Subscribe to Print Edition | Thu., September 06, 2007 Elul 23, 5767 | | Israel Time: 10:22 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Arts & Leisure Real Estate Jewish World National Advertising
Magazine Week's End Business Opinion Rosner's Domain Anglo File Books Travel
Bil'in residents celebrating the High Court of Justice's ruling Tuesday. (Tomer Appelbaum / BauBau)
del.icio.us
Digg It!  new
Last update - 21:34 04/09/2007
Court orders state to alter West Bank separation fence route at Bil'in
By Yuval Yoaz, Haaretz Correspondent, and news agencies

The High Court of Justice Tuesday ordered the state to redraw, partially dismantle and rebuild the route of a 1.7 kilometer section of the West Bank separation fence, which was built on land belonging to Bil'in, a Palestinian village which has become a focus of opposition to the barrier.

For nearly three years, the fence has been at the focus of weekly demonstrations at Bil'in, punctuated by violent confrontations between protesters and soldiers and police deployed at the site.

The existing fence route is built around a part of the Matitiyahu East neighborhood of Modi'in Illit settlement. The government had argued that the route was necessary to protect residents of Modi'in Illit, and completed the section of fence that cut through Bil'in despite the protests.

Advertisement
The three-judge panel, headed by Chief Justice Dorit Beinish, unanimously accepted an appeal petition by the head of the Bil'in local council against the route of the fence and its presence on land belonging to the village. They ordered defense planners to change the barrier's route so it causes less harm
to the village's residents

The fence occupies 260 dunams of village land. It also blocks access to another 1,700 dunams between the barrier and the pre-1967 Green Line border.

Residents of the village went to court arguing that the current route, built on village land, kept them from their fields and orchards, which remained on the other side of the barrier.

Rejecting the government's argument, Beinish wrote in her decision that "We were not convinced that it is necessary for security-military reasons to retain the current route that passes on Bil'in's lands."

The judges specified that this will require destroying the existing fence in certain places and building a new one, and ordered the government to come up with a new route in a reasonable period of time.

Abdullah Abu Rahma, one of the leaders of the weekly protest at Bil'in, called the court decision "wonderful."

"We want the decision to be implemented immediately," he said.

The Defense Ministry said in a statement that it would study the ruling and respect it.

Israel began building the 680-kilometer (425-mile) barrier along the West Bank in 2002, crediting the fence with contribuiting to a decline in suicide bombings. But the barrier juts into West Bank territory, provoking Palestinian claims that Israel is using security arguments to mask a land grab.
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Peace through soccer?
Hapoel TA will begin operating soccer schools in Nablus-area villages.
Trading potshots
Parents of a slain pilot were shocked to find their letters used by reporters.
  1.   Checks and balances 12:26  |  Yonatan 04/09/07
  2.   Where are the loathing responses? 12:37  |  Nobody 04/09/07
  3.   Peaceful protest OK 13:10  |  English Resident 04/09/07
  4.   But will the order be implemented? 13:21  |  David James Vickery 04/09/07
  5.   A REPLY TO #2 13:43  |  Brant 04/09/07
  6.   Israel, for those who have not it yet, is a society and a 14:08  |  Dafna 04/09/07
  7.   Will the Israeli Apartheid regime implement change though 14:22  |  Stephen Murray 04/09/07
  8.   Curruption at it`s fineist 14:24  |  Sam Weinstein 04/09/07
  9.   Suggestion 14:37  |  Gene 04/09/07
  10.   Sam, are you suggesting... 14:42  |  David James Vickery 04/09/07
  11.   Nobody #2 15:00  |  Somebody 04/09/07
  12.   #2 Nobody 15:08  |  Labhras 04/09/07
  13.   #6 dafna 15:17  |  Labhras 04/09/07
  14.   tiny bit of justice 15:21  |  by gum 04/09/07
  15.   a small ray of light...we hope 15:28  |  Josh Goldman 04/09/07
  16.   FAKE DEMOCRACY 15:41  |  indrajaya 04/09/07
  17.   more comedy from the left wing judges 15:46  |  victor hardman 04/09/07
  18.   Strange But A Start 15:47  |  Abe 04/09/07
  19.   THE APARTHEID WALL- to Dafna or is it Daft-a 15:55  |  sean semple 04/09/07
  20.   #8 Sam Weinstein 16:01  |  Labhras 04/09/07
  21.   An All powerful Supreme Court 16:05  |  Yoav Naor 04/09/07
  22.   NEVER WILL THERE BE A TERRORIST 16:07  |  THE PROPHET 04/09/07
  23.   To somebody 16:10  |  sean semple 04/09/07
  24.   dafna 16:12  |  realism 04/09/07
  25.   Labhras - Why do you dislike Jews? What have we done to you? 16:15  |  Dina 04/09/07
  26.   #4, #5 and #12 - Sadly the ruling will be stonewalled 16:16  |  Don Camillo 04/09/07
  27.   WOW! I am shocked and very much impressed 16:18  |  American 3 04/09/07
  28.   #16 - Indrajaya 16:19  |  Maurice 04/09/07
  29.   When we reclaim all Israel, the ghetto walls will go down forever 16:31  |  Chaim 04/09/07
  30.   Who runs Israel? 16:35  |  Clickfool 04/09/07
  31.   #17 Big-OT in Bed-fast shouting again. 16:38  |  Labhras 04/09/07
  32.   To Maurice - Montreal 16:42  |  indrajaya 04/09/07
  33.   Wall 16:53  |  Matthew 04/09/07
  34.   Ibrahim from Michigan, why have you changed your name to 16:53  |  Lilian 04/09/07
  35.   #25 Dina 17:02  |  Labhras 04/09/07
  36.   And damages... 17:05  |  Murray 04/09/07
  37.   It won`t be real until the military actually 17:06  |  spyguy 04/09/07
  38.   #25 Dina 17:08  |  Labhras 04/09/07
  39.   Putting it in perspective 17:12  |  Shlomo 04/09/07
  40.   #22 Prophet 17:19  |  Baal 04/09/07
  41.   #26 and Israeli Democracy 17:29  |  Polybios 04/09/07
  42.   #29 - Indrajaya 17:37  |  Maurice 04/09/07
  43.   #28 - Clickfool 17:42  |  Maurice 04/09/07
  44.   Biased and Stacked 17:46  |  Double Click 04/09/07
  45.   Licking the Butt of the Islamists 17:47  |  GZLives 04/09/07
  46.   #30 Lillian where do you live???. 17:47  |  Labhras 04/09/07
  47.   Labhras - You don`t need to tell us you have something against us 18:04  |  Dina 04/09/07
  48.   Israel´s real power center 18:18  |  Klas 04/09/07
  49.   #43 Maurice in Montreal, re Clickfool 18:46  |  Labhras 04/09/07
  50.   #45 - GZLives 18:49  |  Maurice 04/09/07
  51.   #26 Don Camillo quick question 18:54  |  Labhras 04/09/07
  52.   Sean No 23 19:05  |  somebody 04/09/07
  53.   #19 - sean 19:08  |  Maurice 04/09/07
  54.   The "supreme" court... 19:17  |  Jew 04/09/07
  55.   Sean from Ireland 19:19  |  somebody 04/09/07
  56.   Ah!! Sean Simple from Derry - watch your language 19:23  |  Bilin no more 04/09/07
  57.   no arguments, only accusations 19:28  |  Ben Sina 04/09/07
  58.   #47 Dina 19:29  |  Labhras 04/09/07
  59.   #49 - Labrhas 19:44  |  Maurice 04/09/07
  60.   To Labhras who is in Ireland 19:48  |  z 04/09/07
  61.   Ripped off and terrorized? 20:03  |  Zvi 04/09/07
  62.   #49 - Labhras (one more note for you) 20:04  |  Maurice 04/09/07
  63.   The high court is putting their nose where it doesn`t belong! 20:13  |  Avraham 04/09/07
  64.   Labrhas, if so many people here have noticed 20:24  |  Rani Kidron 04/09/07
  65.   Irish and other poison 20:50  |  Wade 04/09/07
  66.   #59 Maurice in Montreal 20:54  |  Labhras 04/09/07
