Subscribe to Print Edition | Mon., September 24, 2007 , | | Israel Time: 00:37 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Arts & Leisure Real Estate Jewish World National Advertising
Magazine Week's End Business Opinion Rosner's Domain Anglo File Books Travel
del.icio.us
Digg It!  new
Last update - 22:02 22/09/2007
Wanted: Right-wing artists
By Ehud Asheri

"This is further proof of the fact that the minister of education is trying to impose Peace Now's agenda on the school system. The prime minister must prevent the domination of the school system by the extreme left. Parents should supervise their children's education, because it is impossible to trust the political minister of education."

- MK Zevulun Orlev in response to the decision to introduce two plays that deal with the injustices of the occupation - "Project Jabalya" and "Winter in Qalandiyah"- into the school system's "culture basket"

Good for National Religious Party Chair Zevulun Orlev! In a brilliant intelligence coup, he managed to find two "left-wing" plays out of about 1,000 included in the schools' culture basket, and he immediately warned the nation that the souls of Israeli students were being poisoned. It is a good thing that someone is on guard. Nevertheless, Orlev's reaction provokes several questions. First, it is doubtful whether he saw the two plays, which are based on the personal experiences of Eldad Galor (in Jabalya) and Lia Nirgad (at the Qalandiyah checkpoint) before describing them as "extreme left." Second, why did he wake up only now? The plays have been performed for over a year, and even the decision to include them in the culture basket was made several weeks ago. Third, what does he want from the education minister? The decision was made by an independent professional committee of 100 artists and academicians; it is doubtful whether the minister was even aware of it.

Advertisement
One could of course dismiss Orlev's words as another transparent attempt by a politician to make headlines and political capital at the expense of an ideological rival. But the NRP chair represents a broader cultural phenomenon that has been picking up speed lately. He is not alone in the campaign against artists who want to give artistic expression, mainly in the theater and cinema, to the experience of the Israeli occupation as they know it. His declaration is another step in a renewed campaign against the freedom of expression of artists whose work questions the justice of Israeli policy in the territories.

On Tuesday, a District Court began hearing a libel suit by five reserve soldiers against Mohammed Bakri, the director of the film "Jenin, Jenin," who documented conversations with residents of the Jenin refugee camp several days after Operation Defensive Shield in April 2002. The sequence of events in this case is a good illustration of the extent of the battle against works that are incompatible with the prevailing concept of Israeli patriotism.

At first the film was rejected by the Censorship Board for Films and Plays. After a two-year public battle, the High Court of Justice accepted Bakri's petition and allowed the film to be screened commercially ("the board's decision goes too far in undermining freedom of expression ... The council is not authorized to restrict political or ideological statements even if the government or most of the public disagrees with them"). This time, MK Aryeh Eldad was the first to jump in: "The High Court justices are performing a wonderful service for the enemy behind the foolish claim of freedom of expression."

Meanwhile, the five reservists filed a libel suit against Bakri ("We set out to defend the State of Israel in a tough battle that took place in Jenin. When we returned home, we saw the film, which presents us as war criminals," said Yonatan Van Kaspel, one of the plaintiffs). Four and a half years of mediation did not convince the plaintiffs to withdraw their suit. They continue to treat the film as a journalistic document that presumes to reflect the factual situation, instead of seeing it as a subjective work of art that documents the Palestinians' narrative and mood.

A similar fate greeted the play "Hebron," a recently staged co-production of the Habima and Cameri theaters. The play deals with the human dimension of the bloody conflict between Jews and Arabs in the City of the Patriarchs. But for some reason, from the first moment, it was labeled anti-Israeli. Matot Arim, a right-wing organization that supports Jewish settlement in Hebron, quickly organized a series of demonstrations with the slogan "Israeli theater in the service of Hamas," and there was quite an uproar.

If we add in the Yehoshua Rabinowitz Foundation's withdrawal of support for the cinema project "Jaffa" due to the anti-Zionist reputation of the designated director, Eyal Sivan, we get a disturbing picture: Israeli society is showing symptoms of going back 37 years, to the dark days of "The Queen of the Bathtub." The censor's initial decision to reject Hanoch Levin's text (when the board was asked to explain its decision, it backtracked on its rejection) and the tumultuous demonstrations against the play have been seen all these years as a childhood disease of a society suffering from a temporary nationalist virus. But it turns out that the virus was only dormant, and has now reawakened and returned to threaten the emotional health of Israeli democracy.

Orlev, Eldad and those who share their views can claim that artistic freedom of expression is always exploited in the service of the same ideological camp. There is something to that. One can understand why this trend frustrates them: It contradicts their political interest and is seen by them as assisting enemy propaganda. They are incapable of seeing it for what it really is - proof of society's strength and its ability to include skeptical voices. But instead of encouraging creativity in their own camp and joining the marketplace of artistic ideas, they are embarking on a fight to the finish against other artists. If they cannot beat the "leftists," they can at least make their lives miserable.
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Jewels of the East
For years Kfar Saba, Ra'anana and Hod Hasharon have been competing for the lead.
Dodging the crunch
The Bachar Commission did a fine job of protecting us from the global credit crunch.
  1.   survival instinct 23:49  |  Jewish State 22/09/07
  2.   reservist soldiers against the truth 05:03  |  dana 23/09/07
  3.   " All they are saying is give piece a chance" 06:20  |  Rob 23/09/07
  4.   Jewish state?? 09:35  |  A.M. 23/09/07
  5.   Educating all of you, especially Dana 09:42  |  FOX 23/09/07
  6.   Left means bllody dictatirship 10:03  |  afraid to reveal 23/09/07
  7.   "a subjective work of art" 10:44  |  JonathanInTelAviv 23/09/07
  8.   typical right-wing mentality 11:51  |  Danny 23/09/07
  9.   help 18:11  |  me 23/09/07
  10.   Ehud, if based on total falsehoods is it still work of art? 19:49  |  Genuine Tosefta 23/09/07
  11.   Freedom osf expression: a licensed to insult and demoralize 21:12  |  Gil 23/09/07
  12.   Intimidation is becoming the mode. 00:18  |  Esther 24/09/07
  13.   The Market Place of artisic ideas??...please 06:58  |  Mary 24/09/07
  14.   Deliberate lies 10:42  |  Vladimir 24/09/07
  15.   Educating Dana II 11:03  |  Jacob 24/09/07
  16.   "Jenini, Jenin" is not subjecive but objective lies 11:41  |  Alain 24/09/07
  17.   What about Pals dissents, or simply unofficial?? 11:42  |  Alain 24/09/07
  18.   to no 12 11:53  |  fish 24/09/07
  19.   I hope he succeeds [in making you miserable]! 15:51  |  David 24/09/07
  20.   Esther big word reactionary 17:36  |  Mary 24/09/07
  21.   DEVELOP CRITICAL MINDS. 17:55  |  SM 24/09/07
  22.   #Danny, the left wing scholar???Wrong! 18:25  |  Claudia 24/09/07
  23.   Not all of us want to committ suicide 18:59  |  Ronaldo 24/09/07
  24.   NUTS 19:36  |  Jim 24/09/07
  25.   citation please? 23:58  |  NR 24/09/07
 Today Online
High Court postpones ruling on JNF land sales to non-Jews
Responses: 143
Ahmadinejad: Why must Palestinians pay for the Holocaust?
Responses: 429
Yakobson: Israel must not agree to let Syria reoccupy Galilee
Responses: 92
Danny Rubinstein: IDF victories against militants breed terror
Responses: 46
Leading Israeli authors, intellectuals urge truce with Hamas
Responses: 143


More Headlines
00:18 Iranian president: If Holocaust happened, why must Palestinians pay?
22:44 Protesters face off at Columbia ahead of Ahmadinejad speech
20:41 Mazuz orders police probe of PM over purchase of J'lem home
14:57 High Court delays ruling on JNF land sales to non-Jews
16:51 Syrian official: After IAF raid, Israel can forget about peace
21:21 Court to State: Clarify stance on family reunification ban
18:02 Knesset approves Ayalon appointment as minister without portfolio
22:12 University heads, faculty threaten strike over funds dispute
21:44 European Union will not fund Polish college with anti-Semitic ties
19:06 Jerusalem municipality to erect sukkah made entirely of candy
18:16 AG decides to indict ex-finance min. Hirchson for fraud, theft
18:41 Russia, Israel to sign deal on removal of visa requirements
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
Long-term Israel programs
MASA is your gateway. More programs. More grants.
Eldan Rent a Car
Israel's leading car rental company offers you a 20% discount on all online reservations
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
Dead Sea Salt
Beauty and skin care from the Dead Sea. Coupon code HAARETZ for 10% off!
Israeli History Documentaries.
Own a piece of Israel?s treasured past.
Junkyard
Junk a car - get free towing nationwide and a tax-deductible receipt.
Holiday Inn and Crown Plaza Israel
Lowest internet rate Guaranteed at ichotelsgroup.com !
Home| TV| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved