PMO legal advisor: State can't blacklist 'draft-dodging' artists - Haaretz

Subscribe to Print Edition

Tue., September 04, 2007 Elul 21, 5767

Israel Time: 08:13 (EST+7)

web haaretz.com

Back to Homepage

Print Edition

Diplomacy

Defense

Arts & Leisure

Real Estate

Jewish World

National

Advertising

Magazine

Week's End

Business

Opinion

Rosner's Domain

Anglo File

Books

Travel

del.icio.us

Digg It! new

Last update - 22:46 03/09/2007

PMO legal advisor: State can't blacklist 'draft-dodging' artists

By Barak Ravid, Haaretz Correspondent

The state cannot prevent artists who did not serve in the army from performing in the celebrations marking Israel's 60th Independence Day next year, the Prime Minister's Office legal advisor said Monday.

At a meeting of the ministerial committee for the 60th Independence Day celebrations, Attorney Shlomit Barnea said that the state is legally banned from "blacklisting draft dodgers," and from overtly refusing to hire them.

Such a policy would be unconstitutional, as it would discriminate against these artists and breach the principle of equal opportunities in employment.

	Advertisement

Additionally, the law already stipulates penalties against draft dodgers, which cannot be enacted twice. Barnea also said that "there should be a distinction between the State of Israel and the IDF." Barnea said that the IDF's reaction is understandable, but the state cannot behave in the same way.

Barnea also said that it is impossible to pinpoint who is a "draft dodger" in legal terms. She said that the law defines a draft dodger exclusively as someone who publicly defies a call-up, or knowingly abuses extenuating articles of the law, like entering a false marriage in order to receive an exemption from military service.

Chief IDF Education Officer Brigadier General Eli Shermeister said during the meeting that the IDF is currently devising a master plan to deal with draft dodgers, which will be submitted to the panel shortly. "We won't attend events where draft dodgers perform," he said. "We know of artists who have actively avoided service, and we will not cooperate with them."

He also said that the IDF enables artists to do reserve duty "in line with their career, not necessarily in combat units." The IDF will "favor those who have served, but draft dodgers are banned and so are those who promote draft-dodging," Shermeister said.

Committee Chairman Ruhama Avraham said that "after the panel receives the IDF's official position, it will hold another meeting where a decision on the matter will be made."

During the meeting, the panel also voted on the logo of the 60th Independence Day celebrations. There were initially 100 different designs that were later short-listed to six frontrunners.

The following projects were also approved: an event in honor of volunteers; the construction of 60 playgrounds in development towns; and the production of a musical play recounting the country's history, with the participation of children from Sderot and Kiryat Shmona, which will tour Jewish communities worldwide.

Bookmark to del.icio.us


	Love the game
	Gym teachers want kids to enjoy being active in school physical education lessons.


	Grand masses
	The organizer of a classical music festival brings the masses to Mozart.




1.	"Legal" does not ="appropriate". The KKK is legal, too.	23:00	\|	Citizen	03/09/07

2.	Rabin Hugged A Draft Dodger	23:18	\|	Ben Israel	03/09/07

3.	Let the Market Rule	23:34	\|	MB	03/09/07

4.	Draft dodgers	00:17	\|	Mike	04/09/07

5.	draft dodging artists	00:21	\|	Edward	04/09/07

6.	JAIL	02:17	\|	NEIL GOLAN	04/09/07

7.	The left and the performing arts	03:21	\|	Connie	04/09/07

8.	Shame on me - I`m a Beast	04:31	\|	Avi	04/09/07

Today Online


	Sderot parents to boycott schools over Qassam fire
	Responses: 398


	Editorial: In any peace move, Israel must first evacuate the outposts
	Responses: 178


	Jailed Fatah leader Barghouti slams Hamas' 'bloody coup'
	Responses: 179


	PM: Unclear if accord can be reached with Abbas by summit
	Responses: 120


	Haaretz.com TV: The old-new Jewish trend sweeping Manhattan
	Responses: 22

Rosner's Domain

* Rosner's Mailbox: "AIPAC supported the Iraq policy"

* WTR: Blaming Israel for global warming

* Guest: Author of Sex, God, Christmas & Jews

* Reform leader to Muslim Americans: Fight opportunists who demonize you

More Headlines
03:42 PM: Israel won't remain quiet in face of Qassams


08:10 Defense Min. sitting on plan to lift W. Bank roadblocks for a year


07:23 AG: State will back gays' rights to property even if Knesset won't


07:24 Mofaz warns PM not to make 'irreversible concessions' to PA


08:03 Povery report will show that 1.6 million Israelis live in poverty


07:11 IDF chief okays comprehensive upgrade program for the military


06:30 Gov't: Company restoring Holocaust victims' property must pay for survivors' welfare


06:44 UN: Gaza students lack textbooks due to border crossing closures


05:30 EU foreign policy chief, Jordanian FM discuss Mideast peace moves


23:47 Germany concerned by plans to urge aliyah among its Russian Jews