Subscribe to Print Edition | Tue., September 18, 2007 , | | Israel Time: 04:39 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Arts & Leisure Real Estate Jewish World National Advertising
Magazine Week's End Business Opinion Rosner's Domain Anglo File Books Travel
del.icio.us
Digg It!  new
Last update - 10:13 16/09/2007
Repay Gaza in kind
By Yehuda Ben Meir

The Israeli government's policy toward Gaza is fundamentally flawed. For some reason, it has not internalized the dramatic change in the status of the Gaza Strip since the August 2005 disengagement and the June 2007 Hamas military putsch and takeover of the territory. When I read that the government is consulting with the Israel Defense Forces' International Law Division about whether it is permissible to cut off electricity to Gaza - that is, to a hostile entity that has declared war on Israel - I don't know whether to laugh or cry. This could well serve as another example of the exaggerated role of the judiciary, which is taking over our lives and threatening to paralyze the ability of the government's branches to operate.

The basic solution to the Qassam plague is not to conquer Gaza. Neither does it lie in inventing brilliant technologies. The last thing the IDF needs is to turn into a police force controlling a million and a half Gazans. For every missile there is an anti-missile; and for every anti-missile, an anti-anti-missile will be invented. From the dawn of history, a defense has been found for every innovation in attack techniques, and a breach has been found in every defense. The answer for the Qassams is, and has always been, the proven and familiar response for countering any aggressive intent - that is, deterrence and a crushing response "in kind." This is the only response that has proven itself over the years."

Syria does not launch missiles against Israel - not because Bashar Assad is a disciple of Aaron, but because he fears Israel's response. Hassan Nasrallah does not use the thousands of missiles in Hezbollah's arsenal - not because he has pangs of conscience, but because he fears a similar response to the one he encountered last year, when he was compelled to apologize to his fellow countrymen and explain that he would not have abducted the two IDF soldiers had he known that Israel's response would be so severe. Today, there is no need to differentiate between Syria and Gaza, or between Hezbollah and Hamas.

Advertisement
The argument that Israel is prohibited from striking against civilian targets or assets in Gaza as a response to the wild aggression unleashed against it is a baseless fabrication. No country acts in this manner - not during World War II, not prior to it and not subsequent to it. Throughout the Cold War, the West's doctrine consisted of -mutually assured destruction' and this premise saved the free world from the brutal Soviet regime. President Kennedy threatened that if even one missile were fired from Cuba against any target in the Western hemisphere, the U.S. would strike at the Soviet Union with all the power at its disposal. And the intention was not to hit Soviet military bases, but cities like Moscow, Stalingrad and Leningrad. In the Kosovo war, the North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO) not the U.S. alone, but NATO, including the hypocritical countries in Western Europe attacked all of Serbia's civilian infrastructure for weeks, bombing embassies and killing hundreds of civilians, until Slobodan Milosevic was forced to surrender.

Israel is entitled not only to cut off Gaza's electricity, but also to hit every power plant in Gaza because the electricity is used to operate the lathes that produce the Qassam rockets. Israel is entitled to destroy all the bridges and roads in Gaza because they are used to transport the Qassams that are launched against Israeli citizens. And Israel is entitled to strike against the institutions and facilities of the Hamas government that stands behind the launching of Qassams. This is how any normal country would behave and this is how the State of Israel should also act until Khaled Meshal apologizes to the Palestinians and explains that he would not have allowed Islamic Jihad to launch Qassams at Sderot or Zikim if he had known that Israel would respond in this manner.


The writer is a senior research fellow at the Institute for National Security Studies in Tel Aviv.
Bookmark to del.icio.us
From Russina with love
Israel will cancel visa requirements for Russian tourists if Russia reciprocates.
The Sumatran hope
A pair of Sumatran tigers at Jerusalem's Biblical Zoo could be expecting an heir.
  1.   finally a sane article in this paper 09:31  |  joe 16/09/07
  2.   In Kennedy times there was no Stalingrad 10:06  |  dangor 16/09/07
  3.   when is olmert are and his cohorts going to go ? 10:49  |  victor hardman 16/09/07
  4.   Repay Who With What? 11:14  |  Maureen Ann 16/09/07
  5.   Follow Western precedents in war: no error 11:14  |  Jasmine Murphy 16/09/07
  6.   Don`t cut anything off, make good behaviour a condition 11:21  |  Allon 16/09/07
  7.   A strategy for losers 11:25  |  Natallie Durson 16/09/07
  8.   DON`T REPAY; TAKE BACK GAZA,PEACE AND SECURITY UPON ISRAEL))))) 12:16  |  VOICE of MOSHIACH))) 16/09/07
  9.   there are far less arabs in Gaza 12:27  |  yisraeli shfui 16/09/07
  10.   Repay Gaza in kind 12:46  |  khader herzallah 16/09/07
  11.   War ......... and peace JOE #1 13:03  |  Mary 16/09/07
  12.   Durson big talker Why did your country bomb Hiroshima??? 13:05  |  Mary 16/09/07
  13.   Sick logic 13:50  |  M 16/09/07
  14.   If It Is Jews, Who In The World Cares? 13:54  |  Yoram 16/09/07
  15.   Khader Herzallah 13:54  |  Jasmine Murphy 16/09/07
  16.   repay Gaza in kind 14:22  |  truth 16/09/07
  17.   Quassams 14:27  |  iletzter 16/09/07
  18.   jasmine Murphy whose ceasefire ? 14:29  |  Truth 16/09/07
  19.   so its criminal to fight against an occupation? 15:06  |  cristina 16/09/07
  20.   Yes! Natalie is RIGHT! 15:23  |  Avi (from Poland) 16/09/07
  21.   # 11 are you advocating a genocide in Gaza, dear Mary? 15:33  |  Kris 16/09/07
  22.   Its not about "occupation" 15:37  |  APS 16/09/07
  23.   Truth - unilateral ceasefire by Israel 15:38  |  Jasmine Murphy 16/09/07
  24.   # 2 dangor 16:05  |  Lynn 16/09/07
  25.   cristina on colonial racism 16:09  |  Lynn 16/09/07
  26.   Re Jasmine Murphy # 15 16:10  |  khader herzallah 16/09/07
  27.   THANK YOU!!! 16:17  |  EVEN 16/09/07
  28.   #19 where is cristina writing about ? 16:22  |  victor hardman 16/09/07
  29.   Very good article 16:38  |  KUTW 16/09/07
  30.   Natalie of LA LA LAND 16:41  |  GABE 1 16/09/07
  31.   Israeli lives, a human right 16:44  |  KUTW 16/09/07
  32.   Kris who sits in Austria 16:47  |  dear Mary 16/09/07
  33.   NATO bombings on the Serbians 16:48  |  KUTW 16/09/07
  34.   19. cristina: Israel is fighting against occupation 17:04  |  KUTW 16/09/07
  35.   Targetted assassinations 17:11  |  Nick Ferriman 16/09/07
  36.   Mr Ben Meir, Gaza is still a ghetto. 17:18  |  Occupation Magazine 16/09/07
  37.   please read your post again 17:28  |  Kris 16/09/07
  38.   Repay Gaza In Kind 17:44  |  Jim 16/09/07
  39.   Khader#10 - more marketing than fact 17:58  |  William 16/09/07
  40.   KUTW#32 - Chinese embassy bombing no accident 18:02  |  William 16/09/07
  41.   Gaza must be razed to rubble 18:03  |  Chaim Gorenstein 16/09/07
  42.   Khader, Truth et al - on truce 18:07  |  William 16/09/07
  43.   Sorry Nick, nothing illegal here #33 18:13  |  William 16/09/07
  44.   khader herzallah 18:13  |  Chaim Gorenstein 16/09/07
  45.   #33 more tears from nick numbers of jews murdered is too low 18:14  |  victor hardman 16/09/07
  46.   10. khader herzallah: Repay Gaza in kind 18:16  |  KUTW 16/09/07
  47.   10. khader herzallah: pals are not cats 18:19  |  KUTW 16/09/07
  48.   7. Natallie Durson: the losers 18:22  |  KUTW 16/09/07
  49.   khader herzallah # 26 18:28  |  ChanahS 16/09/07
  50.   Khader Herzallah 18:46  |  Jasmine Murphy 16/09/07
  51.   Insane, militaristic article 19:03  |  steve 16/09/07
  52.   Slow learners 19:35  |  Colin Wright 16/09/07
  53.   Message #19 of Christina 19:15  |  Yitzhak 16/09/07
  54.   Repay Gaza In Kind (Cont.) 19:35  |  Jim 16/09/07
  55.   repay gaza 19:37  |  mike 16/09/07
  56.   Repay Gaza in kind, Is the only way to resolve 19:51  |  Daniel 16/09/07
  57.   Very good article-please publish more like it 20:11  |  Daniel 16/09/07
  58.   40. William: Chinese embassy bombing 20:47  |  KUTW 16/09/07
  59.   51. steve: So Israel is occupying Lebanon!!! 20:52  |  KUTW 16/09/07
  60.   yoram 14 21:04  |  realism 16/09/07
  61.   victor hardman 45 21:12  |  realism 16/09/07
  62.   "entitled" "in kind" response- not enough 21:22  |  BenTemalion 16/09/07
  63.   NOT REPAY - PREVENT 21:33  |  Dr David I. Gross 16/09/07
  64.   Foolish article - Israel already a rogue state violating Intl law 21:33  |  Rick 16/09/07
  65.   Let the genocide begin, **BUT** remember 21:42  |  spyguy 16/09/07
  66.   Barrel of a Gun 22:01  |  Ezzie 16/09/07
  67.   64. Rick: terrorism according to Intl law? 22:07  |  KUTW 16/09/07
  68.   bentemalion 62 22:10  |  realism 16/09/07
  69.   64. Rick: attacks on civilians 22:13  |  KUTW 16/09/07
  70.   "in kind." 22:16  |  akiva P 16/09/07
  71.   65. spyguy: the genocide begun a long time ago by Pals 22:16  |  KUTW 16/09/07
  72.   #64 rick is back with more useless information 22:28  |  victor hardman 16/09/07
  73.   #61 realism is a misnomer for you ????? 22:33  |  victor hardman 16/09/07
  74.   #34 KUTW - absolutely irrelevant 22:37  |  Rick 16/09/07
  75.   #65 what is spyguy smoking ?? geno what?? 22:38  |  victor hardman 16/09/07
  76.   #60- When Has Israel Killed 20,000 Palestinians ? 22:53  |  Yoram 17/09/07
  77.   Absolutly Correct 22:55  |  Ron 16/09/07
  78.   Rick Garland 23:07  |  Israelit 16/09/07
  79.   #7 Nat Durson 23:09  |  Twogunz 16/09/07
  80.   Khader # 10 23:12  |  Twogunz 16/09/07
  81.   # 67 KUTW 23:26  |  nathan 16/09/07
  82.   #7 Natallie Durson 23:26  |  Nemesis