Subscribe to Print Edition | Tue., August 21, 2007 Elul 7, 5767 | | Israel Time: 18:15 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Arts & Leisure Real Estate Jewish World National Advertising
Magazine Week's End Business Opinion Rosner's Domain Anglo File Travel Sports
del.icio.us
Digg It!  new
Last update - 10:05 16/08/2007
The falsity of the "enlightened"
By Dr. Ron Breiman

The psychologist Professor Carlo Strenger (Haaretz, August 12) tried to show sympathy to the distress experienced by the religious right who, according to Strenger, live "in the Bible." The arguments presented in his article are characterized by false and distorted analysis of the Israeli reality, using terms as if taken from "1984," George Orwell's novel in which truth and falsity were used interchangeably, and brain-washing was a major tool in the hands of a dangerous government.

Strenger divides the Israelis roughly into two groups: The first - henceforth, the "enlightened" in their own view - "follows the liberal-modern tradition. Its worldview is guided by concepts including universal human rights and the rule of law. It considers human life, not the state or the land, a universal value." The second group - henceforth, the religious right - is one whose "world is dominated by sacred values from ancient texts."

Strenger forgets that the liberal-modern tradition he admires is based on exactly those ancient texts, the Bible. He disregards a huge section of the public - henceforth, the secular "orange" citizens - that follows the liberal-modern tradition, but does not renounce the sources of Jewish heritage. Strenger thinks only about the religious right when he claims "that many Israelis feel that the foundation of their existence is in danger."

Advertisement
Only he who cannot observe the mendacity of the "peace process" - that inevitably led to the loss of about 1,500 Jewish lives as well as thousand of Arab lives - does not realize that hundreds of thousands of secular "orange" citizens see an existential threat in the continued rolling down along the leftist slant. Strenger uses words regarding human life as a universal value, but disregards the enormous loss of lives as a result of the Orwellian "peace process."

Strenger suggests the "initiation of a humane, compassionate dialogue with the religious right," but with his lack of tendency to compromise (where Jews are concerned, not Arabs), pre-dictates the outcome of the dialogue: "It must be unequivocally clear that this cannot end in compromise." Even his compassion is aggressive.

The division of Israeli citizens into "enlightened" and those who are not is the outcome of continuous brainwashing that was exercised on the Israeli public by unilateral, biased and recruited media without real discussion for the Oslo "peace," for the Geneva "initiative," for the "security" fence, for the eviction of Jews from their homes, for the past "citron" (Sharon) and the present one (Olmert), and for ignoring their corruption, provided that they follow the Orwellian "peace" track.

It is time to establish the party of the secular "orange" citizens, who will serve as a political home and electoral address for hundreds of thousands of Israelis being disregarded by the media and by the Strengers. It is time to establish the party for those who cannot vote either for Likud or the National Union-National Religious Party.

It is time to show that he who talks a true Zionist language can attract the majority of Israeli electorate, both secular and religious, which is sick and tired of the lies and dangers of the last 14 years, since the Oslo disaster. The Israeli public is fed up with falsity of the "enlightened" and prefers hearing the truth, even if it means blood, sweat and tears. The Israeli public does not need the thought police of "peace," but truth and hope.

The author is a former chairman of Professors for a Strong Israel.
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Working it out
Half of all Israelis don't renew their gym membership. Here is how to defy the statistics.
Tel Aviv or bust
The prices of apartments Tel Aviv are surging, and many are small and badly maintained.
  1.   AN EFFORT FOR A COMPLETE HEGEMONY 10:31  |  indrajaya 16/08/07
  2.   excellent article 10:43  |  ka 16/08/07
  3.   Strong Israel ? 11:00  |  Andrew Watson 16/08/07
  4.   What are your recommendations??? 11:26  |  Bandar Michaels 16/08/07
  5.   What`s to Cirticize? 11:35  |  Natallie Durson 16/08/07
  6.   Israel DOES NOT want peace, it pretends it does 11:39  |  mehmet 16/08/07
  7.   #4: Here are MY recommendations! 11:58  |  G. Marcus 16/08/07
  8.   Mehmet 12:14  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 16/08/07
  9.   Mehmet, The `Palestinians` shd have accepted autonomy fr Begin... 12:43  |  Pavel 16/08/07
  10.   blood, sweat and tears 12:49  |  Akiva Patysh 16/08/07
  11.   Itwon`t work G. Marcus 12:52  |  Bandar Michael 16/08/07
  12.   good luck with your theory, dr. breiman 13:00  |  eric 16/08/07
  13.   Balance view 13:05  |  Chaim 16/08/07
  14.   More spin,along with the economic horizons,the Peres 5% land sway 13:55  |  lakshmi 16/08/07
  15.   There is out there a compromise that most Israelis will accept 15:18  |  Sam 16/08/07
  16.   Margie please 15:29  |  mehmet 16/08/07
  17.   Mehmet 15:44  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 16/08/07
  18.   The falsity of the enlightened. 15:53  |  sandra chitayat 16/08/07
  19.   This Column Is Not for Anti-Israel Crowd 15:59  |  Jane 16/08/07
  20.   Peace is an existential threat? 15:59  |  Ibrahim 16/08/07
  21.   Do not criticise the enlightened ones who control Bagaz & Media 16:18  |  TheyKnowBest 16/08/07
  22.   My response to Lakshimi: NO, THE LAND IS ALL OURS FOREVER 16:19  |  Yehuda Maccabbee 16/08/07
  23.   Let us Support the Enlightened Margie 16:23  |  Bitter Truth 16/08/07
  24.   land and macabbee 16:54  |  truth 16/08/07
  25.   But it`s not much that separates Breiman from Olmert, isn`t it? 17:09  |  christoph 16/08/07
  26.   # 19 jane 17:10  |  Axel 16/08/07
  27.   Thank you Haaretz...... 17:12  |  Choni Davidowitz 16/08/07
  28.   Ibrahim of Michigan 17:14  |  Akiva Patysh 16/08/07
  29.   # 22 yehuda 17:24  |  Axel 16/08/07
  30.   Akiva on "Process" 17:28  |  Ibrahim 16/08/07
  31.   the peace process is bankrupt 17:31  |  Pssd Off American 16/08/07
  32.   But maybe I misunderstood something. 17:35  |  christoph 16/08/07
  33.   Margie and Other Zionists Ignore Reality 17:45  |  Meir 16/08/07
  34.   Where did I hear this pitch before 17:56  |  Mark Lincoln 16/08/07
  35.   Margie - there is no moral highground 18:06  |  Josh Goldman 16/08/07
  36.   A Nuclear armed Israel 18:08  |  Ahmed Mohammed 16/08/07
  37.   True that progressive have the bible as a base, they are not 18:14  |  Am 16/08/07
  38.   Do not forget the third group 18:43  |  Chick 16/08/07
  39.   # 37 chick 19:07  |  Axel 16/08/07
  40.   Ibrahim, Dialogue...a moderating influence. 19:12  |  Akiva Patysh 16/08/07
  41.   Clarification for Josh Goldman 19:12  |  Bitter Truth 16/08/07
  42.   I Am Jewish,a Zionist and a Citizen of Israel 19:12  |  Jane 16/08/07
  43.   And What Is Truth and Hope!?? 19:16  |  Yaakov Sullivan 16/08/07
  44.   To Chaim #13 19:17  |  YH 16/08/07
  45.   #42: And already there where true Zionists belong to. In Florida 19:23  |  Andreas 16/08/07
  46.   #6, Mehmet, quoting Noam Chomsky 19:35  |  Jak 16/08/07
  47.   Dr. Ron 19:49  |  michael 16/08/07
  48.   Michael/canada 19:58  |  huh?? 16/08/07
  49.   `Bitter truth` is my master 20:08  |  Enlightened Margie 16/08/07
  50.   Enlightened? 20:19  |  Dov 16/08/07
  51.   TO Margie in Tel Aviv #8 20:29  |  Steve Beikirch 16/08/07
  52.   Ahmed Mohammed 20:36  |  Mark Lincoln 16/08/07
  53.   The New Masada 20:36  |  The Other Alan 16/08/07
