Subscribe to Print Edition | Wed., September 26, 2007 , | | Israel Time: 03:56 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Arts & Leisure Real Estate Jewish World National Advertising
Magazine Week's End Business Opinion Rosner's Domain Anglo File Books Travel
del.icio.us
Digg It!  new
Last update - 10:12 24/09/2007
How many were arrested last night?
By Danny Rubinstein

Last Thursday I joined a group of senior Palestinian Authority officials who traveled from Ramallah to Jericho for the dedication of the new Palestinian Security Academy training ground. PA Chairman Mahmoud Abbas was the guest of honor. He had just completed his joint press conference with Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice, and was stopping in Jericho en route to Jordan. From there he was to fly to the United States, where he will meet today with President George Bush at the United Nations in New York.

Jericho is considered a quiet town. With the exception of the hotel, the closed casino at the southern entrance to the city and the destroyed police building, it looks fairly miserable, as it was when the Israel Defense Forces occupied it over 40 years ago. The Security Academy complex is northwest of the city. It is an impressive structure, with classrooms, computer systems, and a spacious, modern gym, all built with aid money, mainly American.

The first class, 120 officers from all of the PA security organizations, will begin its training in the coming days. The students will learn basic subjects, including administration and law. General Tawfiq Tirawi, the strongman of the West Bank security organizations, is emphatic: "They will also learn Hebrew - there will be no officer here who does not know Hebrew well."

Advertisement
There seems to be a serious effort to revamp the PA security forces in the West Bank, but it is not clear whether the attempt will work. In recent years security control over a number of cities in the West Bank was transferred to Palestinian organizations, which failed.

According to IDF sources, each time the IDF stopped raiding a city in the West Bank it became a safe haven for militants preparing attacks inside Israel, such as the one that was foiled in recent days in South Tel Aviv.

The West Bank security question is governed by paradox. The great concern is that if the IDF withdraws completely from Palestinian urban centers (what used to constitute Area A), terrorist cells will find room to organize themselves. Moreover, Hamas activists will become more powerful and will pose a threat to the institutions of the Palestinian Authority, toppling them as they did in the Gaza Strip.

As such, the IDF and the Palestinian security organizations are now focused on hunting down militants and carrying out extensive arrests in the West Bank. Among those arrested are Hamas activists, and also some who are suspected terrorists. For months now, Israeli news reports announce the number of fugitives arrested the night before. The arrests of Hamas activists in the West Bank by the PA has already caused some discontent in the larger cities.

On the one hand, the intense activity of the IDF in the West Bank ensures that Abbas' security organizations remain in control there and prevents the strengthening of Hamas, but the opposite is also true. The PA is becoming very weakened by Israel's operations. It is increasingly seen as an authority that is managing to survive in the West Bank only thanks to the IDF and the collaborators working for Israel's Shin Bet intelligence service. In the West Bank they joke that Abbas and his men, who also include a group of 200 Fatah refugees from the Gaza Strip, do not dare travel stray too far from Ramallah and the Muqata'a, the presidential complex. Some (Nabil Sha'ath, Mohammed Dahlan and Hassan Asfur) spend most of their time in Egypt , while others appear to have become exasperated with the Palestinian nation-building effort and simply moved to Amman. How long can this continue?

Shortly before his death three years ago, the sociologist Gadi Yatziv wrote that in the IDF struggle against terrorism, victory is part of failure. It is impossible to win because every raid, assassination, arrest and roadblock stir rage and hatred and broaden the pool of conscripts for terrorist cells. But it is also impossible to fail because the spokesmen of the Israeli security establishment will always claim that without these raids and roadblocks, terrorism will be much worse. It is an argument that cannot be refuted.
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Dead or alive
How can a person be deemed dead by modern medicine if his heart continues to beat?
Betting against Grant
After one match as manager of Chelsea, the English press is already listing replacements.
  1.   the guys right 10:44  |  ravi 24/09/07
  2.   OSAMA BIN LADEN MENTOR WAS A PALESTINIAN 10:49  |  indrajaya 24/09/07
  3.   Abbas will be the death of Fatah 11:22  |  Natallie Durson 24/09/07
  4.   Danny, you are dead wrong, the more and harder you beat Arab 11:32  |  Uzi 24/09/07
  5.   israel will not win this war,no doubt about it,all that israeli 11:36  |  lakshmi 24/09/07
  6.   Traitor 11:37  |  Jacob for TRUTH 24/09/07
  7.   How safe are these Terrorists? U R in Platonic cave 11:43  |  Jay 24/09/07
  8.   There can never be any separate Arab political entity 12:00  |  Uzi 24/09/07
  9.   The greatest Arab failures: 12:03  |  Uzi 24/09/07
  10.   "Juden-frei Israel" 12:13  |  Dirk 24/09/07
  11.   to Uzi 12:15  |  Dirk 24/09/07
  12.   uzi 4 12:26  |  realism 24/09/07
  13.   Danny Rubinstein ,commit suicide yourself,insted of demanding it 12:51  |  Absolute Sweden 24/09/07
  14.   IDF INACTION AGAINST MILITANTS - ALLOWS TERROR 13:00  |  Mitch Iginer 24/09/07
  15.   Rubinstein attacked Israel "apartheid" ! Now IDF ! 2nd try 14:01  |  Alberto Cohen 24/09/07
  16.   danny rubinstein has become akiva eldar 14:22  |  lovepals 24/09/07
  17.   lakshmi "israel will not win this war" 14:24  |  muslimpopulation150m 24/09/07
  18.   rubinstein obviously not a student of history nor keen observer 14:29  |  ralph 24/09/07
  19.   Re #4 southern Lebanon pullback, Gaza 14:45  |  DJStahl 24/09/07
  20.   IDF breed terror 15:38  |  Israel Letzter 24/09/07
  21.   No IDF action = Lets just let them bomb us all 15:52  |  Dakkar 24/09/07
  22.   Danny Rubinstein correct in highlighting dilemma 16:15  |  Smadar 24/09/07
  23.   smadar 16:30  |  ezra shohet 24/09/07
  24.   Rubinstein`s Nonsense 16:49  |  Ben Israel 24/09/07
  25.   what does failure? 17:27  |  khairi janbek 24/09/07
  26.   #23 Ezra Shohet 17:29  |  Smadar 24/09/07
  27.   Rubinstein and "quiet towns" 17:31  |  Miriam 24/09/07
  28.   #4 Uzi - think instead of hating millions of people you know not 18:05  |  Rick 24/09/07
  29.   CLEVER MAN MR RUBINSTEIN, LET TERROR ROAM FREE AND WIN 18:11  |  Jorge 24/09/07
  30.   indrajaya,hey,dumbass,al qaeda was born to stop the infidels of 18:31  |  terrornator 24/09/07
  31.   3Natalie D.that process is well under way,fatah is thoroughly 19:00  |  lakshmi 24/09/07
  32.   Uzi is correct 19:12  |  Boruch 24/09/07
  33.   Haaretz has become another media whore: 19:17  |  Fortuna Benmayor 24/09/07
  34.   Rubinstein trying Arab logic 101 19:19  |  peter 24/09/07
  35.   Dirk #11, I`m not impressed with your reading and comprehension 19:44  |  Uzi 24/09/07
  36.   It`s just Einstein and a fact::action = reaction 19:46  |  Mark B. 24/09/07
  37.   Danny Rubinstein & his `militants` 19:51  |  Shmuel R 24/09/07
  38.   "realism" #12, it so happens that the "checkpoints" save Israeli 19:57  |  Uzi 24/09/07
  39.   Rick #28, why are you so concerned with the wellbeing of "Arab 20:21  |  Uzi 24/09/07
  40.   Look at the results 20:29  |  A Friedman 24/09/07
  41.   lakshmi and "his last hurrah" 20:32  |  babrimosque 24/09/07
  42.   Solution: Replace IDF with temporary international police 21:29  |  Ivar 24/09/07
  43.   I(t is a shame Danny Rubinstein 22:00  |  rich 24/09/07
  44.   #42 ivar returns to lal la land once more 22:56  |  victor hardman 24/09/07
  45.   Quite backwards 23:46  |  Scharker Yid 24/09/07
  46.   uzi 38 23:59  |  realism 24/09/07
  47.   #44Hardman-dates 00:27  |  Labhras 25/09/07
  48.   Rick in Garland, Texas 00:34  |  rich 25/09/07
  49.   #46, realism... 01:23  |  Silvienne 25/09/07
  50.   #38, Uzi... 01:26  |  Silvienne 25/09/07
  51.   #32, Boruch 01:27  |  Silvienne 25/09/07
  52.   "realism" #46, typically you continue to show that you are 03:02  |  Uzi 25/09/07
  53.   Did you atone? 04:07  |  Micha 25/09/07
  54.   #47, Uzi from Haifa... 04:13  |  Silvienne 25/09/07
  55.   # 3 I must repeat, Fatmah, that the best.... 05:46  |  Misha 25/09/07
  56.   # 42 Ivar, get rid of anticemitic feelings and than come back... 06:28  |  Misha 25/09/07
  57.   #39 Uzi - I oppose all violence against innocents 06:36  |  Rick 25/09/07
  58.   Response to #39 - CORRECTION - stats wrong 06:49  |  Rick 25/09/07
  59.   indrajaya,hey,dumbass,al qaeda was born to stop the infidels of 07:11  |  mike ben moshe 25/09/07
  60.   World wide danger 07:24  |  JW 25/09/07
  61.   #47 labarse joins the impractical nobodies who post 08:38  |  victor hardman 25/09/07
  62.   Danny Ruinstein 11:19  |  Ralph Jones, M.D. 25/09/07
 Today Online
Shmuel Rosner: Israel is clear loser from Ahmadinejad's visit
Responses: 594
Carlo Strenger: Israel on path to becoming a pariah state
Responses: 195
Amira Hass: Showing Palestinians that there are other Israelis
Responses: 68
Ben-Eliezer: Barghouti is best chance for breakthrough with PA
Responses: 113


More Headlines
03:25 Syria willing to transfer disputed Shaba Farms to UN custody
03:45 Ahmadinejad: The Iran nuclear issue is closed
02:25 Texas governor announces establishment of Texas-Israel Chamber of Commerce
01:11 Documents show Israel lobbying to import nuclear material
01:02 PM: Jewish Agency still has key role in bringing Jews to Israel
23:52 Ben-Eliezer: Continued neglect of Israeli Arabs may spark 'internal Intifada'
19:08 Bank Hapoalim to sever ties with Palestinian banks in Gaza
21:31 Hamas urges Saudis not to go to U.S.-led Mideast conference
21:06 Court won't let children visit father in Sderot due to security concerns
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
Invest in Macedonia
New Business Heaven in Europe
Long-term Israel programs
MASA is your gateway. More programs. More grants.
Eldan Rent a Car
Israel's leading car rental company offers you a 20% discount on all online reservations
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
Dead Sea Salt
Beauty and skin care from the Dead Sea. Coupon code HAARETZ for 10% off!
Israeli History Documentaries.
Own a piece of Israel?s treasured past.
Junkyard
Junk a car - get free towing nationwide and a tax-deductible receipt.
Holiday Inn and Crown Plaza Israel
Lowest internet rate Guaranteed at ichotelsgroup.com !