Subscribe to Print Edition | Wed., September 05, 2007 Elul 22, 5767 | | Israel Time: 04:38 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Arts & Leisure Real Estate Jewish World National Advertising
Magazine Week's End Business Opinion Rosner's Domain Anglo File Books Travel
del.icio.us
Digg It!  new
Last update - 10:17 02/09/2007
Children of war
By Gideon Levy

Again children. Five children killed in Gaza in eight days. The public indifference to their killing - the last three, for example, were accorded only a short item on the margins of page 11 in Yedioth Ahronoth, a sickening matter in itself - cannot blur the fact that the IDF is waging a war against children. A year ago, a fifth of those killed in the "Summer Rain" operation in Gaza were children; during the past two weeks, they comprised a quarter of the 21 killed. If, heaven forbid, children are hurt in Sderot, we will have to remember this before we begin raising hell.

The IDF explains that the Palestinians make a practice of sending children to collect the Qassam launchers. However, in this case, the children killed were not collecting launchers. The first two were killed while collecting carob fruit and the next three - according to the IDF's own investigation - were playing tag. But even if we accept the IDF's claim that there is a general trend of sending children to collect launchers (which has not been proven), that should have brought about an immediate halt to firing at launcher collectors.

But the IDF does not care whether its victims are liable to be children. The fact is that it shoots at figures it considers suspicious, with full knowledge - according to its own contention - that they are liable to be children. Therefore, an IDF that fires at launcher collectors is an army that kills children, without any intention of preventing this. This then is not a series of unfortunate mistakes, as it is being portrayed, but rather reflects the army's contempt for the lives of Palestinian children and its terrifying indifference to their fate.

Advertisement
A society that holds ethical considerations in high regard would at least ask itself: Is it permissible to shoot at anyone who is approaching the launchers, even if we know that some of these people may be small children, lacking in judgment, and thus not punishable? Or are we lifting all restraints on our war operations? Even if we accept the IDF's claims that its sophisticated vision devices do not enable them to distinguish between a 10-year-old boy and an adult, the IDF cannot evade its responsibility for this criminal action. Even if we assumed a completely distorted assumption that anyone who goes near the launchers is subject to death, the fact that children are involved should have changed the rules. Add to this the fact that the firing at launcher collectors has halted the Qassams, or even reduce their number, and you arrive at another chilling conclusion: The IDF shoots at children to wreak vengeance and punish.

No child in Sderot is more secure as a result of this killing. On the contrary.

Anyone who takes an honest look at the progression of events during the past two months will discover that the Qassams have a context: They are almost always fired after an IDF assassination operation, and there have been many of these. The question of who started it is not a childish question in this context. The IDF has returned to liquidations, and in a big way. And in their wake there has been an increase in Qassam firings.

That is the truth, and they are hiding it from us. When Gabi Ashkenazi and Ehud Barak assumed their positions, the reins were loosened. If Barak were a representative of the political right, perhaps a public outcry would have already been sounded against the IDF's wild actions in Gaza. But everything is permitted to Barak, and even the fact that the victims are children does not matter - not to him and not to the Israeli public.

Yes, the children of Gaza gather around the Qassams. It is practically the only diversion they have in their lives. It is their amusement park. Those who arrogantly preach to their parents "to watch over them" have never visited Beit Hanoun. There is nothing there, except for the filthy alleys and meager homes. Even if it is true that those launching the Qassams are taking advantage of these miserable children (which has yet to be proven), this should not shape our moral portrait. Yes, it is permissible to exercise restraint and caution. Yes, it is not always necessary to respond, especially when the response ends up killing children.

