Subscribe to Print Edition | Wed., September 05, 2007 Elul 22, 5767 | | Israel Time: 20:29 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Arts & Leisure Real Estate Jewish World National Advertising
Magazine Week's End Business Opinion Rosner's Domain Anglo File Books Travel
del.icio.us
Digg It!  new
Last update - 09:58 03/09/2007
First, evacuate the outposts
By Haaretz Editorial

Israeli leaders frequently cast doubt on the ability of Palestinian Authority Chairman Mahmoud Abbas to implement any diplomatic agreement, due to his political weakness. But Israel also has a long-standing commitment - to evacuate illegal outposts in the West Bank - that it has evaded carrying out for years, each time on a different pretext. The upcoming peace conference in Washington provides an appropriate moment to put an end to this foot-dragging over the outposts and to prove that the Israeli government, headed by Ehud Olmert, is capable of fulfilling its obligations. A swift evacuation of outposts also would signal to both the United States and Saudi Arabia, which Olmert is hoping to draw into the diplomatic process, that Israel is serious, and is not just talking.

Yesterday, the ministerial committee on implementing Talia Sasson's report on the illegal outposts, which is chaired by Vice Premier Haim Ramon, met for the first time in about two years. The results were predictable. The ministers heard a report on the growth of the outposts, in defiance of the promises that each of the last two premiers made to the White House. Ramon asked the relevant professionals to propose new rules on planning and building in the settlements and to explain various gaps and contradictions in the data on the number of outposts. Minister Avigdor Lieberman utilized the discussion to remind his supporters that he represents the right wing in this government. And Defense Minister Ehud Barak, who is responsible for evacuating the outposts, thus far has been prolonging the issue through discussions with the settlers on a voluntary evacuation - which, based on past experience, seem unlikely to produce results.

Olmert's predecessor Ariel Sharon promised the American administration that he would evacuate every outpost established during his term as prime minister. But the administration stopped pressuring Israel after the disengagement from the Gaza Strip, and the settlers have interpreted this as a license to continue expanding the outposts. The Sasson Report, which proposed a comprehensive policy for dealing with construction over the Green Line, was never implemented. Olmert began his term by destroying nine houses in the outpost of Amona, but was frightened by the violent pictures that evacuation produced. Since then, he has preferred to play for time. Now, the issue has arisen once again, due to a Peace Now petition to the High Court of Justice demanding the evacuation of Migron, built on private Palestinian land. The state put the court off with repeated postponements, but now it must submit an appropriate response. Meanwhile, U.S. President George Bush reiterated that Israel must evacuate the outposts, in his July 16 speech on the Middle East.

Advertisement
The very existence of the outposts, as well as their continued growth, call the government's ability to carry out its diplomatic commitments into question. The prime minister's attempts to reach an agreement of principles with Abbas will look like a sorry joke if Olmert does not want - or is not able - to evacuate so much as a single outpost. Olmert's view is that after the agreement of principles is reached, it should be implemented gradually, in keeping with the stages of the road map peace plan. Yet even the road map obligates Israel to evacuate the outposts during the very first stage. Why should Israeli citizens, or the international community, take the prime minister's diplomatic moves seriously as long as Olmert evades implementing even the very first step?
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Torah and broadcasting
A Ch. 1 reporter has placed a Torah scroll in the Israel Broadcasting Authority building.
New Year cycle
Want to get fit? Cycling offers exercise for everyone, regardless of size or shape.
  1.   DON`T MAKE A WRONG MOVE, PLEASE 10:08  |  indrajaya 03/09/07
  2.   Yes, and the sooner the better 10:11  |  Silvienne 03/09/07
  3.   How to repeat the failure of Oslo... 10:17  |  Giles Martin 03/09/07
  4.   HAARETZ JOKE OF THE YEAR!! 10:19  |  PAUL HARRIS 03/09/07
  5.   ...continued... 10:20  |  Giles Martin 03/09/07
  6.   MAKING ANY LAND JEW EXCLUDED IS NO BETTER THAN HITLER ?? 10:23  |  Bill 03/09/07
  7.   NO WAY 10:25  |  indrajaya 03/09/07
  8.   ALL settlements are illegal! 10:58  |  lakshmi 03/09/07
  9.   It won`t work 11:07  |  Walter 03/09/07
  10.   And then, "Haaretz"? What has Gaza evacuation brought? 11:08  |  Absolute Sweden 03/09/07
  11.   Palestinian behaviour and negotiating position 11:15  |  Sam 03/09/07
  12.   Don`t evacuate the posts..keep them..because 11:15  |  KA 03/09/07
  13.   First, stop the Qassams 11:53  |  Burned Liberal 03/09/07
  14.   reality 12:11  |  chaim 03/09/07
  15.   ENOUGH WITH ABBAS/HAMAS:RETAKE GAZA,W.BANK,BUILD CITIES,PEACE)))) 12:19  |  VOICE of MOSHIACH))) 03/09/07
  16.   An IDF refusal to evacuate settlements and a Gov`t policy to 12:19  |  Joseph E . 03/09/07
  17.   @2 whom did they ppromise and under what terms silvienne 12:29  |  victor hardman 03/09/07
  18.   Israel should not evacuate even one caravan until 12:33  |  Judith, Haifa 03/09/07
  19.   Only a boycott will produce results 12:38  |  Danny 03/09/07
  20.   #3GILES DOESNT KNOW ABOUT EQUITY 12:38  |  PAUL HARRIS 03/09/07
  21.   KA 12:42  |  Sam 03/09/07
  22.   #17 They promised the AMERICANS, victor 13:14  |  Johnboy 03/09/07
  23.   To dismanttle Dome of the Rock instead of outposts 13:24  |  Joseph E . 03/09/07
  24.   #22 and the treaty was signed where johnboy 13:27  |  victor hardman 03/09/07
  25.   Evacuate Sderot and Haifa first ! 13:55  |  Alberto Cohen 03/09/07
  26.   You`re right, victor hardman 13:58  |  Murray 03/09/07
  27.   Silvienne 14:04  |  Miriam 03/09/07
  28.   Sorry ! evacuating ONLY the outpost nt good enough 2 reach PEACE 14:04  |  Alberto Cohen 03/09/07
  29.   Fair & doable plan for painless end to the Israeli "occupation": 14:13  |  Uzi 03/09/07
  30.   Why Doesnt ISrael EVer Ask Why Abbas ALWAYS condemns Every Israel 14:14  |  ME 03/09/07
  31.   #24 Yes, I see it now Victor 14:15  |  Johnboy 03/09/07
  32.   on miriam to silvienne 14:20  |  Axel 03/09/07
  33.   Reminder: Haaretz is an enemy of Israel 14:22  |  John Ryan 03/09/07
  34.   KA 12 & Sam 21,the one state idea has been put forward since the 14:45  |  lakshmi 03/09/07
  35.   The FIRST STEP 14:47  |  Natasha 03/09/07
  36.   a picture of Johnboy at home 14:55  |  a camera 03/09/07
  37.   Axel on Miriam 14:57  |  Israeli 03/09/07
  38.   Evacuating Outposts? 14:57  |  Dagma 03/09/07
  39.   Silvienne 15:01  |  Israeli 03/09/07
  40.   Lakshmi- Surprise! The world doesn`t march to your tune! 15:02  |  Sam 03/09/07
  41.   #31johnboy and the impossible dream 15:03  |  victor hardman 03/09/07
  42.   Axel from Germany 15:21  |  Miriam 03/09/07
  43.   #26 ademocracy changes governments and policies murray 15:23  |  victor hardman 03/09/07
  44.   #34lackschmoe and legal / which court are they to be heard in ? 15:35  |  victor hardman 03/09/07