  67.   Tzvi #61 21:05  |  Mary 04/09/07
  68.   #53 Maurice re sean post 19 21:11  |  Labhras 04/09/07
  69.   Ireland and equal education 21:13  |  Mozie 04/09/07
  70.   #60 ZZZZZZZ 21:23  |  Labhras 04/09/07
  71.   Like a dying scorpion Beinish takes revenge on Israel 21:48  |  Absolute Sweden 04/09/07
  72.   The wall 21:51  |  B 04/09/07
  73.   The PROPHET - Why was Israel lost again and again? 22:24  |  Wandering Jew 04/09/07
  74.   Ich bin ein Bili`iner 22:25  |  wibism 04/09/07
  75.   z 22:27  |  HuH?! 04/09/07
  76.   #66 Mozie 22:41  |  Labhras 04/09/07
  77.   Rani Kidron, on tormenting 23:14  |  Ibrahim 04/09/07
  78.   #63 AVRAHAM 23:25  |  Courcey 04/09/07
  79.   #76labarse and irish apartheid catholics and non catholics 23:32  |  victor hardman 04/09/07
  80.   #66 & 68 Labhras 23:52  |  Maurice 04/09/07
  81.   #64 Rani Kidron 00:02  |  Labhras 05/09/07
  82.   #66 - One last comment to you 00:03  |  Maurice 05/09/07
  83.   #79 - Victor Hardman 00:08  |  Maurice 05/09/07
  84.   #75 HuH? Good on you! 00:17  |  hala 05/09/07
  85.   Build anything and anywhere you like it,`s your own country 00:43  |  indrajaya 05/09/07
  86.   It`s a security barrier ,stupid 00:52  |  Steve Larrone 05/09/07
  87.   At last humane JUSTICE is prevail, 00:56  |  Harrisson 05/09/07
  88.   #80 ERIN GO BRAGH!, monsieur Maurice 00:59  |  hala 05/09/07
  89.   Security should come first. 01:34  |  Dr David I. Gross 05/09/07
  90.   bilin 03:31  |  tom 05/09/07
  91.   Good News! 03:31  |  steve dill 05/09/07
  92.   Reroute the whole barrier without taking our land 03:59  |  Elias Khoury 05/09/07
  93.   Labhras, Clickfool and Don Camillo 04:29  |  Robert 05/09/07
  94.   Indrajaya 04:42  |  Avrum 05/09/07
  95.   #76 labhr ass 04:59  |  No quarter 05/09/07
  96.   Meanwhile... IDF bulldozing of Palestinian homes continues... 05:28  |  Maureen Ann 05/09/07
  97.   west bANK fence 05:31  |  leah 05/09/07
  98.   LABRHAS ARROGANCE 05:41  |  Brant 05/09/07
  99.   #35, Labhras 05:49  |  Silvienne 05/09/07
  100.   #47, Labhras... 05:52  |  Silvienne 05/09/07
  101.   #13 05:54  |  JES 05/09/07
  102.   #63, Avraham... 05:55  |  Silvienne 05/09/07
  103.   $64, Rani Kidron to Labhras 05:59  |  Silvienne 05/09/07
  104.   #93, Robert 06:03  |  Silvienne 05/09/07
  105.   #95, "No quarter" 06:05  |  Silvienne 05/09/07
  106.   #80, Maurice to Labhras... 06:07  |  Silvienne 05/09/07
  107.   Clickfool #30 -- do you know of a single instance... 06:15  |  bbl 05/09/07
  108.   #8 Sam Weinstein 06:23  |  tad 05/09/07
  109.   #45 GZLives 06:26  |  tad 05/09/07
  110.   #89 Dr. Gross 06:29  |  tad 05/09/07
  111.   #91 Steve Gill 06:31  |  tad 05/09/07
  112.   BIL`IN`S LAND IS IN ARABIA, NOT IN ISRAEL!!! 07:04  |  Tony Neeman 05/09/07
  113.   PRETEND LIKE THE REST OF IT IS LEGAL 07:35  |  indrajaya 05/09/07
  114.   I am proud of our courts and our country! 08:13  |  Nurit 05/09/07
  115.   #106 bbl - an instance like, perhaps, this one? 09:16  |  Johnboy 05/09/07
  116.   For Victor Hardman, of Boxlotto Bingo fame # 79 09:49  |  Clickfool 05/09/07
  117.   Of course 09:51  |  Clickfool 05/09/07
  118.   Palestine land 1948-2007 10:23  |  Dav 05/09/07
  119.   So Called Democracy 11:54  |  Mark 05/09/07
  120.   Wonderful vision, leah 13:16  |  Murray 05/09/07
  121.   Silvienne 13:52  |  Robert 05/09/07
  122.   JOhnny boy - that is not an example of what I asked for 18:08  |  bbl 05/09/07
  123.   Alhamdulilah!! 18:41  |  Tom S 05/09/07
  124.   # 6 Labra in the number game?... 18:54  |  Misha 05/09/07
  125.   WEST BANK SEPARATION 19:21  |  RonH 05/09/07
  126.   #121, Robert, yes, you are right... 19:53  |  Silvienne 05/09/07
  127.   I Support the Fence But Not on Pal Land 00:41  |  Jane 06/09/07
  128.   #122 Ahhh, so we have to consider OBFUSCATION... 04:05  |  Johnboy 06/09/07
  129.   #127, Jane 04:23  |  Silvienne 06/09/07
  130.   tad - put brain in gear before engageing mouth/pen 04:25  |  Dr David I.. Gross 06/09/07
  131.   Silvienne 04:34  |  Dr David I. Gross 06/09/07
  132.   #122 bbl - perhaps this one as well.... 09:39  |  Johnboy 06/09/07
 Today Online
U.S. prof. who says Jews use Holocaust to curb critics resigns
Responses: 49
Yet again, a British royal fails to make his visit to Israel official
Responses: 26
Editorial: Cutting off Gaza utilities illegal, counterproductive
Send response
Arens: Only way to halt Qassams is to push them out of range
Send response
Amira Hass: Routine life at checkpoints evades Israeli media
Send response
Rosner's Domain
Blog: Young American Jews are alienated from Israel
* WTR: A safe haven in Iran for terrorists
* Blog: From Arkansas to Jerusalem
* Why you should never trust my predictions ever again (if you ever did)


More Headlines
04:23 Israel presents Hamas new offer on Shalit deal
05:12 Sources: IDF objects to Gaza op. because of tensions with Syria
09:30 U.S. prof. who says Jews abuse Holocaust to curb critics resigns
09:28 Pentagon: Israel has boosted its controls over defense exports
09:27 Yisrael Beiteinu platform: Land for peace deals destined to fail
09:37 UN cartographer to plot disputed Shaba Farms' border boundaries
04:11 Education Ministry split over transfer of NIS 50m to Arab communities
03:05 Family of Palestinian who died in jail claims medical negligence
02:41 Britain's Prince Edward arrives in Israel for first royal visit in over a decade
00:46 Israel defeats Serbia in preliminary round of EuroBasket 2007
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
Eldan Rent a Car
Israel's leading car rental company offers you a 20% discount on all online reservations
learn Hebrew online
Sign up for a trial lesson today with Israel's best teachers
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
Dead Sea Salt
Beauty and skin care from the Dead Sea. Coupon code HAARETZ for 10% off!
Hertz Special deals
don't miss Hertz fantastic deals for the "Tishrei" holidays
Israeli History Documentaries.
Own a piece of Israel?s treasured past.
Junkyard
Junk a car - get free towing nationwide and a tax-deductible receipt.
Holiday Inn and Crown Plaza Israel
Lowest internet rate Guaranteed at ichotelsgroup.com !
Home| TV| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved