Subscribe to Print Edition | Mon., September 10, 2007 Elul 27, 5767 | | Israel Time: 06:28 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Arts & Leisure Real Estate Jewish World National Advertising
Magazine Week's End Business Opinion Rosner's Domain Anglo File Books Travel
del.icio.us
Digg It!  new
The only solution that will work
By Gideon Biger

Once again there is discussion of the idea of stabilizing the permanent borders of the State of Israel vis-a-vis a future Palestinian state by changing the cease-fire lines that marked the boundaries of Israel up until the Six-Day War, and adjusting them to the present demographic situation in the Land of Israel. The cease-fire lines were created as a result of agreements between Israel and the Kingdom of Transjordan [later Jordan] after the 1948 war. These agreements drew a line that included within it an Arab population in areas that were not captured by Israeli forces during the war. Included in these areas were the communities of Nahal Iron (Wadi Ara) and communities of lower Samaria, from Baka al-Garbiyeh to Kafr Qasem. Those areas were transferred to Israel without the residents who lived in them being asked their opinion on the matter, in order to ensure transportation and defense routes for Israel.

During the years until the Six-Day War, a situation was created in which a Muslim Arab population existed all along the cease-fire line, and only here and there were a few Jewish communities built along the line, including Mei-Ami, Metzar, Eyal and Yad Hannah, but the Jewish population in those areas was and remains sparse.

The 1967 War led to the de facto (but not de jure) cancellation of the cease-fire line, and during the past 40 years, Jewish settlement has become established east of this line. Today this population numbers about 240,000 people (excluding the Jewish settlers in the Greater Jerusalem area).

Advertisement
Over the past 20 years we have started to realize that the Israeli-Palestinian conflict will be resolved by the establishment of a Palestinian Arab state alongside Israel, to its east. The familiar slogan, "Two States for Two Nations," seems like a good idea, but it involves an inaccurate description of the situation.

If this formula is to be accepted, we are talking about establishment of a Palestinian state that will include no Jewish communities, and opposite it the State of Israel, where two nations will live - about 80 percent Jews and about 20 percent Palestinian Arabs. There is no national equality in this formula, and therefore in the past there have been proposals to set the boundary line between the Palestinian state and Israel in such a way that most of the Jewish communities located beyond the Green Line will remain part of Israel.

This idea requires the annexation of various areas to Israel, up to an area of about 200 square meters (an average between the maximum and minimum demands), with about 200,000 Jews living in them (excluding Greater Jerusalem). The Palestinian position, as presented in various discussions, both official (the Camp David and Taba talks) and unofficial (Geneva), conditions such an arrangement on the annexation of territories of the same size from Israel, within the Green Line.

The idea of "Two States for Two Peoples" is based on the principle that every nation deserves full sovereignty over the territory where its members live. The basis for dividing the world into nation states, especially in Europe and Asia, was based on this principle, and it lay behind the creation of the modern countries. Over 95 percent of the residents of Italy are Italians, who speak the language and share the same religious affiliation, and the population of Greece is Greek in its culture and customs. Estonia is populated by Estonians and Poland by Poles.

Drawing the borders did not create completely homogeneous states, and for economic, security and historical reasons, lines were occasionally drawn that did not include all the members of a nation on the same side of the border, so that national minorities were left on the other side of the line. These minorities, some of which continued and still continue to have ties with the mother country, do not exceed 10 percent to 15 percent of the inhabitants of the country and they tend over time to emigrate, or, alternately, to integrate into the local population.

This situation created considerable tension and a desire to annex various territories to the mother country. These tensions were solved in part by a population exchange between the countries (Turkey-Greece, India-Pakistan, Turkey-Bulgaria, Czechoslovakia-Germany), and occasionally by an exchange of territories. Sometimes the residents of these territories were asked their opinion (the Saar region between Germany and France) and sometimes it was done by agreement between the states without the inhabitants being asked (Italy-Austria, Hungary-Romania, Jordan-Saudi Arabia, Italy-France).

Apparently in the context of a full agreement between the State of Israel and the Palestinian state there will be no escaping a similar agreement, in which territories populated by Jews will be transferred from the jurisdiction of the Palestinian Authority to Israel, and at the same time territories populated by Arabs from Israel will be transferred to the sovereignty of the Palestinian state. These are territories that are now adjacent to the Green Line on both sides. About 200,000 Jews will live legally on about 200 square kilometers to be annexed to Israel, and at the same time about 200,000 Arab Muslims, who presently live on an area of about 200 square kilometers of Israeli territory, will live under Palestinian sovereignty. That will create a situation in which the Palestinian state will be Arab, and a non-Jewish population constituting about 14 percent of the total population will remain in Israel.

The Arab population along the strip from Sendela and Mukbeila in the north down to Kafr Qasem in the south, whose population is entirely Muslim (as opposed to the minorities in the Galilee, which include Christians, Circassians, Druze and others), will be able to maintain economic ties with Israel in accordance with peace agreements between Israel and the Palestinian state, and will immediately be able to fill any public-governmental and security role in the territory of the Palestinian state, something that it cannot do in the State of Israel.

It's true that there will be a temporary situation of financial and social loss on the Palestinian side, and mainly the loss of the right to free expression of opinions and to holding views opposed to those of the regime, but it's a situation that will change over time. The loyal integration of Arabs from the Land of Israel into Jordan following 1950 proves that.

This solution was raised in the past by politicians from the Labor Party (Raanan Cohen and Ephraim Sneh, although later on they dropped it), was given a scientific-ideological basis by this writer, and has been raised as a political-diplomatic idea by Avigdor Lieberman's party Yisrael Beiteinu.

Although today some people consider it a far-fetched solution, it is apparently the only platform that will guarantee, on the one hand, the establishment of an independent Palestinian state without a Jewish population, which will be reinforced by a wealthy, skilled and educated population that has learned to live in freedom in a modern democratic state; and on the other hand, will stabilize the State of Israel as the state of the Jewish people, in which Jews will constitute an absolute majority and there will be no questioning of the goals, activities and path of the state when it comes to its ties with the Jewish world and the Zionist idea.

The writer is a professor in the department of geography and human environment of Tel Aviv University.
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Stops in wine country
Summer is the right time to visit the wine routes that have developed in Israel recently.
Suits, not stories
Italy's uber-designer has come up with a soft, but not surprising, line for winter.
  1.   Just another article on ethnic cleansing 04:07  |  Marlene N. 07/09/07
  2.   To add to my previous post 04:11  |  Marlene N. 07/09/07
  3.   Marlene, Read the article again 06:15  |  Jason, Ph.D. 07/09/07
  4.   Marlene, only one state 10:01  |  Zvi 07/09/07
  5.   DIVORCE 10:19  |  Ron 07/09/07
  6.   MARLENE.Reverse ethnic cleansing silly.The land becomes Palestine 10:24  |  PETER S.M. 07/09/07
  7.   Good Idea which is ripe for abuse 10:37  |  Natallie Durson 07/09/07
  8.   More new ideas - an alternative solution 10:50  |  dana 07/09/07
  9.   The Greater Israel Project 11:00  |  Clickfool 07/09/07
  10.   good, there are five million Jews, and five million Palestinians 11:03  |  American 07/09/07
  11.   Can`t do it fifty years after the fact 11:06  |  MarkC 07/09/07
  12.   avoiding the only viable alternative 11:32  |  victor hardman 07/09/07
  13.   A fly in Biger`s ointment: 11:45  |  Danny 07/09/07
  14.   Give me your cand and suck your thumb 12:39  |  Bernhard 07/09/07
  15.   Mandate for Palestine and Occupation 12:46  |  Trust 07/09/07
  16.   Where idiots can become professors 12:55  |  Axel 07/09/07
  17.   Marlene is right-only one state of Palestine 12:56  |  Amin Nusseibeh 07/09/07
  18.   Marlene is right-only one state of Palestine 12:56  |  Amin Nusseibeh 07/09/07
  19.   #16 Axel 13:14  |  Response 07/09/07
  20.   18 really why bother posting that-nonsense 13:34  |  JON FEIGENBAUM 07/09/07
  21.   # 19 response 13:40  |  Axel 07/09/07
  22.   IF I WERE AN ARAB, THIS WOULD SOUND 13:49  |  indrajaya 07/09/07
  23.   #15 i hope trust that johnboy,toosofta, and others take note 13:51  |  victor hardman 07/09/07
  24.   To the "One-Staters" Give Up You`re Beat 13:56  |  Jane 07/09/07
  25.   Axel, #21 14:05  |  Response 07/09/07
  26.   Israeli Arabs Want To Stay That Way 14:16  |  dyinglikeflies 07/09/07
  27.   NO DEAL POSSIBLE! 14:43  |  Chuck 07/09/07
  28.   THERE will HAVE to be give and take on both sides 14:52  |  JON FEIGENBAUM 07/09/07
  29.   REWRITING HISTORY 15:05  |  abram 07/09/07
  30.   # 25 response 15:14  |  Axel 07/09/07
  31.   27 CHIUCk will happen 10 days from NEVER 15:15  |  JON FEIGENBAUM 07/09/07
  32.   # 24 jane 15:16  |  Axel 07/09/07
  33.   200 square meters for peace? 15:53  |  Jonathan S 07/09/07
  34.   "12 Hictor vardman 16:12  |  Labhras 07/09/07
  35.   The author has failed ideas but they can be modified 16:14  |  Ibrahim 07/09/07
  36.   JANE @ #24 VERY WELL SAID 16:19  |  GABE1 07/09/07
  37.   JON FEIGENBAUM #28 16:26  |  GABE1 07/09/07
  38.   It Must Have Been A Typo, Prof. Gideon Biger 16:29  |  Jeff Northridge 07/09/07
  39.   to response - to give you another example 16:31  |  Axel 07/09/07
  40.   To Axel From Germany- You Created Us 16:45  |  dyinglikeflies 07/09/07
  41.   Axel of Germany @16 16:59  |  GABE1 07/09/07
  42.   HAARETZ CENSORS 17:02  |  GABE! 07/09/07
  43.   Biger should bugger off 17:03  |  Tosefta 07/09/07
  44.   Chuck # 27 In That Case,... 17:10  |  Jeff Northridge 07/09/07
  45.   1.Marlene,well said,but there is another solution,not the 17:16  |  lakshmi 07/09/07
  46.   Sounds great, but the Israeli Arabs won`t compromise for peace 17:23  |  McQueen 07/09/07
  47.   Trust #15 17:33  |  Veritas 07/09/07
  48.   Response #19 17:38  |  Veritas 07/09/07
  49.   "15 Trust 18:07  |  Labhras 07/09/07
  50.   Bravo! 18:45  |  B 07/09/07
  51.   #13 18:53  |  B 07/09/07
  52.   #11 18:57  |  B 07/09/07
  53.   #14 18:59  |  B 07/09/07
  54.   Disarm the leftists 19:19  |  B 07/09/07
  55.   #15 Trust; D`Amato is ignorant of history 19:30  |  Tosefta 07/09/07
  56.   As an Israeli-Arab.... 19:34  |  Rami 07/09/07
  57.   #35 "Veritas" 19:41  |  Trust 07/09/07
  58.   @13, danny idiot it was done in74 in cypres 19:44  |  vladimir 07/09/07
  59.   @16, axel, believe me it is more difficult to get 19:49  |  vladimir 07/09/07
  60.   #37 Labhras 19:57  |  Trust 07/09/07
  61.   can be proposed but not imposed 20:07  |  roberto 07/09/07
  62.   Trust # 15 & Veritas # 35 The End Of The Mandate 20:19  |  Jeff Northridge 07/09/07
  63.   # 39 vladimir 20:29  |  Axel 07/09/07
  64.   Mr. Biger 20:30  |  Tareq 07/09/07
  65.   Bigger and Smaller. 20:43  |  zmogus 07/09/07
  66.   #10 - you forgot Jordan 20:45  |  Tim 07/09/07
  67.   vladimeer 20:51  |  Ibrahim 07/09/07
  68.   #15 Trust; D`Amato is ignorant of history 20:55  |  Tosefta 07/09/07
  69.   Transfer of Jews is mandatory 21:26  |  Scharker Yid 07/09/07
  70.   Trust #38 21:30  |  Veritas 07/09/07
  71.   Peace when 2 democratic states created 21:51  |  B`galil 07/09/07
  72.   "Veritas" #40 22:11  |  Trust 07/09/07
  73.   #40 labarse and veritas argue that black is white and we are nuts 22:17  |  victor hardman 07/09/07
  74.   the mandate 22:22  |  Gene Warech 07/09/07
  75.   40Veritas,I agree that armistice and ceasefire lines do not make 22:25  |  lakshmi 07/09/07
  76.   Chuck - #27 22:28  |  David Israel 07/09/07
  77.   Veritas # 40 Borders (part 1) 22:50  |  Jeff Northridge 07/09/07
  78.   To Marlene Newesri, #1 22:53  |  Jake 07/09/07
  79.   Why palestinians do not want idependence 22:56  |  Daniel 07/09/07
  80.