Subscribe to Print Edition | Tue., October 09, 2007 , | | Israel Time: 03:36 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Arts & Leisure Real Estate Jewish World National Advertising
Magazine Week's End Business Opinion Rosner's Domain Anglo File Books Travel
del.icio.us
Digg It!  new
Last update - 10:26 17/08/2007
Who is a Jew?
By Dan Ben-David
The question of "who is a Jew?" has been debated since Israel attained statehood. It is a fundamental question for matters of citizenship and marriage here. But as with many other issues, the emphasis is not always on the primary essence of the question: We deal with matters of quantity, rather than quality. Even if we manage to solve the issue of quantity, and we find a way to integrate hundreds of thousands of olim who are not Jewish according to halacha - and Jews abroad find a way to slow the rate of assimilation in their communities - we will still be left with the issue of quality.

What will be the nature of the State of Israel in another generation or two? Democracy is a necessary but insufficient condition. There are currently three main alternatives struggling to define the nature of Judaism here. Should no changes be forthcoming, each one will bring about the end of Israel as the home of the Jewish people.

The first alternative is the ultra-Orthodox (Haredi). Is this the flag that could or should unite us? On the one hand, it could be argued that their uncompromising traditions may be the only glue that can prevent widespread assimilation, as seen in Diaspora communities. On the other hand, this population has produced no significant uprising against its rampant shirking of the draft in a country facing clear and present existential threats. It also has produced no large-scale, organized dissension against a leadership that prevents its grade-school students from receiving a core curriculum necessary to survive and thrive in a modern economy and society. Is this the enlightened Judaism that continues the path of Maimonides, who was one of our greatest rabbis - and also a physician?
Advertisement
The second alternative, that of the Orthodox Jews who serve in the army and work for a living, could have been the bridge between the modern world and traditional Judaism. These are observant Jews who excel in furthering Israel's society and economy. But where is the massive group organizing to save this population from a leadership with selective democratic principles when it comes to settling the whole of the Land of Israel, a leadership with no compunctions against encouraging its soldiers to rebel against orders not to its liking - even at the cost of fostering a behavioral cancer in the army that could rapidly spread to other parts of society that object to various policies of the elected government?

The third alternative trying to define Israel's Jewish character is that of the secular Jews. This is the Israeli version of the modern secular world. However, what added value does secular Judaism offer future generations, so that they will choose to remain in the Jewish state, and risk their lives and those of their children to preserve this nation? What kind of thread could bind sabras, who are strangers to synagogues, with their brothers abroad - be they Orthodox, Conservative or Reform - who are unfamiliar with a Judaism unconnected to the temple?

These three alternatives in their current forms - individually and as a group - represent a dead end for the Jewish state. If this country does not learn to separate between religion and politics - which corrupts religion - we will find it extremely difficult to create another alternative, where pluralism, defining the future character of Judaism, could flourish.

