IDF court lawyers to slow down legal proceedings against Palestinians - Haaretz

Subscribe to Print Edition

Thu., October 11, 2007 ,

Israel Time: 18:38 (EST+7)

web haaretz.com

Back to Homepage

Print Edition

Diplomacy

Defense

Arts & Leisure

Real Estate

Jewish World

National

Advertising

Magazine

Week's End

Business

Opinion

Rosner's Domain

Anglo File

Books

Travel

del.icio.us

Digg It! new

Last update - 10:57 07/10/2007

IDF court lawyers to slow down legal proceedings against Palestinians

By Amira Hass , Haaretz Correspondent

The hearing for three Palestinian minors in a military court in the West Bank went quickly several days ago: Their lawyer pleaded guilty to the charges immediately after the indictment was read, and on the basis of the admission they were sentenced to a number of months in prison.

But when the fourth indictment was read out, against a minor accused of stone-throwing, the lawyer's behavior changed. After another lawyer whispered something to him, he demanded that his client be freed on bail -and the judge accepted his request - even though the prosecution's appeal of the decision was later accepted. As a result, the court and the military prosecutor will spend more time and resources to convict him.

The lawyer who represented the minors was implementing the decision made a month ago by lawyers representing thousands of Palestinians tried every year in the two military courts in the West Bank, mostly on security offenses.

	Advertisement

According to the decision, lawyers will now have to insist on utilizing all the legal avenues available and using all the rights granted by law to the defendant. The decision came after the lawyers concluded that their previous policy of reaching quick compromises with the military prosecutor harmed their clients and did not meet the standards of justice and law.

For example, lawyers now demand that indictments be translated into Arabic as a condition for proceeding, a requirement not enforced for a very long time. The lawyers are also demanding copiers to photocopy files, and they have agreed among themselves not to participate in hearings on remands until the end of the proceedings if they have not had time to study the case. The lawyers also oppose that evidence be presented against their clients without the witnesses being invited to testify in court.

Dozens of defense attorneys, Palestinians and Israelis, made the decision in a meeting initiated by the Ramallah-based prisoners organization, affiliated with Fatah and headed by Qadura Fares, himself a former security prisoner.

The decision was made in response to a number of troubling comments made two months ago by the new head of Military Prosecution, Erez Hason.

According to lawyers present at the meeting with Hason, he said that in his opinion the sentences levied by the military courts are not severe enough and he will act to increase them.

The Spokesman's Office for the Israel Defense Forces declined to comment on the content of the meeting with Hason.

The problem is "a lack of uniform criteria in setting punishments in military courts, and discrimination between defendants, which is sometimes determined based on personal relationships with preferences for certain lawyers," Ali Gozlan, an East Jerusalem lawyer, told Haaretz.

"Sometimes it's difficult to understand what is behind the plea bargain: the interest in closing cases as fast as possible, the [heavy case] load, the evidence or the personal relationships between the prosecutor and the lawyer," he said.

The IDF Spokesman's Office said in response: "The level of punishment is set by the military court and not by the military prosecution." The IDF added that "the military strictly keeps to proper legal procedure and defendants' rights are fully protected, with guarantees of proper representation and the right to be heard."

Bookmark to del.icio.us


	Bad publicity
	Tiv Taam is fighting for public opinion in order to counter a consumer affairs T.V. show.


	The biggest stage
	For the first time in its history, Maccabi Tel Aviv will play against the New York Knicks.




1.	what a strange idea	06:02	\|	realism	07/10/07

2.	Good for Israel`s lawyers	06:36	\|	Steve	07/10/07

3.	Novel concept....	07:49	\|	Palestinian Brit	07/10/07

4.	Three minor Palestinians on trial for stone throwing!!!	08:06	\|	Silvienne	07/10/07

5.	lawyers will now have to insist on utilizing all the legal avenue	09:11	\|	Vitaly	07/10/07

6.	#4 SIlvienne - stones can kill	09:51	\|	Shlomo	07/10/07

7.	to #3	09:57	\|	D Hirod	07/10/07

8.	welcome to the Israeli dictatorship	10:31	\|	Leona	07/10/07

9.	#6 "stones can kill"	10:46	\|	ballistic	07/10/07

10.	America had to outsource military tribunals	11:20	\|	Natallie Durson	07/10/07

11.	We are growing inured to this....	11:35	\|	Esther	07/10/07

12.	The threat of state power	13:00	\|	Nick Ferriman	07/10/07

13.	lawyers #4	14:09	\|	colin	07/10/07

14.	#12 Ferriman - I see you`re still at it	15:55	\|	* BEN JABO	07/10/07

15.	#4 Silvienne	16:04	\|	* BEN JABO	07/10/07

16.	Leona`s rant (#8)	23:16	\|	Yoni	07/10/07

17.	palestinian Brit #3 - language differences and fairness	23:53	\|	dana	07/10/07

18.	Natalie Durson #10 - the difference between US and israel	00:04	\|	dana	08/10/07

19.	#18 Dana - look at your paper currency	02:30	\|	* BEN JABO	08/10/07

20.	#6, Shlomo...actually, no, I didn`t know that..	02:36	\|	Silvienne	08/10/07

21.	#9, ballistic and the "hyena nation"!	02:39	\|	Silvienne	08/10/07

22.	#11, Esther...	02:41	\|	Silvienne	08/10/07

23.	#13, Colin...Ah, but it`s always foolish to presume...	02:43	\|	Silvienne	08/10/07

24.	#8, Leona...do you have more info on this?	02:46	\|	Silvienne	08/10/07

25.	#16, Yoni...	02:55	\|	Silvienne	08/10/07

26.	#17, dana from sunnyvale	02:58	\|	Silvienne	08/10/07

27.	#24 Silvienne	18:04	\|	* BEN JABO	08/10/07

28.	#26 Silvienne - you`ll never get it	18:09	\|	* BEN JABO	08/10/07

29.	#26 Silvienne - you`re out of touch	18:19	\|	* BEN JABO	08/10/07

30.	#27, Ben Jabo, I was quoting Leona`s post	01:47	\|	Silvienne	09/10/07

31.	#28, Ben Jabo, I was replying to Dana about	01:49	\|	Silvienne	09/10/07

32.	Ben Jabo & Language& Dana`s Post	01:52	\|	Silvienne	09/10/07

33.	#32 Silvienne	17:36	\|	* BEN JABO	09/10/07

34.	Ben Jabo....from Yoni	03:26	\|	Silviennne	10/10/07

35.	#34 Silvienne - Thanks	18:34	\|	* BEN JABO	11/10/07

Today Online


	Senior Fatah official rules out reconciliation with rival Hamas
	Responses: 100


	Meron Benvenisti: E. J'lem Arabs oppose division of the city
	Responses: 30


	Harel: Constitution must ensure Israel's Jewish identity
	Responses: 52


	Report: Top PA official warns failed summit may spark intifada
	Responses: 137


	Rightists to launch bid to free Yitzhak Rabin's assassin Yigal Amir
	Responses: 32


	Rosner: Can Ann Coulter want Jews to become Christian?
	Responses: 22

Rosner's Domain

* Romney's position on attacking Iran? better ask his lawyers

* WTR: The debate over Tutu

* Understanding the Israeli Attack on Syria

* Poll: A divided Jerusalem?

More Headlines
17:47 Avigdor Lieberman: Peace talks could bring about government's collapse


17:24 Assad casts doubt on Syrian participation in peace summit


15:39 Rightists to launch campaign to free Rabin assassin Yigal Amir


14:47 Leonardo DiCaprio's girlfriend Bar Rafaeli sues Yedioth Ahronoth for libel


17:45 Police probe of PM in Bank Leumi affair ends after 4 hours


16:53 French official: Police on trail of suspect in 1980 shul bombing


18:34 PA furious over move to forbid visitors from bringing prisoners candy


15:37 Two Iraqi children to arrive in Israel for open heart surgery


12:55 Palestinians: Border Police troops kill Fatah militant near Jenin


13:45 Senior Fatah official rules out reconciliation with rival Hamas


13:14 Briton killed while clearing IDF cluster bombs in southern Lebanon


16:41 Israeli scientists build Red Sea concrete reef to lure divers