Human dignity - Haaretz

Subscribe to Print Edition

Thu., October 11, 2007 ,

Israel Time: 16:05 (EST+7)

web haaretz.com

Back to Homepage

Print Edition

Diplomacy

Defense

Arts & Leisure

Real Estate

Jewish World

National

Advertising

Magazine

Week's End

Business

Opinion

Rosner's Domain

Anglo File

Books

Travel

del.icio.us

Digg It! new

Human dignity

By Haaretz Editorial

It is doubtful that a more resonant, or chilling, way could have been found to raise the issue of the distress of Israeli drug addicts than the story of 200 mothers who formed an association to demand that their addicted children be sent for forced treatment (Haaretz Magazine, October 5). The mothers' story once again brought out the dry statistics, which are disturbing in and of themselves: Some 300,000 Israelis use drugs, of whom about 100,000 are addicts and/or alcoholics. But especially chilling were the human stories the mothers told about their children: young men and women who were led by a combination of economic and emotional pressure into erasing their humanity, selling their bodies or committing crimes to obtain drugs. These are the people we all encounter begging on city streets, and most of us simply look away.

Their mothers, brave women who have decided to save their children even at the price of being stigmatized, are now demanding that we look them in the face. The fact that all are immigrants from the former Soviet Union has two implications. On the one hand, their children's deterioration attests to a particularly problematic situation among this group of immigrants (the percentage of drug users among immigrant teens is two and a half times the percentage among veteran Israeli teens). This stems, according to the Anti-Drug Authority, from a combination of absorption difficulties, the single-parent families that are characteristic of these immigrants, and discriminatory treatment of those who are not Jewish according to Jewish law. This last factor ought to be particularly disturbing because it depends entirely on the behavior of the society they are entering: The young immigrants are not responsible for the fact that the state legislated the "grandchild clause," and the argument over this clause should not be waged on their backs.

On the other hand, the fact that the mothers have organized - something that other sectors with similar problems did not do in the past - demonstrates the exceptionally positive side of the Soviet immigration: initiative and willingness to take responsibility instead of just blaming the government, even if this puts them at risk socially. Moreover, they are making a legitimate demand that only the state can satisfy.

	Advertisement

And indeed, the state should pick up the gauntlet and formulate a comprehensive national program that, for the first time, would include compulsory treatment of drug addicts who are not capable of deciding for themselves. The Finance Ministry, which is constantly demanding cutbacks in social services, must remember that cutbacks on this issue would cost the taxpayers far more than they save, due to the frequent property crimes committed by addicts and the cost of their subsequent jail terms.

Compulsory treatment naturally raises problems. First, it would require legislation to define who constitutes an addict the state may treat forcibly. It is also necessary to ensure that the law is not exploited by people seeking to get rid of unwanted relatives. But the fundamental question - whether the state even has the right to compel addicts to undergo treatment - ought to be answered affirmatively. The dangers that addicts pose to society, along with the fact that their own mothers are the ones making the request, should lead to the conclusion that in this matter, a person's human dignity takes precedence over his liberty.

Bookmark to del.icio.us


	Bad publicity
	Tiv Taam is fighting for public opinion in order to counter a consumer affairs T.V. show.


	The biggest stage
	For the first time in its history, Maccabi Tel Aviv will play against the New York Knicks.




1.	How about worrying about the dignity of cannabis users?	03:51	\|	newageblues	09/10/07

2.	compulsory treatment of addicts	11:04	\|	Michael Sijes	09/10/07

3.	Dignity or Liberty	11:47	\|	Yona Schear	09/10/07

4.	Dignity or Liberty	11:53	\|	James Schear	09/10/07

5.	drug addiction	15:18	\|	Michael Alford-Cline	09/10/07

6.	drug adiction	21:58	\|	booby goodman	09/10/07

7.	Haaretz` Re: Your finance Minister	21:27	\|	Dutch	10/10/07

8.	it`s the quality of the treatment that counts	16:01	\|	newageblues	11/10/07

Today Online


	Senior Fatah official rules out reconciliation with rival Hamas
	Responses: 83


	Meron Benvenisti: E. J'lem Arabs oppose division of the city
	Responses: 21


	Harel: Constitution must ensure Israel's Jewish identity
	Responses: 34


	Report: Top PA official warns failed summit may spark intifada
	Responses: 87


	Rightists to launch bid to free Yitzhak Rabin's assassin Yigal Amir
	Responses: 4

More Headlines
14:01 Assad: Israel is trying to cover up failed IAF strike


15:39 Rightists to launch campaign to free Rabin assassin Yigal Amir


14:47 Leonardo DiCaprio's girlfriend Bar Rafaeli sues Yedioth Ahronoth for libel


15:38 Report: Qureia warns failed Mideast summit may spark third intifada


12:55 Palestinians: Border Police troops kill Fatah militant near Jenin


15:52 French official: Police on trail of suspect in 1980 shul bombing


13:45 Senior Fatah official rules out reconciliation with rival Hamas


13:14 Briton killed while clearing IDF cluster bombs in southern Lebanon


15:37 Two Iraqi children to arrive in Israel for open heart surgery


11:52 Haaretz survey: 51% of Israelis back Olmert's talks with Abbas


12:32 Israel denies it believes troops captured by Hezbollah are dead