In face of criticism, PR campaign to explain Israel's refugee policy - Haaretz

Subscribe to Print Edition

Fri., August 31, 2007 Elul 17, 5767

Israel Time: 00:17 (EST+7)

web haaretz.com

Back to Homepage

Print Edition

Diplomacy

Defense

Arts & Leisure

Real Estate

Jewish World

National

Advertising

Magazine

Week's End

Business

Opinion

Rosner's Domain

Anglo File

Books

Sports

del.icio.us

Digg It! new

Last update - 13:09 30/08/2007

In face of criticism, PR campaign to explain Israel's refugee policy

By Barak Ravid and Nurit Wurgraft, Haaretz Correspondents

The Foreign Ministry has launched a campaign to justify Israel's policy on refugees from Darfur who entered Israel but were deported to Egypt.

A great deal of international criticism has been leveled at Israel, mainly by American Jewish organizations, for its treatment of asylum-seekers in general and Darfurians in particular.

The campaign includes disseminating a dossier already sent to Israeli embassies worldwide, meetings with Jewish and American leaders and media campaigns.

	Advertisement

One defense of Israeli policy contained in the dossier reads, "Al-Qaida's presence in Sudan means that Israel must be aware that terror operatives might try to infiltrate with the refugees."

Jewish organizations are the leading proponents in the United States of the international campaign to aid Darfur refugees, and have exerted public leverage to promote legislation on the matter. They harshly criticized Israel for its "return upon arrival" policy, whereby refugees are sent to Egypt immediately when caught.

Israel last week deported 50 Africans, mostly from Darfur, to Egypt for the first time.

Israeli diplomats have been instructed to clarify that "the infiltrators are being sent back to Egypt in collaboration with UN refugee agencies and the Egyptian authorities, pending guarantees that they will not be sent back to Sudan."

The diplomats also highlight that Israel does a good deal for the refugees and has even agreed to absorb 500 of them. "Given Israel's size and limited resources, it has taken significant measures," the dossier says. "Israel is well aware of its responsibility as a sovereign state, but we cannot address this complex issue on our own."

Israeli diplomats repeat the message that the majority of Africans crossing into Israel are migrant workers, but only a handful of them are actually from Sudan. They were also instructed to explain that Israel is not bordering Sudan and the countries have no diplomatic ties, and are hence officially in a state of war.

"Those who try to enter Israel depart from sovereign Egypt, thus the original reason for their dislocation no longer exists," the dossier says. "Therefore, Egypt, as a signatory of the International Refugee Convention, is responsible for their wellbeing."

UN: Darfurians deported to Egypt won't be returned to Sudan
The 48 infiltrators whom Israel sent back to Egypt about 10 days ago will not be returned to Sudan, the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR) told the Foreign Ministry in Jerusalem.

A Foreign Ministry official said UN officials had met with most of the infiltrators in a detention camp in Cairo, but that they had not yet been accorded refugee status.

The Foreign Ministry continues to work with the UN and Egypt to ensure that its treatment of infiltrators is legal, the official said. He added that Israel was also looking into having other countries take in the refugees.

Meanwhile, volunteers from Physicians for Human Rights (PHR) yesterday visited the Sudanese refugees staying at the Be'er Sheva soldier's hostel. "One woman is to undergo surgery tomorrow at Soroka Hospital, and it is unclear who will take care of her when she comes back," PHR chairman Dr. Danny Filc said. "It's absurd that the army holds them there, but doesn't send a doctor," he added.

More Jewish World news and features

Bookmark to del.icio.us


	Young Stalin
	A new book on the tyrant's early years is compelling, but doesn't offer anything new.


	Deconstructing Harry
	Is two teens' project translating books to Hebrew a nice hobby, or copyright infringment?




1.	There is really very little to explain: Most of the people	09:46	\|	Ruti	30/08/07

2.	Israel is doing a good job - where is everyone else	09:55	\|	Claire	30/08/07

3.	Selection	10:37	\|	Esther	30/08/07

4.	Another PR disaster	12:08	\|	David Olesker	30/08/07

5.	Note to Israel: Go light on the PR effort	12:08	\|	Natallie Durson	30/08/07

6.	What PR...what a joke	12:36	\|	Fussion	30/08/07

7.	israel and public relations	13:04	\|	scanadu	30/08/07

8.	Durson cold cold heart	13:34	\|	Margie in Tel Aviv	30/08/07

9.	Ms. Durson, as a non-Jew, I thought your interest in Israel was	14:21	\|	Ruti	30/08/07

10.	refugees	14:35	\|	rose	30/08/07

11.	Israel should pool with other states	14:51	\|	DrO	30/08/07

12.	Natalie!	15:49	\|	truth seeker	30/08/07

13.	#5 Natalie Durson	16:18	\|	Fussion	30/08/07

14.	11: DrO, the Boat People were neither	16:36	\|	David Teich	30/08/07

15.	# 12 Truth Seeker	16:45	\|	Natallie Durson	30/08/07

16.	Only in Israel (and OLMERT must go!)	17:26	\|	Polybios	30/08/07

17.	Israel is not obligated AT ALL	17:45	\|	Kevin	30/08/07

18.	Always the same blunders	19:45	\|	Alan	30/08/07

19.	Darfur Refugees	23:31	\|	CSB	31/08/07

Today Online


	Bradley Burston: Let the settlers stay where they are
	Responses: 220


	IDF: Three children killed in Gaza Tuesday were just playing tag
	Responses: 317


	Egyptian Actors' Union to probe movie star working with Israeli
	Responses: 111


	Rosner/Benn: Olmert and Abbas are talking. But who's listening?
	Responses: 13


	Editorial: Israel must not behave like a terrorist organization
	Responses: 119


	Danny Rubinstein: Palestinian public holds extreme views despite talk of peace
	Responses: 78

Rosner's Domain

* Reform leader to Muslim Americans: Fight opportunists who demonize you

* Blog & poll: Olmert and Abbas talking. Are you listening?

* WTR: Why was Freehold Township filming a rabbi?

* How can Jewish state reject refugees, refuse to recognize a genocide?

More Headlines
22:56 20 people wounded as Hamas violently disperses Fatah protest in Gaza


23:17 Reform Jewish leader urges U.S. Muslims to condemn violence


22:30 Rescuers retrieve bodies of two missing sailors in the Haifa bay


20:51 Angela Merkel named recipient of highest German Jewry honor


21:00 Two people hurt as ultralight aircraft crashes in Ein Vered


23:01 Interior Minister accused of preventing converts from immigrating to Israel


19:39 IDF seriously wounds Fatah militant in Nablus; three rockets hit Negev


20:20 Italian court extends Heftsiba CEO Boaz Yona's remand by 10 days


17:09 21-year-old killed, his two brothers hurt in brawl at Nazareth store