Subscribe to Print Edition | Wed., September 12, 2007 Elul 29, 5767 | | Israel Time: 16:28 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Arts & Leisure Real Estate Jewish World National Advertising
Magazine Week's End Business Opinion Rosner's Domain Anglo File Books Travel
A Beirut suburb damaged by IAF air strikes during the Second Lebanon War. (AP Archives)
del.icio.us
Digg It!  new
Last update - 16:21 06/09/2007
Rights group: IDF indiscriminately struck Lebanon civilians
By The Associated Press

In its harshest condemnation of Israel since the Second Lebanon War, Human Rights Watch charged that most of the Lebanese civilian casualties came from indiscriminate Israeli air strikes, according to a report to released Thursday.

Presenting the group's findings at a news conference, Human Rights Watch executive director Kenneth Roth said there were only rare cases of Hezbollah operating in civilian villages.

"To the contrary, once the war started, most Hezbollah military officials and even many political officials left the villages," he said. And indeed what we found is that most Hezbollah military activity was conducted from prepared positions outside Lebanese villages in the hills and valleys around."

Advertisement
Israel has said that it attacked civilian areas because Hezbollah set up rocket launchers in villages and towns.

More than 1,000 Lebanese were killed in the 34-day conflict last summer, which began after Hezbollah staged a cross-border raid, killing three Israel Defense Forces soldiers and capturing two others, Ehud Goldwasser and Eldad Regev. They are still being held.

Israel Air Force warplanes targeted Lebanese infrastructure, including bridges and Beirut Airport, and heavily damaged a neighborhood in Beirut known as a Hezbollah stronghold, as well as attacking Hezbollah centers in villages near the border. Hezbollah fired nearly 4,000 rockets at northern Israel, killing 44 civilians. In the fighting, 119 Israeli soldiers were killed.

Roth said a in the statement issued before the report's release that, "Israel wrongfully acted as if all civilians had heeded its warnings to evacuate southern Lebanon when it knew they had not, disregarding its continuing legal duty to distinguish between military targets and civilians."

He added, "Issuing warnings doesn't make indiscriminate attacks lawful."

Foreign Ministry spokesman Mark Regev rejected the report's findings. "Hezbollah adopted a deliberate strategy of shielding itself behind the civilian population and turning the civilians in Lebanon into a human shield," he said, charging that Hezbollah broke the first fundamental rule of war in that they deliberately exploited the civilian population of Lebanon as a human shield.

The full report was released at a news conference in Jerusalem on Thursday. Human Rights Watch had to cancel a similar news conference in Beirut last month because of threats of Hezbollah protests. That report accused Hezbollah of firing rockets indiscriminately at civilian areas in Israel.

Human Rights Watch said it investigated 94 cases of Israeli air, artillery and ground attacks to discern the circumstances surrounding the deaths of 510 civilians and 51 combatants, about half the death toll in Lebanon in the conflict.

The group said simple movement of vehicles or people, such as attempting to buy bread or moving around private homes, could trigger a deadly Israeli attack. The group charged that Israeli aircraft targeted vehicles carrying fleeing civilians.

Roth said that Hezbollah guerrillas did not wear uniforms, making it hard to pick them out from civilians, but that did not justify the Israeli military's failure to distinguish between them. He said the laws of war dictate if in doubt to treat the person as a civilian.

The report said the investigation refutes the argument made by Israeli officials that most of the Lebanese civilian casualties were due to Hezbollah routinely hiding among civilians. It said Hezbollah did at times fire rockets from, and store weapons in, populated areas and deploy its forces among the civilian population.

However, the human rights group said it found no evidence in these cases of separate legal violation of shielding, which is the deliberate use of civilians to render combatants immune from attack. Also, it said, Hezbollah conducted most of its activities and stored most of its weapons away from civilians.

Regev said there were countless documented examples of civilian facilities being used for military purposes - missiles in houses, mosques and schools used for storing weapons.

