Beinisch: Friedmann's reforms are assault on Israeli democracy<br><br> - Haaretz

Subscribe to Print Edition

Wed., August 29, 2007 Elul 15, 5767

Israel Time: 22:38 (EST+7)

web haaretz.com

Back to Homepage

Print Edition

Diplomacy

Defense

Arts & Leisure

Real Estate

Jewish World

National

Advertising

Magazine

Week's End

Business

Opinion

Rosner's Domain

Anglo File

Books

Sports

del.icio.us

Digg It! new

Last update - 22:10 27/08/2007

Beinisch: Friedmann's reforms are assault on Israeli democracy

By Yuval Yoaz, Haaretz Correspondent

Chief Justice Dorit Beinisch Monday attacked Justice Minister Daniel Friedmann, calling the minister's proposals for curbs on the High Court constitued a direct assault on Israeli democracy.

Friedmann has urged restrictions on the universal right to petition the High Court of Justice and on the constitutional validity of its rulings in matters of public affairs.

Beinisch made the comments as she and Friedmann attended the swearing-in ceremony Monday for new High Court judges at the President's Residence.

	Advertisement

In her speech, Beinisch said that "judges can fulfill their role as the defenders of human rights if, and only if, the judicial system is accessible to everyone; only when judges face human suffering, or the distress of the unprivileged."

She said that "the attempts to restrict the High Court's jurisdiction, preventing it from ruling in these issues, are a direct assault on the democratic character of the State of Israel, on the viable democracy which our society has established and takes pride in."

"The validity of the petition must not be determined by the petitioner's identity, but by the essence of the matter at hand," she said.

She also referred to the minister's recurrent criticism of the High Court of Justice. "Criticism which is exclusively motivated by the desire to discredit the court, to undermine its jurisdiction and destroy its credibility and autonomy, will not dispirit us. The court cannot overlook its obligation to protect the rule of law and human rights."

Beinisch told Judge Hanan Meltzer, a new appointee to the High Court, that she hoped that "the court you are joining today will remain the same high court of justice you knew as a lawyer, and that its numerous achievements will not be forgone."

Friedmann said that he hopes "to alleviate the High Court's terrible workload, which does not detract from its prominent status in our society and in the world. The apparatus should be improved, and I hope this goal could be achieved by cooperation."

Bookmark to del.icio.us


	Bon voyage
	The declining quality of airline service is causing 750 million travelers bitter suffering.


	Satmar silence
	No posters, crowds or even criticism greeted the Satmar Rebbe in Jerusalem.




1.	Nice, very Nice: what a Loulou..	16:20	\|	Bozaglow	27/08/07

2.	Thus saith the JM....	16:56	\|	Esther	27/08/07

3.	The will of the people shall be supreme	17:00	\|	Yisrael	27/08/07

4.	Isnt it final time that	17:03	\|	JM	27/08/07

5.	The High Court of Justice is not high and has no justice	17:27	\|	afraid to reveal	27/08/07

6.	Conspiracy Theory:Imagine This	18:28	\|	Friedgate	27/08/07

7.	Grudgingly re Buzaglow #1	18:58	\|	Esther	27/08/07

8.	Assault on Democracy?	19:10	\|	Ezra	27/08/07

9.	Almost all respondents have a death wish.	20:07	\|	S	27/08/07

10.	Law courts must remain free of any political influence.	20:47	\|	H.H.M	27/08/07

11.	clear danger	22:30	\|	realism	29/08/07

Today Online


	Hezbollah to file lawsuits against Israel for war damage
	Responses: 208


	Hass: Israel, PA agree impoverishing Gaza will topple Hamas
	Responses: 71


	Arab farmers forced to sell land to non-Jews for sabbatical year
	Responses: 101


	Israel considering construction of fence on Egyptian border
	Responses: 126


	Haaretz.com TV: J'lem police keep the peace at naptime
	Responses: 21

Rosner's Domain

* Iraq and Gaza: History in combat

* Blog & poll: 3 writers critique the Walt-Mearsheimer book

* Why is Senator Shelby holding the Iran divestment bill?

* WTR: A sympathetic story about an Israeli settler?

More Headlines
22:13 Three Palestinian children killed in IDF strike in Gaza


22:08 Rights group says silenced by Hezbollah, Lebanon over report


18:47 Hospital refuses order to transfer paralyzed Palestinian girl


20:20 UN Mideast envoy expresses 'guarded optimism' about peace


22:26 Labor Party cancels collective wage agreement with employees


21:43 Zambian soccer player for Hapoel Be'er Sheva dies during practice


17:59 Security officials: IDF reducing troop presence in Golan in effort to ease tensions


17:04 Israel, EU lawmakers blast UN meeting on Palestinian rights


19:36 Lebanese minister slams Hezbollah telephone network


19:09 Career soldier's gun accidentally discharges; brother critically hurt