Subscribe to Print Edition | Thu., October 11, 2007 , | | Israel Time: 07:55 (EST+7) web haaretz.com   Back to Homepage Print Edition Diplomacy Defense Arts & Leisure Real Estate Jewish World National Advertising Magazine Week's End Business Opinion Rosner's Domain Anglo File Books Travel

del.icio.us Digg It!  new Last update - 09:58 10/10/2007 The right of the link By Eliezer Yaari In her article "The right and the return" (Haaretz, October 3), Ruth Gavison discusses what is again becoming the watershed in the interrupted dialogue between the Palestinians and Israel. At issue are historical rights, and in this case Israel's unwillingness to recognize the Palestinians' right of return. As in all the previous rounds, this watershed will end the diplomatic discussions aimed at an agreement. Gavison proposes an alternative definition for "the right of return": "the desire to return," which she says Israel would recognize. On the other hand, she says that remaining in the framework of the "right of return" is a recipe for disaster. Missing in Gavison's approach is an overall concept recognizing that both sides in the conflict are in a crisis of self-definition stemming from their inability to realize that there is no direct connection between a cultural, historical and practical attachment and a future political right. Not only the Palestinians suffer from a difficulty in bridging the gap between the attachment and the right. The motivating force of practical Zionism since 1967 has been the attempt to turn the historical attachment to all parts of the Land of Israel, which nobody disputes, into a political right. To translate the desire to return to Shiloh, Beit El, Anatot and Hebron - the cradle of the nation - into a diplomatic right over which there can be no compromise because it is impossible to compromise on a right granted thousands of years ago. By dint of that same right, claim those who hold it sacred, the Zionists came to the Jezreel Valley and Jerusalem, and afterward to Shiloh and Hebron. Advertisement It should be recalled that from the outset Zionism conceded the political right to all parts of the Land of Israel, and tried to achieve international political recognition of the Jewish homeland in the Land of Israel, within any possible physical border. At the same time, the national institutions of the Jewish people never conceded their attachment to parts of the Land of Israel that did not receive political recognition. This view - a bond that does not translate into a full right to the territory - was shared by national-religious Zionism, as opposed to the secular Revisionist camp, which did not give up the distinction between an attachment and a right. Recognition of the fact that Israel would not be able to continue to define itself as a democratic nation state without a strong national majority prevented the annexation of the territories occupied in the Six-Day War. Although there are people who propose achieving this majority through ethnic cleansing, the Israelis and their various governments have rejected these ideas and still do. In the talks between former prime minister Ehud Barak and Yasser Arafat, too, Israel demanded that the Palestinians concede the right of return, without distinguishing between the political right and what was understood as a demand to give up the bond, the desire to return (according to Gavison's definition). Justice will be achieved when both sides undergo this process in which they concede the political right without losing the bond. Israeli society must also learn to be satisfied with the desire to return to parts of the Land of Israel, with the attachment alone, without any intention of turning it into the political right to return. In that context we should mention that even those who say we should be satisfied with a bond must have such a bond. The problem with the Israeli center, and mainly with the left, is that they no longer have any major leaders who can confront the camp of believers on this issue. But leaders from the past like David Ben-Gurion and Berl Katznelson did not hesitate to confront religious Zionism's spiritual leaders and present a diplomatic viewpoint that separates the attachment to the land from the political right to it. One of the reasons why the left and center, which have given up on the attachment to the land (despite hollow declarations about "Jerusalem the city that was reunified") are having difficulty dealing with the Palestinian side is due to this absence of a bond. For this purpose there is no difference between Ehud Olmert, Ehud Barak, Yossi Beilin, Avigdor Lieberman or Zehava Gal-On. The writer is the director-general of the New Israel Fund. Bookmark to del.icio.us Bad publicity Tiv Taam is fighting for public opinion in order to counter a consumer affairs T.V. show. The biggest stage For the first time in its history, Maccabi Tel Aviv will play against the New York Knicks.   1.   Ethnic Cleansing? Can we use that term now? 11:01  |  Natallie Durson 10/10/07   2.   the "Promised Land" 11:58  |  Oldtimer 10/10/07   3.   Oldtimer you wrong 12:15  |  Tamir Palestine 10/10/07   4.   "The chosen" 13:51  |  Oldtimer 10/10/07   5.   In The Bible it`s Israel 14:05  |  Read The Bible 10/10/07   6.   For Any Non-Leftists Reading Haartez 14:50  |  Yisrael 10/10/07   7.   read the bible 5 15:52  |  realism 10/10/07   8.   excuse me... 16:00  |  bernard 10/10/07   9.   I`m not sure which Bible you are reading 17:22  |  Tamir Palestine 10/10/07   10.   People who later converted to Christian and Islam lived here 17:28  |  Tamir Palestine 10/10/07   11.   My Pal moslim friend grand, grand parents were jews 17:37  |  Tamir Palestine 10/10/07   12.   The mandate: Bible 18:50  |  Oldtimer 10/10/07   13.   Natalie 04:51  |  Paul Katz 11/10/07

Today Online Amir Oren: Extremist Islam is the enemy, not the Palestinians Responses: 266 Ephraim Sneh: When it comes to Iran, Israel must expect the worst Responses: 134 Abbas lays out first precise demands for Palestinian borders Responses: 341 German historian publishes chilling read: Hitler's fan mail Responses: 89 U.S. gov't said split over Israeli intel on N. Korea- Syria ties Responses: 79 Haaretz TV: Many Arab J'lem residents are on 'wrong' side of fence Responses: 12 More Headlines 03:54 MI assessment: Mideast peace summit likely to fail 07:16 Hamas says it plans to conduct reconciliation talks with Fatah 07:27 Putin says a nuclear Iran would be a strategic threat to Russia 06:03 Germany to set free Iranian assassin despite Israel's plea 07:13 Jerusalem conference seeks to revive the language of Ladino 04:15 Police to resume questioning of PM over Bank Leumi affair 03:00 Barak won't interfere in legal clash over final Winograd report 06:18 Israeli WWII veterans honored for service to Royal Navy 23:55 U.S. House committee passes Armenian genocide resolution 22:19 Putin spurns Leviev, invites 'Gaydamak's rabbi' to Kremlin Previous Editions Select Day 10 oct 09 oct 08 oct 07 oct 05 oct 04 oct 03 oct 02 oct 01 oct 30 sep 28 sep 27 sep

Special Offers Advertisement learn Hebrew online with israel's best teachers. Sign up for a trial lesson today Invest in Macedonia New Business Heaven in Europe Long-term Israel programs MASA is your gateway. More programs. More grants. Eldan Rent a Car Israel's leading car rental company offers you a 20% discount on all online reservations JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here! Dead Sea Salt Beauty and skin care from the Dead Sea. Coupon code HAARETZ for 10% off! Israeli History Documentaries. Own a piece of Israel?s treasured past. Junkyard Junk a car - get free towing nationwide and a tax-deductible receipt. Holiday Inn and Crown Plaza Israel Lowest internet rate Guaranteed at ichotelsgroup.com !

Home | TV | Print Edition | Diplomacy | Opinion | Arts & Leisure | Sports | Jewish World | Underground | Site rules |

© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved