Subscribe to Print Edition | Fri., October 12, 2007 , | | Israel Time: 06:12 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Arts & Leisure Real Estate Jewish World National Advertising
Magazine Week's End Business Opinion Rosner's Domain Anglo File Books Travel
del.icio.us
Digg It!  new
Last update - 09:22 09/10/2007
The cat's tail
By Yoel Marcus

If peace breaks out between the Israelis and Palestinians at the Annapolis summit, I'll eat my hat.

Coincidentally or not, three days after the scheduled opening date, on November 29, it will be 60 years since the UN General Assembly approved the Partition Plan for creating two states in Mandatory Palestine. The Jews greeted the resolution with singing and dancing. The Arabs flatly rejected it, opening fire on two Egged buses the very next day.

The declaration of statehood on May 14, 1948 kicked off the War of Independence, and the blood spilled since then has smeared every page of the history books. Arab stupidity, intransigence and hatred dragged Israel into the Six-Day War, leading to 40 years of occupation and dominion over the Palestinian people.
Advertisement
It has taken us a long time to understand that this glorious victory, studied in military academies around the world, was a pyrrhic victory. Today no democratic country rules another people, except Israel. Israel has become a prisoner of its 40-year occupation, turning us into a chronic target of terrorism and censure. We are denounced by both the Islamic world and the enlightened world.

The Annapolis summit takes us back 60 years, but with one difference. Most of the Palestinians are prepared to divide the country today, but on condition that they don't pay a penny for their idiocy, their ineptitude and their crimes, not to mention the Jewish blood they have spilled. They demand that we turn the clock back, that we pay them restitution, that we agree to their right of return, and so on and so on.

I don't know what Arab Palestine would have looked like if the Palestinians had accepted the UN Partition Plan in 1947. My guess is that their state would have been bigger, we would have been reasonably good neighbors, and they would be better off than they are today. But the world has changed. Political interests have changed. Imperialism has gone out of style. The Cold War between the superpowers has turned into a struggle against a new enemy: crazed Islamic fundamentalists who have declared global war on the infidels, on the Great Satan, on the Little Satan. All are targets of deadly, indiscriminate terror - terror that is nurturing nuclear claws.

Who would have believed that after the annihilation of 6 million Jews, a Holocaust-denying Muslim leader would get up in New York and openly declare that his goal is wiping out Israel? Who would have believed that his emissaries and instructors would be infiltrating Israel to help Palestinian extremist organizations complete the job that Hitler didn't finish?

If there was ever a time when strong leaders were needed to reach an agreement between the two peoples, before a third intifada breaks out, the time is now. The first to realize this was Ariel Sharon, who sent the dream of a Greater Israel into the deep freeze and focused on disengaging from the territories and dividing the land. No one knows what he would have done had he seen how the evacuation of Gush Katif turned out, with Gaza turning from a liberated territory into a Hamas base for attacks on Israeli towns. But it is clear now that unilateral disengagement was a mistake. There is no substitute for an agreement between the parties, and there never will be.

On the eve of the summit, the problem is the feeble leadership of Ehud Olmert and Mahmoud Abbas (Abu Mazen). They look more like two British gentlemen meeting for a drink at the club than tough statesmen who can force the extremists in their camps to accept peace based on mutual concessions and conciliation with the enemy.

I find it hard to imagine Abu Mazen putting his foot down in Gaza, halting terror, dissolving the terrorist organizations and ending the Qassam rocket fire. I find it hard to imagine Olmert, under a cloud of criminal investigations, getting a quarter of a million Greater Israel groupies to give up the territories and kiss some of their settlements goodbye. In the cabinet, I don't see how Olmert will get around Ehud Barak, who opposes the summit and calls it "hot air," or Tzipi Livni and Avi Dichter, who are riddled with doubt, or Shaul Mofaz, who says that "Jerusalem is not a piece of real estate."

These guys can't even tie a knot in a cat's tail, Pinhas Sapir used to say about politicians of the Olmert and Abu Mazen ilk. With George W. Bush and Olmert scraping the bottom of the barrel in the public opinion polls, and Abu Mazen lacking his people's support, peace is not going to erupt in Annapolis. But the importance of this summit is that it is held at all. No one ever died from talking.
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Mover and baker
N.Y. celebrity baker Ron Ben-Israel created a two-ton cake to mark the Plaza's centennial.
Show must go on
The glory of making the pilgrimage to NYC and play against the Knicks has its price.
  1.   mr. marcus is perfectly right 09:29  |  saul a. readner 09/10/07
  2.   verbal fornication 09:46  |  KMS 09/10/07
  3.   Try to denyit: but facts are facts 09:51  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 09/10/07
  4.   Ethnocratic- not democratic Israel don`t want peace 09:54  |  Petter 09/10/07
  5.   Excellent, Yoel! 09:56  |  S 09/10/07
  6.   Olmert and Abbas are inconsequential. Bush is boss 10:08  |  Natallie Durson 09/10/07
  7.   Zionism=Nazism 10:11  |  Albert 09/10/07
  8.   Wrong conclusions,it`s false "none died of talking",Münich is an 10:21  |  Absolute Sweden 09/10/07
  9.   Yoel, what can one say after that? 10:26  |  Esther 09/10/07
  10.   Never the right time for peace 10:30  |  Andrew watson 09/10/07
  11.   Impossible to make peace with a fictional entity because there 10:41  |  Uzi 09/10/07
  12.   NOTE FOR LABARSEAND JOHNBOY 10:45  |  paul harris 09/10/07
  13.   Arabs must spell out what they GIVE in return for what they want 10:47  |  Uzi 09/10/07
  14.   ruling another people 11:09  |  john 09/10/07
  15.   Inconsistent 11:19  |  bill 09/10/07
  16.   #6 Why would I, Paul Harris? 11:32  |  Johnboy 09/10/07
  17.   Sorry Yoel 11:35  |  Palestinian Prince 09/10/07
  18.   Margie # 2 11:38  |  Guido 09/10/07
  19.   #7 They are an OCCUPIED PEOPLE, Uzi! 11:48  |  Johnboy 09/10/07
  20.   #12 THE PALESTINIAN STATE IS CALLED JORDAN 11:50  |  paul harris 09/10/07
  21.   albert and his strange view of zionism and nazism 12:06  |  scallywag 09/10/07
  22.   BOTH ARE LAME DUCKS:PEACE IS A FANTASY 12:09  |  R.EALITY 09/10/07
  23.   Guido 12:16  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 09/10/07
  24.   kms and natallie 12:19  |  scallywag 09/10/07
  25.   Any Step Towards Peace is a Step in the Right Direction 12:26  |  Jane 09/10/07
  26.   palestinian prince 12:28  |  scallywag 09/10/07
  27.   It`s the Fox not the cat`s tail ! 12:31  |  Akram Zekaria 09/10/07
  28.   Johnny Johnny Johnny boy 12:36  |  Jasmine Murphy 09/10/07
  29.   Same ideology Scallywag 12:45  |  Albert 09/10/07
  30.   Beg to differ. Nat #6 12:57  |  Esther 09/10/07
  31.   #20 Paul Harris remains chronologically-challenged 13:03  |  Johnboy 09/10/07
  32.   again to albert 13:05  |  scallywag 09/10/07
  33.   Albert what reasoning powers you lack 13:12  |  Jasmine Murphy 09/10/07
  34.   #31 JB MAKES HIS OWN HISTORY UP AS USUAL 13:15  |  paul harris 09/10/07
  35.   No danger of eating your hat 13:16  |  Truths 09/10/07
  36.   How can a guy with a PhD in Holocaust denial make peace? 13:20  |  Oiy Oiy Oiy 09/10/07
  37.   #28 Jasmine puts on the rose-colored glasses 13:22  |  Johnboy 09/10/07
  38.   Peace forum 13:29  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 09/10/07
  39.   #73 Akram`s slept thru his history lessons 13:35  |  Johnboy 09/10/07
  40.   Marcus too weak to understand the truth 13:39  |  Frank 09/10/07
  41.   #33 Jasmine Murphy doesn`t know Israeli policy between 67-73 13:49  |  Johnboy 09/10/07
  42.   #34 Paul Harris rants his ignorance again 13:57  |  Johnboy 09/10/07
  43.   #38 Margie who believes she is a peacemaker 14:01  |  Labhras 09/10/07
  44.   No magic formula 14:12  |  ScotGuy 09/10/07
  45.   Olmert and the Churchmouse 14:19  |  Tony Anthony 09/10/07
  46.   Bloody their noses johnny boy? 14:30  |  Jasmine Murphy 09/10/07
  47.   Scallywag 14:32  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 09/10/07
  48.   Esther #9 14:36  |  S 09/10/07
  49.   Locating Natalie Durson - for your further action 14:56  |  Yonatan 09/10/07
  50.   #7 Albert = Albert Speer 14:58  |  Yonatan 09/10/07
  51.   kms 15:05  |  A.M. 09/10/07
  52.   S # 49 15:09  |  American in NY 09/10/07
  53.   #42JB AND MORE HOMEMADE HISTORY 15:12  |  paul harris 09/10/07
  54.   Yoel Marcus- Living in Denial 15:40  |  Yoram 09/10/07
  55.   Margie #47 16:22  |  Guido 09/10/07
  56.   Power corrupts, and absolute power should be humoured 16:26  |  Philip Lundquist 09/10/07
  57.   #46 Spare me the ignorance, Jasmine 16:38  |  Johnboy 09/10/07
  58.   #53 Time to put on your thinking cap, Paul Harris 16:54  |  Johnboy 09/10/07
  59.   THE DOG`S TAIL... OR ABBAS`s DREAMLAND 16:55  |  Titanus 09/10/07
  60.   mysterious ways 17:01  |  khairi janbek 09/10/07
  61.   39# Johnboy: Read facts as quoted bellow:-pt-1 17:01  |  Akram Zekaria 09/10/07
  62.   American in NY #52 17:03  |  S 09/10/07
  63.   JB YOU ARE TOTALLY INSANE I HAVE NEVER READ 17:10  |  paul harris 09/10/07
  64.   Johnboy # 46 17:15  |  Guido 09/10/07
  65.   tough statesmenship means a la Jimmy Carter style 17:21  |  Smadar 09/10/07
  66.   You`re right about non-violence & Johnboy, Jasmine 17:37  |  Polybios 09/10/07
  67.   Marcus - Finally, He Learned Something 17:50  |  Tod Zuckderman 09/10/07
  68.   guido cc. margie 17:54  |  scallywag 09/10/07
  69.   39#Johnboy:Read facts as quoted bellow.pt-2 17:58  |  Akram Zekaria 09/10/07
  70.   Albert and false analogies 18:17  |  Professor 09/10/07
  71.   Mr.Markus A Well Written Piece With Clarity.. 18:19  |  Kath` 09/10/07
  72.   Polybios 18:36  |  Jasmine Murphy 09/10/07
  73.   Polybios 18:36  |  Jasmine Murphy 09/10/07
  74.   #47 Margie in Ta wants a country- but where is the map. 18:43  |  Labhras 09/10/07
  75.   Yoram (54) - Great Post 19:00  |  Tod Zuckerman 09/10/07
  76.   Bottom Line 19:25  |  Danite 09/10/07
  77.   Margie`s peace forum 19:56  |  guesswho 09/10/07
  78.   Guido 20:48  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 09/10/07
  79.   ENOUGH! ALWAYS An Excuse...Sharon (The STRONG Leader) Did What?! 21:53  |  Proud Pal Defender 09/10/07
  80.   labhras re margie 74 21:56  |  scallywag 09/10/07
  81.   proud pal defender and excuses 22:08  |  scallywag 09/10/07
  82.   #61 Read the DAMN MANDATE TEXT, Akram 23:25  |  Johnboy 09/10/07
  83.   #63 You can`t "abandon" a trust, Paul Harris 23:36  |  Johnboy 09/10/07
  84.   &4labarse an irish idjit and hollow laughs 23:38  |  victor hardman 09/10/07
  85.   #63 On the UN powers and responsibilities, Paul Harris 23:41  |  Johnboy 09/10/07
  86.   #64 The offer was based on the Jarring Plan, Guido 23:48  |  Johnboy 09/10/07
  87.   #69 The McMahon pledge as as binding as Balfour, Akram 23:58  |  Johnboy 09/10/07
  88.   YOEL MARCUS - A REALIST 00:04  |  Stephen 10/10/07
  89.   ACTUALLY 50% OF THIS COLUMN IS TRUE 00:48  |  PalestniansAreA Myth 10/10/07
  90.   Of course he is too weak 02:02  |  Mark Lincoln 10/10/07
  91.   Does not the Master Race have that right? 02:12  |  Mark Lincoln 10/10/07
  92.   natallie 02:16  |  joel armstrong 10/10/07
  93.   Margie # 86 06:19  |  Guido 10/10/07
  94.   Olmert is not the right person... 06:51  |  Billy Joe 10/10/07
  95.   RIGHT MARCUS..I`LL EAT MY HAT 06:57  |  indrajaya 10/10/07
  96.   Yonatan #49 - reident TB detectives, Ltd. 07:40  |  dana 10/10/07
  97.   #78 Ahh, you have the zionist version of the Saudi Plan, Margie 08:11  |  Johnboy 10/10/07
  98.   #85JUB HAS NOT YET DISCOVERED THE GA HAS NO POWERS 08:26  |  paul harris 10/10/07
  99.   #87 JB LOOK UP ACQUIESENCE AND PERFORMANCE 08:37  |  paul harris 10/10/07
  100.   Margie #78 (2nd try) 08:47  |  Guido 10/10/07
  101.   82#Johnboy. The truth there was no Jordan pre 1922 or ever. 08:51  |  Akram Zekaria 10/10/07
  102.   johnboy and art. 25 09:08  |  scallywag 10/10/07
  103.   johnboy and mcmahon 09:14  |  scallywag 10/10/07
  104.   Stop the Hasbara 09:18  |  John 10/10/07
  105.   To scallywag 09:33  |  John 10/10/07
  106.   For S #48 09:38  |  Esther 10/10/07
  107.   Crash, bang, boom 09:54  |  Michael II 10/10/07
  108.   Guido mired in the muck 10:00  |  peter 10/10/07
  109.   videogameboy`s new-age projections 10:11  |  peter 10/10/07
  110.   If peace breaks out between the Israelis and Palestinians at the 10:49  |  Marian 10/10/07
  111.   If peace breaks out - correction 10:50  |  Marian 10/10/07
  112.   Guido 12:14  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 10/10/07
  113.   87# Johnboy: Jordan is Palestine made as British Garrison.pt-1 13:31  |  Akram Zekaria 10/10/07
  114.   Margie # 112 13:45  |  Guido 10/10/07
  115.   87# Johnboy: Jordan is Palestine made as British Garrison.pt-2 13:54  |  Akram Zekaria 10/10/07
  116.   97# Johnboy: On Zionist version ? 14:47  |  Akram Zekaria. 10/10/07
  117.   to KMS 19:10  |  aggieh 10/10/07
  118.   Yonatan Super slueth 20:29  |  American in NY 10/10/07
  119.   American in NY #52 - Gaps too far to bridge? 00:14  |  dana 11/10/07
  120.   #98 Paul Harris really does need to re-read my posts 01:41  |  Johnboy 11/10/07
  121.   #101 You make some poor arguments here, Akram 01:57  |  Johnboy 11/10/07
  122.   #103 No shit, hey, scallywag? 02:05  |  Johnboy 11/10/07
  123.   #109 So, Peter, explain something to me..... 02:17  |  Johnboy 11/10/07
  124.   #113 I`ll try one more time with you too, Akram 06:04  |  Johnboy 11/10/07
  125.   dana # 119 15:01  |  American in NY 11/10/07
  126.   Peter # 109 15:14  |  American in NY 11/10/07
  127.   Johnboy:The truth must rule at the end of the day. 05:43  |  Akram Zekaria 12/10/07
 Today Online
Senior Fatah official rules out reconciliation with rival Hamas
Responses: 163
Meron Benvenisti: E. J'lem Arabs oppose division of the city
Responses: 69
Harel: Constitution must ensure Israel's Jewish identity
Responses: 107
Report: Top PA official warns failed summit may spark intifada
Responses: 284
Rightists to launch bid to free Yitzhak Rabin's assassin Yigal Amir
Responses: 73
Rosner: Can Ann Coulter want Jews to become Christian?
Responses: 145