The way to stop the firing of Qassams is not through indiscriminate killing. Every launcher can be replaced. The start of the school year bodes ill, for us and for them. Anyone who truly seeks to stop the firing of Qassams should reach a cease-fire agreement with the current government in Gaza. That is the only way and it is possible. The liquidations, the shelling and the killing of children will work in exactly the opposite direction of what is intended. In the meantime, look what is happening to us and to our army.
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Torah and broadcasting
A Ch. 1 reporter has placed a Torah scroll in the Israel Broadcasting Authority building.
New Year cycle
Want to get fit? Cycling offers exercise for everyone, regardless of size or shape.
  1.   Life is going on 10:55  |  Ibrahim Shvonce 02/09/07
  2.   Human Rights Watch Blames The Terrorists For A Change 10:56  |  Yishai Kohen 02/09/07
  3.   The life is going on 10:57  |  Ibrahim Shvonce 02/09/07
  4.   CHILD KILLER 11:11  |  indrajaya 02/09/07
  5.   ISRAEL BEGIN TO ENJOY "LOLITAS" 11:13  |  indrajaya 02/09/07
  6.   Earth to Gideon Levy! We are at war. 11:22  |  David Stoler. 02/09/07
  7.   An excellent article... 11:22  |  Silvienne 02/09/07
  8.   Thank you, Mr. Levy... 11:45  |  Richard Silverstein 02/09/07
  9.   Silvienne 11:48  |  Gina 02/09/07
  10.   Children of war 12:02  |  Joe 02/09/07
  11.   Hello, there is a war going on! 12:13  |  Paul Henzen 02/09/07
  12.   Gideon Levy is one of the most fanatic anti-Israel columnists. 12:14  |  Ken Jurist 02/09/07
  13.   Children of War 12:21  |  Sue 02/09/07
  14.   Israels policy of Collective Punishment 12:22  |  Natallie Durson 02/09/07
  15.   Hamas built exhibition celebrating Sbarros massacre. 12:25  |  Dave Kelso 02/09/07
  16.   Praise 12:37  |  Angelo Tito Anselmi 02/09/07
  17.   Rocket launchers are murder weapons, not "diversions" 12:46  |  Briton 02/09/07
  18.   Mr.Levy is right and wrong 12:57  |  Shlomo from Tel-Aviv 02/09/07
  19.   Children of terror 13:01  |  Gabe 02/09/07
  20.   Tiresome 13:03  |  fred 02/09/07
  21.   #2 - Why should Haaretz care? 13:04  |  Mahona 02/09/07
  22.   What do you expect, Gideon? 13:04  |  Danny 02/09/07
  23.   israel is like an old man eating tiger that once it has tasted 13:24  |  lakshmi 02/09/07
  24.   killing children 13:37  |  hipolito dormal 02/09/07
  25.   IDF Army of Shame 13:40  |  El-Bireh 02/09/07
  26.   To #9 Shlomo from Tel Aviv 13:42  |  hipolito dormal 02/09/07
  27.   why blame the idf... 13:46  |  ravi 02/09/07
  28.   # 10 Gabe 14:00  |  Nick Ferriman 02/09/07
  29.   Sometimes it`s hard to be analytical, 14:09  |  Rowan Berkeley 02/09/07
  30.   Children?? These kids are being trained to kill Jews 14:10  |  SLAVO 02/09/07
  31.   #8, Gina 14:11  |  Silvienne 02/09/07
  32.   #10, Briton 14:13  |  Silvienne 02/09/07
  33.   #21 ferriman can you give the ratio for iraq? 14:15  |  victor hardman 02/09/07
  34.   Gideon Levy 14:22  |  Sam 02/09/07
  35.   Mr. Levi 14:24  |  Dr. Allan 02/09/07
  36.   Gina 14:25  |  Leah 02/09/07
  37.   #23, SLAVO, bravo you clown 14:31  |  VIPER 02/09/07
  38.   #23, Slavo 14:34  |  Silvienne 02/09/07
  39.   Israel`s fractured society 14:34  |  Chris Linthwaite 02/09/07
  40.   11Shlomo from Tel Aviv,shows typical israeli cunning! 14:38  |  lakshmi 02/09/07
  41.   Mr. Levy....... 14:41  |  Marlene N. 02/09/07
  42.   To Gideon Levy 14:58  |  Steven 02/09/07
  43.   The answer is really simple Silvienne No. 23 15:15  |  Marlene N. 02/09/07
  44.   LEVY ommits Pal.children routinely sent out to confront the IDF 15:17  |  PETER SM 02/09/07
  45.   Killing Machines 15:18  |  Walid 02/09/07
  46.   Levy and hollow moral outrage 15:29  |  peter 02/09/07
  47.   Silvienne #30 15:34  |  Check the Facts 02/09/07
  48.   Mr Levi. 15:35  |  Mary 02/09/07
  49.   Marlene free pass for the arabist apologist 15:35  |  peter 02/09/07
  50.   Translation error 15:40  |  Mark Marshall 02/09/07
  51.   CHILD martyrs& brainwashing for Jihad is a staple of Pal. media, 15:42  |  PETER SM 02/09/07
  52.   Arabs have been murdering Israeli children for generations 15:46  |  PETER S .M. 02/09/07
  53.   #35-boo hoo freaking hoo viper 15:47  |  peter 02/09/07
  54.   To all you maliscious Israel bashers 15:49  |  ChanahS 02/09/07
  55.   #45-Walid swings and misses again 15:53  |  peter 02/09/07
  56.   Gideon Levy is correct, a cease-fire will stop the Qassams 15:54  |  Smadar 02/09/07
  57.   Pal society 15:59  |  Nerys 02/09/07
  58.   To no 6 David Stoler 16:02  |  jp 02/09/07
  59.   MARLENE N worried about refugees?You should be livid about Darfur 16:03  |  PETER.SM 02/09/07
  60.   TIME TO LIST ISRAEL AS A TERRORIST STATE AGAIN 16:13  |  Dutch 02/09/07
  61.   #54 Smadar wants another cease-fire 16:23  |  peter 02/09/07
  62.   Wait for it.... 16:24  |  nathan 02/09/07
  63.   BANKRUPT ISLAMIC SOCIETY 16:32  |  JON FEIGENBAUM 02/09/07
  64.   Gideon, You` re right the IDF deliberately targets Palestinians 16:42  |  Dutch 02/09/07
  65.   NICK FERRIMAN 28 16:43  |  JON FEIGENBAUM 02/09/07
  66.   Walid #45 You have a skewed sense of reality! 16:44  |  Jacques 02/09/07
  67.   Palestinian Children 16:48  |  Aram 02/09/07
  68.   More Leftist idiocies and cowardice 16:48  |  Frank 02/09/07
  69.   30 billion 16:53  |  Jacob 02/09/07
  70.   Hamas fired rockets which killed their own kids 16:56  |  Lynn 02/09/07
  71.   43 MARLENE /EXCUSRE US, for more not getting killed 16:57  |  JON FEIGENBAUM 02/09/07
  72.   #63 Aram 17:05  |  Check the Facts 02/09/07
  73.   Cease fire to include the West Bank 17:09  |  Tosefta 02/09/07
  74.   #60 Dutch 17:10  |  Steven 02/09/07
  75.   The disgusting use of children by the Islamists 17:11  |  J.J. Doring 02/09/07
  76.   The Arabs seem to thrive on murder 17:17  |  US CITIZEN 02/09/07
  77.   Children ???? 17:18  |  John Klekota 02/09/07
  78.   As Always, Blame the Jew 17:20  |  J of Hollywood 02/09/07
  79.   ISRAELIS AND PEDOPHILIA 17:27  |  indrajaya 02/09/07
  80.   The"not care" comment. 17:27  |  De 02/09/07
  81.   To Natalie Durson 17:34  |  Richard 02/09/07