A Hasidic sect discovers democracy - Haaretz

Subscribe to Print Edition

Sun., October 07, 2007 ,

Israel Time: 00:23 (EST+7)

web haaretz.com

Back to Homepage

Print Edition

Diplomacy

Defense

Arts & Leisure

Real Estate

Jewish World

National

Advertising

Magazine

Week's End

Business

Opinion

Rosner's Domain

Anglo File

Books

Travel

del.icio.us

Digg It! new

Last update - 11:47 24/09/2007

A Hasidic sect discovers democracy

By Shlomo Shamir

NEW YORK - This is an election in every sense of the word. There is a voter's registry with a list of those eligible to vote; voters must present valid identification; the contenders are waging a fierce campaign; and the tension between the opposing camps is palpable. What makes this election unprecedented is the identity of the contenders: This election will determine which of two rabbinic leaders of the Bobov Hasidic sect has the most support among Bobov Hasidim.

One contender is Rabbi Ben Zion Halberstam, son of Rabbi Shlomo Halberstam, who revived the Bobov Hasidic dynasty in America after the Holocaust, but died in 2000. The other is Rabbi Mordechai David Unger, son-in-law of Rabbi Naftali Halberstam, who briefly succeeded Rabbi Shlomo Halberstam, but then died two and a half years ago.

The elections, which began about a week ago and are expected to continue for another few days, were forced on Bobov Hasidim by a rabbinic court in response to a suit brought by several followers of Rabbi Unger against Rabbi Ben Zion Halberstam. In accordance with Jewish law, rabbinic judges were chosen by mutual consent to determine which of the two rabbis would bear the exclusive title of Admor of Bobov, or leader of the sect.

	Advertisement

"Something like this has never happened in the history of the Hasidic movement," remarked one Hasidic Jew, leaning against the gate at the entrance of the central Bobov beit midrash (Torah study center) in Brooklyn's Borough Park neighborhood. "That a Hasidic rabbinic leader would be elected by a vote - our forefathers never dreamed of such a thing."

Only followers of Rabbi Halberstam currently worship in the central beit midrash. Followers of Rabbi Unger have established their own temporary beit midrash in response to the hostility engendered by the split between the camps.

The movement's single yeshiva students were denied the right to vote in the current election, so voters are required to provide proof that they are married. The decorum has been exemplary, and the Hasidic voters appear to have whole-heartedly embraced the mitzvah (commandment) of voting. But attempts to elicit comments from potential voters met with reluctance.

"They don't like talking about it, because the election is an expression of the painful split that took place among Bobov Hasidim," explained one yeshiva student, after he was promised that his identity would be concealed. "And this is happening during the [High Holidays] period of mercy and forgiveness," he added.

In order to prevent members of other Hasidic sects from voting, election organizers established a registry of eligible voters. "It's a very precise list," one Hasid remarked. But the number of names on the list remains a secret.

Instead of a ballot, voters are asked to respond to a questionnaire prepared by the rabbinic court. The questionnaire, written in Yiddish, contains eight questions phrased as demands. For example, "I demand that the authority of the Bobov Hasidic court's rabbinic leadership rest with..." The voter then marks the empty square next to the name of the preferred rabbi, Rabbi Halberstam or Rabbi Unger.

Voters are also asked to respond to the following question: "If my side is granted the authority and the other side's rabbinic leader splits from the Hasidic court to establish his own community, I demand one of the following: That the other side not be entitled to use the name Bobov, even as a name that accompanies another title, or that the other side be entitled to be called 'Bobov,' but only on condition that it adds a modifying name to that title."

Both sides cautiously avoid making predictions regarding the outcome of the election. "The results will not be known until after the holidays," explained one of Rabbi Halberstam's faithful.

Nevertheless, word has it that the number of voters in Rabbi Halberstam's beit midrash is several times larger than in that of Rabbi Unger.

"We cannot prevent Rabbi Unger from serving as Admor, but we will staunchly oppose him bearing the title," the Halberstam supported promised.

Bookmark to del.icio.us


	Clalit's 'star' doctors
	Clalit is in talks with the treasury over approval of its 'Star Program' for hospitals.


	I have a sukkah
	My husband's sukkah was developed with the help of design software from NASA.




1.	Modern American solution	15:34	\|	Motic	24/09/07

2.	AWESOME! "Halakha inclines to the majority!"	16:48	\|	Hal	24/09/07

3.	Female voters?	20:44	\|	cor	24/09/07

4.	female voters	22:35	\|	i	24/09/07

5.	the females are the voters	00:23	\|	Sean	25/09/07

6.	Re: Female voters #3	00:45	\|	jk	25/09/07

7.	halacha	07:29	\|	yank	25/09/07

8.	Totally WRONG!	22:10	\|	Bobowa	25/09/07

9.	Orthodoxy and democracy	09:26	\|	Joseph	26/09/07

10.	bobov	17:59	\|	emes	26/09/07

11.	What Next...Set Term Limits?	05:19	\|	Reader	28/09/07

12.	Fantasy Land	23:57	\|	Reality	07/10/07

Today Online


	Palestinian militants in Gaza fire Katyusha at southern Israel
	Responses: 117


	Rosner: Was Archbishop Tutu comparing Israel and Hitler?
	Responses: 122


	Gideon Levy: IDF's scandalous killing of children
	Responses: 261


	Syria paper urges return of Golan 'by any means'
	Responses: 157


	Palestinian Christian activist stabbed to death in Gaza
	Responses: 109

More Headlines
22:44 Turkish FM, in J'lem: Israel must explain IAF strike on Syria


23:44 IDF says Hamas responsible for Katyusha fired from Gaza Strip


19:16 Livni: Israel shouldn't rush into concessions for sake of summit


23:30 Mofaz orders disciplinary hearings into Ben-Gurion near-collision


19:20 Bronfman offering unique prize for 'next great Jewish idea'


22:08 Serbian police stop 26 neo-Nazis marching despite ban


20:20 Secondary school teachers to launch strike on Wednesday


19:40 Rocker Bryan Adams to sing for peace at Israel, West Bank concerts


19:18 MK hands Peres national plan to reduce energy consumption