More Headlines
04:13 U.S. grills Israel over road planned on Arab land
05:00 Israel: Gaza arms smuggling could nix Annapolis meet
04:55 Erekat: Mideast peace summit without Israel-PA deal is mistake
23:24 Lebanese authorities free Israeli held on suspicion of espionage
05:59 Peace concert in Jericho called off over security concerns
03:13 White House slams approval of Armenian genocide measure
22:53 Yesha halts talks with gov't after settlement construction frozen
05:07 Police: Alperon family hired foreign hitmen to kill mob boss Abergil
00:31 English news site belonging to Yedioth Ahronoth to close down
22:54 Treasury D-G: Zelekha's conduct is harming the economy of Israel
15:39 Rightists to launch campaign to free Rabin assassin Yigal Amir
22:54 Ex-U.S.S.R. Jews to convene for the first time at Moscow event
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
learn Hebrew online
with israel's best teachers. Sign up for a trial lesson today
Invest in Macedonia
New Business Heaven in Europe
Long-term Israel programs
MASA is your gateway. More programs. More grants.
Eldan Rent a Car
Israel's leading car rental company offers you a 20% discount on all online reservations
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
Dead Sea Salt
Beauty and skin care from the Dead Sea. Coupon code HAARETZ for 10% off!
Israeli History Documentaries.
Own a piece of Israel?s treasured past.
Junkyard
Junk a car - get free towing nationwide and a tax-deductible receipt.
Holiday Inn and Crown Plaza Israel
Lowest internet rate Guaranteed at ichotelsgroup.com !
Home| TV| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved