Subscribe to Print Edition | Mon., September 10, 2007 Elul 27, 5767 | | Israel Time: 12:01 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Arts & Leisure Real Estate Jewish World National Advertising
Magazine Week's End Business Opinion Rosner's Domain Anglo File Books Travel
del.icio.us
Digg It!  new
Last update - 09:46 06/09/2007
Taking Lieberman's advice
By Moshe Arens

Minister for Strategic Threats Avigdor Lieberman is finally making his weight felt around the cabinet table. The majority, including our new defense minister, it seems, is prepared to support his proposal of starving the population of Gaza into submission. This is not a case of the correct decision being taken after all other alternatives have been exhausted. It is rather a case of stubbornly rejecting the only effective means of keeping Sderot's children out of range of Qassam rockets, and reaching for the most nonsensical, inhumane and ineffective of all alternatives - collective punishment.

The prime minister has already publicly issued the orders to the IDF: go after every launcher and kill every terrorist involved in launching Qassam rockets. And the Qassams keep coming. Rockets against the children of Sderot is not acceptable to us, we will not remain indifferent to this outrage, he says - so what else is new? His rhetoric does not seem to make much of an impression on those in Gaza who launch Qassams to greet Sderot's children on the opening of the new school year.

There are no magic solutions and no one-shot solutions, he repeats interminably. In other words, the people in Sderot better get used to it.

Advertisement
In three years we will have a system which will intercept the Qassams in mid-air, the defense minister promises, so wait and see. Thick walls and reinforced concrete roofs will in time protect the citizens of Sderot in their homes, and their children in school, so have a little patience.

How are they going to get from home to school? Why not underground tunnels?

But the Qassams keep coming, and Islamic Jihad and Hamas are delivering stinging defeats day after day to the IDF. If Hezbollah could do it in Lebanon, why can't they do it in Sderot? And they are doing it.

Now using the terminology of market economics, the government thinks it has come up with the answer - we shall attach a price to every Qassam launched against Israel. We will cut off water and electricity to the population of Gaza until they understand that this must stop. In other words, once starved and thirsty, they will force the terrorists to stop launching Qassams.

It won't work. Collective punishment of civilian populations did not work in World War II, and it did not work when Vietnam was carpet-bombed, and it won't work in Gaza under a Hamas leadership. It won't last.

The international community will quickly mobilize help for the starving and the thirsty in Gaza. Water tankers will bring water from Egypt to Gaza, generators will be flown in from Europe, and Israel will be asked to contribute to this humanitarian cause. It is immoral, and not worthy of Israel, and the people of Israel will not stand for it.

The Qassam rockets are being launched from a distance of one to three kilometers from the wall surrounding the Gaza Strip. The only way to put a stop to this is for the IDF to enter Gaza to this depth, and put the Qassams out of range. There is no other way. Just as in the Second Lebanon War, the only way to stop the rocketing of Galilee was for IDF ground forces to reach the launching sites of the short-range rockets. Now the Olmert government, reinforced by the new defense minister, is repeating the same mistake they made then. Who cares about the Winograd report?

How long are we going to stay there after the IDF has put the Qassams out of range, ask the perennial doubters. The answer is simple - as long as the children of Sderot will need protection.
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Stops in wine country
Summer is the right time to visit the wine routes that have developed in Israel recently.
Suits, not stories
Italy's uber-designer has come up with a soft, but not surprising, line for winter.
  1.   wwhen the idf was in gaza qassams still came over 10:31  |  victor hardman 06/09/07
  2.   Arens is right. 10:54  |  S 06/09/07
  3.   Militants will always have a way to strike Israel 11:15  |  Natallie Durson 06/09/07
  4.   PUSH PALESTINAINS OUT OF RANGE 11:26  |  Moshe 06/09/07
  5.   How many years have they used the Kassams/Katushs?Why in 3 years? 11:53  |  Gull 06/09/07
  6.   Great.. until they make longer range rockets... 11:53  |  Allon 06/09/07
  7.   Arens is correct! 12:18  |  Dafna 06/09/07
  8.   Zionist aliens 12:24  |  Hannah 06/09/07
  9.   Only way to halt Qassams is to make them unnecessary 12:34  |  John 06/09/07
  10.   # 4 hey, moshe 13:14  |  Axel 06/09/07
  11.   MOSHE ARENS - LACK of KNOWLEDGE in HISTORY DEPARTMENT (VIETNAM) 13:26  |  Gil 06/09/07
  12.   #9 israel did that in gazaIT DIDNT WORK john 13:36  |  victor hardman 06/09/07
  13.   MOSHE ARENS ? Why 3 YEARS for a SYSTEM that ALREADY EXISTS 13:37  |  Gil 06/09/07
  14.   Agreed, except 13:52  |  Mark Lincoln 06/09/07
  15.   then what...? 13:55  |  ravi 06/09/07
  16.   Arens doesn`t go far enough 13:56  |  Lisa 06/09/07
  17.   John - No illegal Settlement or Settlements in Gaza 13:56  |  Gil 06/09/07
  18.   Hannah - Well Hannah I am at Home (#8) 14:05  |  Gil 06/09/07
  19.   Solution to Rocket Attacks 14:26  |  Brod 06/09/07
  20.   annex land for every rocket that lands 14:34  |  Igor D. 06/09/07
  21.   Britain didnt pay the electricity bills for Nazi Germany 14:44  |  Joe 06/09/07
  22.   Hiroshima DID work 14:49  |  James 06/09/07
  23.   hannah 14:58  |  alan 06/09/07
  24.   Hannah (#8) Sorry to tell you I am at home 15:08  |  Gil 06/09/07
  25.   MOSHE ARENS ? Why 3 YEARS for a SYSTEM that ALREADY EXISTS 15:09  |  Gil 06/09/07
  26.   MOSHE ARENS - LACK of KNOWLEDGE in HISTORY DEPARTMENT (VIETNAM) 15:10  |  Gil 06/09/07
  27.   #8 hannah extols "go back wher you came from" 15:14  |  victor hardman 06/09/07
  28.   Rhetoric and Wasted Time 16:05  |  Yoram 06/09/07
  29.   Collective punishment does work 16:08  |  Ofer 06/09/07
  30.   Awful logic on Raffah crossing (Jeff Northridge, yesterday) 16:24  |  Tosefta 06/09/07
  31.   About Hannah`s "Go Back Where You Came From" 16:27  |  Tony Anthony 06/09/07
  32.   The best way is a cease fire agreement 16:46  |  Tosefta 06/09/07
  33.   Depopulate as many miles as nessecery 16:52  |  TOMY 06/09/07
  34.   Lieberman`s Collective Punishment could backfire 17:48  |  Dutch 06/09/07
  35.   #17, Joe 18:15  |  Silvienne 06/09/07
  36.   To protect Sederot is very simple. 18:17  |  Ellen Rosser 06/09/07
  37.   As Hannah denies the national rights of the 18:20  |  Nicolas from Paris 06/09/07
  38.   Finally - a logical answer 18:22  |  Sabbasaul 06/09/07
  39.   I Have Been Saying/Writing THis Since Gaza WithDrawal! 18:23  |  Ben S 06/09/07
  40.   Hannah is Dana 18:27  |  Danite 06/09/07
  41.   Dutch 18:29  |  Danite 06/09/07
  42.   #27AS USUAL DORIS CONFUSES 18:36  |  PAUL HARRIS 06/09/07
  43.   25 - Offer 18:37  |  Nicolas from Paris 06/09/07
  44.   SIMPLE LOGIC FOR A CHILD:RETAKE GAZA SETTLE JEWS THERE, ANNEX IT! 18:38  |  VOICE of MOSHIACH))) 06/09/07
  45.   Disengagement 19:04  |  B 06/09/07
  46.   Put them out of range how? 19:10  |  B 06/09/07
  47.   Arens is wrong it worked in WW2 19:31  |  pace306 06/09/07
  48.   Russia stopped supplying Germany with bread on the first day of t 19:33  |  Gary 06/09/07
  49.   #17 Joe 19:44  |  Boycott 06/09/07
  50.   Would Hamas "rat out" Islamic Jihad to IDF?? 20:52  |  Voice of Reason 06/09/07
  51.   FIRST-let-HAARETZ TAKE ARENS`ADVICE 21:19  |  moshe brodetzky 06/09/07
  52.   # 32 Gary 21:29  |  Axel 06/09/07
  53.   @16, igor d. good idea 21:44  |  vladimir 06/09/07
  54.   ARAB HANNA 21:47  |  GABE1 06/09/07
  55.   It`s really quite simple 21:49  |  W 06/09/07
  56.   #21 Gil, Re Israel`s missile defense 23:37  |  Dutch 06/09/07
  57.   #43 DORIS THEY GOT OUT OF GAZA AND THE QASSAMS STILL KEEP COMING 23:59  |  PAUL HARRIS 06/09/07
  58.   Better to cut electricity 00:44  |  Ron 07/09/07
  59.   STARVE GAZA, LOSE AMERICAN JEWS 00:50  |  Arik Silverman 07/09/07
  60.   Halfway measures won`t work 01:05  |  Moshe 07/09/07
  61.   How long are we going ? 01:39  |  Dr. Ari Nir 07/09/07
  62.   To Dutch 04:19  |  YH 07/09/07
  63.   Gaza is Palestine or Egypt 04:38  |  Avrum 07/09/07
  64.   To 55 Arik 05:15  |  Ron 07/09/07
  65.   Mr Arens and pussyfooting.... 06:43  |  Mary 07/09/07
  66.   Whether or not it will work...do it anyway! 07:00  |  R Brock 07/09/07
  67.   GABE 1 07:12  |  Miriam 07/09/07
  68.   Mr Silverman and American Jews 07:50  |  Mar 07/09/07
  69.   Measures against Gaza 08:42  |  Isaac Haskiya 07/09/07
  70.   Hannah´s Palestine Lands. 08:53  |  Isaac Haskiya 07/09/07
  71.   taking Liebermans` advice 08:59  |  Martin List,M.D. 07/09/07
  72.   #59 arik and the most popular jews in the cemetery 09:04  |  victor hardman 07/09/07
  73.   Axel´s quotes on Gaza subject 09:12  |  Isaac Haskiya 07/09/07
  74.   DUCH (#56) - SORRY FOR SPOILING YOUR DREAM 11:35  |  Gil 07/09/07
  75.   Gil, A chronic problem requires more than a Bandaid 17:34  |  Dutch 07/09/07
  76.   Exactly like all begers. 20:56  |  Akram Zekaria 07/09/07
  77.   Akram Zekaria, Your comments fail to reflect the reality 03:40  |  Dutch 08/09/07
  78.   Akram Zekaria, Your comments fail to reflect the reality 03:45  |  Dutch 08/09/07
  79.   78# Those like Dutch made the Palestinians beggers. 06:36  |  Akram Zekaria 08/09/07
  80.   78# Dutch is one of them. 02:47  |  Akram Zekaria 10/09/07
 Today Online
Avraham Burg: Muslims as the Jews of the 21st Century
Responses: 22
Akiva Eldar: On Syria: Victory can't take place of accord
Responses: 7
<