  45.   # 38 dagma 15:47  |  Axel 03/09/07
  46.   Intelligence of Jew-Free Gaza Model 15:52  |  B 03/09/07
  47.   Israel itself is illgal, it will have to go 15:53  |  KM 03/09/07
  48.   40Sam,sorry,but your one liner is no argument;my post did not say 15:59  |  lakshmi 03/09/07
  49.   To Paul H.....re: #4 16:01  |  Who 03/09/07
  50.   Evacuate them right after the "peace conference" 16:09  |  Tosefta 03/09/07
  51.   Lakshmi-I`m not impressed by resolutions and other dictates 16:13  |  Sam 03/09/07
  52.   Just what are you arguing, victor hardman #43 16:16  |  Murray 03/09/07
  53.   Olmert`s Logic 16:17  |  Jo Jo 03/09/07
  54.   Why Tosefta? 16:21  |  Mark Lincoln 03/09/07
  55.   To be or not to be..... 16:26  |  Esther 03/09/07
  56.   47. KM is illgal, it will have to go 16:30  |  KUTW 03/09/07
  57.   One-state solution 16:32  |  W 03/09/07
  58.   nonsense bult on nonsense 16:33  |  peter 03/09/07
  59.   Evacuating Outposts? NO! 16:36  |  Dolly 03/09/07
  60.   "government is not a complete smartut (rag) of the settlers" 16:39  |  Sam 03/09/07
  61.   For JoJo #53 16:42  |  Esther 03/09/07
  62.   KM you are illiterate. You`ll have to go 16:48  |  Authority 03/09/07
  63.   They do insist (Mark Lincoln #54) 16:48  |  Tosefta 03/09/07
  64.   To Axel # 45 - Law Enforcement.....? 16:49  |  Dagma 03/09/07
  65.   During War Winston Churchill said:WARS are NOT Won by EVACUATIONS 17:01  |  Linda Rivera 03/09/07
  66.   "Peace" Agreements Bring Suffering & WAR to Israel 17:02  |  Linda Rivera 03/09/07
  67.   To Tosefta # 50 - The Road Map 17:06  |  Dagma 03/09/07
  68.   Peace between Israelis and Palestinians is essential for world pe 17:07  |  Objective observer 03/09/07
  69.   evacuate Tel Aviv 17:15  |  Amin Nusseibeh 03/09/07
  70.   Israel its own enemy 17:18  |  truth 03/09/07
  71.   evacuation of outposts would become more of a reality... 17:19  |  Smadar 03/09/07
  72.   44Victor hardman,this is the judgment of the well known 17:23  |  lakshmi 03/09/07
  73.   #57 W`s one-state 17:23  |  peter 03/09/07
  74.   51Sam,you have not answered my question:do you have the knowledge 17:25  |  lakshmi 03/09/07
  75.   To DOLLY # 59 Evacuating Outposts 17:26  |  Missknowall 03/09/07
  76.   Dagma-Law Enforcement 17:28  |  Ray 03/09/07
  77.   60Sam,although you don`t seem to understand the political concept 17:31  |  lakshmi 03/09/07
  78.   Haaretz won`t be Happy til Tel Aviv is SURROUNDED by ARAB Armies 17:32  |  Linda Rivera 03/09/07
  79.   Silvienne: Even Exchange? 17:35  |  CHGODMK 03/09/07
  80.   illegal outposts...? 17:36  |  ravi 03/09/07
  81.   Rivera#74 17:47  |  Ray 03/09/07
  82.   So confused (Dagma #67) 17:53  |  Tosefta 03/09/07
  83.   #43 Big-OT in Bed-fast 17:54  |  Labhras 03/09/07
  84.   To Tosefta # 53 17:55  |  Dolly 03/09/07
  85.   Lakshmi-you jump from one issue to another making little sense 18:00  |  Sam 03/09/07
  86.   KAPOS WILL GET KILLED 18:01  |  Kadur KAHANISTI 03/09/07
  87.   #69 Amin Nusseibeh - long time no hear my friend 18:01  |  Smadar 03/09/07
  88.   Why is Everybody so keen to have those Outposts removed? 18:06  |  Sandy 03/09/07
  89.   #44 Victor hardhead not in Belfast 18:07  |  Labhras 03/09/07
  90.   Judea and Samaria are Israeli Territories. Israel is sovereign. 18:08  |  AV 03/09/07
  91.   SAFTEY FIRST 18:13  |  Dr. David I. Gross 03/09/07
  92.   Dolly-shoot Rockets 18:17  |  Ray 03/09/07
  93.   To Ray # 76 - Ray-Law Enforcxement 18:17  |  Dagma 03/09/07
  94.   What the soldiers should do 18:25  |  KUTW 03/09/07
  95.   To Ray # 76 - Ray-Law-Enforcement [2] 18:30  |  Dagma 03/09/07
  96.   First 18:30  |  Ralph 03/09/07
  97.   #84 Dolly 18:31  |  Labhras 03/09/07
  98.   Why remove the "illegal" outposts (Dolly #84) 18:32  |  Tosefta 03/09/07
  99.   An idea 18:33  |  KUTW 03/09/07
  100.   To Kadur KAHANISTI # 86 - Arabs must pay! 18:55  |  Dolly 03/09/07
  101.   85Sam,it is obvious you don`t have the knowledge or background in 19:04  |  lakshmi 03/09/07
  102.   First, evacuate D. Rubinstein 19:13  |  Arnold Flick 03/09/07
  103.   # 97 Labra, nothing is free in this world.... 19:27  |  Misha 03/09/07
  104.   all settlements are outposts 19:27  |  kevin 03/09/07
  105.   No Reason Why Jews Should Leave W.Bank 19:40  |  S.Tayput 03/09/07
  106.   DAgma 19:41  |  Ray 03/09/07
  107.   #102 Arnold Flick 19:43  |  Labhras 03/09/07
  108.   Good article 19:45  |  tadchase 03/09/07
  109.   Johnboy on Resolution 181 19:46  |  Tosefta 03/09/07
  110.   Tosefta - `watch what we do, not what we say." 19:55  |  Mark Lincoln 03/09/07
  111.   #90 AV 19:55  |  Labhras 03/09/07
  112.   To Tosefta # 82 - So Confused Tosefta better read up 19:59  |  Dagma 03/09/07
  113.   Oy vey, Dagma #112 20:14  |  Tosefta 03/09/07
  114.   Esther #55 and # 61 20:15  |  Jo Jo 03/09/07
  115.   To Dr. David L. Gross # 91 ARABS HAVE TO ACCEPT THEIR RESPONSIB 20:20  |  Dagma 03/09/07
  116.   "Windy" Indy 20:21  |  Art Calick 03/09/07
  117.   Being a dummy cuts both ways (Mark Lincoln #110) 20:22  |  Tosefta 03/09/07
  118.   a weak bush 20:37  |  michael 03/09/07
  119.   No, FIRST EVACUATE THE REFUGEE "CAMPS" 20:43  |  Shifra 03/09/07
  120.   87Smadar,some reflections on your post to Amin Nussbeih,1.your 20:51  |  lakshmi 03/09/07
  121.   To Labhras # 97 Hyprocracy or Arrogance 21:05  |  Dolly 03/09/07
  122.   Lakshmi- "agreed upon..... at end of WW1" 21:33  |  Sam 03/09/07
  123.   Waitangi solution ( PART 1) 21:47  |  A Kiwi Observer 03/09/07
  124.   #121 Dolly 21:50  |  Labhras 03/09/07
  125.   #120 lakshmi - 2nd post Re: Amin Nussbeih & your thoughts 21:56  |  Smadar 03/09/07
  126.   Waitangi solution ( PART 2) 21:58  |  A Kiwi Observer 03/09/07
  127.   Labhras 111 to AV 22:12  |  alan 03/09/07
  128.   #89 labarse the brass is so droll today 22:17  |  victor hardman 03/09/07
  129.   Negociating the Haaretz way 22:30  |  Frank 03/09/07
  130.   Backwards logic on sequence. Caravans do not equal shooting. 22:57  |  Dr. L. Brnd 03/09/07
  131.   26 Outposts in the West Bank to be evacuated 23:00  |  Dagma 03/09/07
  132.   122Sam,so you do know something about the history of the idea of 23:03  |  lakshmi 03/09/07
  133.   124Smadar,good for you that returned with copies of Reuven! but 23:09  |  lakshmi 03/09/07
  134.   TO DOLLY:ARABS TO PAY FOR ONLY 100 YEARS! 23:11  |  Kadur Kahanisti 03/09/07
  135.   Is there again a precision problem here? (Lakshmi #48 re Sam) 23:12  |  Tosefta 03/09/07
  136.   real peace 23:17  |  citizen zero 03/09/07
  137.   Churchill`s wisdom for Slowman 23:51  |  Editor 03/09/07
  138.   Typical left-wing, stupid thinking from Haaretz 00:49  |  Steven A. 04/09/07
  139.   #10 Sweden - evacuation of Gaza was nothing 00:51  |  Don Camillo 04/09/07
  140.   Dagma 00:59  |  Dr David I. Gross 04/09/07
  141.   Smadar, you are not the problem 01:06  |  Amin Nusseibeh 04/09/07
  142.   Most TB posters opt for Israel`s destruction 01:10  |  spyguy 04/09/07
  143.   Settlements must be expanded, not evacuated 01:43  |  Moshe 04/09/07
  144.   #6, Bill 02:18  |  Hannah 04/09/07
  145.   #130 Amin Nusseibeh - wow! isn`t it late for you in U.K.? 02:25  |  Smadar 04/09/07
  146.   #131, Spyguy 02:34  |  Hannah 04/09/07
  147.   # 128 D/Camillio - already second anti-Semite trying Yiddish 02:41  |  17 04/09/07
  148.   Name one positive results of hundreds of Israeli "peace moves"! 03:14  |  Chaim 04/09/07
  149.   #109 No, Tosefta, I don`t think so 03:35  |  Johnboy 04/09/07
  150.   Is there again a precision problem here? (Lakshmi #48 re Sam) 03:35  |  Tosefta 04/09/07
  151.   evacuation 03:36  |  Im Pacted Colon 04/09/07
  152.   #98 Just to point out something to you, Tosefta... 03:46  |  Johnboy 04/09/07
  153.   Amin 03:49  |  Avi 04/09/07
  154.   Tosefta - what Baker had to lose 03:49  |  Mark Lincoln 04/09/07
  155.   Again, NO on 181, and a comment (Johnboy #133, 136) 04:31  |  Tosefta 04/09/07
  156.   Re 1 fake indrajaya post 05:00  |  Alan the real one 04/09/07
  157.   #133 False Hannah Alert 05:23  |  Hannah 04/09/07
  158.   Haaretz editors live in never-never land 05:36  |  Jorge 04/09/07
  159.   #109 Tosefta, further to my post #136 05:45  |  Johnboy 04/09/07
  160.   #17, Victor in Belfast 06:19  |  Silvienne 04/09/07
  161.   Thanks for the ref (Johnboy #148) 06:21  |  Tosefta 04/09/07
  162.   Lakshmi knows... 06:29  |  Nathan Rai 04/09/07
  163.   absolute Sweden- look at Gaza again 06:30  |  truth 04/09/07
  164.   FAKE HANNAH (aka Ms Kohn) ALERT! #146 06:33  |  Hannah 04/09/07
  165.   Lakshmi - You are really precious... 06:36  |  Nathan Rai 04/09/07
  166.   #32, Axel.. 06:37  |  Silvienne 04/09/07
  167.   Moshe and settlements 06:38  |  truth 04/09/07
  168.   chaim and hubris 06:41  |  truth 04/09/07
  169.   #42, Bad Luck Miriam!!! 06:43  |  Silvienne 04/09/07
  170.   #139 - Enlightenment requested 06:45  |  Nathan Rai 04/09/07
  171.   #148 Johnboy Mandate 06:46  |  D`Amato 04/09/07
  172.   #133 is our Hannah, not False 06:46  |  Hannah 04/09/07
  173.   Hannah 06:52  |  Bill 04/09/07
  174.   #160, Bill 07:08  |  Hannah 04/09/07
  175.   Johnboy 07:09  |  Reid 04/09/07
  176.   Hey! Haaretz, where`s my post? 07:09  |  PADDY 04/09/07
  177.   #156 The Truth about Moshe 07:18  |  Nathan Rai 04/09/07
  178.   #163 You need to read the comments, my friend 07:23  |  Johnboy 04/09/07
  179.   #160 - Truth - Truely true 07:27  |  Nathan Rai 04/09/07
  180.   #152 then strictly prove it by treaty silvienne 07:49  |  victor hardman 04/09/07
  181.   BELFAST BOY - VICTOR 07:56  |  PADDY 04/09/07
