Subscribe to Print Edition | Sun., September 09, 2007 Elul 26, 5767 | | Israel Time: 17:19 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Arts & Leisure Real Estate Jewish World National Advertising
Magazine Week's End Business Opinion Rosner's Domain Anglo File Books Travel
del.icio.us
Digg It!  new
Last update - 08:25 29/08/2007
Rabbinate forces Arab farmers to sell land to non-Jews for sabbatical year
By Yair Ettinger, Haaretz Correspondent

The beginning of the Jewish sabbatical year is just two weeks away, but the kashrut certification bureaucrats are breaking new records for the absurd: Kashrut supervisors from the Chief Rabbinate are forcing Israeli Arabs to sign a document that gives the Israel Lands Administration and the Chief Rabbinate the right to sell the land to a non-Jew as a condition for continued kosher certification for their produce. If they refuse to sign, they were told that the wholesalers to whom they sell their goods will also lose their kashrut certification.

The loss of the certificate would mean that the farmers and wholesalers would be unable to sell their produce in Jewish towns and stores.

MK Ahmed Tibi (Ra'am-Ta'al) called on Arab farmers not to sign the forms, saying that it was an illegal demand.

Advertisement
Distributors in the wholesale fruit and vegetable market at Tzrifin have recently received the documents they were requested to distribute to every farmer they buy from. The form gives the ILA and the Chief Rabbinate, or their agents, power of attorney to sell the land on which they grow produce to non-Jews during the sabbatical year, which occurs every seven years according to Jewish law and during which the land is required to lie fallow, and which begins on Rosh Hashanah in two weeks.

The document is the legal basis for symbolicly selling the land to a non-Jew for the year-long period, known as "Heiter Mechira." This sale is a legal fiction that allows the land to be farmed and the produce sold to Jews during the sabbatical year.

The Chief Rabbinate and the ILA will serve as the go-betweens who will "sell" the land to a non-Jew on the eve of Rosh Hashanah.

According to halakha, Jewish religious law, during the sabbatical year Jews may eat produce grown in the Land of Israel only if it was grown on land owned by non-Jews.

However, kashrut supervisors in the center of the country, acting on the orders of Rabbi Avraham Yosef, the Chief Rabbi of Holon, are also demanding that Arab farmers sign the document.

One Arab farmer who was given the document said that he was terrified to find out that he was required to sell his land as a condition to continue selling his produce with rabbinical supervision. "For 30 years, I have been in agriculture, and I have seen five or six sabbatical years," he said. "Suddenly, they are telling us that they will remove the kashrut [certification] from our wholesalers if we do not agree to sell the land. People are scared, since our produce is sold to Jews all over the country."

A kashrut supervisor from the rabbinate explained that they wanted "to be sure that all of the land is sold to a non-Jew. The problem is that some of the Arab farmers are [leasing] ILA land, and are farming what is in fact Jewish land. [Any non-Jew who] presents us with a land registry deed that proves that the land is his will be exempted from signing the forms," said the supervisor.

The head of the Chief Rabbinate's committee on the sabbatical year, Rabbi Zeev Witman, promised that "All the agricultural produce grown by Arabs will be accepted. They can ignore this document."

On the other hand, Rabbi Yosef insisted that "Arab farmers must sign, since there are many go-betweens among Arab farmers and we want to discourage them."

More Jewish World news and features
Bookmark to del.icio.us
A puzzle unsolved
The death of Charles Jordan is one of the biggest mysteries of the Cold War era.
My world, a bag
Israel can learn a lot from how other countries are fighting the plastic bag plague.
  1.   who would believe them? 02:55  |  realism 29/08/07
  2.   Someone get Alan Dershowitz to sue this mob 03:06  |  B`galil 29/08/07
  3.   What a stupid practise 03:12  |  Dan 29/08/07
  4.   Arabs to buy Jewish farmland! 03:58  |  Omran 29/08/07
  5.   Who believes Haaretz b.s. anyway? 05:09  |  Jake 29/08/07
  6.   This is extortion. 05:12  |  Maki 29/08/07
  7.   Rabbis have too much time on their hands... 05:40  |  Silvienne 29/08/07
  8.   Leave the damn land alone! 05:43  |  David R 29/08/07
  9.   The article doesn`t make sense... 05:46  |  Tom 29/08/07
  10.   Who said that Israel is not an Apartheid state? 05:47  |  Petteri 29/08/07
  11.   HAREDIM PSYCHO PHOBIA BY HAARETZ 06:10  |  ALBERT 29/08/07
  12.   The Rabbis will bring the distruction 06:25  |  Dan Z 29/08/07
  13.   what`s not understood 06:31  |  jenk 29/08/07
  14.   This story is FALSE 06:33  |  Kenneth 29/08/07
  15.   Are the farmers permitted to tend... 06:38  |  Maureen Ann 29/08/07
  16.   shmita 06:57  |  tony 29/08/07
  17.   Coincidencies 07:27  |  Kris 29/08/07
  18.   How gan you press jewish religios law onto non-jews? 07:32  |  Kris 29/08/07
  19.   ILA has to sell, not the farmers 07:42  |  cor 29/08/07
  20.   Secularists and Europeans are Racists 07:42  |  Yaakov 29/08/07
  21.   RE TO TOM 07:54  |  oo 29/08/07
  22.   Big deal 07:57  |  David 29/08/07
  23.   #8 is right, leave the land alone! 07:59  |  Gili 29/08/07
  24.   Shmita 08:02  |  Humble Jew 29/08/07
  25.   Non-jew owners will not need to buy its own land 08:08  |  Marcelo 29/08/07
  26.   shmita 08:16  |  elchonon 29/08/07
  27.   I don`t believe this article! 08:21  |  Avraham 29/08/07
  28.   Are they trying to fool God?!! 08:50  |  M.A 29/08/07
  29.   Re #3, #8 the fallow year 08:52  |  DJStahl 29/08/07
  30.   to B`galil you are so right, we all have get 09:22  |  Puhi 29/08/07
  31.   if they own the land they have nothing to worry about 09:36  |  Sarah 29/08/07
  32.   If they won`t sell land to Jews why sell food? 09:36  |  Efox 29/08/07
  33.   This article makes no sense 09:40  |  Efox 29/08/07
  34.   Hey Stupids! You Hate The Rabbinate But Did Not Read The Article! 09:42  |  Efox 29/08/07
  35.   The Nomads Do Not Know How To Farm! 09:45  |  Efox 29/08/07
  36.   # Yaakov. Kosher and Halal. 09:54  |  Maureen Ann 29/08/07
  37.   efox 28 09:57  |  realism 29/08/07
  38.   1. If the Arabs do not own the land 10:00  |  Zev 29/08/07
  39.   #33 barbie 10:44  |  Rab Burns 29/08/07
  40.   THE ONE WHO OWNS IS THE ONE WHO SELLS 10:45  |  Jay A Friedman 29/08/07
  41.   Clam down, breathe, and understand 10:57  |  Slibovitz 29/08/07
  42.   important to follow this up 11:09  |  of human rights 29/08/07
  43.   THE VOICE FROM THE MIDDLE AGES! 11:27  |  Robert 29/08/07
  44.   get your facts right for once, if you can 11:35  |  Just A jew 29/08/07
  45.   If they want a kashrut certificate they need to sign. 11:47  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 29/08/07
  46.   WHEN ARE THEY GOING TO JOIN THE MODERN WORLD ? 11:51  |  PAUL HARRIS 29/08/07
  47.   the magical figure 7 and the ancient world 11:55  |  victor hardman 29/08/07
  48.   Wonderful! :-) 12:04  |  Maimon 29/08/07
  49.   AMEN PUHI 12:18  |  B`galil 29/08/07
  50.   Land 12:23  |  Matthew 29/08/07
  51.   # 37 Jay 12:28  |  AviYerushalmi 29/08/07
  52.   Tradition 13:10  |  jacob 29/08/07
  53.   The Rabbinate: Home of the absurd 13:21  |  David Teich 29/08/07
  54.   Reforming Halacha 13:33  |  Alicia 29/08/07
  55.   How can a farmer sell land he is only leasing? 13:40  |  G 29/08/07
  56.   Matthew - Land 13:41  |  Slibovitz 29/08/07
  57.   Matthew 13:47  |  Nik Miller 29/08/07
  58.   senseless article 13:53  |  scanadu 29/08/07
  59.   Beyond the looking glass 13:56  |  Mark Lincoln 29/08/07
  60.   arabs selling to non-jews 14:00  |  scanadu 29/08/07
  61.   34Maureen Ann,the cruelty of religious practices,but here it is 14:15  |  lakshmi 29/08/07
  62.   forcing arabs to sell land to non Jews 14:15  |  H. Katz 29/08/07
  63.   Efox funny guy 14:28  |  Rachel 29/08/07
  64.   aparthied lives.. 14:29  |  ravi 29/08/07
  65.   Interference 14:49  |  Avi Yerushalmi 29/08/07
  66.   smitta 14:55  |  aryeh shore 29/08/07
  67.   Most are a bunch of ignoramuses. Go study a bit 15:37  |  Jesus 29/08/07
  68.   59ravi,amen to that! And it is soon to happen,the talk being 15:51  |  lakshmi 29/08/07
  69.   So Israel doesn`t buy produce from abroad? 15:56  |  Ibrahim 29/08/07
  70.   PL. listen to #1 Realism. he is right. 16:21  |  Filistinian 29/08/07
  71.   Misleading headline 16:33  |  peter 29/08/07
  72.   Humble Jew - What are you doing in Christian USA? 16:34  |  USA 29/08/07
  73.   Sabbatical Year 16:34  |  Naim S. Mahlab 29/08/07
  74.   #13 Waht if the farmer does not have a land registry? 17:00  |  Kevin 29/08/07
  75.   #44 B`galil, We can not pick and choose from the Torah 17:11  |  Kevin 29/08/07
  76.   Rabbinate Forces. etc. 17:13  |  S. Isser 29/08/07
  77.   Let it all lie fallow 17:22  |  Michael 29/08/07
  78.   Efox- Are you talking about jews? 17:22  |  Wandering Jew 29/08/07
  79.   zev 17:24  |  HuH?! 29/08/07
  80.   Margie in tel aviv 17:34  |  Danite 29/08/07
  81.   Oylem Goylem?? 17:36  |  Danite 29/08/07
  82.   And then Jewish farmers? 17:55  |  W 29/08/07
  83.   Shmitah 18:33  |  Rabbi 29/08/07
  84.   avi 60 18:46  |  realism 29/08/07
  85.   Mr Ettinger, please inform your sources... 18:56  |  Mary 29/08/07
  86.   To # 8 & 23 re "leave the land alone" 19:42  |  David 29/08/07
  87.   GUARANTEED NON KOSHER. 19:46  |  SM 29/08/07
  88.   aarons sons were given the priesthood-not rabbis 20:01  |  de sterix 29/08/07
  89.   To SM # 82 - Guaranteed Non-kosher 20:06  |  David 29/08/07
  90.   Are you sure we are talking about Israel not Iran? 20:11  |  Rami 29/08/07
  91.   Ibrahim#69 20:25  |  SHIMON 29/08/07
  92.   Jewish land 20:55  |  Joe 29/08/07
  93.   #69-Ibrahim hates to be cynical 20:55  |  peter 29/08/07
  94.   Israel is a Jewish state not a secular state 21:00  |  Kevin 29/08/07
  95.   Yaakov 21:00  |  charles 29/08/07
  96.   Ibrahim 21:16  |  ODP1 29/08/07
  97.   Danite 21:29  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 29/08/07
  98.   Selling Land 21:29  |  P. J. Casey 29/08/07
  99.   re: Wandering Jew 22:04  |  Efox 29/08/07
  100.   The Fundamental Problem is this Article makes No Sense 22:10  |  Efox 29/08/07
  101.   re: realism 22:14  |  Efox 29/08/07
  102.   re: Silvienne 22:16  |  Efox 29/08/07
  103.   #94 KEVIN THE IRISHMAN AND AN ERROR 22:17  |  PAUL HARRIS 29/08/07
  104.   Rabbi Yosef vs. Rabbi Witman 22:33  |  jh 29/08/07
  105.   @69 ibrahim, please do not demonstrate your idiocy, we know that 22:43  |  vladimir 29/08/07
  106.   #97 Margie, of course you can 22:46  |  Kevin 29/08/07
  107.   to every israeli basher. 22:46  |  vladimir 29/08/07
  108.   #93, peter, you cannot reason with one like ibrahim 22:54  |  vladimir 29/08/07
  109.   Sabbatical year 23:18  |  Cyaser 29/08/07
  110.   107Vladimir,this is not a trivial matter,it is about land grab & 23:55  |  lakshmi 29/08/07
  111.   Rabbinate forces Arab farmers to sell land to non-Jews for sabba 00:14  |  Jim Weinberg 30/08/07
  112.   another absurdity of the orthodox struggle hold on Israel 00:48  |  Rabbi Art Donsky 30/08/07
  113.   to Yair Ettinger 01:19  |  Brurya 30/08/07
  114.   Ibrahim 01:25  |  Danite 30/08/07
  115.   #110 Lakshmi; this is NOT about land-grab! 01:30  |  Alicia 30/08/07
  116.   Religous Courts, Not the Govenment 01:42  |  Slibovitz 30/08/07
  117.   I have a much better idea 02:11  |  Eli Gottlieb 30/08/07
  118.   Margie in Tel Aviv 02:55  |  Danite 30/08/07
  119.   114Alicia,the title of the article is Rabbinate forces Arab 02:59  |  lakshmi 30/08/07
  120.   PAUL HARRIS 05:30  |  Stephen Connor 30/08/07
  121.   #110 Lakshmi 06:22  |  Johnboy 30/08/07
  122.   #119 - Lakshmi & Johnboy 07:32  |  JES 30/08/07
  123.   Outrage about nothing - Haaretz intolerance 07:53  |  Moises 30/08/07
  124.   Eli Gottlieb #117 - people don`t see opportunities 07:55  |  Moises 30/08/07
  125.   #122 JES 08:00  |  Silvienne 30/08/07
  126.   lakshmi #119 - If they sneezed it would be a land grab 08:06  |  Moises 30/08/07
  127.   #120STEVEN IN THE TWILIGHT ABOUT DEALING WITH RELIGION 08:50  |  PAUL HARRIS 30/08/07
  128.   To Lakshmi 09:00  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 30/08/07
  129.   #127 Paul Harris. Why don`t you believe in miracles? 09:05  |  Maureen Ann 30/08/07
  130.   Why should Israeli Arabs `trust Israel` 09:11  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 30/08/07
  131.   #119 Lakshmi 09:54  |  Alicia 30/08/07
  132.   hmmmm...interesting...but how about "forgiveness of debt"? 11:47  |  eric 30/08/07
  133.   122JES,126 Moises,Margie TA,Alcia 131 14:32  |  lakshmi 30/08/07
  134.   margie 130 14:50  |  realism 30/08/07
  135.   #132-eric confirms he`s a snake 15:40  |  peter 30/08/07
  136.   #133 - Lakshmi 16:02  |  JES 30/08/07
  137.   136JES,why did the Arab MKs advise the Arab farmers not to sign? 17:36  |  lakshmi 30/08/07
  138.   #137 - Lakshmi 20:25  |  JES 30/08/07
  139.   138JES,you haven`t answered my question about the general policy 22:51  |  lakshmi 30/08/07
  140.   Land must stay fallow no matter who owns it! 23:19  |  sam 30/08/07
  141.   to B`Galil 00:01  |  Puhi 31/08/07
  142.   #95 Harris, Israel is a Jewish state 01:51  |  Kevin 31/08/07
  143.   #139 - Lakshim, again 06:54  |  JES 31/08/07
  144.   Re #120 Annulment of Christian marriages, Islamic banking 17:12  |  DJStahl 31/08/07
  145.   139: When have you ever answered, Lakshmi? 19:23  |  David Teich 31/08/07
  146.   re #88 have to make a correction ?fruit from new tree not to be- 23:49  |  de sterix 31/08/07
  147.   Leadership! Stop Fundamentalism! 16:12  |  Enlightenment Soon 02/09/07
  148.   djstahl 144 14:55  |  realism 05/09/07
  149.   Torah and Israel are not fiction 16:37  |  larry 09/09/07
 Today Online
Olmert: Public can't always be informed of IDF operations
Responses: 72
Amir Oren: Syria does not want to be seen as a nuclear offender
Responses: 13
Gideon Levy: When will Israel learn civilian suffering does not breed moderation?
Responses: 60
MKs propose changes to Law of Return after neo-Nazi arrests
Responses: 110
Haaretz.com TV: Cellcom won't send officials to Sderot
Responses: 1
Rosner's Domain
* Too many Jews here at the Nuremberg trials
* WTR: Young Jews and Israel: Party doesn't matter
* New Poll: Will the next year be better for Israel?
* Rosner's Guest: Author of Sex, God, Christmas & Jews


More Headlines
15:13 Report: Syria has proof for Turkey of IAF flyover
16:52 Noam Shalit: Israel's deterrence mustn't rest on my son's back
13:59 IDF arrests Palestinian youth with 3 bombs, thwarting T.A. attack
14:23 MKs suggest amending Law of Return in wake of neo-Nazi arrests
16:54 Netanyahu to Winograd panel: Decision to enter war was hasty
14:36 Archeologists discover segment of J'lem drain from Second Temple period
14:35 Prof. slams Yad Vashem role in panel on WWII killing of Lithuanians
14:20 Miami synagogue auctions off seats on eBay for at least $1.8 million
12:57 Abbas to press Olmert on Accord of Principles in Monday meeting
16:36 Ex-U.S. official had warned of N. Korean nuclear facilities in Syria
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
Eldan Rent a Car
Israel's leading car rental company offers you a 20% discount on all online reservations
learn Hebrew online
Sign up for a trial lesson today with Israel's best teachers
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
Dead Sea Salt
Beauty and skin care from the Dead Sea. Coupon code HAARETZ for 10% off!
Hertz Special deals
don't miss Hertz fantastic deals for the "Tishrei" holidays
Israeli History Documentaries.
Own a piece of Israel?s treasured past.
Junkyard
Junk a car - get free towing nationwide and a tax-deductible receipt.
Holiday Inn and Crown Plaza Israel
Lowest internet rate Guaranteed at ichotelsgroup.com !
Home| TV| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved