Subscribe to Print Edition | Tue., October 02, 2007 , | | Israel Time: 11:49 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Arts & Leisure Real Estate Jewish World National Advertising
Magazine Week's End Business Opinion Rosner's Domain Anglo File Books Travel
del.icio.us
Digg It!  new
Last update - 10:34 25/09/2007
On the way to a pariah state
By Carlo Strenger

Henry Kissinger used to say that Israel has no foreign policy, only internal politics. Listening to our politicians, you often indeed wonder whether any of them has any long-term strategy. Given that every Israeli politician is supposed to care for Israel's long-term survival, it is stunning to see that an important event in the U.S. with enormous implications for Israel has gone all but unnoticed here.

Eighteen months ago, two senior political scientists, Stephen M. Walt and John J. Mearsheimer, from Harvard and the University of Chicago, respectively, published a paper claiming that U.S. Middle Eastern policy, including the misguided Iraq war and its unqualified support for Israel over the last decades, has run counter to true U.S. interests. They blame the influence of the Israel Lobby for this.

The paper generated a lot of commotion in Jewish circles in the U.S., but surprisingly, has been disregarded in Israel. W&M have now published The Israel Lobby and U.S. Foreign Policy as a book. Their conclusion: the U.S. needs to start relating to Israel like any other country, and no longer see a special ally in us, because the close relation with Israel harms U.S. interests.

Advertisement
W&M paint Israel as a rogue state that does not abide by international law, and is not up to the standards expected of a Western state. The subtext is clear: Israel is just another problematic Middle Eastern country, and should be treated as such - and the number of policy makers and opinion leaders who think this way is growing.

My concern here is not with the question whether W&M are right in the details of their analysis of the power of the Israel Lobby. My point is that their anti-Israeli stance is the tip of a growing iceberg that is simply disregarded by Israel's decision makers. Dismissing W&M as a fringe phenomenon is shortsighted, because it does not take into account a consistent development over the last few years.

It is something of a consensus that the confrontation with Political Islam has become the Western world's No. 1 geopolitical problem. This is generally called the "Clash of Civilizations," following Samuel Huntington and Bernard Lewis. A growing number of decision makers in Europe and the U.S. think that Israel, while not necessarily the main cause for the rise of Political Islam, has become a symbol around which Islamist extremism coalesces - and there is good evidence for this. Watch any Jihadist Web site, even if run from Pakistan, and you will find that images from the West Bank are the core of their iconography.

Israel's way of dealing with the Palestinians and Lebanon in the last few decades has led to a long-term process in which the Western world is beginning to see Israel as a pariah state that has no true affinity to Western values. Hence, it is not on the 'right' side of the clash of civilizations, as was reflected in the French ambassador to Britain calling Israel "that shitty little country" not long ago.

This development is consistently disregarded by Israeli decision makers. Short-term political bickering is on their minds more than the survival of Israel, which in theory is their main goal. Any criticism of Israel's policies is dismissed as an expression of the New Anti-Semitism. The proof often provided is that we are not judged by the same standard as our neighbors: "Jordan, Syria, Iraq and Saudi Arabia can get away with inhuman behavior a lot worse than ours," the argument runs.

My point is simple: the day we are no longer judged by the standards of the West is the beginning of Israel's end, because it means that the West has decided we are no longer part of it, and hence will not be committed to Israel's existence. The day may come when Israel will, as W&M suggest, be seen as just another troublesome country that destabilizes the world.

Behaving in a manner befitting the standards of the Western world is far more important for Israel's long-term survival than gaining a few square miles here and there, by building the security wall through Palestinian territories, tearing apart villages, homes and schools, and expanding settlements. Every such act is not just a moral outrage; it pushes Israel one step closer to being disqualified from belonging to the West.

My argument is not just about being loved by the world - though this factor must not be dismissed. Many of us believe that Israel's moral fiber has been fatally harmed by the occupation and by the two Lebanon wars. The result is that both morally and strategically, the continued occupation and subjugation of the Palestinian people has put us on the wrong side of history.

The writer is professor of Psychology at Tel Aviv University, and a member of the Permanent Monitoring Panel on Terrorism of the World Federation of Scientists.
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Lights out
Electric company cancels emergency bond issue due to credit rating reduction fears.
No free lunches
Accountant General Zelekha demands VIPs pay taxes on their free medical benefits.
  1.   Stenger , Who is on the "Right" Side of History? 08:58  |  Ben Israel 25/09/07
  2.   long-term strategy is to win 09:36  |  joe 25/09/07
  3.   the writer is a left wing idiot without balance 10:49  |  victor hardman 25/09/07
  4.   A thoughtful article 10:57  |  Natallie Durson 25/09/07
  5.   Spoiled Brat 11:04  |  Walid 25/09/07
  6.   like Israelis even care 11:10  |  ted 25/09/07
  7.   pariah 11:15  |  Ralph 25/09/07
  8.   Israel is a pariah state... 11:19  |  Richard 25/09/07
  9.   Israel, an immature state. 11:19  |  Jens 25/09/07
  10.   professor carlo strenger 11:24  |  harzion 25/09/07
  11.   why would any israeli think european states 11:26  |  harzion 25/09/07
  12.   professor carlo strenger europe has bloody teeth 11:29  |  harzion 25/09/07
  13.   Another good article. Is it time to pay attention? 11:31  |  dana 25/09/07
  14.   professor strenger do you not feel a little queasy 11:31  |  harzion 25/09/07
  15.   Sad day whatever...... 11:37  |  Esther 25/09/07
  16.   Israel is already a pariah state 11:47  |  Chris Linthwaite 25/09/07
  17.   #7 jens can tell us which state anywhere matured in 60 years 11:55  |  victor hardman 25/09/07
  18.   Oh come off it 12:01  |  Shalom Freedman 25/09/07
  19.   Ouch! I have to agree with Natallie #2? 12:12  |  S 25/09/07
  20.   never let the enemy define you 12:15  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 25/09/07
  21.   # 1.... To Victor...Truth is painful 12:17  |  Farooq 25/09/07
  22.   "Western Standards" 12:19  |  osvaldo 25/09/07
  23.   Israel is constantly told "she is a light unto nations" 12:20  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 25/09/07
  24.   the conflict must be solved 12:27  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 25/09/07
  25.   Pariah state 12:31  |  Sean 25/09/07
  26.   Haaretz is becoming un-readably left 12:33  |  dyinglikeflies 25/09/07
  27.   Jens- Ah, and what of parenting the cousins? 12:33  |  Tzvi 25/09/07
  28.   harzion, all posts, you are correct, as always 12:35  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 25/09/07
  29.   Carlo the Liar,.No western country tolerates as much as Israel 12:37  |  Absolute Sweden 25/09/07
  30.   Time for Israel to be treated like everyone else 12:37  |  Slibovitz 25/09/07
  31.   to #3 to #3 Spoiled Brat 12:37  |  NB 25/09/07
  32.   So what have the Darfur victims done to deserve their fate? 12:38  |  Tzvi 25/09/07
  33.   #3 Walid 12:44  |  Sarah 25/09/07
  34.   Carlo confused 12:45  |  peter 25/09/07
  35.   carlo is right 12:54  |  ravi 25/09/07
  36.   Israel is no longer a Western state 12:56  |  Keith T 25/09/07
  37.   Clever vision ... 12:56  |  Leandro 25/09/07
  38.   A clear test 12:58  |  Chris Linthwaite 25/09/07
  39.   The point 13:10  |  Paul Easton 25/09/07
  40.   Spoiled brat? 13:10  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 25/09/07
  41.   Israel is an international pariah already 13:14  |  gearoid 25/09/07
  42.   Natallie Durson 13:19  |  AM 25/09/07
  43.   responses which don`t hit the point 13:22  |  Michael 25/09/07
  44.   Brilliant analysis, of first magnitude importance! 13:25  |  Ivar 25/09/07
  45.   Pariah state 13:25  |  Choni Davidowitz 25/09/07
  46.   A fine analysis - moral confusion 13:26  |  thru-other-eyes 25/09/07
  47.   Good article - is it time to pay attention yet? 2nd try 13:31  |  dana 25/09/07
  48.   the problem is that Israel is surrounded by hordes 13:36  |  Trembling Palestine 25/09/07
  49.   israel has been hanging on to the coat tails of the Americans,and 13:36  |  lakshmi 25/09/07
  50.   without OIL 13:37  |  real vision 25/09/07
  51.   the minute the US stops supporting Israel, the 13:39  |  Trembling Palestine 25/09/07
  52.   Not only wrong side of history 13:41  |  Jan Elshout 25/09/07
  53.   Whine, whine whine, whine, whine, whine, etc. 13:41  |  Judith, Haifa 25/09/07
  54.   pariah state Israel ? 13:45  |  maurice grima 25/09/07
  55.   clever vision # 22 13:49  |  real vision 25/09/07
  56.   NB 13:53  |  Walid 25/09/07
  57.   Hardman, Absolute Sweden & Co. 13:54  |  Gad Giladi 25/09/07
  58.   are Christian Journalists captured and forced to convert to Islam 13:54  |  Susanna/Shoshanna 25/09/07
  59.   Carlo "the Jackal" will rot in hell for his words 13:59  |  Rabbi Izzy Lahm 25/09/07
  60.   Predictable reactions 13:59  |  Murray 25/09/07
  61.   Sarah 14:00  |  Walid 25/09/07
  62.   pariah 14:04  |  iletzter 25/09/07
  63.   THE HARM HAS BEEN DONE... and Israel is leading towards disaster 14:14  |  TrippleJump 25/09/07
  64.   THE WRITER IS A LEFT-WING LUNATIC 14:15  |  NEUTRAL 25/09/07
  65.   anti-Semitism is a cornerstone of the Western civilization 14:20  |  no name 25/09/07
  66.   Free `The Israel Lobby..`chapters in NYTimes 14:26  |  vhobie 25/09/07
  67.   Israel is indeed a shitty country 14:29  |  KMS 25/09/07
  68.   confused 14:31  |  Shimon 25/09/07
  69.   #32 Real Vision 14:38  |  Chris Linthwaite 25/09/07
  70.   Polling Data 14:39  |  Daybreak 25/09/07
  71.   Carlo and the "pariah state" 14:40  |  Hastaroth 25/09/07
  72.   Spoiled brat? Sibling jealousy? 14:44  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 25/09/07
  73.   #38 WELL SAID, GAD GILADI 14:44  |  Don Camillo 25/09/07
  74.   #43 Rabbi Izzy Lahm 14:52  |  Chris Linthwaite 25/09/07
  75.   #42 gad giladi and personal attacks on the brainless 14:56  |  victor hardman 25/09/07
  76.   #59 Correction 14:59  |  Daybreak 25/09/07
  77.   Chris Linthwaite 15:03  |  Walid 25/09/07
  78.   Carlo makes a point 15:05  |  peter 25/09/07
  79.   Maurice Grima and imperial racism 15:09  |  Truths 25/09/07
  80.   Israel might have crossed border already.. 15:11  |  Adil 25/09/07
  81.   Occupation and its discontents 15:14  |  Tosefta