  182.   Don Camillo - Gaza Evacuation `Nothing` 07:58  |  Reid 04/09/07
  183.   #170 Johnboy 08:08  |  D`Amato 04/09/07
  184.   Spyguy - on Israel`s Destruction 08:08  |  Reid 04/09/07
  185.   WANTED: Israelis willing to protest `OUTPOSTS` . No Education Req 08:11  |  Pavel 04/09/07
  186.   #173, Bill 09:02  |  Hannah 04/09/07
  187.   To Kadur Kahanisti # 134 - Arab . 09:07  |  Dagma 04/09/07
  188.   To Pavel # 185 - 26 Illegal Outposts to be evacuated 09:16  |  Dagma 04/09/07
  189.   Now that Israelis are Evacuating Outposts in the West Bank 09:45  |  Dolly 04/09/07
  190.   Crazy Hannah 09:49  |  Hannah 04/09/07
  191.   Full retreat to the 1967 lines is the precondition to peace 10:11  |  Ivar 04/09/07
  192.   #183 Yes, he did 10:22  |  Johnboy 04/09/07
  193.   Oslo over all else, including democracy? 14:14  |  Cha 04/09/07
  194.   #189 Dolly is touchingly naive... 16:35  |  Johnboy 04/09/07
  195.   To spyguy # 142 16:55  |  Dagma 04/09/07
  196.   #194, Johnboy 17:38  |  Silvienne 04/09/07
  197.   PalestinianSympathy is on the wane...... 18:35  |  Dogma 04/09/07
  198.   To Johnboy # 194 Outposts CLEARLY being evacuated 18:51  |  Dolly 04/09/07
  199.   #180, Victor Hardman 20:13  |  Silvienne 04/09/07
  200.   #195, Dagma 20:19  |  Silvienne 04/09/07
  201.   To Ivar # 191 The Saudi Plan 21:28  |  Missknowall 04/09/07
  202.   #196 Not quite Silvienne 10:26  |  Johnboy 05/09/07
  203.   #202, Johnboy... 19:19  |  Silvienne 05/09/07
 Today Online
Israel to naturalize several hundred Darfur refugees
Responses: 186
PMO: Gov't preparing plan to cut off services to Gaza
Responses: 235
Justice Min. retreats on move to bar gays from inheritance law
Responses: 102
Shmuel Rosner: JFK, Marilyn, and predicting pro-Israel sympathies
Responses: 18


More Headlines
20:12 PMO: Gov't preparing plan to cut off services to Gaza
19:15 Red Cross says Hamas may allow it to visit abducted IDF soldier Gilad Shalit
17:56 High Court: Controversial settlement neighborhood to remain in place
18:41 Britain's Prince Edward arrives in Israel for first royal visit in over a decade
19:50 Lebanon seeks German aid in arming, training army to fight militants
20:00 Israel to grant citizenship to hundreds of Darfur refugees
10:37 Three IDF soldiers hurt, one moderately, in Nablus operation
14:28 Mofaz bars Islamic Movement head from road safety campaign
17:03 Arab League chief: Mideast summit shouldn't favor Israel
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
Eldan Rent a Car
Israel's leading car rental company offers you a 20% discount on all online reservations
learn Hebrew online
Sign up for a trial lesson today with Israel's best teachers
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
Dead Sea Salt
Beauty and skin care from the Dead Sea. Coupon code HAARETZ for 10% off!
Hertz Special deals
don't miss Hertz fantastic deals for the "Tishrei" holidays
Israeli History Documentaries.
Own a piece of Israel?s treasured past.
Junkyard
Junk a car - get free towing nationwide and a tax-deductible receipt.
Holiday Inn and Crown Plaza Israel
Lowest internet rate Guaranteed at ichotelsgroup.com !
Home| TV| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved