In other words, anti-Semitism - Haaretz

Subscribe to Print Edition

Sun., October 14, 2007 ,

Israel Time: 00:56 (EST+7)

web haaretz.com

Back to Homepage

Print Edition

Diplomacy

Defense

Arts & Leisure

Real Estate

Jewish World

National

Advertising

Magazine

Week's End

Business

Opinion

Rosner's Domain

Anglo File

Books

Travel

del.icio.us

Digg It! new

Last update - 11:18 04/10/2007

In other words, anti-Semitism

By Gadi Eshel

In recent years, a growing need has developed for a distinction between two ostensibly similar terms that in fact differ significantly. The profligate and light-minded use of the term "left" is not accurate, and therefore, it should be distinguished from the Hebrew homophone spelled with a different first letter (samekh instead of sin), which has come to mean "post-Zionist" - though that, too, is in effect a substitute for another concept: "anti-Zionist."

In Israel's existential debate, the second term differs from the classical "left." The second "left" is the old anti-Semitism, but this time, it is home-grown. This is not a reference to the minor issue of neo-Nazi youth who immigrated from the former Soviet Union, but rather to an incomprehensible and incurable disease of mankind: self-hatred. The symptoms of this disease arise anew after every withdrawal from the territories, and the pretenses behind which it hides are innumerable.

The symptoms are familiar: anti-Zionism ("I'm not against the Jews, I'm only against ..."), Holocaust denial ("What Israel is doing to the Palestinians is worse than the Holocaust"), denial of the existence of a Jewish people, hatred of "settlers," hatred of the Land of Israel, hatred of the Jewish heritage, hatred of the "orange" protesters [who opposed the withdrawal from Gaza], hatred of the ultra-Orthodox, hatred of those evacuated [from Gaza], hatred of outposts, and so forth. This hatred wears many masks: "a Palestinian nation," "human rights" (Palestinian of course), "the rule of law," "strengthening the moderates," "victims of peace," "the peace process," "only a diplomatic solution," "territories," "the sanctity of man and not of land," "a window of opportunity," "the pogrom of chopping down olive trees," etc. What does all this have to do with the classical "left"?

	Advertisement

The division between "right" and "left" originated in the seating plan of the French National Assembly after the revolution. On the right side of the hall sat the delegates who favored preserving the regime, and on the left were those who demanded radical change in the regime and in society. Later, this division referred to socioeconomic views: capitalism and a free market versus socialism and a planned economy. In the Western world in general, and in the United States in particular, the division between "right" and "left" ("liberals" in the U.S.) also describes differences over religion (Christianity), the legal system and nationalism/patriotism.

In Israel, this division is inaccurate. Here, on both sides of the equation, everything is intermingled. Not everyone on the "right" is Zionist and committed to Israel's existence, and not everyone on the "left" is opposed.

The anti-Zionist and anti-Jewish side is led by the reigning elite, which is "rightist" in socioeconomic terms: The barons of the press and the electronic media promote the Palestinian agenda. The capitalists are the ones who fund the various peace organizations and promote their agenda of delegitimizing the Israel Defense Forces, the state and the settlements. A unique species of blaming Israel and the Jews for all the world's ills has developed in the academic world. These ills began with the barbaric colonialist invasion of Palestine by East European Jews.

Nor is every "religious person" automatically committed to a return to Zion and to the Jewish state. On the contrary, the ultra-Orthodox have reservations in principle, and Neturei Karta [an extremist ultra-Orthodox sect] has adopted the most bizarre type of "auto-anti-Semitism": It praises every suicide bombing and every abomination uttered by Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad.

It must be remembered that the roots of the Zionist left are the return to Zion, the redemption of the land (the entire land!) and Jewish labor. For A.D. Gordon, the pioneers of the Second Aliyah [wave of immigration] and the founders of the Histadrut labor federation, these three fundamentals were inseparable. The Uganda plan was shot down in the Sixth Zionist Congress in 1903 by left-wing Zionists from Russia. Joseph Trumpeldor, Yitzhak Tabenkin, Israel Galili, Natan Alterman, Moshe Shamir and Berl Katznelson were "left." That is really not today's version of the "left," whose entire existence and essence is the destruction of the Jewish state and the establishment of "free" Palestine on its ruins.

This new left is to a great extent a mutation of the classical left. It has taken the classical left's place thanks to the spreading vacuum in the old left's vision and institutions, from the kibbutz to the Labor Party. But it is proper to claim that the entire camp has changed its stripes? That this is an overarching conversion?

Identifying the "left" with anti-Zionism makes it possible to label the entire right as "extreme right," and to make "left" include an obligation to cleanse the "West Bank" of Jews. As though there were a natural symmetry: There is side A, which wants to eliminate Israel, and side B, which chooses life, but both are legitimate.

The division between "left" and "right" has taken hold and has already sowed destruction in Israel. The good news is that the label "left" is not a divine decree. It remains to be seen whether the homophone will catch on as a way to describe the new left.

The writer holds a doctorate in engineering.

Bookmark to del.icio.us


	Public discontent
	Teachers are replacing port workers in the public's mind as the 'official, serial national strikers.'


	Bad for academia?
	A Haifa professor says funding from corporations gives rise to some ethical conundrums.