  54.   #35 yeled tov mi Yerushalayim 20:44  |  peter 16/08/07
  55.   To Steve Beikirch 20:49  |  Gene 16/08/07
  56.   Jane - correct on this issue 20:49  |  Mark Lincoln 16/08/07
  57.   Re #37 building a house before you`ve managed a hut 20:55  |  DJStahl 16/08/07
  58.   Beikirch in Texas 20:58  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 16/08/07
  59.   Dov of Netanya Israel 20:58  |  Akiva Patysh 16/08/07
  60.   There is one other aspect 21:01  |  Mark Lincoln 16/08/07
  61.   Why there is no peace on the ME 21:01  |  Gene 16/08/07
  62.   It was the ultra emotional and irrational 21:03  |  Mark Lincoln 16/08/07
  63.   Jane - Why are you in the America and not in Israel? 21:47  |  Man on a tree 16/08/07
  64.   # 42 jane 21:54  |  Axel 16/08/07
  65.   #37 Alex We can differ on numbers but one question 21:56  |  Chick 16/08/07
  66.   A somewhat modified biblical approach 21:57  |  Stanley 16/08/07
  67.   Glossary time: What is an "existential threat"? 22:12  |  Pssd Off American 16/08/07
  68.   # 5 Fatma, again an empty bubbling.... 22:15  |  Misha 16/08/07
  69.   Great article 22:21  |  KUTW 16/08/07
  70.   Life and the ?enlightened? 22:27  |  KUTW 16/08/07
  71.   TELL IT TO THE 22 HUGE OIL RICH STRICTLY ISLAMIC COUNTRIES 22:29  |  PalestiniansAreAMyth 16/08/07
  72.   # 6 Mehmet, it is easier to imagine.... 22:33  |  Misha 16/08/07
  73.   #54 po american and understanding 22:39  |  victor hardman 16/08/07
  74.   1. indrajaya HEGEMONY 22:59  |  KUTW 16/08/07
  75.   2. Andrew Watson: The Oslo Accord 23:02  |  KUTW 16/08/07
  76.   4. Bandar Michaels: recommendations 23:08  |  KUTW 16/08/07
  77.   5. Natallie Durson: What`s to Criticize? 23:13  |  KUTW 16/08/07
  78.   6. mehmet: you will know them from their actions 23:16  |  KUTW 16/08/07
  79.   # 65 chick 23:20  |  Axel 16/08/07
  80.   # 58 margie 23:26  |  Axel 16/08/07
  81.   Palestiniansareamyth 23:26  |  Meir 16/08/07
  82.   # 61 Gene 23:31  |  Axel 16/08/07
  83.   Axel when I`m asked a direct question I reply directly 23:41  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 16/08/07
  84.   #79 Alex- You do not know much of anything 23:41  |  Chick 16/08/07
  85.   Man on a Tree- My Job and Fate 23:46  |  Jane 16/08/07
  86.   Name one benefit Israel has ever enjoyed from the "peace process" 23:52  |  Chaim 16/08/07
  87.   Axel the Nazi Judging Jews Ha 23:52  |  Jane 16/08/07
  88.   # 79 Alex 2nd Attempt 23:59  |  Chick 16/08/07
  89.   Mark Lincoln - Changes Always Occur 00:01  |  Jane 17/08/07
  90.   14. lakshmi spin 00:14  |  KUTW 17/08/07
  91.   West Bank not Occupied Territory 00:27  |  Avi Yerushalmi 17/08/07
  92.   to Alex- Third Attempt 00:28  |  Chick 17/08/07
  93.   Palestinian Muslims do apartheid against Jews 00:29  |  AV 17/08/07
  94.   Pssd Off American 00:36  |  Akiva Patysh 17/08/07
  95.   West Bank not Occupied Territory.Part 2 00:36  |  Avi Yerushalmy 17/08/07
  96.   20 Ibrahim: Peace is an existential threat? 00:41  |  KUTW 17/08/07
  97.   What Islamist states do is RELEVANT! 00:47  |  Joe 17/08/07
  98.   Guy on a tree limb 01:45  |  Mark Lincoln 17/08/07
  99.   Man on a Tree 02:16  |  Jane 17/08/07
  100.   # 84 chick 02:21  |  Axel 17/08/07
  101.   Mark Lincoln-I Am Sure Most Agree 02:25  |  Jane 17/08/07
  102.   61 gene 02:29  |  michael 17/08/07
  103.   Akiva Patysh - more help needed 02:51  |  Pssd Off American 17/08/07
  104.   Margie from TA, your credibility is falling fast... 02:52  |  Ibrahim 17/08/07
  105.   #20 Yes, Ibrahim, How do you reason with such people 03:01  |  Dutch 17/08/07
  106.   #19, Jane 03:11  |  Hannah 17/08/07
  107.   #19, Jane from Palm Beach 04:14  |  Silvienne 17/08/07
  108.   #42, Jane... 04:17  |  Silvienne 17/08/07
  109.   #42, Andreas, don`t say that! 04:18  |  Silvienne 17/08/07
  110.   #63, Man on a tree....I already asked her that... 04:20  |  Silvienne 17/08/07
  111.   #64, Well said, Axel.. 04:21  |  Silvienne 17/08/07
  112.   #85, Jane....her job and her fate 04:24  |  Silvienne 17/08/07
  113.   #87, Jane the Intolerant judging the rest of us 04:27  |  Silvienne 17/08/07
  114.   ANDREW WATSON #3 05:24  |  JOJO 17/08/07
  115.   Jane, Rabbi Sirwirsky was Conservative 05:29  |  Mark Lincoln 17/08/07
  116.   You are preaching to the choir Jane 05:36  |  Mark Lincoln 17/08/07
  117.   HANNA 106 05:37  |  JOJO 17/08/07
  118.   In General 05:56  |  JOJO 17/08/07
  119.   Ibrahim of Michigan, peace, an existential threat... 06:13  |  Akiva Patysh 17/08/07
  120.   #95 Avi makes some bold claims 06:25  |  Johnboy 17/08/07
  121.   #113 JANE IS CORRECT SILVIENNE 06:27  |  paul harris 17/08/07
  122.   Most of the talkbacks do not address issue 06:36  |  Dr. Ron Breiman 17/08/07
  123.   #117, jojo 06:37  |  Hannah 17/08/07
  124.   Israel is running out of options 06:38  |  spyguy 17/08/07
  125.   simple Silvienne on "loyalties" 06:55  |  Akiva Patysh 17/08/07
  126.   #6, Mehmet 06:56  |  Silvienne 17/08/07
  127.   #116, at last, I actually agree with Mark Lincoln 07:00  |  Silvienne 17/08/07
  128.   To Ibrahim, AKA "same old, same old" 07:11  |  sabashimon 17/08/07
  129.   Dr. Ron Breiman of Tel Aviv 07:19  |  Akiva Patysh 17/08/07
  130.   The master race and the chosen people 07:31  |  Omran 17/08/07
  131.   #121, Paul Harris 07:37  |  Silvienne 17/08/07
  132.   #125, Asinine Akiva on "understanding" 07:42  |  Silvienne 17/08/07
  133.   #123, Hannah 07:44  |  Silvienne 17/08/07
  134.   Silvienne, Re Jane 08:05  |  Dutch 17/08/07
  135.   Ibrahim and no credibility 08:13  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 17/08/07
  136.   Silvienne, the supercilious simpleton... 08:14  |  Akiva Patysh 17/08/07
  137.   The "enlightened" left will lose Israel. 09:25  |  Zev 17/08/07
  138.   Man on a tree 09:27  |  Bill 17/08/07
  139.   Spyguy- Typical Palestinian delusions 09:32  |  Sam 17/08/07
  140.   # 75, # 91, # 95, # 114 09:38  |  Andrew Watson 17/08/07
  141.   Mark Lincoln, .The falsity of the "enlightened" 10:08  |  Akiva Patysh 17/08/07
  142.   #139 - Sam are you willing to bet your life 10:39  |  spyguy 17/08/07
  143.   107Silvienne 10:47  |  krdj 17/08/07
  144.   Hey jane #19,42 - tarzan asked me to tell you that 11:21  |  dana 17/08/07
  145.   Johnboy #120 11:44  |  Avi Yerushalmi 17/08/07
  146.   Johnboy ,continued 11:53  |  Avi Yerushalmi 17/08/07
  147.   RE #140 Watsonian reality 12:39  |  DJStahl 17/08/07
  148.   Silvienne# 132 12:46  |  Pietro 17/08/07
  149.   132- Silvienne 12:55  |  Bill2 17/08/07
  150.   #145 I think you need to look up "casus belli" Avi 13:25  |  Johnboy 17/08/07
  151.   #145 Avi`s twisted logic 13:33  |  Johnboy 17/08/07
  152.   #146 And you need to look up the UN Charter, Avi 13:37  |  Johnboy 17/08/07
  153.   Johnboy # 150, 151,152 15:24  |  Avi Yerushalmi 17/08/07
  154.   Dutch, thanks for your post..."I`m Not Worthy!" 04:17  |  Silvienne 18/08/07
  155.   #138, Bill 04:19  |  Silvienne 18/08/07
  156.   #143, krdj, can`t imagine whatever you were thinking... 04:24  |  Silvienne 18/08/07
  157.   #149, Bill2, No, I never said Israel is a communist country 04:26  |  Silvienne 18/08/07
  158.   #148, Pietro, well, thanks for letting me know that 04:29  |  Silvienne 18/08/07
  159.   #153 Wrong in the first sentence, Avi 04:44  |  Johnboy 18/08/07
  160.   #153 And, finally, wrong here as well Avi 05:03  |  Johnboy 18/08/07
  161.   #153 Wrong here too Avi, 2nd try 10:53  |  Johnboy 18/08/07
  162.   Johnboy #161 23:34  |  Avi Yerushalmi 18/08/07
  163.   #159 Johnboy - Your 159 remindes of George Orwell`s: "Certain ... 18:10  |  Jak 21/08/07
 Today Online
Bradley Burston: Hamas the cripple, Gaza the doomed
Responses: 112
Israeli ex-official: PA could thwart Hamas by giving welfare
Responses: 55
Rabbi rejects charges N.Y. Arab school will be anti-Israel
Responses: 72
Yoel Marcus: Olmert's peace moves are nothing but hot air
Responses: 48
Evidence suggests that people who attend synagogue live longer
Responses: 51


More Headlines
15:43 IDF troops kill three Palestinian gunmen near Gaza fence
17:23 EU says will resume fuel aid for Gaza Strip's electric company
13:59 Peres meets with Palestinian PM at his Jerusalem residence
17:44 Hanegbi to Winograd panel: War led to diplomatic achievement
17:05 Jewish-Hawaiian surfing guru donates surfboards to Gazans
18:02 Nazi archive records arrive at Yad Vashem, U.S. Holocaust Museum
16:02 Tehran: Detained Iranian-U.S. academic to be released on bail
12:30 Builders seek permits for 10,000 additional Palestinian workers
10:40 Police suspect boy shot at Nitzanim was wounded by stray IDF bullet
11:06 Physician arrested for conspiring to kill his son-in-law
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
learn Hebrew online
Sign up for a trial lesson today with Israel's best teachers
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
LEUMI
Mortgages in Israel tailor made to your specific needs and currency
Dead Sea Salt
Beauty and skin care from the Dead Sea. Coupon code HAARETZ for 10% off!
Hertz Special deals
don't miss Hertz fantastic deals for the "Tishrei" holidays
Israeli History Documentaries.
Own a piece of Israel?s treasured past.
Junkyard
Junk a car - get free towing nationwide and a tax-deductible receipt.
Holiday Inn and Crown Plaza Israel
Lowest internet rate Guaranteed at ichotelsgroup.com !
Home| TV| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved