthwaite 12/10/07
  44.   Tell one state 16:47  |  Imke 12/10/07
  45.   Tosefta 16:59  |  Danite 12/10/07
  46.   This Isn`t Going To Matter In The Long Run 17:21  |  Yosemite 12/10/07
  47.   Where is Anton, from Bonn, who denied it yesterday? 17:23  |  Fortuna Benmayor 12/10/07
  48.   Hey German Jews, Aren`t You Proud ? 17:25  |  Tod Zuckerman 12/10/07
  49.   To Jonathan S. You were right, I was wrong. 17:26  |  Fortuna Benmayor 12/10/07
  50.   To Jonathan S 18:06  |  Persian Kitty 12/10/07
  51.   Iraq also trades with Iran 18:17  |  MichaelF 12/10/07
  52.   Germany says this, does that. Just like "all" other countries... 18:27  |  bat yam 12/10/07
  53.   Mark 18:43  |  Ruth 12/10/07
  54.   UGY the she-camel`s owner (re Dumbite #42) 19:04  |  Tosefta 12/10/07
  55.   Germany`s is acting as a criminal nation. 19:15  |  Tatiana 12/10/07
  56.   Jonathan S: Israel & SA during the apartheid years 19:19  |  Jethro 12/10/07
  57.   #47, Fortuna Benmayor 19:38  |  Anton 12/10/07
  58.   For Fortuna Benmayor 19:40  |  Jonathan S 12/10/07
  59.   For Persian Kitty from Frankfurt Cat 19:48  |  Jonathan S 12/10/07
  60.   #39 Jonathan S 19:59  |  Chris Linthwaite 12/10/07
  61.   Blinded Tosefta and paranoid Germans 20:32  |  Jonathan S 12/10/07
  62.   Bravo Chris Linthwaite! 21:16  |  Jonathan S 12/10/07
  63.   No 55, Germany , Russia need Iran 21:29  |  TigerPaul 12/10/07
  64.   The israeli Glass-Box 22:06  |  Bernd 12/10/07
  65.   THE WRITER; A `JOURNALIST` OR AN ANTO-IRANIAN ZIONIST RACIST? 22:21  |  JACKAL 12/10/07
  66.   #58 Jonathan S, the garbage consumer 22:22  |  Tosefta 12/10/07
  67.   christipher hitchens is a drink-sodden Trotskyist-turned zionist 22:23  |  JACKAL 12/10/07
  68.   Germany has no shame. The country is a psychopath 23:45  |  Jason from colorado 12/10/07
  69.   question 2 the Germany bashers ? 01:01  |  Alex 13/10/07
  70.   # 24 Jonathan S 01:02  |  Lynn 13/10/07
  71.   Jonathan S # 36 01:04  |  Lynn 13/10/07
  72.   #9 01:12  |  Alex 13/10/07
  73.   ashamed german 01:14  |  jens 13/10/07
  74.   T0 No. 40 millie Misconceptions 01:41  |  Aren haich 13/10/07
  75.   the dual-use conundrum 03:37  |  joebhed 13/10/07
  76.   Jonathan, whazzat again? 03:48  |  joebhed 13/10/07
  77.   Finding the truth 05:06  |  Neil 13/10/07
  78.   Tossed Fetta: re paranoia and Jonathon S 05:12  |  Star of David 13/10/07
  79.   for Tosefta 05:16  |  Star of David 13/10/07
  80.   Akbar Hashemi Rafsanjani 07:09  |  Yosemite 13/10/07
  81.   Chris Linthwaite 08:42  |  MarkC