Subscribe to Print Edition | Thu., October 04, 2007 , | | Israel Time: 16:24 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Arts & Leisure Real Estate Jewish World National Advertising
Magazine Week's End Business Opinion Rosner's Domain Anglo File Books Travel
del.icio.us
Digg It!  new
Last update - 10:28 30/09/2007
The war for the house
By Gideon Levy

Theirs is an apartment building no one has ever heard of. No architectural International Style, no style at all, just an apartment building. Five floors, 11 families, new tiles in one of the bathrooms. Situated on a hillside, the house hovers above the city below. Hovers? Hovered.

Many other buildings surround this one. Densely constructed, the houses almost touch one another. A narrow alley, the width of a person, separates the buildings. All of the residents of the apartment building are family members - parents, siblings and cousins. They built one floor on top of another, residing in cramped proximity. Residing? Resided.

Last Thursday, the bulldozer arrived. How did the bulldozer get to a home at the end of the narrow alleyway? Along the way, as they say, the bulldozer paved a route of destruction for itself, damaging all the homes in its path. Here it demolished a stone fence, there it cracked a wall. What difference does it make already? Some of the homes have now become hazardous for human residence, their cracked walls threatening to collapse. The bulldozer finally reached its destination and began razing the building.

Advertisement
The five stories collapsed like a house of cards, stirring up a huge cloud of dust, burying everything in the apartment building: kitchen utensils, furniture, toys, electronic appliances and memories. Nothing remained; everything was buried. Last week, I saw two children trying to save something: the new bicycles purchased for the school year. Demolished walls with iron rods protruding from them covered the red bikes the children struggled to extract. Finally, they uncovered them: bent, smashed. Pain surfaced on the faces of the children, a girl and a boy, nine or 10 years old. Nothing remained of their home. Just a row of children's clothing fluttered in the wind, hung on a wire descending from the remains of the roof. The staircase remains suspended in the air on iron rods, leading nowhere, threatening to crash down at any moment on our heads and upon the heads of the rummaging children.

Here lives the Mabruk family, not happily. The father, Ali, his sons and daughters. About three weeks ago, the Israel Defense Forces killed his son, Nasser; another son, Majid, is still wanted by Israel. A fighting family, active in the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine. A giant red flag of the Popular Front is now planted among the ruins of the house, protesting the world that has shown no interest in them. Not far from there, at the end of a row of houses, the soldier Ben Zion Henman was killed in a gun battle that erupted here about 10 days ago. Within the camp, Mohammed Khaled, 17, and Adib Salim, 38, were killed. Adib was a disabled tirmis [lupin bean] salesman, paralyzed on the right side of his body. He fell, bleeding, under a sign memorializing his brother, Jamal, a Hamas activist who was liquidated here by a missile in 2001. The IDF claims that the paralyzed Adib was armed. In its response, the IDF emphasizes as supporting evidence the fact that his brother was a terrorist.

It was a successful operation: The IDF prevented a horrible suicide attack. Some of the planners of this attack were here, among the alleyways of the Ein Beit Ilma camp, located on the western edge of Nablus. No one can dispute the need to carry out an operation like this, which prevented killing. The fact that only two Palestinians were killed during the three days of the nameless operation - this time the IDF did not follow its habit of assigning the operation one of the childish names it favors - attests to the caution the soldiers employed.

In this light, there is even more reason to ask: Why the apartment building? Why was it necessary to destroy the lives of 11 families? How will it contribute to the security of Israel, even if the IDF calls the building a "combat post?" When will we finally wean ourselves of this unnecessary and criminal means of destroying the homes of innocent people? Does the fact that the commander of the Popular Front in the camp lives in the house justify demolishing the entire five-story building? When will the IDF learn that the next terrorists will sprout from among these very ruins? Was not the urge for revenge aroused in the heart of the child who searched for the bicycle among the ruins of his home, who saw his world destroyed? Anyone wishing to become acquainted with the real "infrastructure of terror" is invited to travel to Nablus, to see the ruins of the home at the edge of the Ein Beit Ilma camp.
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Sidewalk or cafe
Israel's cities seem content to let eating establishments pour out onto the street.
My favorite cafe
Authors weigh in on their favorite spots to while the day away.
  1.   This is a disgusting action - truly biblical in nastiness 10:34  |  dana 30/09/07
  2.   What`s The Alternative? 10:38  |  Mark 30/09/07
  3.   THIS IS WHY (2nd TRY) 10:49  |  indrajaya 30/09/07
  4.   birth of a terrorist? 10:56  |  eric 30/09/07
  5.   #2, Mark 10:56  |  Anton 30/09/07
  6.   Levy drank tea with planners of suicide attack in Tel Aviv 10:57  |  Absolute Sweden 30/09/07
  7.   Way to IDF 10:57  |  Amos 30/09/07
  8.   Mark, you are mad 10:59  |  Marilyn 30/09/07
  9.   because israel is a wholly owned us subsidiary 10:59  |  Rowan Berkeley 30/09/07
  10.   gidy gideon with more sad support for terrorists 11:03  |  victor hardman 30/09/07
  11.   dana "less civilised nasty self righteous jews" 11:06  |  danaofarabia 30/09/07
  12.   Why must Palestinians shoot the homes in Shderot? 11:08  |  Just asking 30/09/07
  13.   dana "israel is rampant with criminality" 11:11  |  danaofarabia 30/09/07
  14.   Why?So They Don`t Have That Building to Plan Again 11:12  |  Jane 30/09/07
  15.   Harassment is built in to the system at every step 11:15  |  Natallie Durson 30/09/07
  16.   dana your reply on america`s wars 11:17  |  danaofarabia 30/09/07
  17.   dont abuse levy 11:19  |  giora 30/09/07
  18.   Levy not all people are as fair as you! 11:19  |  Roxana from IRAN 30/09/07
  19.   #7 Amos 11:24  |  Boycott 30/09/07
  20.   natallie durson real name mohammed abdulla 11:26  |  ucla 30/09/07
  21.   #11 danaofarabia "less civilised..." 11:26  |  Warren 30/09/07
  22.   #4 why eric it was britain they preceded the idf 11:30  |  victor hardman 30/09/07
  23.   australian warren 11:38  |  halevy 30/09/07
  24.   Anton from Bonn: You ask. - I answer. 11:40  |  Vittorio 30/09/07
  25.   Marilyn #8.You ask:Mark, you are mad?- Mark isn`t mad. You are. 11:43  |  Vittorio 30/09/07
  26.   Traitor G.Levy: Can you recalla single your article that condemns 11:48  |  Vittorio 30/09/07
  27.   There could be a simple reason 11:50  |  Jonathan S 30/09/07
  28.   If israel was `a democracy` 11:54  |  Rowan Berkeley 30/09/07
  29.   To 19--A mistaken dogma 11:55  |  Amos 30/09/07
  30.   FOR FUN OBVIOUSLY!! WHAT OTHER REASON COULD THERE POSSIBLY BE? 11:59  |  Mitch Iginer 30/09/07
  31.   #24, Vittorio 12:03  |  Anton 30/09/07
  32.   to Marylin from Aussie land 12:07  |  Yonatan 30/09/07
  33.   Gideon Levy & his war against Israel 12:29  |  Alan L 30/09/07
  34.   re # 26 Gideon Levy the traitor 12:34  |  Berrouria 30/09/07
  35.   Mitch Iginer, I concur 12:45  |  akiva (zionist) 30/09/07
  36.   No sympathies 12:48  |  Steven A. 30/09/07
  37.   The lesson that backfired 12:56  |  Alice of Wonderland 30/09/07
  38.   Gideon Levy 12:58  |  Detached 30/09/07
  39.   The Building had to be Exorcised! 13:00  |  FOX 30/09/07
  40.   Why Gideon,because israel is a criminal state & should be brought 13:04  |  lakshmi 30/09/07
  41.   To Detached....Keep on trying...but your guilt trip wont work 13:14  |  SLAVO 30/09/07
  42.   One thing Israel hates more than the Palestinians themselves is - 13:17  |  Danny 30/09/07
  43.   Alice, rattling the cage like !@#$ 13:18  |  FOX 30/09/07
  44.   mark 2 13:25  |  realism 30/09/07
  45.   victor hardman 22 13:31  |  realism 30/09/07
  46.   Mark and alternative 13:32  |  Truths 30/09/07
  47.   FOX 13:35  |  akiva (zionist) 30/09/07
  48.   #43 Please FOX, read yesterday´s news on a new HR org, in the UN 13:39  |  Alice of Wonderland 30/09/07
  49.   Boycott # 19 13:44  |  ChanahS 30/09/07
  50.   Why, why, why??? 13:45  |  Marlene N. 30/09/07
  51.   Levy is a noble journalists - Where is a Palestinian Levy? 13:53  |  Truth Approached 30/09/07
  52.   Why, why, why??? ethnic cleansing VS. clearing qassam areas 13:54  |  akiva (zionist) 30/09/07
  53.   rampant with criminality... FROM California???! 13:57  |  akiva (zionist) 30/09/07
  54.   #22 where did you get that idea realism 14:16  |  victor hardman 30/09/07
  55.   I can only assume 14:26  |  English Resident 30/09/07
  56.   It`s comes naturally... 14:27  |  Victor 30/09/07
  57.   Algeria 14:40  |  Felf 30/09/07
  58.   Pregnant Palestinian hid weapons, bomb belt found for TA attack 14:40  |  Ken Jurist 30/09/07
  59.   Gideon Levy is one of the most fanatic anti-Israel columnists . 14:42  |  David Stoler 30/09/07
  60.   Stop deluding yourself No. 52 14:52  |  Marlene N. 30/09/07
  61.   Yonatan #32...get it right ! 14:57  |  nathan 30/09/07
  62.   IDF actions in extracting terrorist fine, but why really destroy 15:15  |  Smadar 30/09/07
  63.   #3 Indrajaya, Re Supreme Court 15:21  |  Dutch 30/09/07
  64.   # 55 I can only assume 15:24  |  Lynn 30/09/07
  65.   #3 indrajaya, Re Supreme Court 15:37  |  Dutch 30/09/07
  66.   Marlene # 60 15:38  |  ChanahS 30/09/07
  67.   Zionist, not Jews, are the Nazis of our time 15:39  |  German 30/09/07
  68.   What kind of propaganda painting is that, Gideon? 15:50  |  Denton 30/09/07
  69.   Gideon ,How can you take this disgraceful & heartless army ? 15:52  |  Dutch 30/09/07
  70.   The reason why they can do that Indraya 16:02  |  Marlene N. 30/09/07
  71.   # 67 German 16:09  |  Zionist 30/09/07
  72.   $#70 no terorism no idf no british army or police 16:19  |  victor hardman 30/09/07
  73.   No Chanah, I will not bring a list 16:20  |  Marlene N. 30/09/07
  74.   Gideon, take Doris` advice (69) and join Hamas right now! 16:22  |  martyrmaker 30/09/07
  75.   The war for the house 16:24  |  Mark Jeffery Koch 30/09/07
  76.   The Light unto Nations growing Dimmer. 16:24  |  Labhras 30/09/07
  77.   Collective Punishment is against the Geneva Convention 16:25  |  Tosefta 30/09/07
  78.   What will prevent terrorism better? 16:26  |  Peter 30/09/07
  79.   Wrong relativity theory from German #67 16:37  |  Jonathan S 30/09/07
  80.   Mr. Levi 16:42  |  Dr. Allan 30/09/07
  81.   Mr. Levi 16:45  |  Dr. Allan