Subscribe to Print Edition | Thu., November 15, 2007 Kislev 5, 5768 | | Israel Time: 12:23 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Arts & Leisure Real Estate Jewish World National Advertising
Easy Start Magazine Business Opinion Rosner's Domain Anglo File Week's End Books
del.icio.us
Digg It!  new
Last update - 09:29 07/10/2007
Mohammed al-Dura lives on
By Gideon Levy
tags: Israel

The concern Israel demonstrates for the fate of one Palestinian boy touches the heart: Again, note what a fuss is being made about the case of the killing of Mohammed al-Dura. Our heart is impervious to the fate of other children who have been killed. Just little Mohammed continues to haunt us. But the question of who killed al-Dura is not important. And maybe he is even alive, as some eccentrics claim. Perhaps he committed suicide, as the strange investigations are liable to suggest.

All of these are tasteless questions designed to divert attention from the truly important issues: According to data collected by human rights group B'Tselem, Israel is responsible for killing more than 850 Palestinian children and teenagers since al-Dura was killed, including 92 in the past year alone. Last October, we killed 31 children in Gaza. This is what should have raised a storm and not the measurements by the former head of the Israel Defense Forces' Southern Command, Yom Tov Samiyeh, aimed at proving that his soldiers did not kill al-Dura, or the "investigations" by the physicist Nahum Shahaf. In an eccentric obsession, Shahaf has devoted the past years to this affair, after previously having also obtained "amazing material" on the murder of Yitzhak Rabin.

Al-Dura refuses to step down from the stage because he has become an icon of the Palestinian struggle and a symbol of Israeli brutality. A thousand Nahum Shahafs will not succeed in blurring the unequivocal fact that a scandalous killing of children is taking place in the territories.
Advertisement
Even if the director of the Government Press Office, Danny Seaman, is right in determining that the film made by the reliable and experienced French journalist Charles Enderlin was "staged," and even if he succeeds in clearing Israel from responsibility for this killing, what will we say about the other children who have been killed? That their killing was also "staged?" That the IDF did not kill them through carelessness and contempt for their lives; by being trigger-happy and even acting with premeditation? If Israel were really interested in improving its "public relations," it would embrace the al-Dura family instead of all the foolish investigations. It would provide compensation to the family and show the world that it is truly and sincerely sorry about the death of one child.

The question of who killed al-Dura is like the question of what Joseph Trumpeldor mumbled before his death. The myth in both cases is already stronger than any investigation. Al-Dura became a symbol because his killing was documented on videotape. All the other hundreds of children were killed without cameras present, so no one is interested in their fate. If there had been a camera in Bushara Barjis' room in the Jenin refugee camp while she was studying for a pre-matriculation test, we would have a film showing an IDF sniper firing a bullet at her head. If there had been a photographer near Jamal Jabaji from the Askar camp, we would see soldiers emerging from an armored jeep and aiming their weapons at the head of a child who threw stones at them. But these children did not become symbols; there are no stamps bearing their portraits, no streets named after them and no songs composed for them as with al-Dura because they were not filmed at the time of their deaths.

Al-Dura became a symbol because every struggle needs a symbol, a shrine for the masses of dead and the anonymous heroes. The assumption that the IDF soldiers firing at Palestinians at the Netzarim junction killed the boy cradled in his father's arms exactly seven years ago is the most reasonable one. As far as we can remember, there has been no other case in which Palestinians fired at the IDF and hit a Palestinian child.

But even if there is some doubt, it is certain that the IDF has killed and is killing children. So this ridiculous focus on who killed al-Dura, a question that will never be resolved, is no more than a tempest in a putrid teapot. There should be a tempest, a great and mighty one, but one focused on an entirely different issue: Why is the IDF continuing to kill children at such a frightening pace, and why doesn't Israel take responsibility for this and compensate the families of those killed? But no one is conducting "investigations" about this.
Bookmark to del.icio.us
New Kids in the Strip
Hamas' new police band lifts spirits by crooning about Islamic holy war.
Less than equal
A poll shows 70% of youth don't think Bedouin deserve the same rights as Jews
  1.   Part1: why US cant attavck Iran? 09:36  |  Shahin 07/10/07
  2.   Part2: why Iran does not need nuclear warhead? 09:37  |  Shahin 07/10/07
  3.   Part3: conclusion 09:37  |  Shahin 07/10/07
  4.   ISRAEL DIED BEFORE SHE BORNED 09:46  |  Rabi Chris 07/10/07
  5.   Another astonishing discovery of Haaretz 09:49  |  shahin 07/10/07
  6.   A courageous article... 10:02  |  Silvienne 07/10/07
  7.   Food for thought 10:21  |  D Hirod 07/10/07
  8.   A key incident in effort to undermine Israel`s legitimacy 10:22  |  Shalom Freedman 07/10/07
  9.   Objection 10:26  |  A 07/10/07
  10.   Part1: Why US/IS can`t attack Iran 10:35  |  Shahin 07/10/07
  11.   Gideon Levy & his war against Israel 10:35  |  Arthur G 07/10/07
  12.   Terrorists Kill Children 10:38  |  Jane 07/10/07
  13.   MENE,MENE, TEKEL, UPHARSIN 10:46  |  Clickfool 07/10/07
  14.   #1 It simply will not happen Silvienne 10:48  |  Johnboy 07/10/07
  15.   Arabs deliberately target Israeli/Jewish children while Israel 10:52  |  Susanna/Shoshanna 07/10/07
  16.   For Shahin, on the best Israeli targets for Iran # 1 10:54  |  Clickfool 07/10/07
  17.   Haaretz is not a newspaper but a rag 10:58  |  Ian Zwerling 07/10/07
  18.   haaretz showing no shame in stooping 10:59  |  peter 07/10/07
  19.   gideon levy, i will hung you with big pleasure. 11:01  |  v 07/10/07
  20.   Gideon: Quick ! grab yourself an umbrella ! 11:04  |  Westwell 07/10/07
  21.   #1 What a .... 11:07  |  Uzi 07/10/07
  22.   #1 feel sorry for your suicidal selves,which is an oxymoron 11:07  |  Susanna/Shoshanna 07/10/07
  23.   12...jane.... 11:23  |  ravi 07/10/07
  24.   Gideon Levy crawls from under his rock again 11:25  |  Steven A. 07/10/07
  25.   Israel ran out of excuses 11:28  |  Westwell 07/10/07
  26.   For Rabi Chris on the birth of Israel # 4 11:30  |  Clickfool 07/10/07
  27.   giddy and logic dont make us all laugh 11:33  |  victor hardman 07/10/07
  28.   For Ian Zwerling # 17 11:35  |  Clickfool 07/10/07
  29.   #16 the yellow streak should be reported for 11:37  |  victor hardman 07/10/07
  30.   Gideon Levy gives a voice to the defenseless. 11:37  |  Maureen Ann 07/10/07
  31.   For Maureen Ann # 30 11:49  |  Clickfool 07/10/07
  32.   Gideon Levy`s honest and integrity should be applauded 11:51  |  Kim 07/10/07
  33.   Thank you Mr. Levy! But can you understand... 11:51  |  Dutch Dirk 07/10/07
  34.   For Dutch Dirk # 33 12:02  |  Clickfool 07/10/07
  35.   Ian Zwerling 12:05  |  Khalid 07/10/07
  36.   get the record straight 12:06  |  ellen 07/10/07
  37.   Let us all do the math 12:08  |  Westwell 07/10/07
  38.   shameless country, shameless people 12:12  |  KMS 07/10/07
  39.   Pedophile Levy,his concern for children is like an embrace from a 12:12  |  Absolute Sweden 07/10/07
  40.   Pals assasinated by Pals are no News (for Amira and Gideon) 12:16  |  GF 07/10/07
  41.   #38 kms leaves out the facts to support his/her libels 12:19  |  victor hardman 07/10/07
  42.   Ghandi: first they ignore you and then they ridicule you 12:24  |  Kim 07/10/07
  43.   #16clickfool-they are not that stupid but you forget the U.S. 12:27  |  Susanna/Shoshanna 07/10/07
  44.   shoshana on human shields-15 12:39  |  Hubal 07/10/07
  45.   ISRAEL COULD KILL 1,000000 CHILDREN BUT DOESN`T- HAMAS WOULD 12:41  |  Mitch Iginer 07/10/07
  46.   collateral damage 12:45  |  tj 07/10/07
  47.   to mr. clickfool 12:47  |  tj 07/10/07
  48.   Clickfool 12:50  |  Shahin 07/10/07
  49.   Are Arab Childrens` lives more important than Jewish 12:53  |  Dagma 07/10/07
  50.   Now we understand why... 13:06  |  Shahin 07/10/07
  51.   #4, Rabi Chris 13:08  |  Hannah 07/10/07
  52.   Zionists will not allow the tree in front of Anne Franks` house.. 13:14  |  Hannah 07/10/07
  53.   Response to Dagma 13:14  |  Kim 07/10/07
  54.   Family Values 13:15  |  Natallie Durson 07/10/07
  55.   #8, #9 Denial wont get you anything 13:15  |  Kris 07/10/07
  56.   To Mitch Iginer 13:15  |  christa 07/10/07
  57.   # 12 Israeli do care for JEWISH children 13:16  |  Kris 07/10/07
  58.   #6, Sylvianne 13:20  |  Hannah 07/10/07
  59.   ONE INTENTIONAL MURDER IS WORSE THAN MANY UNINTENTIONAL 13:21  |  Ben 07/10/07
  60.   #16 another one in denial of facts 13:22  |  Kris 07/10/07
  61.   Gideon Levy, Jewish children were killed in Shderot 13:22  |  Arnon 07/10/07
  62.   #8, Shalom (for a misnomer) Freedman (for another misnomer) 13:27  |  Hannah 07/10/07
  63.   No surprise from Gideon 13:28  |  howiej 07/10/07
  64.   #41 Victor Hardhead 13:29  |  Labhras 07/10/07
  65.   #11, Arthur G. 13:31  |  Hannah 07/10/07
  66.   shoshana on human shields-15 13:33  |  Hubal 07/10/07
  67.   #17,#18,#19,#24 another one in denial of facts 13:33  |  Kris 07/10/07
  68.   #56christa- It would take 100,000 years at this rate. 13:34  |  Mitch Iginer 07/10/07
  69.   Israelites can rightfully kill the children... 13:34  |  Shahin 07/10/07
  70.   #12, Jane 13:37  |  Hannah 07/10/07
  71.   #29 Victor Hardhead talks about racial incitement. 13:37  |  Labhras 07/10/07
  72.   HUMAN STUPIDITY 13:38  |  howiej 07/10/07
  73.   #13, Clickfool 13:39  |  Hannah 07/10/07
  74.   Mitch Ignier: read the testimonies of Shrovim Shtika soldiers 13:39  |  Kim 07/10/07
  75.   No israely child... 13:39  |  Nano 07/10/07
  76.   westwell 13:42  |  Shahin 07/10/07
  77.   To Shoshanna 13:44  |  Nano 07/10/07
  78.   #14, Johnboy 13:45  |  Hannah 07/10/07
  79.   Absolute Sweden 13:46  |  Shahin 07/10/07
  80.   #69 Shah-It`s MUSLIMS that murder out of chosenness. 13:47  |  Mike 07/10/07
  81.   #15, Shoshanna 13:50  |