The report found that Hezbollah used hilltop UN positions for shelling Israel, which it said might be shielding, but said that required further investigation.
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Purring with humanity
A non-profit organization has set up a shelter housing some 700 cats in Latrun.
Bicycling Tel Aviv
Tel Aviv will soon join the list of cities that offer bicycle rentals at a nominal cost.
  1.   HRW 10:48  |  av 06/09/07
  2.   CAN`T MAKE THE SAME ACCUSATION VS HEZBOLLAH 10:56  |  Jay A Friedman 06/09/07
  3.   more proof 10:58  |  VIPER 06/09/07
  4.   WHY DON`T THEY JUST STOP TO REPORT 11:03  |  indrajaya 06/09/07
  5.   THESE REALLY CIVILIANS 11:05  |  Jay A Friedman 06/09/07
  6.   Duh ! 11:10  |  Natalliedurson@yahoo 06/09/07
  7.   We must not dismiss HRW findings, they are important 11:34  |  Shlomo from Tel-Aviv 06/09/07
  8.   HRW pretty much confirming media coverage outside Israel 11:35  |  Michael 06/09/07
  9.   about HRW 11:37  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 06/09/07
  10.   FAKE INDRAJAYA ALERT # 4 11:37  |  indrajaya 06/09/07
  11.   so soros sez 11:40  |  BenTemalion 06/09/07
  12.   To Jay A Friedman 11:43  |  Shlomo from Tel-Aviv 06/09/07
  13.   Natallie 11:47  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 06/09/07
  14.   HRW WHICH ONES WERE THE CIVILLIANS ? 11:49  |  PAUL HARRIS 06/09/07
  15.   What does deterrence mean? 11:55  |  JS 06/09/07
  16.   Right or wrong who cares? 11:57  |  Lebanese 06/09/07
  17.   HRW needs credibility first 12:16  |  B`galil 06/09/07
  18.   israel`s lawlessness& brutality were finally revealed to the 12:30  |  lakshmi 06/09/07
  19.   There are photos of destruction in Haifa 12:38  |  Lilly 06/09/07
  20.   HRW - a yellow report 12:52  |  Vernon Marriott 06/09/07
  21.   good morning Jay... 12:52  |  Sammy 06/09/07
  22.   un aided hizbullah 12:58  |  peter 06/09/07
  23.   Hesballa focused almost exclusively on Israeli civillian targets 13:05  |  PETER SM 06/09/07
  24.   7 Shlomo from Tel Aviv has it right 13:06  |  Michael 06/09/07
  25.   HUMAN RIGHTS OUTFIT 13:08  |  SKOOTLEMOUTH 06/09/07
  26.   simply murder.... 13:23  |  ravi 06/09/07
  27.   HRW DOESN`T HAVE A 3 YEAR OLD`S COMPREHENSION OF `INDISCRIMINATE" 13:23  |  Mitch Iginer 06/09/07
  28.   Margie in Tel Aviv. Not bunkers, it was the size of the bombs. 13:36  |  Michael 06/09/07
  29.   HRW - Go ahead 13:36  |  Imad 06/09/07
  30.   THEY INDISCRIMINATELY DESTROYED EGYPTIAN AIRFORCE IN 180 MINUTES 13:45  |  Atta Typpesh 06/09/07
  31.   #9 Margie in Tel Aviv stop lying! 13:47  |  Factfinder 06/09/07
  32.   #6 Natallie 13:57  |  Harald 06/09/07
  33.   19....absurdity has its limits... 13:57  |  ravi 06/09/07
  34.   Well, then they are even 14:00  |  Lynn 06/09/07
  35.   # 18 lakshmi and HRW 14:02  |  Lynn 06/09/07
  36.   #17 B`galil a reputed scholar and researcher 14:02  |  Factfinder 06/09/07
  37.   Israeli and IDF criminals will now be invited as resident scholar 14:03  |  El-Birawi 06/09/07
  38.   LAKSHMI.they were too frightened to present it in Lebanon 14:05  |  PETER SM 06/09/07
  39.   Human Rights Watch 14:11  |  JordanisPlaestine 06/09/07
  40.   IDF/IAF cowards have no moral standards... 14:12  |  Dutch Dirk 06/09/07
  41.   Instructions to Hezbollah 14:18  |  AL 06/09/07
  42.   No shit 14:26  |  Maral 06/09/07
  43.   its called war and lebanese started it! 14:28  |  Igor D. 06/09/07
  44.   a few more clusterbombs please 14:30  |  Igor D. 06/09/07
  45.   #19 Hmmm, no, I don`t think so Lilly 14:33  |  Johnboy 06/09/07
  46.   #17 B`galil needs to read first 14:36  |  Johnboy 06/09/07
  47.   #24 El-Birawi 14:37  |  Lynn 06/09/07
  48.   Factfinder of Jerusalem 14:41  |  Lynn 06/09/07
  49.   Av #1 14:41  |  jjvanka 06/09/07
  50.   Igor sputters nonsense 14:47  |  Maral 06/09/07
  51.   Discriminating terrorists who try to remain indicriminate 14:49  |  John 06/09/07
  52.   WHY did HRW cancel it s presentation in Beirut 14:49  |  PETER SM 06/09/07
  53.   #9 Margie in Tel Aviv 14:53  |  Johnboy 06/09/07
  54.   ROCKETS INTO ISREAL from Lebanon #16 15:08  |  JON FEIGENBAUM 06/09/07
  55.   Rights group do not see quassam rockets 15:10  |  Daniel 06/09/07
  56.   #23 Recognized by the UN? I rest my case 15:11  |  B`galil 06/09/07
  57.   # 2 Jay A Friedman 15:13  |  Saba 06/09/07
  58.   So What? 15:15  |  * BEN JABO 06/09/07
  59.   NUT allie Durson 15:24  |  * BEN JABO 06/09/07
  60.   #6 15:26  |  Moshe 06/09/07
  61.   VIPER WHO CONTROLES THE FORINE PRESS IN LEBANON 15:31  |  Gil 06/09/07
  62.   Hizbullah Islamofascists.. civilians ??? a joke 15:42  |  maurice 06/09/07
  63.   to lakshmi#18 15:45  |  Ilya 06/09/07
  64.   Johnboy re Margie 15:53  |  Maral 06/09/07
  65.   B`galil "pictures don`t lie" 15:56  |  Maral 06/09/07
  66.   AND WHAT HAPPENED IN BINT JBEIL???? 15:56  |  Alon Fisher 06/09/07
  67.   24El Birawi,israel should be brought to trial for war crimes in 15:58  |  lakshmi 06/09/07
  68.   22Lynn,1000 civilians dead in Lebanon,49 in israel,thousands made 16:02  |  lakshmi 06/09/07
  69.   25Peter SM,about the virgins,the 12 tribes of israel each brought 16:05  |  lakshmi 06/09/07
  70.   El Birawi 16:06  |  Danite 06/09/07
  71.   # 16 Lebanese and racism 16:08  |  Lynn 06/09/07
  72.   IDF kills innocent humans 16:09  |  Marz 06/09/07
  73.   google hrw 16:10  |  jon feigenbaum 06/09/07
  74.   SURE. WHILE HEZ READING THEM TALES OF MOTHER GOOSE! 16:11  |  Ambrose 06/09/07
  75.   To # 43 16:12  |  JordanisPalestine 06/09/07
  76.   RELATIVELY SPEAKING of course. 16:12  |  Murray of Montreal 06/09/07
  77.   Lebanese got what they deserved 16:19  |  alan 06/09/07
  78.   51: Lakshmi should be brought to trial 16:20  |  David Teich 06/09/07
  79.   laksmi: Nazrallah 16:23  |  Brad 06/09/07
  80.   10# INDRAJAYA YOU CANT BE IMPERSONATED 16:24