JNF heads oppose law allowing leasing of land only to Jews <br><br> - Haaretz

Subscribe to Print Edition

Wed., October 10, 2007 ,

Israel Time: 19:32 (EST+7)

web haaretz.com

Back to Homepage

Print Edition

Diplomacy

Defense

Arts & Leisure

Real Estate

Jewish World

National

Advertising

Magazine

Week's End

Business

Opinion

Rosner's Domain

Anglo File

Books

Travel



		Deputy JNF chairman Menachem Leibovitz. (Archive)

del.icio.us

Digg It! new

Last update - 14:53 09/10/2007

JNF heads oppose law allowing leasing of land only to Jews

By Shahar Ilan, Haaretz Correspondent

Most of the Jewish National Fund's leadership is against a law that would allow it to continue leasing land only to Jews, deputy JNF chairman Menachem Leibovitz told Haaretz Monday.

"We want to reach an arrangement with the state within three months and there is no reason, no justification and no wisdom in enacting a JNF law. I imagine that is the position of most of the JNF leadership," he said.

The proposed bill calls for a comprehensive land swap with the Israel Lands Administration. Under the deal, the JNF would give the ILA land slated for construction in urban centers, in exchange for rural territory.

	Advertisement

Leibovitz said he believed the bill in question, which would allow the JNF to continue leasing land only to Jews, would be "harmful to the Jewish people." Monday, during the Knesset Economics Committee's first discussion of the bill, JNF legal advisor Meir Alfeia announced unexpectedly that he did not believe he had to tell the committee the JNF's position on the bill.

Sixty-four lawmakers supported the bill in its preliminary reading.

Leibovitz also told Haaretz Monday that at the last meeting, the JNF's board of directors had decided to work toward an arrangement to give the state its lands in urban centers. The JNF would receive available rural lands in exchange.

Attorney General Menachem Mazuz supports this arrangement as a means of solving the crisis over JNF lands.

Aliza Ken of the Justice Ministry told the committee Monday that Mazuz believes the law does severe damage to the cause of equality and even human dignity and will make wrongful discrimination legal. She added that Mazuz said the Israel Lands Authority "has to maintain the principle of equality and could not discriminate based on ethnicity in its actions as manager of JNF lands."

Under the previous policy, in cases when a non-Jewish individual won a tender for JNF lands, the organization would transfer the lot to the ILA and receive alternate land in exchange. Mazuz opposes continuing this policy and supports a comprehensive exchange of lands.

Balad Chairman Jamal Zahalka told the Economics Committee Monday, "You are discriminating against Arabs in the name of Judaism. Shame on you. There is another Judaism."

MK Gilad Erdan (Likud) said the real question was "whether the State of Israel had ended its function. Those who support this law believe that the struggle for the Jewish identity of Israel is not over."

More Jewish World news and features

Bookmark to del.icio.us


	Group goals
	Hapoel T.A. could be given either death or a dream in the UEFA Cup group stage draw.


	Bandits on wheels
	The new vehicles most often stolen in September were Sanyung motorbikes.




1.	pass law that arabs must also sell to jews make it equal first	04:43	\|	ralph	09/10/07

2.	Remove the JNF heads	08:44	\|	Daniel	09/10/07

3.	And do unto thy neighbor....	09:13	\|	Esther	09/10/07

4.	ralph	09:50	\|	A.M.	09/10/07

5.	JNF: A proposed betrayal of generations of Jews	10:30	\|	Jonathan Engel	09/10/07

6.	Complete nonsense,I`m aware of a student dormatory	10:58	\|	Ansolute Sweden	09/10/07

7.	Familiar error	11:08	\|	Murray	09/10/07

8.	To Murray No 7	13:22	\|	Jackie	09/10/07

9.	Not the question, Jackie	13:41	\|	Murray	09/10/07

10.	Murray`s high moral ground	13:42	\|	jerry	09/10/07

11.	What?	14:06	\|	Murray	09/10/07

12.	I smell another lie	14:20	\|	Paul	09/10/07

13.	Nr 7, Murray - thanks	14:56	\|	Ruth	09/10/07

14.	#9 Murray	14:58	\|	John Allen	09/10/07

15.	#14, here we go again	15:11	\|	Ruth	09/10/07

16.	#13 Ruth	15:18	\|	John Allen	09/10/07

17.	Name Sectarian Knesset Members	15:47	\|	Ann Fink	09/10/07

18.	Jewish Credentials	15:54	\|	Ann Fink	09/10/07

19.	#16, John Allen, what`s your point?	16:45	\|	Ruth	09/10/07

20.	why Arabs are killed for selling property to jews?	19:47	\|	ISSY Hass	09/10/07

21.	Just remember: The vast majority of the land...	19:27	\|	Kol ha-Nevi`im	10/10/07

Today Online


	Amir Oren: Extremist Islam is the enemy, not the Palestinians
	Responses: 160


	Ephraim Sneh: When it comes to Iran, Israel must expect the worst
	Responses: 67


	Abbas lays out first precise demands for Palestinian borders
	Responses: 178


	German historian publishes chilling read: Hitler's fan mail
	Responses: 59


	U.S. gov't said split over Israeli intel on N. Korea- Syria ties
	Responses: 59


	Haaretz TV: Many Arab J'lem residents are on 'wrong' side of fence
	Responses: 3

Rosner's Domain

* Romney's position on attacking Iran? better ask his lawyers

* WTR: The debate over Tutu

* Understanding the Israeli Attack on Syria

* Poll: A divided Jerusalem?

More Headlines
19:26 Comptroller issues order preventing Zelekha ouster


19:31 PA Chair Abbas lays out first precise demands for Palestinian borders


17:37 High Court: Labor laws to apply to Palestinians in settlements


19:30 Poland honors 53 who risked lives to save Jews in WWII


19:29 Bush urges Congress to reject Armenian genocide resolution


13:10 New York Times: U.S. gov't split over Israeli data on Syria-N. Korea ties


15:02 PA sources: IDF kills Fatah militant, wounds another in Nablus raid


17:32 PA: Israel grants permanent residency to 3,500 West Bank Palestinians


16:50 Palestinian-born Jewish convert convicted of aiding Islamic Jihad


14:02 German historian publishes chilling read: Hitler's fan mail