Police, Justice Ministry refusing to investigate officers for perjury - Haaretz

Subscribe to Print Edition

Mon., September 24, 2007 ,

Israel Time: 20:02 (EST+7)

web haaretz.com

Back to Homepage

Print Edition

Diplomacy

Defense

Arts & Leisure

Real Estate

Jewish World

National

Advertising

Magazine

Week's End

Business

Opinion

Rosner's Domain

Anglo File

Books

Travel

del.icio.us

Digg It! new

Last update - 04:59 23/09/2007

Police, Justice Ministry refusing to investigate officers for perjury

By Roni Singer-Heruti, Haaretz Correspondent

Despite a judge's ruling that three Tel Aviv police officers lied on the stand when they claimed to have been brutally assaulted, both the Justice Ministry's Police Investigations Department and the police have declined to investigate the case or take action against the officers.

All the officers are still in blue. Meanwhile, this incident has compromised police credibility more than any other in recent months, say sources involved in the case.

In May, the Tel Aviv Magistrate's Court court acquitted three young men whom several police officers accused of assault three years ago, after a video showed the officers' accounts to be untrue.

	Advertisement

The officers told the judge that they had arrived at a party after neighbors complained about the noise, and that the three men hurled glass bottles at them. They also claimed revelers beat a female officer while she was lying unconscious on the ground.

Judge Shmuel Landman ruled the testimony uncredible.

"I am disturbed by the standards the police officers demonstrated in their testimony," he wrote in his ruling. "We must not have police officers take to the stand, and then claim that black is white and white is black. This gives rise to somber reflections on the standards of the officers who testified before me."

Landman based his ruling on a video tape the officers had confiscated from the revelers. After the defendants requested that the footage be introduced as evidence, it showed the police's account to be false.

Despite the judge's misgivings about the officers' performance, credibility and standards, all are still serving in the police's Yiftah Region. Moreover, the authorities apparently have no intention of heeding the judge's criticism of Roni Dolinski, Idan Albachri and Karmit Or Lev - whose testimonies gave the judge special cause for concern.

"There is no reason to initiate an investigation into the officers' actions, given the circumstances and the fact that the events occurred more than three years ago," the PID told the defendants' attorney, public defender Hagit Larnau. Larnau requested the PID initiate an investigation immediately after Landman's ruling in May.

In its response, the PID mentioned "the doubt concerning the events that led to the use of force, and the doubt as to whether the use of force constituted a violation of protocol." However, the legal truth already had been determined in court, and the judge already had criticized the officers' conduct.

After Larnau pointed this out to the PID, it transferred the case for internal inspection within the police. The case was submitted to the Yiftah Region complaints department - the very unit where the police officers serve.

The complaints officer informed Larnau last month that the case does not merit a probe, and that the complainants - the former defendants - should file individual complaints against the officers.

"These officers, like many others who managed to get away with similar offenses without punishment, feel they are protected," says a veteran criminal lawyer. "I have come across cops who lied about being assaulted. I have seen these same officers complain about other assaults."

Larnau says the fact that the officers managed to get off the hook despite having been harshly criticized by a judge encourages policemen to lie. "This will help create a culture of mendacity in the police force," she says.

Larnau is still trying to get the authorities to investigate the officers. She says she knows of other cases where police officers lied about conflicts with civilians.

"I have handled many cases," she says. "But this case was especially embarrassing because of how these officers behaved. They sat there on the stand and behaved like common criminals. The police and the Justice Department's Police Investigation Unit must not allow them to get away with it without paying for their actions."

Bookmark to del.icio.us


	First sin of the year
	These small, delectable burekas are a perfect way to break the fast, and your diet.


	Subduing artists
	If MK Orlev cannot beat the 'leftists, ' he can at least make their lives miserable.




1.	The police force needs serious attention	07:22	\|	Margie in Tel Aviv	23/09/07

2.	All in a daze work	17:43	\|	Another Jew	23/09/07

3.	If we fired all the liars	17:48	\|	Alex.	23/09/07

4.	In Jerusalem standards are lower	17:51	\|	Just A jew	23/09/07

5.	there are lies,liars and policemen	19:54	\|	Joanna	24/09/07

Today Online


	High Court postpones ruling on JNF land sales to non-Jews
	Responses: 132


	Ahmadinejad, amid N.Y. protests, denies Iran seeks nukes
	Responses: 225


	Yakobson: Israel must not agree to let Syria reoccupy Galilee
	Responses: 70


	Danny Rubinstein: IDF victories against militants breed terror
	Responses: 38


	Leading Israeli authors, intellectuals urge truce with Hamas
	Responses: 120

Rosner's Domain

* Ruth Wisse: Anti-Zionism goes beyond anti-Semitism

* The Israel Factor's Clinton reader

* WTR: Dilbert's lesson of history

* Blog/poll: The most daring experiment in Jewish history

More Headlines
19:54 Ahmadinejad: Iran will not attack Israel or any other country


15:47 Mazuz orders police probe of PM over J'lem home


14:57 High Court delays ruling on JNF land sales to non-Jews


16:51 Syrian official: After IAF raid, Israel can forget about peace


18:16 AG decides to indict ex-finance min. Hirchson for fraud, theft


19:36 Protesters face off at Columbia ahead of Ahmadinejad speech


18:02 Knesset approves Ayalon appointment as minister without portfolio


19:06 Jerusalem municipality to erect sukkah made entirely of candy


09:53 Lebanon said likely to free Israeli arrested for spying, murder


13:17 Israeli officials: J'lem doesn't object to Syria joining peace summit


19:05 Sephardic, Ashkenazi rabbis at odds over 'shmita' ban bypass


18:41 Russia, Israel to sign deal on removal of visa requirements