Subscribe to Print Edition | Tue., September 25, 2007 , | | Israel Time: 18:31 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Arts & Leisure Real Estate Jewish World National Advertising
Magazine Week's End Business Opinion Rosner's Domain Anglo File Books Travel
del.icio.us
Digg It!  new
Last update - 14:42 19/09/2007
Dutch church to reexamine policy of solidarity with Israel
By Cnaan Liphshiz

After 37 years of boasting of "inalienable solidarity" with the people of Israel, the Netherlands' second largest church plans to reexamine its stance this fall. A group of notables from the Protestant Church in the Netherlands (PCN) warned last week that the organization, which has over two million members, is in danger of being "hijacked" by pro-Palestinian activists.

The warning - coauthored by Dr. Jan van der Graaf, who served for 35 years as general secretary within one of the three churches that make up the PCN, and three other prominent church figures - was an open letter against changing the reference to Israel. It was addressed to Minister Henri Veldhuis, a General Synod member who said the clause made the church adopt a biased view that ignored Israeli actions against Palestinians.

At a speech last month in Utrecht for Friends of Sabeel (a Jerusalem-based Palestinian organization), Veldhuis said the church should commit to a bond with Israel "as people of the Torah" instead of the "Jewish people as an ethnic group." Veldhuis also complained that currently, "the church has a stronger bond with a non-believing Alaskan Jewish person than a Palestinian Christian."

Advertisement
The open letter accused Veldhuis of a slanted and hypocritical approach. "We were astonished by your address before a Palestinian liberation organization that pretends to be promoting reconciliation," it read. "You accused Israel but ignored Hamas's Jew-hating ideology. You overlooked the alarming anti-Semitic upsurge in Arab countries."

Veldhuis responded that the signatories "were regrettably and falsely" trying to portray Sabeel and himself as radical left-wing activists. In a conversation with Haaretz, Veldhuis said: "It is important to preserve the lessons of the Holocaust and never forget the Jewish roots of church and bible and to fight anti-Semitism, but we have to take a more realistic position on the Jewish people as an ethnic group and on the State of Israel. The PCN's theology is now idealizing both."

He added that he believes the coauthors - Van der Graaf, Dr. Theo van Campen, Dr. Wulfert de Greef and Dr. Henk van der Meulen - are circling the wagons because of "mounting criticism of Israel's policies."

Van der Graaf said that those who advocate changing the church's charter are "only a highly motivated minority" within PCN, and he believes the clause will ultimately remain unchanged.

The PCN, which was formed in 2004 as a merger of the country's three largest protestant churches, is scheduled to discuss revising its stance on Israel in November.


Bookmark to del.icio.us
Jewels of the East
For years Kfar Saba, Ra'anana and Hod Hasharon have been competing for the lead.
Dodging the crunch
The Bachar Commission did a fine job of protecting us from the global credit crunch.
  1.   MORE Moslems than Jews in Holland & they do Fatwas. 04:33  |  PETER S .M. 19/09/07
  2.   The Church should have solidarity with Christians FIRST 04:37  |  People 19/09/07
  3.   Dutch Church & Israel 04:47  |  Mitch Charles 19/09/07
  4.   A backstabbing Church? Shocking! 06:09  |  Jon 19/09/07
  5.   The Dutch liked the Jews better as victim rather than victimizer 06:53  |  Karma Chameleon 19/09/07
  6.   ISN`T THAT AMAZING? 07:21  |  Indrajaya 19/09/07
  7.   A COUPLE MORE BOMBS ARE NEEDED 07:23  |  indrajaya 19/09/07
  8.   An opinion from the Netherlands 07:24  |  Joep 19/09/07
  9.   Christians Please Resist Arab Pressure 07:26  |  Yosemite 19/09/07
  10.   I expect more and worse 07:27  |  Denton 19/09/07
  11.   Sanity 07:30  |  Bandar Michaels 19/09/07
  12.   DUTCH CHURCH OR ANY CHURCH 07:35  |  charro 19/09/07
  13.   all of europe 07:50  |  real vision 19/09/07
  14.   Fake Indrajaya! 08:12  |  Yosemite 19/09/07
  15.   To Joep 08:21  |  Nigel 19/09/07
  16.   some of the readers here don`t know what ... 08:22  |  Leona 19/09/07
  17.   Dutch Church in: http://www.EUROSTAN.eu 08:27  |  U.Rowstan 19/09/07
  18.   To Denton of Alabama 08:29  |  ArabAmerican 19/09/07
  19.   #12 overtaken by Charro 08:51  |  Warren 19/09/07
  20.   nederland 09:06  |  jaap 19/09/07
  21.   Israel= hateful apartheid that is anti-Christian 09:26  |  Church-goer 19/09/07
  22.   #8 Ignorant biased comments 09:26  |  Semsem 19/09/07
  23.   The Dutch Church and Solidarity 09:35  |  steve 19/09/07
  24.   It Really Doesn`t Matter Since The Holocaust Taught Us Jews That 09:38  |  Stark 19/09/07
  25.   @13, real vision 09:39  |  peter VDH 19/09/07
  26.   After 37 years of being hijacked by zionists, the Church might do 09:45  |  John 19/09/07
  27.   Get used to this type of act 09:50  |  Nechama 19/09/07
  28.   Mossad Pay Attention! Very Important! 09:52  |  Yosemite 19/09/07
  29.   #8 Joep. Pretty decent? 10:00  |  manny.b 19/09/07
  30.   amusing 10:08  |  realism 19/09/07
  31.   "CHURCH Goer"? really the Pope quoted Islam as causing death & 10:56  |  PETER S.M. 19/09/07
  32.   apartheid buster 10:57  |  next 19/09/07
  33.   REALISM even more amusing.Did you read the article? 11:03  |  PETER S.M. 19/09/07
  34.   Israel is fighting the church`s fight here 11:03  |  Lilio 19/09/07
  35.   But how many Christian Palestinians are there? 11:04  |  Biko 19/09/07
  36.   The church will bring down Israeli segregation. Israel sweating 11:06  |  kanu 19/09/07
  37.   Interesting 11:11  |  Chris Linthwaite 19/09/07
  38.   People # 2 11:12  |  Philippe 19/09/07
  39.   Peter SM # 1 11:16  |  Philippe 19/09/07
  40.   RE Laws of inheritance 11:18  |  jackie 19/09/07
  41.   Jon # 4 11:19  |  Philippe 19/09/07
  42.   Karma Chameleon # 5 11:24  |  Philippe 19/09/07
  43.   Israel is on its way out of the family on nations 11:25  |  clair 19/09/07
  44.   And what about Israel`s suffering.. 11:26  |  Ilana 19/09/07
  45.   Joep # 8 11:28  |  Philippe 19/09/07
  46.   Sabeel & Bandar Michaels -- look at the agenda 11:37  |  Slibovitz 19/09/07
  47.   In 1927, 15% of Palestine was Christian 11:37  |  Elias Khoury Estipha 19/09/07
  48.   I hope Nederland becomes the first Muslim European State 11:47  |  Alan 19/09/07
  49.   What a joke 11:58  |  Moshavnik 19/09/07
  50.   VULNERABLE ISRAEL ALWAYS LOOKING FOR SUPPORT 11:58  |  Lakshmi 19/09/07
  51.   SABEEL IS THE POINT!!!!!!!! 11:59  |  Brant 19/09/07
  52.   #21 church goer objects to apartheid 12:02  |  victor hardman 19/09/07
  53.   liberty of religion 12:05  |  charles 19/09/07
  54.   #37 more from deluded chris who thinks islam is on his side ! 12:06  |  victor hardman 19/09/07
  55.   Yosemite, if we truly loves G-D we will loves the jews 12:10  |  FSS 19/09/07
  56.   Elias # 47 12:10  |  charles 19/09/07
  57.   Remember Israel has no respect for Christianity... check out this 12:14  |  Mark 19/09/07
  58.   ArabAmerican 12:15  |  Nephtaly 19/09/07
  59.   V.Hardman. Bet "church goer" isn`t a church goer 12:18  |  PETER S.M. 19/09/07
  60.   #21 churchgoer 12:22  |  matt 19/09/07
  61.   IN Britain Former Archbishop of Canterbury said he was "ashamed- 12:22  |  PETER S.M. 19/09/07
  62.   Dutch church: who cares? 12:26  |  Mark B. 19/09/07
  63.   LAKSHMI.India is very happy to partner with Israel 12:26  |  PETER S.M. 19/09/07
  64.   Slibovitz 12:27  |  Slobberalot 19/09/07
  65.   Dutch no longer on Israels side, very sad indeed ! 12:28  |  Aaron 19/09/07
  66.   #51 Brant 12:32  |  Chris Linthwaite 19/09/07
  67.   palestinian christians should denounce Hamas 12:32  |  FSS 19/09/07
  68.   #53 Charles 12:36  |  Chris Linthwaite 19/09/07
  69.   Fake Lakshmi Post 50! 12:40  |  lakshmi 19/09/07
  70.   "MARK" ARMED Arab thugs invaded the Church of Nativity 12:40  |  PETER S .M. 19/09/07
  71.   This is not about religion,it is about supporting the Liberation 12:41  |  lakshmi 19/09/07
  72.   WE CAN`T SUPPORT APARTHEID ANYMORE 12:50  |  Peter Wardenier 19/09/07
  73.   cut ties with Israel now 12:50  |  Arthur Seyss-Inquart 19/09/07
  74.   Ignorance of the Church and errors of Israel 12:50  |  Nephtaly 19/09/07
  75.   Vocal minority, Holland will remain Jewish friendly 12:56  |  Luka 19/09/07
  76.   CLINTHWAITE Time to take your own head out of the sand 12:59  |  PETER S.M. 19/09/07
  77.   The Dutch were very German friendly, too. Very much so indeed 13:11  |  Hollands licht 19/09/07
  78.   Chris Linthwaite 13:11  |  Nephtaly 19/09/07
  79.   Nephtaly on Ishmael and Isaac/Yaacob 13:12  |  Bandar Michaels 19/09/07
  80.   Peter of Amsterdam 13:13  |  Lynn 19/09/07
  81.   liberty of religion to # 68 13:16  |  charles 19/09/07
  82.