1.	Is he serious?	11:38	\|	Ze`ev	04/10/07

2.	Part of the Problem	11:55	\|	Andrew	04/10/07

3.	The writer holds a doctorate in engineering	12:08	\|	Rani Habelgi	04/10/07

4.	Stupid article, very stupid	12:29	\|	Noel	04/10/07

5.	Reason?	13:02	\|	Claudia Casper	04/10/07

6.	Ze`ev, they found him in an illegal settlement in the Westbank	13:12	\|	Ernst	04/10/07

7.	#1 Of Course the Far Left are Anti Semitic	13:27	\|	ralphsrant1	04/10/07

8.	Gadi Eshel, just a dikduk sheilah.	13:33	\|	akiva (zionist)	04/10/07

9.	In other words, PhD in engineering is good...for engineering.	13:34	\|	zmogus	04/10/07

10.	Typical right-wing drivel	13:40	\|	Danny	04/10/07

11.	Ze`ev	13:43	\|	akiva (zionist)	04/10/07

12.	revolutionary minds	13:58	\|	michel	04/10/07

13.	Just who gave him the idea of writing this "analysis"...	14:01	\|	zmogus	04/10/07

14.	a better distinction of history and present policy.	14:20	\|	Stephan	04/10/07

15.	OK Zeev,	14:22	\|	Buzaglow	04/10/07

16.	auto-anti-Semitism should be exposed!	15:02	\|	Ron the I-Opener	04/10/07

17.	Incoherent	15:09	\|	Dan	04/10/07

18.	has Haaretz proselytize ultra-leftiism for Torath-Hayiim?	15:37	\|	Ariel	04/10/07

19.	Oh, come now Gadi Eshel.....	15:49	\|	Esther	04/10/07

20.	rubbish	16:05	\|	New Israeli	04/10/07

21.	A must read and internalize for very life oriented Jew	16:39	\|	a life oriented Jew	04/10/07

22.	It`s beyond belief. Consider Eshel`s following phrase:	17:19	\|	zmogus	04/10/07

23.	Israeli newspeak is exposed	17:30	\|	Nelly	04/10/07

24.	Come on, do U really believe U can root this disease out?	17:45	\|	Israeli Jew	04/10/07

25.	what?	17:55	\|	PAL	04/10/07

26.	So you suggest I change my name?	17:59	\|	Ulta-leftiism Expert	04/10/07

27.	The Punch line for Dr. Eshel	18:19	\|	Smart Talkback	04/10/07

28.	What nonsense!	18:35	\|	Deborah	04/10/07

29.	After thought about overlapping ideologies...	18:36	\|	Esther	04/10/07

30.	Ssmol is much worse than conventional antiSemitism	18:45	\|	post-post-Zionist	04/10/07

31.	to zmogus	18:58	\|	canadian	04/10/07

32.	The left and anti-Semitism	19:12	\|	Rachel	04/10/07

33.	Well written article Gadi Eshel !!	19:47	\|	Gary	04/10/07

34.	Israel has only a "relative" left	19:49	\|	Natallie Durson	04/10/07

35.	Zionism Right or Left is AntiSemetic	19:54	\|	ARTH	04/10/07

36.	The true value of Gadi Eshel`s rant	19:58	\|	Donny Beisbol	04/10/07

37.	Rachel,the nob of the matter is Israeli elites are anti-Israeli	20:20	\|	Absolute Sweden	04/10/07

38.	The first truly GREAT and honest article on Ha`aretz!	20:29	\|	Nannette	04/10/07

39.	In the US proPalestinians march with Hitler photos	20:41	\|	Gina	04/10/07

40.	Now now Gina	21:50	\|	zmogus	04/10/07

41.	Left Right	21:53	\|	cyclops	04/10/07

42.	Too general But much truth in what he says	22:07	\|	Shalom Freedman	04/10/07

43.	For Nat #34	22:56	\|	Esther	04/10/07

44.	zmogus	23:00	\|	Gina	04/10/07

45.	Motive Questioning fallacy	23:08	\|	Pete	04/10/07

46.	#39, Gina. You want me to help you to word your agenda?	10:35	\|	zmogus	05/10/07

Today Online


	Bradley Burston: Ann Coulter's dream of a Jew-free America
	Responses: 292


	Ministers approve renewal of dig at disputed Mugrabi Gate
	Responses: 81


	Report: Abducted IDF soldiers transferred to Iran after capture
	Responses: 150


	Rice arrives in region to help advance peace talks ahead of summit
	Responses: 121


	Gideon Levy: Israeli journalists can go to Syria and Iraq, but not to the Gaza Strip
	Responses: 51

More Headlines
20:24 AG orders probe against PM over new corruption suspicions


19:15 Rice: Only focus on core issues can advance the peace process


16:16 Barak heads to United States to promote Israeli rocket defense


22:11 Rabin killer Amir asks to attend son's upcoming circumcision


14:51 Israel refuses entry to 6 Gazans in urgent need of medical care


22:42 London Jews celebrate U.K. Jewish history in Trafalgar Square rally


21:59 Islamic Movement leader urges fellow Ra'am-Ta'al MK to quit Knesset


17:57 Israeli historian wins German Book Trade's 2007 peace prize


22:52 Organizers call off T.A. peace concert after one in Jericho cancelled


13:33 Israel denies report that abducted IDF soldiers were turned over to Iran


17:54 Teachers, Treasury conclude meeting over strike without breakthrough


14:06 Lieberman seeks to encourage aliyah of Russian Jews from Canada


15:02 Mugrabi excavations delayed due to appeal by Arab minister