The author teaches economics in the Department of Public Policy at Tel Aviv University.
Bookmark to del.icio.us
The Last Klezmer
Ra?anana will host a concert celebrating the life of musician Leopold Kozlowski.
Dignity or Liberty
The dangers addicts present to society show us that a person?s dignity takes precedence over liberty.
  1.   Israel`s future 10:54  |  English Resident 17/08/07
  2.   Israel only exists as a Jewish state 11:06  |  Dani 17/08/07
  3.   Why trade a headache for an upset stomach? 11:13  |  Joseph 17/08/07
  4.   At least some common sense 11:50  |  Leo 17/08/07
  5.   A START WOULD BE TO REARRANGE THE RELIGIOUS HOLIDAYS IN ISRAEL 11:58  |  paul harris 17/08/07
  6.   Hertzl. 12:05  |  Giles Martin 17/08/07
  7.   Fear of a black hat 12:10  |  DJStahl 17/08/07
  8.   In 2 generations, Religious will be majority &they will decide! 12:39  |  Jo 17/08/07
  9.   Only if there will be complete freedom of religion in Israel 12:45  |  Zev 17/08/07
  10.   Prophetic Tradition of Judaism 13:07  |  Non Violence 17/08/07
  11.   FREEDOM.. 13:17  |  ravi 17/08/07
  12.   THEN THERE WOULD BE NO JEWISH STATE 13:48  |  Dr David I. Gross 17/08/07
  13.   #5 Paul Harris 13:49  |  Labhras 17/08/07
  14.   THE END OF ZIONISM 14:15  |  indrajaya 17/08/07
  15.   For #`s 9 and 11. 14:46  |  Giles Martin 17/08/07
  16.   Apologies, #5. 14:50  |  Giles Martin 17/08/07
  17.   #13 LABARSE MAKES A FUNNY FROM EIRE THE HOME OF ENLIGHTENMENT 15:01  |  paul harris 17/08/07
  18.   Israel`s future 15:04  |  Colman Klein 17/08/07
  19.   #12 DR DAVID AND THE SOUL 15:05  |  paul harris 17/08/07
  20.   israel a virtual jewish state 15:08  |  scanadu 17/08/07
  21.   Toleration 15:10  |  Ky 17/08/07
  22.   #14. Indy 15:10  |  Ambrose 17/08/07
  23.   Jews 15:12  |  j10 17/08/07
  24.   Replies to #12 (David), #14 15:22  |  Leo 17/08/07
  25.   PAINFULLY STUPID 15:25  |  Yechiel 17/08/07
  26.   Mr. Dan Ben-David 15:30  |  Stephen 17/08/07
  27.   Mr. Ben-David 15:35  |  Stephen 17/08/07
  28.   WHO IS A JEW? 15:40  |  ILSupporter 17/08/07
  29.   Israel can not be Talmudic and democratic at the same time 16:03  |  Christ 17/08/07
  30.   Democracy vs. Judaism 16:10  |  Choni Davidowitz 17/08/07
  31.   The future of the Jewish nation 16:14  |  Michael 17/08/07
  32.   The future of the Jewish nation (cntd) 16:18  |  Michael 17/08/07
  33.   #15 Giles Martin 16:20  |  Jasmine Murphy 17/08/07
  34.   Religious freedom an asset to national survival 16:23  |  Ivar 17/08/07
  35.   # 14, FAKE INDRAJAYA 16:34  |  indrajaya 17/08/07
  36.   AM I A JEW 16:35  |  TOBIA 17/08/07
  37.   Bravo #17 and #19 16:39  |  Michael 17/08/07
  38.   Indrajaya You Think The Term Islamist Is Any Better? 16:43  |  Yosemite 17/08/07
  39.   Some food for thought for Choni 16:44  |  Leo 17/08/07
  40.   #13 labarse what is your interest in israels religious? 16:45  |  victor hardman 17/08/07
  41.   Defining a Jewish State 16:53  |  Fred 17/08/07
  42.   seperation of state government and religion ? 16:57  |  virginia orrall 17/08/07
  43.   Do all Israelis Read Spinoza? 17:00  |  Truth Magnified 17/08/07
  44.   LEBHARAS GET A NEW WRITTER 17:28  |  TOBIA 17/08/07
  45.   paul harris - 17:54  |  Dr David I. Gross 17/08/07
  46.   #30 Choni Davidowitz....... 18:08  |  Ky 17/08/07
  47.   False argument, but the solution is right 18:35  |  Tosefta 17/08/07
  48.   it is against the nature of racism 18:35  |  mehmet 17/08/07
  49.   Who is a Jew 19:38  |  Cyasher 17/08/07
  50.   Why separate again? 19:43  |  JK 17/08/07
  51.   The meaning of Israel 19:58  |  Chris Linthwaite 17/08/07
  52.   Who really is a Jew? 20:03  |  Miransky 17/08/07
  53.   It MUST Be Recognized Israel`s Story Is Unique In The World! 20:03  |  Ben 17/08/07
  54.   Conversion Standards 20:06  |  Leonard Oberstein 17/08/07
  55.   Oh we know who is a Jew 20:13  |  peter 17/08/07
  56.   Mamzerim 22:06  |  Asher Strauss 17/08/07
  57.   Only "three alternatives"? 22:08  |  Blogowitz 17/08/07
  58.   Who was a Jew (in biblical times) 22:15  |  Tosefta 17/08/07
  59.   To Tosefta #58 23:32  |  Marrano bnei Anussim 17/08/07
  60.   #49 Cyasher 23:36  |  Labhras 17/08/07
  61.   Continuing 23:41  |  Marrano bnei Anussim 17/08/07
  62.   Re david gross 00:03  |  Billy Jack 18/08/07
  63.   #44 Tobia needs a spell check 00:08  |  Labhras 18/08/07
  64.   #60 Dungsweeper flinging it 00:10  |  peter 18/08/07
  65.   Marranos in Brazil (Ben Annusim #59) 00:25  |  Tosefta 18/08/07
  66.   Re david gross #45 00:27  |  Billy Jack 18/08/07
  67.   Religion and Politics 00:32  |  Jim 18/08/07
  68.   #9 Zev 00:44  |  Jim 18/08/07
  69.   #11 Ravi 01:15  |  Jim 18/08/07
  70.   #64 Brer Wabbit on the looese again 01:39  |  Labhras 18/08/07
  71.   Father or mother? 01:40  |  Fritz 18/08/07
  72.   Israel`s Future and "Who Is a Jew?" 01:46  |  CHGODMK 18/08/07
  73.   Billy Jack 01:46  |  Dr David I. Gross 18/08/07
  74.   Billy Jack 2 01:48  |  Dr David I. Gross 18/08/07
  75.   Ancestry 02:27  |  JAZ 18/08/07
  76.   GOT YOUR ATTENTION LEBHRAS 03:11  |  TOBIA 18/08/07
  77.   learn from the muslims 04:57  |  michael 18/08/07
  78.   hebrew state 05:33  |  jlynch 18/08/07
  79.   Thank god I`m a Jewish atheist 06:24  |  Ian 18/08/07
  80.   "New old jews" to Tosefta 06:45  |  Marrano bnei Anussim 18/08/07
  81.   New old Jews 06:46  |  Marrano bnei Anussim 18/08/07
  82.   Pluralism 06:47  |  Eli 18/08/07
  83.   #17, Paul Harris actually posted something funny... 06:49  |  Silvienne 18/08/07
  84.   #19, Paul Harris, this is a record occasion... 06:52  |  Silvienne 18/08/07
  85.   Is a Jewish stae supposed to be a theocracy? 06:57  |  Otto Rand 18/08/07
  86.   #66, Billy Jack 06:59  |  Silvienne 18/08/07
  87.   #84 SILVIENNE ITS BRTISH AND JEWISH HUMOUR IN COMBO 08:48  |  paul harris 18/08/07
  88.   #87, Paul Harris... 11:13  |  Silvienne 18/08/07
  89.   Jewish state? Option 2: Religious Zionism looks pretty good 12:04  |  Hal 18/08/07
  90.   to Jim on religion and politics 14:21  |  Anubhav 18/08/07
  91.   Finally some common sense ...... 16:32  |  Wiktor 18/08/07
  92.   state and religion 17:50  |  George Duraisingh 18/08/07
  93.   Jewish State 22:04  |  Non Violence 18/08/07
  94.   #23 J10 22:10  |  Big Bill 18/08/07
  95.   391 WIKTOR HAS NO COMMON SENSE 22:27  |  paul harris 18/08/07
  96.   #60,#63 Labhras 00:22  |  Bruce 19/08/07
  97.   Labhras #60 00:53  |  Cyasher 19/08/07
  98.   SECULAR FUTURE 01:09  |  SM 19/08/07
  99.   Labhras #60 01:22  |  Cyasher 19/08/07
  100.   #29 03:11  |  Moshe 19/08/07
  101.   Israel is the Bible 07:39  |  J 19/08/07
  102.   How CAN we even try to seperate DNA and faith? 08:47  |  Atsiylah 19/08/07
  103.   Religion & morality is pure only where separated from government 08:59  |  Ivar 19/08/07
  104.   States (an answer to non violence) 16:56  |  Leo 19/08/07
  105.   responce to Ivar 23:33  |  Atsiylah 19/08/07
  106.   david gross 23:59  |  realism 26/08/07
  107.   Responce to David Gross 03:22  |  Atsiylah 09/10/07
 Today Online
IDF: Hamas in full control of Gaza arms smuggling
Responses: 175
Report: Several North Korean scientists hurt in IAF strike in Syria
Responses: 154
Akiva Eldar: Time is not on Israel's side in the peace process
Responses: 163
Israel, Iran envoys meet at Chile event for book on Zionist group
Responses: 71
Haaretz.com TV: Gay U.S. Jews don't have to choose between their sexuality, religion
Responses: 57


More Headlines
03:26 IDF orders seizure of Arab land near East Jerusalem
03:32 PM Olmert says Palestinians want to move toward peace
01:39 Winograd to drop personal references, expedite report
19:50 Officer who commanded Gilad Shalit's brigade to be promoted
22:47 Top Hamas official says UN chief should quit over pro-Israel partiality
03:15 Druze townships: Gov't discrimination to blame for financial collapse
02:37 Measles strikes Jerusalem's ultra-Orthodox community
23:36 ADL warns Web users not to sign petition against anti-Semitic site
00:09 Court orders Border Police to pay NIS 30,000 to right-wing activists
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
learn Hebrew online
with israel's best teachers. Sign up for a trial lesson today
Invest in Macedonia
New Business Heaven in Europe
Long-term Israel programs
MASA is your gateway. More programs. More grants.
Eldan Rent a Car
Israel's leading car rental company offers you a 20% discount on all online reservations
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
Dead Sea Salt
Beauty and skin care from the Dead Sea. Coupon code HAARETZ for 10% off!
Israeli History Documentaries.
Own a piece of Israel?s treasured past.
Junkyard
Junk a car - get free towing nationwide and a tax-deductible receipt.
Holiday Inn and Crown Plaza Israel
Lowest internet rate Guaranteed at ichotelsgroup.com !
Home| TV| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved